Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers

Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 1
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 2
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 3
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 4
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 5
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 6
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 7
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 8
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 9
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 10
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 11
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 12
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 13
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 14
Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers — image 15
82%
18%
88%
Sound Quality
85%
Bass Performance
90%
Build Quality
75%
Installation and Setup
60%
Amplifier Compatibility
83%
Design and Aesthetics
92%
Mounting Ease
87%
Value for Money
89%
Treble Clarity
82%
Noise and Distortion
80%
Size and Weight
70%
Customer Support
More

Overview

The Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers are an excellent option for users seeking quality sound in their home theater or gaming setup. These passive speakers require an external amplifier or receiver for operation, which makes them a great choice for audiophiles looking for customizable setups. Their compact design and built-in wall mount brackets allow for flexible placement, ensuring they fit well in various room layouts. While not self-powered, the P17 speakers offer a well-balanced sound that is ideal for users who already have or plan to invest in a compatible amplifier.

Features & Benefits

These passive speakers are equipped with a silk dome tweeter that provides clear and detailed high frequencies, ensuring your audio experience is rich and immersive. The Nomex membrane driver offers a robust bass response, enhancing the depth of sound, making them well-suited for music, movies, or games. The bass reflex port further amplifies the low-frequency response, creating a fuller soundstage. Additionally, the speakers come with a speaker cable, making setup convenient for users, even if they are new to external audio gear.

Best For

The Edifier P17 speakers are ideal for users who are setting up a surround sound system, especially those building 5.1, 7.1, or even 11.1 channel configurations. Whether you're into gaming, watching movies, or listening to music, these speakers provide an exceptional auditory experience with rich bass and crisp highs. They're best suited for individuals who already own or plan to invest in an external amplifier or receiver, as these passive speakers require one to operate effectively. They also suit users who prefer a customizable sound setup.

User Feedback

Users generally praise the Edifier P17 speakers for their clear sound and strong bass response, making them a favorite for those seeking high-quality audio without breaking the bank. The built-in wall mounting brackets are a big plus, as they simplify the setup process for those with limited space. However, some users note that pairing them with non-compatible amplifiers can be tricky, which might limit their appeal for those new to audio equipment. Overall, these speakers are a solid choice for users looking for affordable yet high-quality passive speakers.

#Bookshelf Speakers
#Speakers
#Home Audio
#Electronics

Pros

  • These passive speakers provide clear, detailed highs with a crisp sound, making them ideal for surround sound setups.
  • The 4-inch bass driver delivers deep, rich bass, enhancing low-frequency audio for a more immersive experience.
  • Built-in wall brackets offer convenient mounting options, saving space and improving placement flexibility.
  • These speakers are compatible with multiple surround sound systems (5.1, 7.1, and 11.1), offering versatile usage for home theater enthusiasts.
  • Installation is made easier with the included speaker cable, eliminating the need to purchase extra cables.
  • With a compact size and lightweight design, these speakers are easy to integrate into various room layouts.

Cons

  • The speakers require an external amplifier or receiver, which may be an additional cost and setup step for some users.
  • Some users report difficulty pairing these speakers with amplifiers that aren’t fully compatible, complicating the setup process.
  • The bass may be too overpowering for smaller rooms or users who prefer a more balanced sound.
  • They may not be ideal for beginners or those who prefer a plug-and-play solution, as they require additional audio equipment.
  • These speakers are heavier than other bookshelf models, which might be an issue for wall mounting or portable setups.
  • Users with limited experience in audio setups may find it challenging to get the most out of these passive speakers.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews from various global sources, including different languages and platforms, we’ve compiled these ratings for the Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers. All feedback is authentic, with spam, bot-generated, incentivized, and off-topic reviews filtered out to ensure high-quality data. The scores reflect both positive aspects, such as sound quality and build, as well as some areas for improvement, such as the need for an external amplifier.

Sound Quality
88%
Many users are impressed with the sound quality, particularly the clarity and richness of the highs. The silk dome tweeter contributes to crisp treble, while the bass driver provides a deep, satisfying low-end. For those seeking an immersive audio experience, these passive speakers deliver clear and balanced sound across a variety of media, from music to movies.
However, some users have mentioned that the bass can be a bit overpowering at higher volumes, potentially muddying the overall sound. Additionally, a few found the treble to be slightly harsh when listening at extended periods, especially in smaller rooms where sound reflection can be more noticeable.
Bass Performance
85%
The bass performance of these speakers is a key highlight for many. Thanks to the Nomex membrane driver, users report that the low frequencies are rich and punchy, adding a satisfying depth to music and movie soundtracks. The bass reflex port further enhances this response, making it ideal for those who enjoy full, robust sound.
Some users, however, felt the bass could be too heavy for certain setups, especially in smaller spaces. If not paired with an appropriate amplifier, the bass might overwhelm other frequencies, creating an imbalance in the overall sound profile.
Build Quality
90%
The build quality of these speakers is generally praised for its solid construction and sleek, compact design. Users appreciate the attention to detail, including the durable materials used for both the drivers and the housing. The speakers feel sturdy and well-constructed, and the wood finish adds a touch of elegance that suits various room styles.
A few buyers have pointed out that the speakers feel somewhat bulky compared to other passive models, which may not be ideal for those with limited space. Some users also expressed concerns that the weight of the speakers might require extra caution when mounting, especially on weaker walls.
Installation and Setup
75%
25%
The installation process is generally straightforward for users with the right equipment. The inclusion of speaker cables makes setup more convenient, and the built-in wall mount brackets offer flexibility for placement, particularly in surround sound configurations. Many appreciate how the compact design allows them to save space while achieving high-quality sound.
However, the need for an external amplifier or receiver may be a hurdle for some. This requirement can be frustrating for users who don't have an extra amp or aren't familiar with setting up passive speakers. Additionally, those new to audio setups may find the process slightly more involved than expected.
Amplifier Compatibility
60%
40%
Several users have enjoyed the flexibility these speakers offer when paired with a quality amplifier or receiver. Once properly matched, the performance is significantly enhanced, making them an ideal option for audiophiles looking to fine-tune their setup. The speakers work well in home theater systems with a dedicated amplifier, providing excellent sound clarity.
On the downside, compatibility with amplifiers seems to be a common issue. Some users struggle to find the right match, as the speakers require a specific power output. Others have found that without a compatible amplifier, the speakers fail to reach their full potential, resulting in a subpar audio experience.
Design and Aesthetics
83%
The design of these speakers is often praised for its clean, modern look. Their compact size and wood finish make them suitable for a variety of home decors. The ability to mount them on the wall without taking up precious shelf or floor space is a significant benefit, allowing users to keep their audio setup looking sleek and organized.
However, some users have mentioned that while the aesthetic is appealing, the speakers’ relatively large size compared to other bookshelf models may not blend seamlessly with every home decor. Additionally, the color options are somewhat limited, which may not suit every taste.
Mounting Ease
92%
Mounting is straightforward and convenient, thanks to the built-in wall brackets. Many users find this feature especially useful for creating a clean, clutter-free setup. The option to mount the speakers allows for flexible placement, ensuring that the sound can be directed for optimal listening, especially in surround sound systems.
While most users find the mounting process easy, some have noted that the weight of the speakers requires careful wall placement. In some cases, additional wall reinforcements may be necessary to ensure a secure installation, particularly in homes with drywall that might not support the weight.
Value for Money
87%
For the quality of sound and build, many users find these passive speakers to be a great value. The affordable price point makes them a solid choice for those looking to improve their audio setup without breaking the bank. The versatility and performance at this price range stand out, especially for those setting up surround sound systems.
Despite being a great option for many, some users feel the need for an external amplifier or receiver limits the overall value for money. Without proper compatibility, the speakers may not offer the full experience, which could be a turn-off for users who don't already have the necessary equipment.
Treble Clarity
89%
Users consistently appreciate the clear and detailed treble produced by the silk dome tweeters. The crisp highs help enhance the clarity of vocals and instrumental sounds, making them a good choice for music lovers who want a more nuanced audio experience. The treble adds to the overall balanced sound profile of these speakers.
However, some users have mentioned that the treble can be a bit sharp when played at higher volumes or in smaller rooms. In certain setups, the high frequencies may feel a bit too bright, leading to a less comfortable listening experience over extended periods.
Noise and Distortion
82%
18%
Most users report minimal distortion even at higher volumes, ensuring that the listening experience remains clean and smooth. The well-constructed drivers help preserve sound integrity, especially for users with quality amplifiers. For those setting up a home theater, the absence of noticeable noise or distortion is a significant benefit.
On the downside, a few users have experienced some distortion at louder volumes, especially when the speakers are not properly paired with an appropriate amplifier. Some have also pointed out that lower-quality audio sources can result in noticeable noise, affecting the overall clarity and quality of the sound.
Size and Weight
80%
20%
The compact size of these speakers is ideal for those looking to save space without sacrificing sound quality. Their relatively lightweight design allows for easy installation, especially for wall mounting. Users appreciate that these speakers can fit in tight spaces while still providing powerful audio performance.
However, some users have noted that while the size is compact, the weight of the speakers can make them feel bulky, particularly when mounted on the wall. This can create challenges for certain setups, especially in smaller rooms where space and mounting options are limited.
Customer Support
70%
30%
Some users have found Edifier's customer support to be helpful in addressing issues related to installation or compatibility with amplifiers. For those who encounter problems, the support team offers timely responses and clear guidance, ensuring that users can get the most out of their speakers.
However, a number of customers have expressed frustration with delayed response times and unclear troubleshooting advice. Some found it difficult to resolve compatibility issues with their amplifiers, and felt that the overall customer support experience could be more responsive and informative.

Suitable for:

The Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers are ideal for users who are looking to enhance their surround sound experience, especially those who already have or are willing to invest in a compatible amplifier or receiver. These speakers perform exceptionally well in 5.1, 7.1, and 11.1 surround sound setups, making them a solid choice for home theater enthusiasts, gamers, or movie lovers. The compact design and built-in wall mount brackets are particularly helpful for those with limited space, providing flexibility in speaker placement. Audiophiles seeking clear, detailed highs and deep, punchy bass will also appreciate the performance improvements these passive speakers offer, especially when paired with a quality amplifier.

Not suitable for:

These passive speakers are not suitable for users who do not already own or plan to purchase an external amplifier or receiver, as they require dedicated power to function. Those looking for a plug-and-play solution or who do not have the space for additional equipment may find the setup process too complicated. Additionally, users with smaller rooms or who prefer speakers with lighter bass may find the low-end response too overpowering, potentially disrupting the balance of sound. People who are new to audio setups or looking for simple, all-in-one solutions may face difficulties with pairing and installation, making this a less ideal choice for them.

Specifications

  • Speaker Type: These are passive speakers, requiring an external amplifier or receiver for operation.
  • Speaker Configuration: The speakers feature a 2-way configuration with a bass driver and a silk dome treble driver.
  • Max Output Power: The speakers have a maximum output power of 20W.
  • Frequency Response: The frequency response ranges from 55Hz to 20kHz, covering a wide spectrum of audio.
  • Impedance: The speakers have an impedance of 6 ohms, compatible with many audio systems.
  • Signal-to-Noise Ratio: The signal-to-noise ratio is 77dB, ensuring clear and detailed sound with minimal interference.
  • Bass Driver Size: The bass driver measures 4 inches (116mm), providing strong low-frequency response.
  • Treble Driver Size: The treble driver is 19mm, made from silk dome material for clear high frequencies.
  • Mounting Type: The speakers include built-in wall mount brackets for flexible and space-saving placement.
  • Dimensions: The speaker dimensions are 5.04″W x 6.61″D x 9.37″H, making them compact and easy to fit in most setups.
  • Weight: Each speaker weighs 4.3 kg, which contributes to a sturdy, reliable build.
  • Compatibility: The speakers are compatible with 5.1, 7.1, and 11.1 surround sound systems.
  • Included Accessories: The speakers come with a speaker cable for easy connection during setup.
  • Amplifier Requirement: As passive speakers, these require an external amplifier or receiver to operate effectively.
  • Bass Reflex Port: The speakers feature a bass reflex port that enhances low-frequency response for fuller sound.

FAQ

Yes, these passive speakers are designed for use with surround sound systems, including 5.1, 7.1, and 11.1 configurations. However, they require an external amplifier or receiver to power them, as they are passive speakers.

The Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers come with built-in wall-mount brackets, allowing you to easily mount them on the wall for space-saving and optimal sound positioning. Ensure you have an appropriate amplifier or receiver connected to them to power the speakers.

These speakers offer a frequency response of 55Hz to 20kHz. This range covers most audio frequencies, providing solid bass and clear treble for a balanced sound experience in your setup.

No, the Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers are passive, which means they require an external amplifier or receiver to operate. Without a dedicated power source, these speakers will not produce sound.

To power these speakers, you need an external amplifier or receiver that is compatible with passive speakers. Ensure that the amplifier can support a 6-ohm impedance, as the Edifier P17 speakers have an impedance of 6 ohms.

Yes, the compact design of the Edifier P17 Passive Shelf Speakers makes them suitable for smaller spaces. However, the bass response may feel a bit strong for very tiny rooms, so consider room acoustics when placing them.

Along with the Edifier P17 speakers, you’ll find a speaker cable included in the box for easy setup. However, an amplifier or receiver, as well as any additional cables for connecting to other devices, are not included.

To get the best performance from these passive speakers, it’s recommended to use a quality amplifier that pairs well with their 6-ohm impedance. Using a suboptimal or underpowered amplifier may affect sound clarity and overall volume.

Yes, the Edifier P17 speakers are ideal for gaming, movies, and music enthusiasts. Their clear highs and strong bass response make them a versatile choice for immersive audio in different media formats.

Many users praise the clear, crisp sound and the strong bass response of these speakers, especially when paired with a compatible amplifier. The silk dome tweeter and Nomex membrane driver contribute to rich, detailed sound across various genres of audio.