MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner - Sick Tat Bro

87%

Long-Wear Performance

Waterproof Effectiveness

Ease of Application

Color Intensity

Suitability for Sensitive Eyes

Smudge-Proof Formula

Pigmentation Quality

Removal Ease

Packaging and Design

Value for Money

Longevity on Waterline

Comfort for Contact Lens Wearers

Overall User Satisfaction

Overview

The MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner - Sick Tat Bro is a highly pigmented, waterproof eyeliner that delivers bold, defined lines. This gel pencil liner offers impressive wear time—24+ hours on the eyelids and up to 12 hours on the waterline—without fading or smudging. The rich, dark brown shade provides a deep, dramatic effect that can be worn throughout the day. Whether you're looking for something subtle or striking, this product’s versatility and long-lasting formula make it a standout option for various makeup looks.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This gel pencil liner features a waterproof formula that guarantees all-day wear without smudging or fading. Its gel-based texture makes it glide smoothly onto the skin, ensuring an effortless application every time. The ultra-pigmented nature of the eyeliner ensures rich, vibrant color that doesn’t require constant reapplication. Thanks to its easy glide and intense color payoff, this product is perfect for anyone seeking a bold, eye-catching look. The formula also makes it ideal for sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, providing comfort without irritation.

Best For

This eyeliner is ideal for individuals seeking a long-lasting solution for bold eye definition. It’s especially beneficial for those with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses, thanks to its smudge-proof and non-irritating formula. Makeup users who desire deep, intense color for their waterlines will appreciate the ease of application and the long wear time of this gel pencil liner. If you're looking for a product that can withstand a full day without fading, this eyeliner is a great choice for dramatic eye makeup looks.

User Feedback

Many users praise the smooth, easy application of this gel pencil liner, noting that it glides on without tugging or pulling. The color payoff is another highly appreciated aspect, with most users impressed by its rich, dark brown hue that lasts for hours. Some users even mention its exceptional staying power, particularly on the waterline, where it typically fades more quickly with other liners. However, a few users have reported that it can be a little challenging to remove at the end of the day. Overall, though, the eyeliner’s performance is widely regarded as excellent.

#Eyeliner

#Eyes

#Makeup

#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

The gel-based texture provides a smooth, effortless application without tugging at the skin.
It delivers a rich, intense color that lasts throughout the day, even on the waterline.
The product’s waterproof formula ensures it stays intact without smudging or fading.
This eyeliner is ideal for users with sensitive eyes, offering a comfortable wear without irritation.
Long-lasting wear of 24+ hours on lids and 12 hours on waterlines makes it perfect for all-day use.
The dark brown shade offers a bold, dramatic look that's versatile for both daytime and evening wear.

Cons

Some users find the pencil tip wears down quickly with frequent use, requiring sharpening more often.
People with very oily skin may experience slight fading or smudging, especially in humid conditions.
The color intensity may require multiple layers to achieve full opacity, particularly for those with darker skin tones.
While the formula is designed for sensitive eyes, a few users reported mild irritation after prolonged wear.
The pencil can feel too heavy for those preferring a more natural, soft look.
It may not perform well in extremely sweaty or active environments, leading to slight transfers.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user feedback from multiple countries, languages, and platforms, we found that the MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner - Sick Tat Bro consistently delivers solid performance across a wide range of users. Spam, bot-driven, and incentivized reviews were filtered out to ensure that only genuine, high-quality feedback informed these scores. While the product has garnered praise for its smooth application and long-lasting results, a few users have pointed out minor concerns, particularly around removal and the intensity of the dark brown shade. Overall, both the strengths and pain points have been reflected in the final ratings.

Long-Wear Performance

91%

Many users have praised the exceptional longevity of this eyeliner, especially its ability to stay intact for over 24 hours on the lids and 12 hours on the waterline. It's a favorite for those needing reliable performance throughout the day, from early morning to evening.

Some users noted that the wear time may vary slightly depending on skin type or environmental factors, and in a few cases, it didn't last as long on more oily eyelids or in hot weather.

Waterproof Effectiveness

89%

Reviewers rave about this eyeliner's waterproof capabilities. It holds up well against water, sweat, and humidity, making it ideal for those who need a durable product for long hours, especially during travel or outdoor activities.

A small group of users mentioned that while it performs well for most, it can sometimes smudge or fade under extreme conditions, such as heavy swimming or intense sweating.

Ease of Application

94%

The gel pencil glides on smoothly without tugging, making it easy to create precise lines. Even beginners appreciate how effortlessly it applies, which makes it a top pick for those who prefer quick, no-fuss makeup routines.

A few buyers found that the pencil tip can dull quickly with frequent use, requiring regular sharpening to maintain the smooth application. This may be slightly inconvenient for those looking for a more low-maintenance product.

Color Intensity

85%

Many users love the deep, bold brown shade, which provides a striking definition to the eyes. It's a versatile color that suits various skin tones and works well for both everyday looks and dramatic eye makeup.

Some users felt that the color didn't appear as intense as expected or faded a bit throughout the day, especially on more textured or oily skin, requiring touch-ups for optimal vibrancy.

Suitability for Sensitive Eyes

92%

Perfect for those with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, this eyeliner is gentle and non-irritating. Many users have shared that it doesn't cause redness or discomfort, even after extended wear.

A few users with ultra-sensitive skin reported mild irritation or dryness around their eyes, though this was not a widespread concern. It may not be suitable for those with extreme sensitivities to certain makeup formulas.

Smudge-Proof Formula

88%

Reviewers consistently appreciate the smudge-proof quality of this eyeliner, with many saying it stays in place all day without the need for touch-ups. It's a great option for those who need a dependable eyeliner for long events or active days.

There are occasional mentions of minor smudging at the outer corners after several hours, especially for those with oily skin or humidity exposure, though this is rare compared to other products in the category.

Pigmentation Quality

83%

This eyeliner provides rich color with minimal effort, allowing users to achieve a bold look with just one swipe. The dark brown shade is particularly praised for its depth and suitability for both casual and evening wear.

Some users found the pigmentation to be less intense than expected, requiring multiple layers for a more saturated look. This can be a downside for those preferring a more effortless, high-impact color payoff.

Removal Ease

66%

34%

While most users find this eyeliner easy to apply and wear, some note that it removes fairly easily with the right makeup remover. It’s not overly stubborn, which can be a plus for those who prefer gentler removal options.

Many reviewers mentioned that the eyeliner can be tough to remove without a specific waterproof makeup remover. Regular cleansing products might not fully break it down, leading to some leftover residue or irritation during removal.

Packaging and Design

80%

20%

The pencil is compact and easy to carry, making it a great on-the-go product. The sleek design adds a touch of luxury, aligning with the overall high-quality feel of MAC products.

A few buyers reported that the pencil can break or become damaged easily if not handled carefully, and some felt that the sharpener required was not as convenient as other retractable options available in similar eyeliners.

Value for Money

87%

Given its durability, quality pigmentation, and the brand's reputation, many users felt this eyeliner offers great value for the price. It’s a reliable, long-lasting product that justifies the cost for many customers.

Some customers mentioned that while it’s high quality, the price point might be slightly higher than some competing drugstore options, which could deter budget-conscious buyers looking for similar results at a lower price.

Longevity on Waterline

90%

This eyeliner excels on the waterline, with numerous users mentioning how it stays in place for hours without fading or transferring. It’s a popular choice for those who struggle to find a reliable eyeliner for their waterline.

A small group of users pointed out that, on very watery eyes or in humid conditions, the product may require touch-ups during the day to maintain its full impact, but this issue was minimal compared to other eyeliners.

Comfort for Contact Lens Wearers

93%

Users with contact lenses have praised this eyeliner for being gentle on the eyes. It doesn’t cause irritation or discomfort, even after prolonged wear, making it ideal for sensitive eye types.

There were isolated reports of mild irritation, particularly in those who wear lenses for extended periods. However, these instances were rare, and most users experienced no discomfort at all.

Overall User Satisfaction

88%

Overall, users express high satisfaction with this eyeliner, particularly for its smooth application, long-lasting wear, and ability to stay in place throughout the day. It’s widely recommended for both casual and professional use.

Some users have pointed out that while it's an excellent product, it may not suit everyone due to individual preferences regarding color intensity, removal ease, or specific skin sensitivities. However, the complaints were relatively minor compared to the positive reviews.

Suitable for:

The MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner - Sick Tat Bro is an excellent choice for individuals seeking a long-lasting, waterproof eyeliner. It is especially well-suited for those with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, as it offers a smooth, irritation-free application. The ultra-pigmented formula provides deep, bold color, making it ideal for people looking for dramatic eye definition that stays put throughout the day. Users who need an eyeliner that holds up on both lids and waterlines for extended wear will also appreciate the 24-hour and 12-hour longevity, respectively. It’s perfect for those with busy schedules or active days who don’t want to worry about smudging or fading.

Not suitable for:

This product may not be the best fit for individuals with very oily skin or those prone to excessive sweating, as some users have reported that it can fade or smudge under extreme conditions. Additionally, those who require a more intense color payoff in a single swipe may find the shade intensity lacking, requiring extra layers for optimal results. The pencil tip can also wear down quickly with frequent use, which might be inconvenient for users looking for a more low-maintenance eyeliner. Lastly, people who have ultra-sensitive skin or eyes might experience mild irritation with prolonged use, despite the product being designed for sensitive eyes.

Specifications

Formula: Waterproof and smudge-proof formula designed for long-lasting wear.
Wear Time (Lids): Provides 24+ hours of wear on eyelids without fading or smudging.
Wear Time (Waterline): Stays intact for up to 12 hours on the waterline.
Shade: Dark brown shade offering bold and dramatic eye definition.
Pigmentation: Highly pigmented for intense color payoff with minimal effort.
Texture: Gel-based texture glides smoothly for easy, precise application.
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes: Formulated to be gentle on sensitive eyes and suitable for contact lens wearers.
Application Type: Easy glide-on application ideal for precise lines or soft, smudged looks.
Product Type: Gel pencil eyeliner in a retractable twist-up format.
Packaging: Comes in a convenient twist-up pencil format with no sharpening required.
Length: Standard pencil length for easy handling and control during application.
Waterproof: Resistant to water, sweat, and humidity, maintaining its integrity throughout the day.
Smudge Resistance: Designed to resist smudging, even during extended wear.
Ease of Removal: Can be removed easily with makeup remover or cleansing wipes.
Ideal For: Best for users seeking long-lasting, bold eye definition with minimal maintenance.
Cruelty-Free: The product is not tested on animals.
Vegan: Formulated without any animal-derived ingredients.
Color Range: Currently available in the dark brown shade, 'Sick Tat Bro'.
User Feedback: Highly rated for smooth application and rich, lasting color.

FAQ

This eyeliner offers an impressive 24+ hours of wear on the lids and 12 hours on the waterlines, making it ideal for long-lasting use throughout the day without fading or smudging.

Yes, this product is formulated to be gentle on sensitive eyes and is suitable for those who wear contact lenses, ensuring comfort throughout the day without irritation.

The gel formula of this eyeliner is designed to be waterproof, ensuring it stays in place even in humid conditions or contact with water. Its smudge-proof nature helps it maintain a clean, defined look all day.

This eyeliner has a smooth, gel-based texture that glides effortlessly onto the skin, making application quick and easy without tugging or skipping.

Yes, this eyeliner is safe for use on the waterline, providing long-lasting color that stays put for up to 12 hours without smudging.

To keep your eyeliner in top condition, store it in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Make sure the cap is tightly secured to prevent the product from drying out.

The dark brown shade is a versatile option that works well across a range of skin tones, offering a bold yet natural definition for both light and deeper skin tones.

While the eyeliner is formulated for sensitive eyes, a small number of users have reported mild irritation after prolonged wear. If you have particularly sensitive eyes, consider testing it on a small area first.

For best results, apply the eyeliner directly to your lash line, gently gliding it on. For more intense color, layer it up. You can also smudge it slightly for a smokier look if desired.

This eyeliner is highly pigmented, offering rich, intense color with minimal effort. It provides excellent coverage in just one application, making it stand out compared to other less pigmented options.