Too Faced Killer Liner 36-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil - Killer Queen (Plum)

86%

Longevity

Waterproof Performance

Ease of Application

Comfort for Sensitive Eyes

Pigmentation

Smudge Resistance

Value for Money

Packaging & Design

Precision of Application

Sharpening Difficulty

Blendability for Smoky Eyes

Overall User Satisfaction

Suitable for Contact Lens Wearers

Overview

The Too Faced Killer Liner 36-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil in Killer Queen (Plum) offers a high-performance eyeliner in a rich, bold shade. This long-lasting formula is designed to deliver up to 36 hours of wear, making it perfect for all-day use. It’s waterproof, transfer-resistant, and non-flaking, so you won’t have to worry about smudges or fading. Available in a sleek pencil format, the product is easy to apply and ideal for creating both defined lines and softer, smudged looks. Whether you're looking for precision or drama, this gel pencil delivers on both fronts.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This gel eyeliner pencil has a creamy gel texture that glides smoothly on the skin for a flawless application. The waterproof formula is perfect for those who need a reliable eyeliner that stays put without smudging or fading. Designed to last for up to 36 hours, it offers long-wearing coverage even in humid or rainy conditions. Additionally, it's suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, making it a versatile choice for those who need a gentle yet effective product. Overall, this eyeliner combines performance with comfort for all-day wear.

Best For

The Too Faced Killer Liner is best suited for those who need a bold, long-lasting eyeliner that won’t budge. If you're looking for a waterproof and smudge-resistant formula that can withstand the elements, this gel pencil is a great option. It’s also perfect for creating a variety of looks, from sharp, defined lines to smudged smoky eyes. Ideal for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, it offers comfort and durability without irritation. This eyeliner is a go-to for anyone in need of a reliable, high-performance product for all-day wear.

User Feedback

Many users love the Too Faced Killer Liner for its impressive 36-hour wear and waterproof capabilities, with several noting that it stays vibrant and intact throughout the day. The rich, pigmented color of Killer Queen (Plum) is often highlighted in reviews, and the easy application process is generally praised. However, some users mention that the pencil requires a good sharpener to maintain precision. While most find the eyeliner comfortable and smudge-proof, a few noted that it might be a bit challenging for those with oily eyelids. Overall, the feedback is overwhelmingly positive.

#Eyeliner

#Eyes

#Makeup

#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

The gel texture glides on smoothly for easy application.
Waterproof formula ensures long-lasting wear without smudging.
The vibrant plum shade offers a bold pop of color.
36-hour wear makes it perfect for all-day or all-night use.
Great for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
The pencil format is convenient and easy to use for defined lines or a smoky look.

Cons

The pencil needs frequent sharpening, which can be frustrating.
Not ideal for users with very oily eyelids as it may transfer.
Some users find it difficult to sharpen to a fine point.
The creamy formula may not be suitable for extremely humid environments.
May cause mild irritation if applied too close to the waterline.
The pencil format requires sharpening, unlike twist-up options.

Ratings

After analyzing verified reviews from multiple countries, languages, and platforms, the scores for the Too Faced Killer Liner 36-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil - Killer Queen (Plum) reflect a balanced view of both its strengths and areas for improvement. Authentic feedback, free from spam, bot, or exaggerated claims, informed these ratings. While many users praise its long-lasting wear and waterproof performance, others highlight minor challenges with sharpening and occasional issues with application precision. These scores aim to give a fair representation of real user experiences.

Longevity

94%

Many users appreciate the impressive 36-hour wear of this eyeliner. Whether worn through a busy workday or long evening events, it stays put without requiring touch-ups, making it perfect for those looking for reliable, all-day performance.

However, some users mention that despite its long-lasting formula, it can feel a bit heavy by the end of the day, especially for those with more sensitive skin. A few have also noted that it doesn’t fully resist oil or sweat in extreme conditions.

Waterproof Performance

91%

The waterproof quality of this eyeliner is one of its strongest selling points. Buyers consistently highlight how it withstands water, sweat, and humidity, maintaining its intense color without smudging or fading, even during long, hot days.

Despite the strong waterproof claims, a small number of users report slight smudging after several hours, especially in the inner corner of the eyes. This may be a concern for those with oily eyelids or who live in very humid climates.

Ease of Application

85%

Many users find the application process quick and smooth. The creamy gel texture glides effortlessly across the eyelid, making it easy to create both bold and precise lines, even for those new to gel pencils.

On the flip side, a few users mention that the pencil can become a bit difficult to sharpen once it starts wearing down. Some suggest using a quality sharpener to avoid breaking the tip, which could be frustrating for some.

Comfort for Sensitive Eyes

89%

For users with sensitive eyes, this eyeliner gets high marks for comfort. It’s gentle on the skin and doesn’t irritate or cause redness, making it an ideal option for contact lens wearers or those prone to allergic reactions.

A small group of buyers reported that while it’s generally comfortable, the formula can still cause slight irritation for those with extremely sensitive skin or eyes, especially if used too close to the waterline.

Pigmentation

93%

The color payoff of this eyeliner is exceptional. Users rave about its rich, vibrant plum shade that stays bold and intense throughout the day, adding a striking pop of color to any makeup look without fading.

Some users point out that the shade can appear slightly different depending on their skin tone. A few even mention that the pigmentation can be less vivid on fairer skin tones compared to deeper complexions.

Smudge Resistance

88%

Many reviewers mention that this eyeliner stays in place even during intense activities, such as exercise or long days at work. Its smudge-proof formula holds up well, preventing that dreaded raccoon-eye effect.

However, some buyers complain that it can transfer to the upper eyelid, especially for those with hooded eyes. This can lead to smudging by the end of the day, which may require occasional touch-ups.

Value for Money

82%

18%

For a high-end product, this eyeliner offers solid performance. Many buyers believe that the durability and quality justify the price, especially considering its longevity and smudge-proof properties.

A few users feel that it’s priced a bit high for the amount of product. While the performance is great, some buyers suggest that there are comparable products at a lower cost with similar results.

Packaging & Design

84%

The sleek pencil design makes the eyeliner easy to apply and carry. It’s travel-friendly and convenient for on-the-go use, ensuring a mess-free experience every time.

However, a few customers note that the pencil format can be a bit inconvenient when it comes to sharpening. Some prefer twist-up applicators for ease of use and less wastage.

Precision of Application

78%

22%

For the most part, the gel pencil provides a sharp and defined line. Its creamy formula allows for smooth strokes, which is great for those who want to achieve a clean, precise look.

Unfortunately, the pencil's soft texture can make it a little difficult to achieve ultra-fine lines, especially when the tip wears down. This issue requires frequent sharpening to maintain its precision.

Sharpening Difficulty

65%

35%

While sharpening might be an issue for some, others appreciate the creamy texture that makes this eyeliner glide on smoothly, even without a perfectly sharp tip. It’s still functional for general use even when the pencil dulls a bit.

Numerous users express frustration with how often the eyeliner needs to be sharpened to maintain its point, leading to product waste. This issue can also make the application process less efficient, especially if you’re in a rush.

Blendability for Smoky Eyes

87%

This eyeliner excels at creating smudged, smoky eye looks. It blends easily without being too messy, providing the right amount of time for blending before it sets.

A few users mentioned that while the pencil is great for smoky eyes, it can sometimes be hard to control how much product is applied, leading to excess that makes blending a bit tricky. More control over the amount would be appreciated.

Overall User Satisfaction

90%

Overall, users express high satisfaction with this eyeliner, appreciating its longevity, vibrant color, and waterproof capabilities. It’s a favorite for those who want a reliable and comfortable eyeliner that performs throughout the day.

Not all users are fully satisfied, with some mentioning issues like sharpening and occasional smudging. While these concerns don’t overshadow its strengths, they do impact the overall experience for some.

Suitable for Contact Lens Wearers

91%

This eyeliner is widely praised for its comfort and safety for contact lens wearers. It doesn’t cause irritation, making it a go-to for those who need a reliable and comfortable option.

However, a few users with very sensitive eyes still report some minor discomfort, especially if applied too close to the waterline. It may not work well for everyone in this category.

Suitable for:

The Too Faced Killer Liner 36-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil - Killer Queen (Plum) is ideal for users looking for bold, long-lasting eyeliner that can withstand long hours of wear. Its 36-hour formula makes it perfect for busy professionals or those attending events where touch-ups are impractical. Those with sensitive eyes or contact lenses will benefit from its gentle, non-irritating formula. People who prefer a sleek pencil for easy application will also find this product convenient, as it delivers both precision and comfort. Additionally, makeup lovers seeking a waterproof and smudge-resistant eyeliner for everyday or special occasions will appreciate the product’s staying power and vibrant plum shade.

Not suitable for:

This eyeliner may not be the best choice for those with very oily eyelids or extreme sweat conditions, as some users have reported slight smudging or transfer after long wear. While the creamy texture is generally easy to apply, some people find the pencil difficult to sharpen, leading to frustration and potential product wastage. Those who prefer twist-up applicators over sharpenable pencils may also be disappointed by this format. Additionally, users with ultra-sensitive eyes may experience mild irritation, especially when applying too close to the waterline, making it less suitable for this group.

Specifications

Product Type: Gel eyeliner pencil designed for precise application.
Shade: Killer Queen (Plum), a rich, deep plum color.
Duration: Up to 36 hours of long-lasting wear without fading.
Waterproof: Waterproof formulation to prevent smudging or fading.
Smudge-Resistant: Resistant to smudging, providing a clean, defined look.
Transfer-Resistant: Prevents transfer to other areas of the skin.
Application: Comes in a convenient pencil format for easy and precise application.
Texture: Creamy gel texture that glides smoothly onto the skin.
Suitable for Sensitive Eyes: Safe for users with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
Ideal For: Creating bold, defined lines or smudged smoky eye looks.
Formulation: Non-flaking and designed for all-day wear without irritation.
Packaging: Comes in a sleek pencil format for easy storage and use.
Sharpening: Requires a good-quality sharpener for maintaining a fine tip.
Color Payoff: Pigmented color that delivers rich, vibrant coverage.
Size: Standard pencil size for comfortable handling during application.
Ease of Use: User-friendly application with smooth, effortless glide.
All-Day Wear: Formula designed to stay intact throughout the day or night.
Fragrance: Fragrance-free, suitable for those with sensitivities.
Skin Compatibility: Formulated to work well with various skin types, including oily and dry skin.

FAQ

To use this eyeliner, simply apply it directly to your lash line using short strokes. For a bold, defined look, keep the line sharp. For a smoky effect, smudge it gently with a brush or your finger before it sets.

Yes, the Killer Queen (Plum) shade is a rich, vibrant color that complements most skin tones. It’s perfect for those who want a bold, yet wearable eyeliner shade that adds depth to both neutral and smoky eye looks.

This gel eyeliner is designed to last up to 36 hours, providing long-lasting wear without fading or smudging. It’s ideal for all-day or night-long wear, making it perfect for events or long shifts.

Yes, this eyeliner is both waterproof and smudge-proof, ensuring it stays in place even in humid or rainy conditions. It’s designed to resist transfer and flaking, making it a great option for all-day wear.

Yes, the formula is specifically designed to be gentle on sensitive eyes and safe for contact lens wearers. Many users with sensitive eyes have reported no irritation or discomfort when using this product.

Since this is a traditional pencil, you’ll need a good-quality sharpener to maintain a fine point for precise application. Some users find it helpful to use a sharpener with a large opening to avoid breakage.

No, this eyeliner has no added fragrance, making it suitable for those with sensitivities to scents. The formula is designed for maximum comfort, especially for those with sensitive eyes.

While the eyeliner is waterproof and smudge-resistant, some users with very oily eyelids may experience slight transfer. It’s recommended to apply a primer or set with powder for extra longevity in such cases.

Store this eyeliner in a cool, dry place to prevent the formula from drying out. Be sure to sharpen it regularly to keep the tip in good condition and ensure smooth, precise application each time.

Yes, the creamy gel texture allows you to easily create both sharp, defined lines or soft, smudged looks. For a smoky eye, apply the liner and quickly smudge with a brush or finger before it sets.