MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

MAC Eye Pencil Coffee — image 1
88%
92%
Ease of Application
89%
Smudge Resistance
88%
Longevity/All-Day Wear
94%
Texture & Blendability
90%
Color Payoff
85%
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes
80%
Packaging & Dispensing
92%
Value for Money
87%
Comfort During Wear
83%
Precision of Application
86%
Alternatives to Black Eyeliner
90%
Overall User Satisfaction
More

Overview

The MAC Eye Pencil Coffee is a highly versatile eye pencil known for its smooth and long-lasting application. This pencil features a rich brown shade, which works well for both bold and subtle eye looks, making it an ideal choice for various occasions. Whether you're looking for a natural everyday look or something more dramatic for a night out, this pencil delivers. With its creamy texture, blending is effortless, and the formula ensures a consistent finish throughout the day. The brown hue offers a soft alternative to traditional black eyeliners, creating a more natural effect on the eyes.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This eye pencil boasts a creamy, smooth texture that glides on effortlessly, minimizing tugging on the delicate skin around the eyes. It features a long-lasting formula that resists smudging and fading, making it ideal for all-day wear without the need for constant touch-ups. The pencil is versatile enough to create both precise, defined lines or softer, smudged eye looks depending on your desired style. The gentle formula is perfect for those with sensitive eyes, providing a comfortable and irritation-free experience throughout wear. Its smudge-resistant nature ensures a flawless finish even during the most active days.

Best For

This MAC eyeliner is perfect for those in need of a reliable, smudge-resistant pencil that can hold up throughout a busy day. Makeup enthusiasts who want a versatile brown eyeliner for both daytime and evening looks will find this product ideal. Its creamy texture and long-lasting formula make it suitable for individuals with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, as it offers a gentle application without irritation. Whether you're creating a bold, defined look or a softer, smudged effect, this pencil is suitable for various styles and occasions, making it a great addition to any makeup kit.

User Feedback

Users consistently praise the easy application and smooth glide of this MAC pencil, appreciating how effortlessly it blends into the skin. Many note that it lasts throughout the day without fading or smudging, making it a reliable option for those with busy schedules. Some users find that it’s a great alternative to black eyeliners, providing a softer and more natural look that is easier to wear daily. On the downside, a few users have mentioned that the pencil can be difficult to sharpen without wasting product, but overall, it has garnered positive feedback for its performance and versatility.

#Eyeliner
#Eyes
#Makeup
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • The creamy texture allows for smooth application without tugging on delicate skin.
  • Long-lasting wear that resists smudging throughout the day, even in humid conditions.
  • Ideal for creating both bold and soft eye looks, offering versatility in makeup styles.
  • Great for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, with minimal irritation reported.
  • The rich brown shade provides a natural, softer alternative to traditional black eyeliners.
  • Perfect for everyday wear or special occasions, blending easily for both daytime and evening looks.

Cons

  • The pencil requires frequent sharpening, which may be inconvenient for some users.
  • Not ideal for those seeking an eyeliner with an ultra-precise, defined line.
  • Some users experienced fading after several hours, especially in oily conditions.
  • The creamy formula can be too soft for those who prefer a firmer pencil for precise lines.
  • Doesn’t perform as well in hot, humid climates where it may smudge more easily.
  • The shade may appear too subtle for those looking for a more intense color payoff.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews from multiple platforms and languages, the ratings for this product reflect authentic feedback from real users. Spam, bot, and incentivized reviews have been filtered out to ensure only high-quality insights are considered. Both strengths and pain points are reflected in the scores, offering a balanced overview based on diverse, global user experiences with this eyeliner pencil.

Ease of Application
92%
Many users appreciate how easily this product glides on the skin without tugging. The smooth texture ensures a comfortable, effortless application, making it a go-to for both beginners and professionals alike. It’s especially praised for quick, smooth lines that don’t require multiple passes.
A few users found that the pencil occasionally requires sharpening more frequently than expected. Additionally, some mention that the smoothness of the application can lead to breakage if not applied gently, which may cause frustration for those seeking a more durable pencil.
Smudge Resistance
89%
This eyeliner holds up well throughout the day without smudging or fading, even in humid conditions or long workdays. Many users rave about how it stays put, making it perfect for all-day wear without the need for touch-ups, particularly for those with oily eyelids.
However, there were occasional mentions of minor smudging after extended hours, especially for those with very oily skin or who rub their eyes often. A few users wished the product offered even more intense smudge-proofing for a truly all-day, no-fade effect.
Longevity/All-Day Wear
88%
The eyeliner’s long-lasting formula is frequently noted as one of its strongest points. Users are pleased that it holds up from morning to night, offering reliable performance without needing mid-day touch-ups. This makes it an excellent choice for busy routines or events.
Some buyers found that it started to fade or settle into fine lines after long periods, particularly in hot or humid conditions. This was especially true for those with more oily skin types, which may affect the staying power.
Texture & Blendability
94%
The creamy texture of this pencil is highly praised, making it easy to blend for softer, smudged looks or to create defined lines. Many users appreciate how effortlessly it transitions between a bold and subtle effect, offering a lot of versatility for different makeup styles.
A few users noted that the creamy texture can make it prone to smudging if applied too thickly or without setting powder. Additionally, some mentioned that it may not provide enough precision for those who prefer a very sharp, defined line.
Color Payoff
90%
The rich brown shade provides a flattering and versatile color that works well for both bold and more natural eye looks. Users love how the shade complements a variety of skin tones and is softer than traditional black eyeliner, offering a more subtle yet still noticeable effect.
A few users felt the color could be a bit too subtle for their liking, especially those who prefer a more intense pigmentation. In some cases, a couple of applications were required to achieve the desired depth, which might be inconvenient for those looking for a quicker result.
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes
85%
Many users with sensitive eyes or contact lenses appreciate how gentle this eyeliner is on their skin. It is frequently mentioned as a great option for those prone to irritation or discomfort with other eyeliners, providing a smooth application without causing redness or stinging.
Some users still experienced mild irritation, especially those with extremely sensitive skin or who wear contact lenses for long hours. Though the product is generally well-tolerated, it's not guaranteed to be 100% irritation-free for everyone.
Packaging & Dispensing
80%
20%
The pencil format is practical and easy to handle, and users like that it’s compact for on-the-go use. The design makes it convenient for travel or carrying in a purse without worrying about spills or breakage.
A few users found that the packaging could be more durable, as the pencil may break during sharpening or the cap may come loose over time. Some also mentioned that a retractable version would be preferable for those who want to avoid sharpening altogether.
Value for Money
92%
For many users, the quality of this eyeliner justifies the price. The smooth application, long-lasting formula, and versatility of the product make it a good investment, particularly for those who use eyeliner daily. It's often seen as a reliable, high-quality product worth the price.
Some buyers feel that the price is a bit high compared to other options on the market. They suggest that while the product is good, there are other eyeliners with similar performance available at a lower cost.
Comfort During Wear
87%
Most users find this product comfortable to wear throughout the day. The creamy texture doesn’t dry out the eyelids, and it feels light without any tugging or pulling. It’s especially appreciated by those who wear makeup for long hours, as it doesn’t cause irritation or discomfort.
However, some users mentioned that it can feel a bit heavy or greasy towards the end of the day, especially for those with oily skin. This may lead to some product migration or smudging around the eyes as the day goes on.
Precision of Application
83%
The product provides reasonable precision for most users, especially when applied with a light hand. It works well for both defined lines and softer, smudged looks, making it versatile in various makeup routines.
However, a few users felt the pencil wasn’t sharp enough for fine detailing or precise lines. Some mentioned that it’s better suited for a softer look rather than ultra-precise eyeliner application, which might be disappointing for those seeking more control.
Alternatives to Black Eyeliner
86%
Many users prefer this brown eyeliner as a softer alternative to black, giving a more natural and warm look. The shade is often mentioned as ideal for creating a more subtle, everyday look, and is versatile enough for both casual and evening wear.
However, a few users still prefer the boldness of black eyeliner and found the brown shade a little too subtle. For those who enjoy a stark contrast, this may not be the best option, as it doesn’t deliver the same intensity as traditional black liners.
Overall User Satisfaction
90%
Overall, users are highly satisfied with this eyeliner. Its smooth application, long-lasting wear, and versatile color make it a go-to product for many. It’s appreciated for its quality and reliability, and many have added it to their daily makeup routines.
Some users feel that while it’s a great product, it might not be suitable for everyone, particularly those who prefer a sharper, more defined line or those with very oily skin. A few also felt the product could offer more color intensity, especially for evening looks.

Suitable for:

This product is ideal for individuals looking for a versatile, smudge-resistant eyeliner that can handle both casual and special occasions. The smooth, creamy texture makes it perfect for those who want an easy application, whether they are creating bold lines or blending out a softer, smoky look. People with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses will appreciate how gentle this eyeliner is, as it provides long-lasting wear without causing irritation. If you're searching for a brown eyeliner that complements a wide range of makeup styles and skin tones, this product offers a warm, subtle alternative to traditional black eyeliners, making it perfect for daily use or more refined evening looks.

Not suitable for:

However, this pencil may not be the best choice for users who prefer ultra-precise, defined lines, as the creamy texture may not offer the sharpness required for fine detailing. Those with oily skin may also find that it doesn’t perform as well in humid conditions, as some users reported smudging or fading throughout the day. People seeking an intense, long-wearing color payoff may be disappointed, as the brown shade can appear softer than some expect. Additionally, users who prefer retractable eyeliners or those who dislike frequent sharpening may find the pencil's design less convenient for their needs.

Specifications

  • Brand: The pencil is manufactured by MAC Cosmetics, a renowned beauty brand.
  • Shade: The eyeliner features a rich brown shade called Coffee, suitable for both bold and subtle eye looks.
  • Type: This is an eye pencil, designed for easy application along the lash line.
  • Texture: The pencil has a creamy texture, ensuring a smooth and blendable application.
  • Formulation: The formula is long-lasting, resistant to smudging and fading throughout the day.
  • Smudge-Resistant: The eyeliner is formulated to stay in place without smudging, making it ideal for all-day wear.
  • Suitable for Sensitive Eyes: The product is specifically formulated to be safe for those with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
  • Color: The pencil offers a versatile brown hue that complements various makeup styles and skin tones.
  • Packaging: The product is sold in a single pencil, offering convenience for both daily use and travel.
  • Application: The pencil provides a smooth, easy glide during application, reducing tugging on the delicate skin around the eyes.
  • Longevity: It provides long-lasting wear, typically lasting up to 8-10 hours without requiring touch-ups.
  • Ideal for: The eyeliner is ideal for both bold and subtle eye looks, depending on how it is applied.
  • Gender: This eyeliner is unisex, suitable for all genders.
  • Country of Manufacture: The product is made in the USA.
  • Smudge Effect: The formula allows for soft, smudged looks, as well as defined, precise lines.
  • All-day Wear: Its long-wear formula ensures it stays intact throughout daily activities, even in humid conditions.
  • Weight: The pencil weighs approximately 1.2 grams, making it lightweight for easy handling.
  • Usage: This eyeliner can be used for daily wear or for special occasions, providing versatile makeup options.

FAQ

For a smooth application, start by gently gliding the pencil along your lash line, using short strokes for precision. You can build the intensity by layering, depending on whether you want a subtle or bold look. Blend with a brush for a softer, smudged effect, or leave it sharp for a defined line.

This eyeliner is formulated with a gentle, creamy texture, making it less likely to cause irritation. It's specifically designed for those with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, ensuring a comfortable experience throughout the day without redness or discomfort.

Yes, the rich brown Coffee shade works well for a wide range of skin tones. It's versatile enough to provide a softer, more natural alternative to black eyeliners, making it great for both day and night looks.

The MAC Eye Pencil Coffee is designed with a long-lasting, smudge-resistant formula that stays put throughout the day. Most users report minimal fading or smudging, even in humid or active conditions.

While liquid eyeliners offer precise, sharp lines, this pencil provides a softer, more blendable look. It’s ideal for those who prefer a less intense, more natural finish, and the creamy texture also makes it easier to smudge for a smoky effect.

No, this pencil is not marketed as waterproof. However, its smudge-resistant formula holds up well in most situations, making it ideal for everyday use. If you're looking for a truly waterproof eyeliner, you may need to explore other options.

Yes, the gentle formula of this pencil makes it suitable for the waterline, especially for those with sensitive eyes. It’s smooth and easy to apply without irritation, but it may require touch-ups during the day depending on your activity level.

The eyeliner offers long-lasting wear with minimal fading. Most users report it lasting up to 8-10 hours without needing touch-ups. However, the wear time can vary depending on skin type and environmental factors like humidity.

To sharpen the pencil, use a good-quality pencil sharpener designed for makeup pencils. Twist the pencil to expose more product and gently sharpen it to your desired point. Make sure to clean the sharpener regularly to avoid product build-up.

Yes, this product is formulated to be safe for contact lens wearers. Its creamy texture and gentle ingredients minimize irritation, making it suitable for people who wear contacts or have sensitive eyes.