Overview

Trish McEvoy Intense Gel Eye Liner comes from a brand better known in professional makeup kits than in drugstore aisles, and that pedigree shows the moment you twist off the cap. This is a gel pencil, not a standard wax crayon, and the Deep Aubergine shade leans more plum than black, which already sets it apart from the usual liner lineup. The brand built its name working alongside makeup artists rather than chasing trends, and this aubergine eye pencil feels like it was designed with that kind of practical, on-set use in mind. At a price closer to a department store counter than a beauty aisle endcap, it positions itself as a considered purchase rather than an impulse buy, and that distinction matters before you even apply it.

Features & Benefits

What stands out first with this gel eyeliner pencil is how it glides rather than drags, even close to the lash line where skin tends to be more sensitive. The gel base lays down color in one pass, so you are not going back over the same line three or four times to get it dark enough. That kind of even pigment matters more than people expect, since patchy color is one of the most common complaints with cheaper pencils. Once set, the formula holds its place through a long workday without migrating into the crease, and the Deep Aubergine shade reads as a richer, slightly warmer alternative to plain black, flattering brown, green, and hazel eyes alike. The pencil shape also makes it easy to switch between a crisp line and a softer, smudged look using just a fingertip.

Best For

This Trish McEvoy liner is not really aimed at someone testing out eyeliner for the first time. It makes more sense for people who already line their eyes daily and have grown tired of liners that fade by lunch or smudge by mid-afternoon. If you have only used liquid liners or a gel-pot-and-brush combination, switching to a pencil takes a little adjustment, but the payoff is speed and control once you get used to it. Anyone who finds plain black a bit harsh, or wants a shade that reads moody rather than stark, will likely appreciate the aubergine tone here. It is also a fair pick for someone already using other Trish McEvoy products, or for buyers who treat a good liner as worth paying more for.

User Feedback

Feedback on this aubergine eye pencil tends to circle around a few consistent points. People frequently mention how easily it glides on without any tugging at the lid, which matters a lot for anyone with sensitive eyes or thinning lashes. Color intensity gets singled out often too, with several buyers noting that one layer is enough to get a fully opaque line. On the downside, the price comes up more than once, especially from people comparing it to drugstore or mid-range pencils that cost a fraction as much. A handful of reviewers also mention needing to sharpen it fairly often to keep the tip precise enough for thin lines, which is a fair trade-off for a gel formula but worth knowing going in. Overall, the sentiment leans positive, with most complaints centered on cost rather than performance.

Pros

  • Glides on smoothly without tugging or dragging at the delicate eyelid skin
  • Lays down rich, opaque color in a single pass, no double dipping required
  • Holds up well through a long day without sliding into the crease
  • The Deep Aubergine shade adds depth and warmth that plain black cannot match
  • Works equally well for a sharp line or a softer, smudged look
  • Feels like a genuine step up in quality compared to drugstore pencils
  • Backed by a brand with real credibility in professional makeup circles
  • Pencil format gives more control than most liquid or gel-pot liners

Cons

  • Price sits well above most mainstream eyeliner pencils, which will deter budget shoppers
  • Only available in one shade here, so there is no classic black option to fall back on
  • Requires regular sharpening, which means keeping a sharpener on hand at all times
  • Sharpening eventually uses up product faster than a retractable or twist-up liner would
  • The premium price may be hard to justify for someone who only wears liner occasionally
  • Such rich, saturated color may read as too bold for a soft, everyday look
  • Buying just one pencil at a time feels less economical than multi-packs of cheaper liners

Ratings

These scores for Trish McEvoy Intense Gel Eye Liner come from an AI-assisted analysis of verified buyer reviews collected from around the world, with spam, bot activity, and incentivized feedback filtered out before any category was scored. The goal is to reflect both what people genuinely love about this aubergine eye pencil and the small frustrations that come up again and again, rather than presenting an inflated, one-sided picture. Where opinions are mixed, that tension shows up directly in the score and the explanation below it.

Application & Glide
91%
Most buyers describe the glide as remarkably smooth, even first thing in the morning before coffee, moving across the lid in one pass without tugging at thinner under-eye skin. Reviewers who struggle with stiffer pencils often call this one of the easier liners they have tried for quick, on-the-go application.
A small number of users with very oily lids note the glide can feel almost too smooth right after application, making it slightly easier to smudge before it sets. This is a minor trade-off tied directly to how soft and buttery the gel formula is.
Color Pigmentation
89%
Reviewers consistently mention that one swipe delivers full, opaque color, which matters on busy mornings when there is no time to layer product. The aubergine tone shows up rich and true rather than sheer or streaky, even on darker skin tones.
A few buyers who wanted a completely flat matte black were initially thrown off by the visible plum undertone in certain lighting. It is a deliberate shade choice rather than a flaw, but it does mean expectations need to match the actual color.
Longevity & All-Day Wear
84%
Many reviewers report it holding strong from a morning commute through a full workday without needing a midday touch-up, which is a common pain point with cheaper liners. People with normal to dry lids tend to report the longest wear times.
Those with oilier eyelids or who wear it in humid climates sometimes notice slight fading or softening by late afternoon. It still outperforms basic drugstore pencils for most users, but it is not entirely immune to typical environmental wear.
Smudge & Transfer Resistance
86%
Once it sets, the formula tends to stay put through naps, workouts, and even a few stray tears, which reviewers mention happily after years of dealing with smudged eyes by lunchtime. It rarely transfers onto eyelids or under-eye areas once fully dry.
There is a brief window right after application where it can smudge if touched too soon, so rushing out the door immediately is not ideal. A handful of buyers wished it set a little faster for quick, on-the-go routines.
Shade Versatility
78%
22%
The Deep Aubergine shade gets praised for pairing well with brown, green, and hazel eyes, adding a subtle warmth that plain black liners cannot offer. Several reviewers say it works for both daytime and evening looks without feeling out of place.
Buyers who specifically want a true black or who wear mostly cool-toned makeup looks sometimes find the plum undertone limiting. Since there is only one shade to choose from, it will not suit every color preference or eye-makeup style.
Pencil Maintenance
67%
33%
Sharpening is straightforward with a standard cosmetic sharpener, and most reviewers do not consider it a major chore compared to other pencil liners they have used. A freshly sharpened tip noticeably improves precision for thin, controlled lines.
Some buyers mention needing to sharpen more often than expected to maintain a sharp point, which uses up product faster over time. This is a normal trait of pencil liners in general, but it is still flagged as a minor recurring hassle.
Value for Money
64%
36%
Buyers who prioritize formula quality over price tend to feel the performance justifies the cost, especially compared to replacing cheaper liners every few weeks. The combination of glide, pigment, and wear is seen as a fair trade for paying more upfront.
Price is the single most repeated concern in reviews, with many buyers directly comparing the cost to similar gel pencils from other brands. Shoppers on a tighter beauty budget often hesitate here, even when they like the performance itself.
Comfort on Sensitive Eyes
82%
18%
The soft glide is frequently mentioned by people with sensitive lids or thinning lashes, since it applies without the dragging sensation that stiffer pencils can cause. This makes it a comfortable option for daily, close-to-the-lash-line application.
A small subset of reviewers with known fragrance or ingredient sensitivities recommend patch testing first, as with any cosmetic applied near the eyes. There is no widespread irritation reported, but individual reactions can still vary.
Brand Trust & Reputation
88%
Trish McEvoy's standing in professional makeup circles gives buyers added confidence before they even try the product, especially those who have used other items from the line. Reviewers often mention trusting the formula quality based on that reputation alone.
A few buyers note that brand reputation alone does not guarantee a perfect match for every skin type or preference, and some still compare it unfavorably to long-time favorite liners from other prestige brands.
Ease of Use for Beginners
71%
29%
Compared to liquid liners, this format is described as far more forgiving for people newer to eye makeup, since mistakes are easier to correct with a quick smudge or wipe. The pencil shape also helps with steadier hand control.
First-time pencil users sometimes need a short adjustment period to get pressure and angle right, since gel pencils can lay down more product than expected initially. A few beginners mention going too dark before figuring out the right amount of pressure.
Packaging & Presentation
76%
24%
The pencil has a clean, understated look that feels appropriate for a higher-end vanity or makeup bag, and reviewers mention it travels reasonably well for a standard pencil format. It does not feel flimsy or cheaply made in hand.
Some buyers wish it came with a built-in sharpener or cap-and-sharpener combo for convenience while traveling, since a separate sharpener has to be packed along with it. This is a small inconvenience rather than a serious drawback.
Overall Buyer Satisfaction
83%
Taken together, most reviewers land on the side of being happy with the purchase, citing the glide, pigment, and wear time as reasons they would consider repurchasing. It tends to earn loyalty once people get past the initial price hesitation.
The main recurring regret comes from buyers who underestimated the price difference compared to drugstore liners before trying it, leading to a few mixed reviews despite generally liking the performance once they had used it.

Suitable for:

Trish McEvoy Intense Gel Eye Liner makes the most sense for someone who already wears eyeliner daily and is tired of reapplying by early afternoon. It is a good fit for buyers who prefer the control of a pencil over the mess of a liquid liner or the extra step of a gel pot and brush. People who find pure black a little flat will likely enjoy the Deep Aubergine shade, since it adds depth without looking like a colored marker. It also suits anyone who already shops the Trish McEvoy line and wants their eye products to match the rest of their routine. Finally, this is a sensible pick for buyers who have decided that paying more for a formula that actually performs is worth it, rather than replacing a cheap liner every few months.

Not suitable for:

Trish McEvoy Intense Gel Eye Liner is not the right call for anyone just starting to experiment with eyeliner who does not want to spend much to test the waters. Buyers who like the precision of liquid liner or the buildable intensity of a gel pot will probably find a pencil format less satisfying, no matter how well it performs. Anyone committed to a strictly black liner may also want to pass, since the Deep Aubergine shade is the only option here and will not give the jet-black contrast some people want. People who dislike sharpening pencils, or who tend to misplace small grooming tools, might find the upkeep mildly annoying over time. Lastly, shoppers who choose makeup primarily by price point should expect to pay noticeably more than they would for a comparable liner at a drugstore.

Specifications

  • Brand: Trish McEvoy is the manufacturer behind this eyeliner pencil.
  • Item Form: The product is formulated and sold as a pencil.
  • Shade: The available shade is called Deep Aubergine.
  • Pack Size: Each purchase includes one eyeliner pencil.
  • Product Category: It is categorized as an eye liner within the Trish McEvoy makeup lineup.
  • Formula Type: The pencil uses a gel-based formula rather than a wax or liquid base.
  • Application Style: It is designed to glide on smoothly and evenly with minimal drag on the lid.
  • Pigment Level: The formula delivers rich, saturated color in a single application.
  • Wear Performance: It is designed to stay in place from the moment it is applied until it is removed.
  • Color Versatility: The aubergine tone is designed to complement multiple eye colors, including brown, green, and hazel.
  • Use Versatility: The pencil shape supports both precise lining and softer, smudged looks.
  • Market Positioning: The product sits within a prestige or luxury makeup line rather than a mass-market one.
  • Amazon Category Rank: It is listed within the Eye Liners category on Amazon's bestseller rankings.
  • Maintenance: As a pencil liner, it requires periodic sharpening to maintain a precise tip.

Related Reviews

Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner – Fishnet (Black)
Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner – Fishnet (Black)
86%
92%
Long-lasting Wear
88%
Smudge-proof Performance
85%
Ease of Application
90%
Matte Finish Quality
93%
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes
More
Trish McEvoy Shape & Enhance Lip Liner - Barely Nude
Trish McEvoy Shape & Enhance Lip Liner - Barely Nude
88%
93%
Application Smoothness
89%
Color Versatility
85%
Long-Lasting Wear
90%
Finish & Texture
87%
Precision & Definition
More
Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g
Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g
78%
84%
Color Payoff
71%
Wear Longevity
88%
Blendability
91%
Ease of Application
57%
Value for Money
More
Trish McEvoy Instant Eye Lift Primer 4ml
Trish McEvoy Instant Eye Lift Primer 4ml
78%
77%
Lifting Effect
86%
Primer Performance
83%
Crease Resistance
84%
Wear Longevity
58%
Value for Money
More
MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner - Sick Tat Bro
MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner - Sick Tat Bro
87%
91%
Long-Wear Performance
89%
Waterproof Effectiveness
94%
Ease of Application
85%
Color Intensity
92%
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes
More
stila Stay All Day® Dual-Ended Liquid Eye Liner - Intense Black
stila Stay All Day® Dual-Ended Liquid Eye Liner - Intense Black
86%
89%
Application Ease
91%
Longevity/All-Day Wear
93%
Waterproof Performance
86%
Precision of Line
90%
Smudge Resistance
More
MAREE Violet Under Eye Patches 20 Pairs
MAREE Violet Under Eye Patches 20 Pairs
76%
83%
Hydration Effectiveness
74%
Puffiness Reduction
91%
Skin Sensitivity Safety
88%
Texture & Application Feel
61%
Patch Adhesion
More
Isdinceutics Hyaluronic Eyes 15g Eye Contour Gel
Isdinceutics Hyaluronic Eyes 15g Eye Contour Gel
75%
83%
Hydration Effectiveness
91%
Texture & Absorption
89%
Sensitivity & Tolerability
61%
Value for Money
74%
Cooling Sensation
More
Eye Magic Premium Eye Lift (S/M Kit + Gel)
Eye Magic Premium Eye Lift (S/M Kit + Gel)
85%
88%
Effectiveness of Lift
91%
Ease of Application
85%
Comfort and Skin Sensitivity
72%
Temporary Results
90%
Affordability vs Surgery
More
Clarins Total Eye Revive Cream-Gel 0.5 Oz
Clarins Total Eye Revive Cream-Gel 0.5 Oz
80%
91%
Texture & Absorption
88%
Applicator Effectiveness
83%
Puffiness Reduction
67%
Dark Circle Coverage
74%
Fine Line Smoothing
More

FAQ

Glide it along the lash line in one smooth pass rather than going back and forth, since the gel formula lays down full color quickly. If you want a softer effect, smudge it right after applying, before it sets, using a fingertip or small brush.

It is formulated mainly for the lash line, though many gel pencils can also work on the waterline. Just expect it to wear off faster there, since that area stays more moist throughout the day.

It is a deep plum-toned shade rather than a true black, so it reads as a softer, slightly warmer alternative once applied. In dim light it can look almost black, but up close the aubergine undertone is clear.

Like most pencil eyeliners, the tip dulls with regular use, so plan on sharpening it every few applications to keep your lines crisp. Keeping a separate sharpener nearby makes this less of a hassle.

The gel formula is meant to set and stay put once applied, and many users say it holds up well without sliding into the crease. Oilier eyelids may see a bit more movement than drier ones, which is true of most liners.

An oil-based or bi-phase makeup remover breaks down the long-wearing gel formula most effectively. Plain soap and water alone tends to take more rubbing than is ideal for the eye area.

It really depends on your routine. This gel eyeliner pencil gives more direct control and is faster for everyday wear, while liquid and gel-pot formulas can offer more dramatic, precise lines for special occasions.

The smooth glide is meant to minimize tugging and dragging, which tends to be easier on sensitive lids than stiffer pencils. Anyone with known sensitivities to certain ingredients should still patch test before applying it close to the eye.

A good part of the cost behind Trish McEvoy Intense Gel Eye Liner comes from the brand's reputation in professional makeup circles, but the smooth application and rich pigment do reflect genuine formula quality too. It sits in the premium tier, so it makes sense if you value performance and finish over saving money.

There is no official wear-count from the brand, but daily use and occasional sharpening mean a small amount of product is used each time, similar to most pencil liners. Most people get a good few months of regular use before needing a replacement.