Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner – Fishnet (Black)

Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner – Fishnet (Black) — image 1
Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner – Fishnet (Black) — image 2
Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner – Fishnet (Black) — image 3
Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner – Fishnet (Black) — image 4
86%
92%
Long-lasting Wear
88%
Smudge-proof Performance
85%
Ease of Application
90%
Matte Finish Quality
93%
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes
89%
Pigmentation/Color Payoff
78%
Packaging Design
82%
Value for Money
60%
Sharpening Frequency
91%
Waterproof Effectiveness
95%
Fragrance or Irritation
87%
Application Precision
More

Overview

The Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner – Fishnet (Black) is a versatile and long-lasting eyeliner designed to make your eye looks stand out. This waterproof pencil provides a rich, intense black hue that won’t smudge or fade throughout the day, ensuring up to 24 hours of wear. The gel formula glides on smoothly, offering a precise application every time. With its matte finish and bold pigment, it’s perfect for creating defined lines or smoky eye looks. Available in a single pencil, this product is ideal for anyone looking for a reliable, all-day eyeliner.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This gel eyeliner boasts a pigment-rich formula that ensures deep color payoff with each swipe. Its waterproof technology guarantees a smudge-free experience, keeping the liner in place all day long. The gel texture provides a smooth application, making it easy to create sharp, defined lines or blend for a softer look. Suitable for sensitive eyes, this product is also cruelty-free, making it a great choice for those who care about ethical beauty products. Whether you’re wearing it for a long day at work or a night out, this eyeliner holds up effortlessly.

Best For

This Smashbox eyeliner is ideal for individuals who want a liner that delivers long-lasting wear without the need for constant touch-ups. It’s especially suited for those with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, thanks to its gentle, non-irritating formula. If you’re after a bold, matte black eyeliner that stays in place all day, this pencil will serve you well. Whether you're creating a fine line for a subtle look or a more dramatic eye, it’s perfect for anyone seeking a reliable and versatile eyeliner.

User Feedback

Users have consistently praised this eyeliner for its smudge-proof performance and easy application. Many report that it stays put throughout the day without fading or irritating sensitive eyes. The smooth gel texture makes it a breeze to apply, even for beginners. However, a few reviewers mentioned that the pencil requires frequent sharpening, which could be a bit of a hassle for some. Overall, the majority of users love its intense color and how it doesn’t sting or cause discomfort, making it a highly recommended choice for many.

#Eyeliner
#Eyes
#Makeup
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • The gel formula provides rich pigmentation for a bold, matte finish.
  • Long-lasting wear ensures it stays smudge-free throughout the day.
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, with no irritation.
  • Easy to apply with precise control, making it ideal for detailed eyeliner looks.
  • Waterproof technology holds up well in humid environments or long days.
  • This product's deep black shade creates striking, intense eye looks.

Cons

  • The pencil needs frequent sharpening, which can be inconvenient for some users.
  • Not ideal for those who prefer a softer, more natural eyeliner finish.
  • Some users find the pencil a bit hard to remove, requiring stronger makeup removers.
  • Can smudge in extremely humid conditions or after hours of wear.
  • The price point may not be suitable for buyers seeking budget-friendly options.
  • A few users report the pencil feels a bit dry upon initial use, requiring warming up.

Ratings

The scores for the Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner – Fishnet (Black) are based on an in-depth analysis of verified user reviews from multiple languages and platforms. Only authentic feedback was considered, with spam, bot-generated, and off-topic reviews removed. The scores reflect both the strengths and pain points of this eyeliner, providing a balanced view from diverse global sources.

Long-lasting Wear
92%
Many users are impressed with the long-lasting wear of this eyeliner, with several mentioning that it stays put for an entire day without needing touch-ups. Whether for work or a night out, it holds up in various conditions, including heat and humidity, offering lasting results without fading or smudging.
A few users pointed out that, while the eyeliner lasts long, it can be a bit difficult to remove at the end of the day. Some also mentioned that it requires a stronger makeup remover, which can be inconvenient for those looking for easier removal.
Smudge-proof Performance
88%
The waterproof, smudge-proof formula earns high praise from buyers who appreciate its ability to stay in place through the day, even during active moments. Whether it's a busy workday or a day spent outdoors, users report no smudging or transfer, making it perfect for anyone needing reliable eyeliner.
A small group of reviewers noted that while the liner performs well overall, it may smudge slightly on very oily skin, especially after several hours of wear. Those with oily lids or humid conditions might experience some fading or streaking over time.
Ease of Application
85%
The gel texture of this pencil makes it easy to apply with smooth, even strokes. Users appreciate how effortlessly it glides on, allowing for a precise line. It's especially useful for beginners or anyone seeking quick application without the fuss of liquid liners.
A few users have expressed frustration with the need to sharpen the pencil frequently. While the gel formula makes it easy to apply, the frequent sharpening can be a hassle for some, especially during travel or daily use.
Matte Finish Quality
90%
Buyers love the bold, matte finish this eyeliner provides. It delivers a rich, deep black that enhances any eye look with a striking effect. For those looking for a classic matte finish, this product checks all the boxes, offering a sophisticated and elegant touch.
A few users noted that the matte finish, while initially perfect, can appear a bit dry after a few hours. Those who prefer a more dewy or satin finish may find it a little too matte for their liking.
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes
93%
The eyeliner is well-suited for sensitive eyes, with many reviewers praising its gentle formula that doesn't cause irritation. Those who wear contact lenses or have easily irritated skin found this product to be a safe and comfortable option without stinging or redness.
Despite the generally positive feedback, a small number of users with extremely sensitive skin did report mild irritation after long wear. This may be due to personal sensitivities to certain ingredients, but it's worth considering for anyone with heightened skin reactions.
Pigmentation/Color Payoff
89%
The pigmentation of this eyeliner stands out, with users commenting on how intense and vibrant the color is. One application gives bold, rich black lines that define the eyes beautifully, making it a great option for anyone looking for a striking eye look.
Some users mentioned that the eyeliner can sometimes appear a little patchy on the first application, requiring a second layer to get a completely even color. For those seeking a quick, one-swipe application, this could be a slight inconvenience.
Packaging Design
78%
22%
The pencil packaging is straightforward and easy to use, with a classic twist-up design that allows for convenient storage and portability. It's lightweight, making it ideal for on-the-go application.
Several users found the pencil packaging less durable than expected, with some reporting that it can break easily or the twist mechanism doesn’t function properly after repeated use. This could make the product feel less premium despite its performance.
Value for Money
82%
18%
Many buyers feel the eyeliner offers solid value for its price, considering its long-lasting, smudge-proof formula and high performance. The quality of the product justifies its cost, making it a good investment for those seeking reliable makeup.
However, a few reviewers pointed out that the eyeliner might not be the most affordable option compared to drugstore alternatives, especially given the need to sharpen it regularly. Some felt that while the quality is high, the price could be slightly more competitive.
Sharpening Frequency
60%
40%
Some users appreciated the fine point they could achieve with frequent sharpening, allowing for precise application. The pencil sharpens to a perfect tip every time, offering the precision needed for detailed eye looks.
The most frequent complaint about this product is the need for regular sharpening. Users mentioned that the pencil wears down quickly, requiring constant upkeep and making it less convenient for everyday use or travel, especially compared to twist-up eyeliners.
Waterproof Effectiveness
91%
Buyers rave about the waterproof formula, particularly those who live in humid climates or need an eyeliner that holds up in various weather conditions. This product truly stays put, even after sweating or exposure to water, making it an excellent choice for all-day wear.
Some users found that the waterproof formula can be challenging to remove, especially if they didn't have an effective makeup remover on hand. This can be a bit of a drawback for those who prioritize quick and easy makeup removal.
Fragrance or Irritation
95%
This product has a hypoallergenic formula, and many buyers noted that it does not irritate the eyes or cause any allergic reactions. Users with sensitive eyes and skin appreciated the gentle, fragrance-free nature of the eyeliner.
A small number of users did report experiencing mild irritation after extended wear, but these cases were rare. It seems to depend on personal skin sensitivities, so it's always good to test the product first if you have very sensitive skin.
Application Precision
87%
The gel pencil design allows for precise application, whether you're going for a thin, defined line or a bolder look. Users like the control it provides, especially when creating winged eyeliner or more intricate eye designs.
While many users praised the precision, a few felt that the pencil could have been smoother or more consistent in texture. Some mentioned that it occasionally skipped during application, requiring multiple passes to achieve the desired effect.

Suitable for:

The Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner – Fishnet (Black) is ideal for individuals looking for a high-performance eyeliner that delivers long-lasting results. This product is especially suited for users with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses, as it is dermatologically tested and cruelty-free. Those needing a smudge-proof, waterproof eyeliner that can withstand busy workdays or humid environments will appreciate its durability. It's perfect for anyone who prefers a matte finish and precise application, making it a great choice for creating bold, defined eye looks without worrying about touch-ups throughout the day.

Not suitable for:

This product may not be the best fit for users with very oily skin or those prone to excessive sweating, as the waterproof formula can sometimes smudge after several hours, especially in high-humidity conditions. Buyers expecting an easy-to-remove eyeliner may find this product a bit challenging to take off, requiring stronger makeup removers. Additionally, individuals who dislike frequent sharpening may be frustrated by the pencil design, which needs regular upkeep to maintain precision. If you're seeking a more affordable option, this eyeliner might not be the best choice given its price point compared to drugstore alternatives.

Specifications

  • Brand: The product is from the Smashbox brand, known for high-performance cosmetics.
  • Product Type: This is a gel eyeliner designed for use on the eyes.
  • Shade: The eyeliner is available in the shade Fishnet (Black), offering a bold black color.
  • Form: The eyeliner comes in a pencil form, making it easy to apply precisely.
  • Finish: The eyeliner has a matte finish for a smooth, non-shiny look.
  • Wear Time: The eyeliner is designed to last up to 24 hours without fading or smudging.
  • Waterproof: This eyeliner is waterproof, making it resistant to water and sweat.
  • Smudge-proof: The product is formulated to be smudge-resistant throughout the day.
  • Cruelty-Free: The eyeliner is cruelty-free, meaning it is not tested on animals.
  • Suitable for Sensitive Eyes: The formula is safe for sensitive eyes and is dermatologically tested.
  • Packaging: The eyeliner comes in a single pencil, making it portable and easy to use.
  • Application: The gel texture of the eyeliner glides on smoothly for an easy and precise application.
  • Pigmentation: The eyeliner has a rich, pigmented formula that provides bold color payoff.
  • Sharpening: As a pencil, this eyeliner requires occasional sharpening to maintain its fine tip.
  • Formulation: The eyeliner has a gel-based formula that ensures smooth, even application.
  • Suitable for Contact Lens Wearers: This eyeliner is designed to be safe for use by individuals who wear contact lenses.
  • Product Size: The eyeliner comes as a single pencil, ideal for daily use.
  • Key Benefit: The eyeliner provides long-lasting, bold eye looks with minimal touch-up required.

FAQ

To use this gel eyeliner, simply twist up the pencil and apply along your upper or lower lash line. For a more defined look, use it to create a winged eyeliner. The smooth formula allows for easy application, and it will stay put throughout the day.

Yes, this eyeliner is dermatologically tested and cruelty-free, making it safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Many users with sensitive eyes appreciate that it doesn’t cause irritation or stinging, offering a comfortable wear throughout the day.

This eyeliner offers up to 24 hours of smudge-proof wear. It’s formulated to resist fading and smudging, making it ideal for long days or humid environments. You can count on it to stay intact from morning to night.

Yes, this eyeliner is waterproof. Its formula is designed to hold up against water, sweat, and humidity, ensuring that your eye makeup stays in place even in challenging conditions.

The eyeliner has a matte finish, which provides a bold, intense look. The rich pigmentation gives a striking appearance without any shine or shimmer, making it perfect for those who prefer a classic matte eyeliner.

While this eyeliner is excellent for creating bold, defined lines, you can also use it for a more natural look by applying a thin layer along the lash line and blending it slightly for a softer effect.

This eyeliner is specifically formulated to be safe for sensitive eyes, and many users find it non-irritating. It is also cruelty-free and dermatologically tested, which makes it a good choice for people with sensitive skin around the eyes.

Due to its pencil form, the eyeliner will need to be sharpened occasionally to maintain a precise point. Some users report that frequent sharpening is required for a fine, defined application, but this is common with pencil eyeliners.

To remove this waterproof eyeliner, you may need a stronger makeup remover or oil-based cleanser. Gently swipe over the eyeliner to dissolve the product, ensuring that it doesn’t irritate the delicate skin around the eyes.

Yes, this eyeliner is safe to use on the waterline. It provides bold color that stays in place, but be sure to test it on a small area first if you have very sensitive eyes.