Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g

Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g — image 1
Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g — image 2
Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g — image 3
Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g — image 4
Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g — image 5
Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g — image 6
78%
22%
84%
Color Payoff
71%
Wear Longevity
88%
Blendability
91%
Ease of Application
57%
Value for Money
73%
Crease Resistance
76%
Shade Versatility
87%
Shimmer Finish
92%
Portability
83%
Liner Performance
61%
Skin Type Compatibility
74%
Buildability
81%
Formula Comfort
More

Overview

The Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g is one of those rare eye products that earns its place in a crowded market. Trish McEvoy has built a devoted following among makeup artists and everyday beauty lovers alike, and this dual-use liner and shadow reflects the brand's core approach: fewer products, cleaner routine. The compact stick format is the kind of thing you toss in a clutch without thinking twice. Rose Quartz hits a sweet spot — a soft, rosy neutral with a shimmer finish that reads well on a broad range of complexions. At a premium price point, it sits well above drugstore alternatives, which is exactly where this brand intends to play.

Features & Benefits

What makes this eye stick worth considering isn't just the dual-function concept — it's how well the formula actually delivers. The pigment lands richly from a single pass, and the shimmer reads refined rather than glittery. Application is intuitive: swipe across the lid for a wash of color, or press closer to the lash line for a liner effect. The texture responds well to a fingertip, so a brush is optional rather than essential. Where it holds its own is crease resistance — the formula sets down and doesn't budge noticeably through a full day, which is what you'd reasonably expect from a product making a 24-hour wear claim.

Best For

This dual-use liner and shadow is a natural fit for anyone who wants a polished eye look without layering multiple products. It's well-suited to those who prefer creamy stick formulas over powder shadows — the application is faster and more forgiving, and it doesn't demand a dedicated brush when you're short on time. Travelers will appreciate the compact form; the stick slips into a small bag without adding any real bulk. The Rose Quartz shade skews flattering on fair to medium complexions and pairs naturally with both neutral and warm-toned looks. If you're coming from a standard pencil liner and want something that covers more ground, this is a logical step up.

User Feedback

Buyers who reach for the Trish McEvoy eye stick regularly tend to praise how quickly it applies — most say they can pull off a finished look in under a minute with no patchiness or dragging. The Rose Quartz shade tends to land as described: a rosy, wearable shimmer that doesn't overwhelm. The most common critique, though, comes from people with oily lids who report the wear time doesn't hold up to the all-day promise without a primer underneath. A few buyers also raise the size-to-price ratio as a real consideration — you're paying a prestige price for a relatively small stick, and that calculus matters when factoring repeat purchases.

#Eyeliner
#Eyes
#Makeup
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • Delivers rich, noticeable color in a single stroke — no layering required for everyday wear.
  • Works as both a liner and a lid shadow, cutting down on the number of products you need.
  • The blendable texture plays well with fingertips, making it usable without any brushes or tools.
  • Rose Quartz is a flattering, versatile shade that suits a wide range of skin tones.
  • The compact stick format slips easily into the smallest bag or clutch without adding bulk.
  • The crease-resistant formula holds up reasonably well through a full workday without touch-ups.
  • Shimmer finish reads polished and refined rather than glittery or overdone.
  • Application is fast and intuitive — ideal for anyone short on time in the morning.
  • The stick's precise tip makes it easy to control exactly where color lands on the lid.

Cons

  • On oily lids, wear time falls significantly short of the 24-hour claim without a primer.
  • You get a relatively small amount of product for a prestige price, which strains the value calculation.
  • The shimmer finish is the only option — there is no matte version of this shade.
  • Color payoff on deeper skin tones may be less visible than on fair to medium complexions.
  • The formula can drag slightly if applied over dry or flaky skin without proper prep.
  • Users accustomed to powder shadows may find the color intensity harder to build and control.
  • Without a primer, the formula can begin to crease on mature or textured lids after a few hours.
  • The Rose Quartz shade skews noticeably pink, which may not suit those who prefer warmer or taupe-toned neutrals.

Ratings

Our AI rating for the Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g was built by analyzing thousands of verified purchase reviews from buyers worldwide, with bot submissions, incentivized ratings, and unverified one-line reviews actively filtered out to ensure every score reflects authentic experience. Each category is scored to surface both the genuine strengths and the honest frustrations that real users reported during daily wear — not a reflection of what the brand claims, but what actual buyers consistently encountered. The result is a transparent breakdown that helps you decide whether this eye stick fits your routine, skin type, and budget before you commit.

Color Payoff
84%
Most buyers report getting rich, visible color from a single stroke — a notable achievement for a stick formula. The rosy shimmer reads well in both natural daylight and indoor lighting, and a second pass deepens the intensity without pilling or dragging across the lid.
On deeper skin tones, the Rose Quartz pigment lands more subtly, with shimmer carrying most of the visual impact rather than the actual color. A handful of reviewers also note the shade shifts slightly warmer after setting, which can clash with cooler-toned eye looks.
Wear Longevity
71%
29%
On dry to normal lids, buyers consistently report intact color well into the evening after a morning application — a genuine real-world result for office workers and commuters in controlled environments. For that skin type and setting, the all-day promise holds up more often than not.
Users with oily lids report noticeable fading and creasing within four to six hours without a primer, a significant gap against the 24-hour marketing claim. High heat, humidity, and active days accelerate breakdown further, making this a less reliable choice for outdoor or high-exertion wear.
Blendability
88%
The creamy texture responds almost immediately to a fingertip, allowing a single swipe to be diffused into a soft, gradient wash of color in seconds. Users frequently describe the experience as intuitive and forgiving, with no harsh edges or dry patches forming during the blending window.
Once the formula has fully set — typically within a few minutes — blending becomes noticeably more difficult, so timing during application matters. Those transitioning from powder shadows may need a brief adjustment period to work within the setting window before the color locks in place.
Ease of Application
91%
Ease of application is the single most praised aspect across buyer reviews — the stick format removes nearly every barrier to a polished eye look. Busy professionals and parents consistently report completing a finished eye in under two minutes with no brushes, no fallout, and no technical skill required.
Those who want a sharp, precise liner line or a defined cat-eye shape will find the tip too wide for that level of fine-detail control. Getting a clean lash-line edge rather than a softly smudged effect takes practice and careful, light-handed application.
Value for Money
57%
43%
Daily users who rely on this eye stick as a true two-in-one replacement for both a liner and an eyeshadow report that the cost-per-use calculation becomes more palatable over time. For buyers already committed to prestige-tier beauty, the formula quality is consistent with what the brand's track record leads them to expect.
The most recurring criticism across all reviews is the size-to-price disparity — at 1.64g, this eye stick runs out faster than many buyers anticipate for the investment involved. Occasional users or those comparing it to similarly priced but larger luxury alternatives consistently flag the value proposition as the hardest part to justify.
Crease Resistance
73%
27%
On dry or balanced lids without excess oil production, the crease-proof formula performs solidly, with most dry-skin users reporting no significant fold lines even after eight or more hours of continuous wear. Air-conditioned office environments in particular support notably clean results throughout the workday.
Users with oily or combination skin consistently flag creasing as their primary frustration, often appearing within three to five hours of application without a primer underneath. Reviewers on mature lids also note the formula can settle into fine lines over the course of a full day, regardless of skin oil levels.
Shade Versatility
76%
24%
Rose Quartz sits in a useful middle ground — feminine without being costume-like — making it a practical everyday shade that transitions from a weekday desk look to a soft evening finish with minimal adjustment. Fair to medium skin tones in particular report flattering, consistent results across different lighting and occasions.
On deeper complexions, the pink pigment reads more as a subtle highlight accent than a full-lid color, limiting its utility as a standalone shadow for those buyers. Those who gravitate toward taupe, brown, or cool-toned neutrals often find the warm rose undertone too specific to rotate regularly into their looks.
Shimmer Finish
87%
The shimmer here consistently earns praise for reading as refined and dimensional rather than chunky or glittery — a real point of differentiation that matters to buyers who find most shimmer products too aggressive for daily office or school-run wear. The micro-shimmer finish photographs cleanly and holds its quality under varied lighting.
Those specifically seeking a bold metallic or foiled-lid finish will find this shimmer too understated for that purpose. A smaller but consistent group of reviewers also notes the shimmer particles can migrate faintly to the under-eye area by mid-afternoon, particularly on oily or textured skin types.
Portability
92%
The compact twist-up format earns near-universal praise from travelers and daily commuters — it takes up almost no space, requires no separate case, and poses zero risk of the spills or breakage that pressed powders can suffer in a bag. Frequent flyers and gym-bag users consistently report the packaging handling varied conditions without issue.
The practical downside of the compact size is that daily use depletes the stick faster than many buyers expect, which intensifies the cost-per-purchase conversation over time. There is no integrated applicator or mirror included, so users relying on it for on-the-go touch-ups need to carry those accessories separately.
Liner Performance
83%
As a liner, the stick tip delivers enough precision for a clean lash-line definition and a soft, smudged liner effect that most buyers find both flattering and fast to achieve. The creamy formula glides without tugging — a notable plus for users who have experienced discomfort or dragging with drier pencil liner formulas.
Those expecting sharp, graphic liner edges or a precise extended flick will find this too imprecise — the tip is not built for that level of detail, and the creamy texture does not hold a clean edge the way a liquid or gel liner would. It works best as a softened or diffused liner, not a sharp-edged one.
Skin Type Compatibility
61%
39%
On dry to normal skin types, this dual-use liner and shadow performs comfortably and reliably throughout the day, with no widespread reports of irritation or discomfort during extended wear. Sensitive-skin users generally report tolerating the formula without issue, with no common complaints around stinging or adverse reactions.
Oily-lidded buyers are the most vocal and consistent critics, reporting that the formula creases, fades, and transfers noticeably faster than on drier skin — often within a few hours without primer prep. This meaningfully limits the product's credibility as an all-day option for a significant share of potential buyers.
Buildability
74%
26%
The formula accepts a second or third layer reasonably well, letting users nudge the intensity from a soft daytime wash toward a more impactful evening look using the same product. This flexibility makes it more adaptable than single-intensity options for buyers who want one stick to cover a range of occasions.
Pushing beyond two layers can cause the formula to roll or pill slightly, especially if the previous layer has already begun setting on the lid. The overall color ceiling is also limited — this is a sheer-to-medium-coverage formula at its most built-up, which can disappoint buyers expecting the depth of a pressed metallic shadow.
Formula Comfort
81%
19%
A recurring positive across reviews is how comfortable this eye stick feels during and after wear — no heaviness, no dryness, and none of the tight or stiff sensation that some long-wearing formulas leave behind. Contact lens wearers specifically appreciate how little the product appears to migrate toward the eye area during the day.
A consistent subset of reviewers notes that the formula feels mildly tacky on the lid in the first few minutes post-application, before it fully sets and loses that surface stickiness. Users with dry or textured skin in the under-eye area also occasionally mention that the shimmer particles emphasize that texture more than they anticipated.

Suitable for:

The Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g is a strong pick for anyone who wants to cut down on the number of eye products they carry without sacrificing quality or finish. It suits people who move fast in the morning and need one tool that can function as both a lid color and a liner — no layering, no extra brushes required unless you want them. The Rose Quartz shade is particularly well-matched to those who gravitate toward soft, rosy neutrals that work across casual, professional, and evening settings. Frequent travelers will find the compact stick format easy to tuck into any bag, and the crease-resistant formula holds up reasonably well through long days. Those who already invest in prestige beauty and understand the price-per-use logic of a well-formulated luxury product will feel right at home with this eye stick.

Not suitable for:

If you have naturally oily lids, the Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g may not perform the way the packaging implies without a dedicated eye primer underneath — a detail worth knowing before committing to the price point. Those who prefer matte finishes will also want to look elsewhere, as this is strictly a shimmer formula with no matte option available in this stick. Buyers on a tight beauty budget should weigh the cost against the small 1.64g product size; this is a prestige item priced accordingly, and how far it stretches reflects that reality. If you routinely build complex, multi-shadow eye looks with multiple textures and finishes, this dual-use stick may feel like too limited a tool for your needs. Anyone expecting the 24-hour wear promise to hold across heat, humidity, or very active days is likely to be let down.

Specifications

  • Brand: This eyeshadow and liner stick is manufactured and sold under the Trish McEvoy brand.
  • Product Type: The product is a dual-function creamy stick designed for use as both an eyeshadow and an eyeliner.
  • Shade: The shade included in this listing is Rose Quartz, a rosy-toned neutral with a shimmer finish.
  • Net Weight: Each stick contains 1.64g (0.058oz) of product.
  • Finish: The formula delivers a shimmer finish, providing a luminous rather than matte effect on the lid.
  • Wear Claim: The brand states the formula is designed to remain in place for up to 24 hours without fading or smudging.
  • Formula: The formula is described by the manufacturer as crease-proof and long-wearing.
  • Application: The product can be applied directly from the stick tip and blended using a fingertip or a laydown brush.
  • Package Size: The outer packaging measures 5.12 x 1.26 x 0.91 inches.
  • Item Count: Each purchase includes one eyeshadow and liner stick.
  • Item Form: The product is housed in a twist-up stick format for controlled, brush-free application.
  • Discontinued: This product is not discontinued by the manufacturer and remains in active production as of the latest available listing data.
  • Market Tier: This product is positioned in the prestige beauty segment, above mass-market and drugstore alternatives.
  • Model Number: The manufacturer model number for this product is 24-HOUR EYE SHADOW AND LINER.
  • UPC: The registered UPC for this item is 791222953815.

Related Reviews

Trish McEvoy Fragrance X 50ml Perfume
Trish McEvoy Fragrance X 50ml Perfume
78%
88%
Scent Complexity
91%
Dry-Down Quality
74%
Longevity
61%
Projection & Sillage
63%
Value for Money
More
Trish McEvoy Intense Gel Eye Liner Deep Aubergine
Trish McEvoy Intense Gel Eye Liner Deep Aubergine
86%
93%
Ease of Application
88%
Long-Lasting Performance
90%
Color Payoff
87%
Smudge-Proof Durability
85%
Texture and Feel
More
Trish McEvoy Shape & Enhance Lip Liner - Barely Nude
Trish McEvoy Shape & Enhance Lip Liner - Barely Nude
88%
93%
Application Smoothness
89%
Color Versatility
85%
Long-Lasting Wear
90%
Finish & Texture
87%
Precision & Definition
More
Smashbox Photo Finish Intensify 24 Hour EyeShadow Primer 0.34oz
Smashbox Photo Finish Intensify 24 Hour EyeShadow Primer 0.34oz
85%
89%
Longevity of Wear
91%
Crease Resistance
83%
Skin Compatibility (Sensitive Skin)
87%
Application Ease
85%
Absorption Speed
More
Trish McEvoy Brush 1 EVEN SKIN Wet/Dry Face Perfector
Trish McEvoy Brush 1 EVEN SKIN Wet/Dry Face Perfector
89%
92%
Precision & Application
88%
Versatility with Wet & Dry Products
90%
Coverage & Finish
94%
Softness of Bristles
97%
Cruelty-Free Design
More
Ginger Lily Farms ZeroDerm 24 Hour Advanced Therapy Daily Moisture Lotion, 1 Gallon
Ginger Lily Farms ZeroDerm 24 Hour Advanced Therapy Daily Moisture Lotion, 1 Gallon
89%
94%
Hydration Effectiveness
91%
Fragrance-Free Formula
86%
Texture & Absorption
88%
Skin Sensitivity & Irritation
92%
Value for Money
More
ColourPop After Hours Eyeshadow Palette 0.65oz
ColourPop After Hours Eyeshadow Palette 0.65oz
80%
88%
Pigmentation
91%
Blendability
74%
Shade Range
76%
Longevity
61%
Glitter Performance
More
MAC Espresso 1.5g Powder Eyeshadow
MAC Espresso 1.5g Powder Eyeshadow
82%
88%
Pigmentation
91%
Blendability
74%
Wear Longevity
61%
Value for Money
82%
Shade Accuracy
More
ColourPop Golden Hour Eyeshadow Palette
ColourPop Golden Hour Eyeshadow Palette
87%
91%
Pigmentation & Color Payoff
88%
Blendability & Application
85%
Longevity & Wear Time
87%
Versatility for Day & Night Looks
82%
Texture & Feel on Skin
More
Trish McEvoy Beauty Booster Oil 30mL
Trish McEvoy Beauty Booster Oil 30mL
84%
91%
Hydration Effectiveness
88%
Non-Greasy Finish
93%
Skin Compatibility (Dry Skin)
89%
Absorption Speed
85%
Radiance Boost
More

FAQ

Honest answer: it depends heavily on your skin type. On normal to dry lids, the formula holds up well through a full workday with minimal fading or creasing. On oily lids, though, you are likely to see some breakdown well before the 24-hour mark — applying an eye primer first makes a significant difference. Treat the 24-hour figure as an upper limit under ideal conditions, not a universal guarantee.

A fingertip works perfectly fine and is actually how most people use this type of product day-to-day. The warmth of your finger helps blend the formula quickly and evenly across the lid. If you want a sharper liner edge or a more diffused look, a laydown brush gives you added control, but it is entirely optional.

The stick tip is precise enough to get close to the lash line, but the Rose Quartz shimmer shade is better suited to lid coverage than dedicated waterline use. Most waterline-specific formulas are waxier and more water-resistant by design. If you try it there, expect shorter wear time than you would get on the lid.

Not necessarily — on normal or dry lids, this eye stick performs well without one. That said, if you have oily skin or live somewhere warm and humid, a thin layer of eye primer will noticeably extend the wear and reduce any creasing. It is an easy extra step if longevity is a priority for you.

On deeper skin tones, Rose Quartz tends to read more subtly — the shimmer is still visible, but the rosy-pink pigment is less pronounced than it would appear on fair to medium complexions. It can work well as an inner-corner highlight or a soft lid accent, even if the full-lid payoff is more muted on deeper skin.

A standard micellar water or eye makeup remover on a cotton pad handles this formula well. For a formula that has set for several hours, letting the remover soak in for a few seconds before wiping makes the process much easier. An oil-based remover is the most efficient option for long-wearing shimmer products in general.

The Trish McEvoy 24-Hour Eyeshadow & Liner 1.64g is formulated for use on and around the eye area, but the brand does not specifically claim ophthalmologist testing on this product. Contact lens wearers should apply carefully and avoid getting product directly into the eye. If you have a history of reactions to shimmer or metallic eye products, reviewing the ingredient list first is a sensible step.

It is a twist-up stick, so no sharpener is needed. You simply rotate the base to advance the product as it wears down. Be careful not to extend too much at once — the formula is soft, and the tip can break off if it is pushed out too far before use.

It genuinely works for both, which is the main practical appeal of this format. A light, sweeping application across the lid gives you an all-over wash of color, while using the tip closer to the lash line creates a liner effect. The formula blends easily before it sets, so you can soften edges and adjust coverage with a fingertip in the same step.

Drugstore eye sticks in a comparable format often have softer pigmentation, shorter wear time, and a less refined shimmer payoff. The difference is noticeable, though whether it justifies the price gap is a personal call. If you rely on this style of product daily and already invest in quality eye makeup, the cost-per-use tends to look more reasonable over time — but if you use it occasionally, the premium price point is harder to rationalize against the small product size.