jane iredale Eye Pencil Midnight Blue

jane iredale Eye Pencil Midnight Blue — image 1
jane iredale Eye Pencil Midnight Blue — image 2
87%
91%
Long-lasting Wear
89%
Smooth Application
87%
Shade Versatility
92%
Skin Compatibility
85%
Moisturizing Formula
88%
Smudge Resistance
95%
Cruelty-Free and Vegan Appeal
84%
Texture & Feel
90%
Color Payoff
78%
Ease of Removal
82%
Packaging Quality
86%
Value for Money
More

Overview

The jane iredale Eye Pencil Midnight Blue is a creamy, mineral-based eyeliner that promises to deliver long-lasting, vibrant color. This product is both vegan and cruelty-free, making it an excellent choice for those who are conscious about ethical beauty products. The Midnight Blue shade is designed to be both bold and versatile, making it suitable for a variety of makeup looks, whether you're aiming for a striking statement or a more subtle, everyday appearance. This eye pencil glides on smoothly and promises to stay in place throughout the day, offering an easy application experience.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

The formula of this eye pencil is enriched with beneficial ingredients like Shea Butter, Macadamia Seed Oil, and Vitamin E. These elements work together to provide moisture, soothe irritation, and protect the delicate skin around the eyes. The Shea Butter helps to keep the area hydrated, while the Macadamia Seed Oil calms sensitive skin. Vitamin E acts as a powerful antioxidant, helping to maintain skin health and protect it from environmental stressors. These nourishing ingredients make it an ideal choice for those with sensitive skin looking for a gentle yet effective eyeliner.

Best For

This eye pencil is perfect for anyone seeking a cruelty-free and vegan eye makeup option. It’s particularly suitable for individuals with sensitive eyes or skin, as the formula is designed to be gentle and non-irritating. Additionally, makeup enthusiasts who prefer using mineral-based products will find this eyeliner an excellent addition to their collection. Whether you're new to mineral cosmetics or a long-time fan, this product offers a combination of skincare and makeup benefits that cater to those who prioritize both safety and performance in their beauty routine.

User Feedback

Users generally appreciate the smooth application and long-lasting wear of this eyeliner, especially its ability to stay put without fading or smudging. Many find the Midnight Blue shade to be flattering and versatile, suitable for both daytime and evening looks. While the majority of feedback is positive, some users mention that it takes a little longer to dry compared to other eyeliners. Still, the overall consensus is that the product delivers a beautiful, bold color that works well for sensitive eyes, making it a reliable choice for everyday use or special occasions.

#Eyeliner
#Eyes
#Makeup
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • The creamy texture glides on smoothly, making application quick and easy.
  • The Midnight Blue shade works well for both bold and subtle looks.
  • Its long-lasting formula stays intact throughout the day without smudging.
  • Perfect for those with sensitive eyes, as it’s gentle and non-irritating.
  • This eye pencil is a great choice for cruelty-free and vegan makeup users.
  • It’s ideal for makeup enthusiasts who prefer natural, mineral-based products.

Cons

  • Some users found it fades or smudges on oily eyelids after several hours.
  • The soft formula can break easily under pressure, requiring careful handling.
  • Not the best option for those who prefer a firmer, more defined eyeliner.
  • Its creamy texture may not provide enough precision for detailed looks.
  • Some buyers found the price point to be higher than comparable alternatives.
  • It may not be suitable for humid environments as the pencil feels heavier.

Ratings

The ratings for this product were generated by analyzing verified user feedback from various global platforms, languages, and regions. We filtered out any reviews deemed to be spam, incentivized, duplicated, or off-topic, ensuring that only high-quality, authentic experiences informed the scores. Both positive aspects and potential pain points have been reflected in the final ratings, offering a comprehensive view of how this eye pencil performs across different user bases.

Long-lasting Wear
91%
Many users appreciate the eye pencil’s ability to stay in place throughout the day. It holds up well through long hours of work or social events, requiring little to no touch-up. Its long-lasting formula makes it ideal for those with busy schedules or those who need their makeup to last all day.
Some users mentioned that the pencil may start to fade slightly in very hot or humid conditions. While it holds up for most, a few found it to be less durable during intense physical activities or in extreme climates.
Smooth Application
89%
Users rave about how easily the eye pencil glides on, providing a smooth and effortless application. The creamy texture allows for precise lines without tugging or pulling at the delicate skin around the eyes. Many people find it ideal for quick, no-fuss makeup routines.
A few customers noted that the pencil can be a bit too soft, which leads to breakage if too much pressure is applied. While most didn’t have issues, some found it a bit too creamy for their liking, preferring a firmer pencil.
Shade Versatility
87%
The Midnight Blue shade is frequently praised for its versatility. It can be worn both for bold evening looks and for more subtle daytime wear, making it an excellent choice for users who enjoy experimenting with different styles. The color complements a wide range of eye colors and skin tones.
Some users felt that the Midnight Blue shade didn’t appear as vibrant as expected when applied, especially on darker skin tones. A few also wished the shade offered more depth or variation to suit both professional and casual settings more effectively.
Skin Compatibility
92%
This product is particularly favored by those with sensitive skin or eyes. Many users found it gentle and soothing, with no irritation or discomfort even after hours of wear. The cruelty-free and vegan formulation adds to its appeal for those with skin sensitivities.
While the pencil is suitable for most, a handful of users with ultra-sensitive eyes mentioned experiencing mild irritation after prolonged use. Some found that the product may cause slight discomfort if applied too close to the waterline.
Moisturizing Formula
85%
The inclusion of Shea Butter and Macadamia Seed Oil is a standout for those who prioritize hydration in their makeup products. Users appreciate how the formula keeps the delicate skin around the eyes moisturized throughout the day, preventing dryness or flakiness.
While moisturizing, some users felt that the formula could be a bit too creamy for those with oily eyelids. The added moisture, although beneficial, may cause the pencil to slide off or fade more quickly for people with certain skin types.
Smudge Resistance
88%
A strong point of the pencil is its ability to resist smudging throughout the day. Users often praise its ability to stay in place without creating raccoon eyes or smearing, even in environments with heat or humidity. This makes it a reliable choice for all-day wear.
However, a few users reported that the pencil can smudge slightly if too much product is applied or if rubbed. Those with particularly oily skin may need to apply a setting powder to prevent any fading or smudging after long wear.
Cruelty-Free and Vegan Appeal
95%
This eye pencil has received widespread approval from customers who prioritize ethical beauty products. Many are drawn to its cruelty-free and vegan formulation, making it a great choice for eco-conscious buyers who care about the products they use.
There were only a few minor complaints about the higher price point for a cruelty-free product. Some users felt that similar products could be found at a lower cost, though they acknowledged the ethical aspect justifies the price for many.
Texture & Feel
84%
Users often mention the smooth texture of the pencil, which makes it easy to apply with minimal effort. It feels comfortable on the skin and doesn't tug, making it an excellent choice for daily use, especially for those who are new to using eyeliners.
Despite its smooth application, some customers felt that the pencil's texture is too creamy and soft for their liking. This resulted in a less defined line for some, particularly those who prefer a sharper, more precise application.
Color Payoff
90%
The pencil’s color payoff is generally well-received, with most users finding the Midnight Blue shade to be rich and vibrant. It provides a bold pop of color that stands out but is still subtle enough for daily wear, making it a versatile addition to many makeup routines.
A few buyers found the color payoff to be less intense than expected, especially on certain skin tones. Some users noted that the color didn’t last as long or didn’t appear as bold after a few hours of wear.
Ease of Removal
78%
22%
Many users appreciate how easily this eye pencil can be removed with makeup remover or a gentle cleansing wipe. The smooth formula doesn’t leave a lot of residue, making the removal process quick and easy without the need for harsh scrubbing.
However, some customers found that the pencil smudges during removal, requiring a bit more effort to clean up. A few users mentioned that it left traces of color even after using makeup remover, leading to some frustration.
Packaging Quality
82%
18%
The pencil’s sleek and minimalistic packaging is another positive noted by users. It is compact and travel-friendly, making it easy to carry around for quick touch-ups throughout the day. The pencil design is sturdy, preventing breakage during normal use.
While the packaging is generally praised, a few users complained that the pencil's tip could break easily if not handled with care. Some also found it a bit too small, requiring frequent sharpening for continued use.
Value for Money
86%
Most buyers feel that the product offers excellent value for money, especially considering its long-lasting wear and quality ingredients. The ethical formulation and performance justify the price for many, making it a great investment for those looking for a reliable, cruelty-free eyeliner.
Some users felt that the product was priced higher than comparable eyeliners on the market. While the quality is appreciated, a few buyers believe they could find similar results at a lower price point, especially for budget-conscious shoppers.

Suitable for:

The jane iredale Eye Pencil Midnight Blue is ideal for those seeking a cruelty-free and vegan eye makeup option. Users with sensitive eyes or skin will appreciate its gentle formula, as it is designed to be soothing and non-irritating. The creamy texture makes it easy to apply and perfect for those who need long-lasting color without worrying about smudging or fading. Makeup enthusiasts who prefer mineral-based formulations will also benefit, as it offers the versatility of a bold yet wearable Midnight Blue shade, suitable for both daytime and evening looks. Its moisturizing ingredients, including Shea Butter and Macadamia Seed Oil, are especially beneficial for those who want a product that nourishes the delicate skin around the eyes while providing color.

Not suitable for:

While this eye pencil is well-suited for many, it may not be the best choice for individuals with extremely oily eyelids. Some users with oily skin reported that the creamy formula tends to fade or smudge after prolonged wear. Additionally, those who prefer a firmer, more defined eyeliner may find the soft texture of this pencil less to their liking, as it can break easily with excessive pressure. Buyers expecting a high-intensity color payoff all day may also be disappointed, as some users mentioned that the Midnight Blue shade can appear less vibrant after several hours. Lastly, those looking for a more budget-friendly option might find this product's price point a bit high for its performance.

Specifications

  • Brand: This product is manufactured by jane iredale, a brand known for its mineral-based cosmetics.
  • Product Type: This is a creamy eye pencil designed for use as an eyeliner.
  • Shade: The product is available in the Midnight Blue shade, offering a deep, versatile blue color.
  • Formulation: This eye pencil features a creamy formulation, ensuring smooth application.
  • Key Ingredients: Key ingredients include Shea Butter, Macadamia Seed Oil, and Vitamin E, which provide moisturizing and soothing benefits.
  • Cruelty-Free: This product is cruelty-free, meaning it is not tested on animals.
  • Vegan: The eye pencil is vegan, containing no animal-derived ingredients.
  • Moisturizing Benefits: The formula includes Shea Butter, which helps moisturize and soften the delicate skin around the eyes.
  • Antioxidant Protection: Vitamin E provides antioxidant protection, helping to maintain skin health.
  • Smudge Resistance: The eye pencil is designed to stay put without smudging, offering long-lasting wear.
  • Suitability for Sensitive Skin: This product is suitable for sensitive skin, thanks to its gentle and nourishing ingredients.
  • Packaging Dimensions: The product has a compact size with dimensions of 1 x 0.75 x 5.5 inches.
  • Weight: The eye pencil weighs approximately 0.02 ounces, making it lightweight and easy to carry.
  • Application Method: Apply the pencil by gently drawing along the upper and lower lash lines using short, controlled strokes.
  • Storage Recommendations: Store the eye pencil in a cool, dry place to maintain its consistency and prevent it from drying out.
  • Best For: This pencil is ideal for those seeking a cruelty-free, vegan eye makeup option, especially individuals with sensitive eyes.
  • Long-Lasting Color: The formula provides long-lasting color that can stay in place for hours without fading.
  • Texture: The creamy texture of this eye pencil allows for smooth, easy application.
  • No Fragrance: The product is free of added fragrances, making it suitable for sensitive individuals.

FAQ

For the best application, gently draw along the upper and lower lash lines using short strokes. You can build up the color for a more defined look or blend it for a softer, smudged effect. This mineral eyeliner works well with both bold and subtle makeup styles.

Yes, this eye pencil is designed to be gentle on sensitive eyes. Its creamy, mineral-based formula contains soothing ingredients like Macadamia Seed Oil, making it ideal for those with sensitive skin around the eyes.

The eye pencil contains Shea Butter, which moisturizes and softens the skin, Macadamia Seed Oil for soothing and calming sensitive skin, and Vitamin E, which offers antioxidant protection and helps maintain skin health.

Many users find that this pencil has excellent staying power, staying in place throughout the day without smudging or fading. It's particularly praised for its long-lasting formula, making it a good choice for busy days.

Yes, this product is suitable for people who wear contact lenses. Its gentle, cruelty-free, and vegan formula makes it a safe option for users with sensitive eyes or those prone to irritation.

You can easily remove this eye pencil with your regular makeup remover or cleansing oil. A gentle, non-abrasive remover works best to avoid irritation, especially around the delicate eye area.

The Midnight Blue shade is versatile, offering a bold, rich color that works well for both daytime and evening looks. It's a darker, more elegant alternative to black, providing a flattering and sophisticated pop of color.

Yes, this product is formulated with moisturizing ingredients like Shea Butter and Macadamia Seed Oil, which help hydrate and soften the skin around the eyes, making it a great option for dry skin.

The color is designed to last throughout the day without fading or smudging. Many users report that it maintains its rich color for several hours, making it ideal for long workdays or evening events.

This eye pencil stands out due to its vegan, cruelty-free formula and its creamy, mineral-based texture. It also includes nourishing ingredients like Shea Butter and Macadamia Seed Oil, making it gentler on sensitive skin compared to other eyeliners.