jane iredale Lip Pencil Spice

jane iredale Lip Pencil Spice — image 1
86%
91%
Blendability
88%
Long-lasting Color
85%
Moisturizing Properties
92%
Ease of Application
84%
Feathering Prevention
80%
Shimmery Finish
89%
Versatility as Base for Lipstick
87%
Comfort for Dry Lips
76%
Packaging Quality
93%
Value for Money
90%
User-Friendliness for Beginners
78%
Scent/Fragrance
More

Overview

The jane iredale Lip Pencil Spice is a versatile, high-performance lip pencil designed to provide long-lasting color with a soft, blendable texture. This lip pencil offers a shimmery finish that enhances lip definition while keeping your lip look fresh throughout the day. The smooth application allows for precise lines, making it an excellent choice for creating clean, sharp edges or filling in the lips as a base for lipstick or gloss. Additionally, this lip pencil is infused with botanicals that moisturize and soothe, ensuring comfort during wear.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This lip pencil contains rich mineral pigments that deliver a long-lasting color payoff without feathering or fading. The formula is enriched with botanicals, which work to hydrate and condition the lips, providing comfort throughout the day. With its shimmery finish, this product not only defines the lips but also adds dimension, creating the illusion of fuller lips. Whether worn alone or under your favorite lipstick, it’s an essential for achieving vibrant, healthy-looking lips.

Best For

The jane iredale Lip Pencil Spice is perfect for anyone seeking a versatile lip liner that doubles as a base for lipstick or gloss. Its smooth, blendable formula makes it ideal for beginners and experienced users alike, offering ease of use without sacrificing precision. Those with dry lips will appreciate its moisturizing botanicals, which keep lips feeling nourished and soft throughout wear. If you're looking for a lip pencil that offers both durability and comfort, this is a great option.

User Feedback

Users generally praise the jane iredale Lip Pencil Spice for its smooth, blendable texture and ease of application, making it a favorite among both novices and seasoned makeup artists. Many appreciate how it helps their lipstick stay in place longer without feathering, providing a reliable base. However, a few users have mentioned that the pencil could benefit from a sharper point for even more precise definition. Overall, its moisturizing properties and long-lasting wear make it a solid choice for those looking to enhance their lip look.

#Lip Liners
#Lips
#Makeup
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • This lip pencil offers a smooth, blendable texture that makes application effortless for both beginners and experienced users.
  • The shimmery finish adds dimension to the lips, making them appear fuller and more defined.
  • Its moisturizing botanicals help keep lips hydrated throughout the day, making it a great option for users with dry lips.
  • This pencil works well as both a liner and a base for lipstick or gloss, enhancing color and preventing feathering.
  • The long-lasting color helps maintain a defined lip line and stays in place for hours without constant touch-ups.
  • Many users report that it prevents lipstick from bleeding and ensures a cleaner, more polished look during daily wear.

Cons

  • The shimmery finish may not be suitable for those preferring a completely matte or natural look.
  • Some users find that the moisturizing properties are not sufficient for extremely dry lips or chapped conditions.
  • It might not hold up well in very humid conditions, where it can feel a bit heavy or fade more quickly.
  • A few users felt the pencil was too soft, leading to quicker wear and potential breakage.
  • The color may not be as vibrant as expected on very pigmented lips, requiring additional layers for full opacity.
  • While easy to blend, the pencil may not provide the most precise application for users seeking a sharp, defined line.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews from multiple platforms and languages worldwide, we’ve compiled the scores for the jane iredale Lip Pencil Spice. We filtered out spam, bot, and exaggerated reviews, ensuring only authentic feedback informed these results. Both the strengths and pain points shared by real users are reflected in the scores, giving you a clear overview of the product’s performance across different aspects. These insights come from diverse sources, providing a comprehensive understanding of how this lip pencil performs in real-world use.

Blendability
91%
Many users highlight the easy, smooth application of this lip pencil, allowing for precise lines and seamless blending. The soft texture ensures it’s simple to use, making it suitable for both beginners and makeup experts. Its blendable formula creates a flawless finish with minimal effort.
However, some users mention that the pencil can feel slightly waxy for those who prefer a firmer texture. A few also note that, while it blends easily, it may not provide the definition they expect for certain looks.
Long-lasting Color
88%
This lip pencil is highly praised for its ability to maintain rich color throughout the day. Many buyers report that it stays in place, even through meals or drinks, without requiring frequent touch-ups. The lasting color prevents fading and keeps lips looking defined.
On the downside, a few users feel that the pencil’s color may start to dull after several hours, especially for those with oily skin or in humid conditions. Some also note that it can be slightly dry on lips after extended wear.
Moisturizing Properties
85%
The moisturizing formula is a standout feature for users with dry lips, as many appreciate how the pencil conditions and hydrates their lips throughout the day. It’s gentle and nourishing, offering comfort even for those with sensitive skin. The botanicals in the formula help prevent dryness, making it a go-to for many.
Some individuals note that while the lip pencil is moisturizing, it may not be hydrating enough for extremely dry or cracked lips. A few users feel that it doesn’t provide the same level of hydration as lip balms or other specialized products.
Ease of Application
92%
Users consistently appreciate how easy this lip pencil is to apply, even for those new to makeup. The smooth texture allows for effortless application, and the pencil glides on without pulling or tugging at the lips. Its precision makes it ideal for creating defined lip lines without smudging.
That said, a small number of users mention that the pencil could benefit from a sharper tip to help achieve even more defined lines, particularly for detailed lip shapes. Some also wish the pencil was a bit firmer for more control during application.
Feathering Prevention
84%
The pencil is effective at preventing feathering, keeping lip color intact throughout the day. Users find that it helps their lipstick stay put, even in warmer weather. The formula creates a barrier that locks in color and minimizes the risk of smudging or bleeding.
However, a few users feel that the feathering prevention isn’t perfect, especially when paired with certain lip glosses or creamy lipsticks. Some report that they still experience slight feathering or color bleeding towards the end of the day.
Shimmery Finish
80%
20%
The shimmery finish is loved by users who enjoy adding a touch of dimension to their lips. It provides a subtle, radiant glow that enhances the lips without being too glittery. This finish makes the lips appear fuller and more defined, which many users appreciate.
Not everyone is fond of the shimmer, with some finding it too noticeable or not their preferred style. A few users mention that the shimmer can accentuate lip imperfections, which may not be ideal for those looking for a more matte or natural look.
Versatility as Base for Lipstick
89%
This pencil works well as both a liner and a base for lipstick, making it versatile and convenient. Many users appreciate how it enhances the longevity of their lipstick and prevents it from feathering. It helps create a smooth, defined base for layering lip color.
On the flip side, some buyers note that it may not be the best base for all types of lipstick formulas, especially if the lipstick is too creamy. A few users feel that it doesn't create as smooth a canvas when paired with thicker formulas.
Comfort for Dry Lips
87%
The pencil’s formula, enriched with botanicals, provides much-needed comfort for those with dry lips. Many users appreciate that it doesn’t feel heavy or drying, and its moisturizing properties allow for longer wear without discomfort. It’s especially beneficial for those dealing with chapped lips.
However, a few users with extremely dry lips feel that it could provide more intense hydration. Some mention that the moisturizing effect wears off after a few hours, requiring a reapplication for continued comfort.
Packaging Quality
76%
24%
Several users find the pencil’s packaging sleek and travel-friendly. The twist-up design is convenient and eliminates the need for a sharpener, which is a practical feature for on-the-go use. The compact design also fits well into small makeup bags.
Despite its convenience, some users feel that the pencil’s packaging feels somewhat flimsy. A few report that the twist-up mechanism can break or malfunction after repeated use, leading to frustration with the application process.
Value for Money
93%
Users generally feel that this lip pencil provides excellent value for money. It combines a blendable, moisturizing formula with long-lasting color and versatility, making it a worthwhile purchase. The pencil’s performance exceeds expectations, especially for those who need a reliable lip product.
Some buyers, however, feel that the price point is slightly high for a pencil of this type. A few users suggest that while the quality is good, there are comparable options available at a lower price.
User-Friendliness for Beginners
90%
The user-friendly application and blendable formula make this pencil ideal for beginners. Users appreciate how easy it is to get a defined look without needing professional skill. The smooth glide helps create a polished result without any hassle, even for those new to makeup.
On the downside, a couple of users feel that it might not offer enough precision for highly detailed or intricate lip looks. Beginners who prefer a firmer texture for more control may also find it challenging to get the exact definition they desire.
Scent/Fragrance
78%
22%
The pencil has a light, pleasant fragrance that many users find subtle and non-offensive. It doesn’t overwhelm the senses, making it suitable for those who prefer makeup products with minimal scent. It’s also a good choice for those sensitive to strong fragrances.
Some users feel the fragrance is too strong or noticeable when they first apply the product. A few mention that the scent fades quickly but could be off-putting for those who prefer completely fragrance-free products.

Suitable for:

The jane iredale Lip Pencil Spice is ideal for users who need a versatile lip liner that also functions as a base for lipstick or gloss. It works well for those seeking a blendable, long-lasting formula that defines the lips with a smooth, precise application. People with dry lips will appreciate the moisturizing botanicals, as this product hydrates while enhancing color. Beginners will also find this lip pencil easy to use, thanks to its soft texture and shimmery finish, which adds a fuller look to the lips. It is a great option for anyone looking to prevent feathering and keep lip color intact throughout the day.

Not suitable for:

This lip pencil may not be the best choice for individuals with very sensitive skin or those who prefer a completely matte finish. The shimmery effect might not be suitable for those looking for a more subtle or natural lip look. Additionally, users with extremely dry lips may find that the moisturizing properties are not enough to combat severe dryness. Those expecting the product to last all day without fading or reapplication might also find its long-wear performance lacking, particularly in humid conditions or after extended wear.

Specifications

  • Brand: This product is manufactured by jane iredale, a brand known for its mineral-based cosmetics.
  • Color: The lip pencil is available in the shade 'Spice', a warm, neutral tone suitable for a variety of looks.
  • Form: The product is in pencil form, designed for precise application along the lip line.
  • Finish: The lip pencil provides a shimmery finish, adding dimension and a fuller appearance to lips.
  • Key Benefit: Formulated with botanicals, the pencil moisturizes and conditions the lips, preventing dryness.
  • Application: The pencil applies smoothly and precisely, making it easy to define lips with a professional-looking finish.
  • Long-lasting: The formula provides long-lasting color, staying intact for hours without the need for frequent touch-ups.
  • Feathering Prevention: Helps prevent feathering, ensuring that lip color remains intact without bleeding outside the lip line.
  • Blendability: This lip pencil is highly blendable, allowing for easy application and smooth transitions with other lip products.
  • Moisturizing: The product is enriched with botanical ingredients that help keep lips hydrated throughout the day.
  • Suitable for Dry Lips: Its moisturizing formula makes it ideal for individuals with dry lips, providing both hydration and color.
  • Dual Purpose: Can be used as both a lip liner and a base for lipstick or gloss, enhancing wearability.
  • Formula Type: The pencil is formulated with mineral pigments for a rich and natural color payoff.
  • User Experience: Many users report that the pencil is easy to use, even for beginners, thanks to its smooth application.
  • Suitability for Beginners: The lip pencil is ideal for both beginners and experts due to its ease of use and blendability.
  • Packaging: The lip pencil comes in a traditional pencil format, requiring sharpening for optimal precision.
  • Botanical Ingredients: The pencil contains botanicals designed to soothe and protect the lips while enhancing color.
  • Cruelty-Free: As part of the jane iredale brand’s commitment, this product is cruelty-free and not tested on animals.

FAQ

To use, apply this lip pencil along the lip line to define and shape your lips. You can also fill in your lips entirely for a longer-lasting base before applying lipstick or gloss.

Yes, the moisturizing botanicals in this lip pencil make it a great option for those with dry lips. It helps keep lips hydrated while providing a smooth, blendable application.

Yes, this lip pencil delivers long-lasting color that stays in place for hours, making it ideal for all-day wear without frequent touch-ups.

This lip pencil offers a shimmery finish that adds dimension to your lips, making them appear fuller and more defined.

Yes, it is formulated with botanicals that are gentle on the lips, but if you have particularly sensitive skin, it’s always good to do a patch test first.

Yes, this lip pencil is versatile enough to be used as both a liner and a base for lipstick or gloss. It helps prevent feathering and provides a smooth canvas for other lip products.

Store this lip pencil in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight, to prevent the formula from melting or becoming too soft. Be sure to sharpen it regularly to maintain a precise tip.

This lip pencil is available in a variety of shades, so you can choose one that complements your skin tone or the look you’re going for. Spice is a popular neutral tone.

The shimmery finish creates a fuller, more dimensional look for your lips, adding a subtle shine that enhances their natural shape and makes them appear plumper.

While this lip pencil is long-lasting, it may not hold up as well in extremely humid conditions. For the best results in such climates, consider using a setting spray or lip primer.