Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, 2 Matte Tonka

Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, 2 Matte Tonka — image 1
Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, 2 Matte Tonka — image 2
Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, 2 Matte Tonka — image 3
Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, 2 Matte Tonka — image 4
88%
92%
Longevity/Duration
95%
Waterproof Performance
88%
Precision of Application
83%
Matte Finish
90%
Ease of Use
89%
Ingredient Quality (Rosehip Oil, Vitamin E)
87%
Packaging & Convenience (Sharpener)
91%
Smudge Resistance
84%
Suitability for Sensitive Skin
93%
Color Intensity
86%
Value for Money
81%
Consistency Across Batches
More

Overview

The Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, 2 Matte Tonka is a high-performance eyeliner designed for precision and durability. This waterproof, retractable pencil delivers a bold, matte finish with an easy-to-use, creamy yet firm tip. Thanks to its integrated sharpener, it's perfect for on-the-go application, ensuring you always have a sharp line wherever you are. Whether you’re heading to work or out for the evening, this eyeliner offers a long-lasting, smudge-proof solution for your makeup routine.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

Formulated with nourishing ingredients like Rosehip Oil, Bisabolol, and Vitamin E, this eyeliner is not only effective but also gentle on the skin. Its long-lasting and smudge-proof formula ensures that your eyeliner stays intact, even in challenging conditions like sweat or humidity. The creamy tip offers smooth, precise application, making it easy to create both thin and thick lines. Whether you need a subtle or bold look, this waterproof eyeliner guarantees consistent, reliable results throughout the day.

Best For

This eyeliner is ideal for individuals looking for a waterproof and long-wearing pencil that can handle a busy day. Those who need precision for creating both thin and thick lines will find this pencil a perfect choice. If you're someone who values a matte finish and requires a dependable eyeliner that holds up throughout the day, this product is an excellent addition to your makeup collection. It’s especially suitable for those who need a reliable eyeliner that won’t budge in humid or rainy conditions.

User Feedback

Many users praise this eyeliner for its intense color and smooth application, with a few mentioning how easy it is to create defined lines. Its waterproof and long-lasting properties are frequently highlighted, making it a popular choice for those who need a dependable product for all-day wear. On the downside, some users note that while the matte finish is perfect for daily use, it might not deliver the dramatic look that others prefer. Overall, most users are pleased with its durability and consistency.

#Eyeliner
#Eyes
#Makeup
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • The waterproof formula holds up well in humid or rainy conditions, making it ideal for all-day wear.
  • Offers smooth, precise application that works well for both thin and thick eyeliner looks.
  • The integrated sharpener makes it convenient for on-the-go use without needing extra tools.
  • Enriched with nourishing ingredients like Rosehip Oil, which helps keep the delicate eye area comfortable.
  • Its matte finish provides a more subtle, natural look that’s suitable for daily wear.
  • Long-lasting, it stays intact even during busy workdays or active outdoor activities.

Cons

  • The matte finish may not be bold enough for users seeking a more dramatic eyeliner look.
  • Some users reported that the pencil tip feels a bit too firm, making application less smooth for certain preferences.
  • This product may not be suitable for those with very oily skin, as it can smudge or fade over time.
  • Not ideal for sensitive eyes, as some users experienced mild irritation during extended wear.
  • The color may not appear as intense on darker skin tones, requiring multiple layers for full coverage.
  • Its firm texture may make it harder to blend for those looking for a softer, smudged eyeliner effect.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews from a variety of international sources, we gathered insights from multiple languages and platforms to assess the Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, 2 Matte Tonka. Spam, bot, incentivized, and duplicate reviews were filtered out, ensuring only high-quality, authentic feedback contributed to the results. Both strengths and pain points are reflected in the scores, providing a balanced perspective for potential buyers.

Longevity/Duration
92%
Many users appreciate the long-lasting effect of this product. It holds up well throughout the day, even in humid or rainy conditions, providing confidence for all-day wear without the need for reapplication. This makes it a great option for busy days or outdoor events.
However, a few users mentioned that while the eyeliner is long-lasting, it can feel slightly dry when first applied, especially for those with very sensitive skin. Some also reported a minor smudging after several hours of wear in extreme conditions.
Waterproof Performance
95%
This waterproof eyeliner is praised for its exceptional resistance to water, sweat, and tears. Reviewers often mention that it stays put even during intense activities or exposure to moisture, making it ideal for workouts, rainy days, or long nights.
That said, some users noted that removal can be a bit challenging, requiring a good makeup remover to fully clean the area. A few also mentioned it could potentially cause slight irritation around the eyes after prolonged wear.
Precision of Application
88%
The precise tip of the pencil allows for smooth and accurate application, even when creating finer lines. Users appreciate how easy it is to achieve both subtle and bold looks without worrying about unevenness or smudging.
Despite the precision, some reviewers mentioned that the tip can wear down quickly with frequent use. Additionally, there were a few reports of the pencil feeling a bit too firm for those who prefer a softer, more forgiving eyeliner texture.
Matte Finish
83%
The matte finish of this eyeliner is loved by those who prefer a sophisticated, understated look. It provides a smooth, non-glossy definition that works well for both everyday use and professional settings.
However, some users found the matte finish to be too subtle for occasions where they prefer a more dramatic, shiny look. Others mentioned that the finish could sometimes appear a bit flat compared to other eyeliner formulations with a glossier effect.
Ease of Use
90%
The retractable design and integrated sharpener make this eyeliner incredibly user-friendly. Buyers appreciate the convenience of not having to deal with sharpening and the ease of carrying it around for touch-ups on the go.
A few users mentioned that the pencil can break or become difficult to apply when it’s too cold or dry. Some also noted that while the sharpener is handy, it doesn’t always work as smoothly as expected, occasionally leaving the pencil blunt.
Ingredient Quality (Rosehip Oil, Vitamin E)
89%
The inclusion of nourishing ingredients like Rosehip Oil and Vitamin E is highly appreciated, especially by users with sensitive skin. These ingredients help provide a comfortable wear throughout the day, keeping the delicate skin around the eyes moisturized and protected.
While the ingredients are praised, some users with very sensitive eyes experienced mild irritation. A few also felt that the inclusion of these ingredients didn’t significantly enhance the performance of the product compared to other eyeliners without such formulations.
Packaging & Convenience (Sharpener)
87%
The integrated sharpener adds an extra layer of convenience for those who are always on the go. It ensures that users can maintain a precise tip without the hassle of carrying an additional sharpener separately, making this eyeliner practical for travel.
However, some users found the sharpener to be a bit too small or difficult to use, leading to frustration when trying to maintain the pencil’s point. Others felt that it could have been designed more efficiently for smoother operation.
Smudge Resistance
91%
This eyeliner is highly resistant to smudging, even during long days or hot, sweaty conditions. Many buyers report that it stays intact through activities like exercising or wearing makeup all day without needing to worry about it running or leaving marks under the eyes.
On the downside, a few users noted that while it’s generally smudge-resistant, it may not hold up well against very oily skin, with some experiencing fading or slight transfer. Others mentioned that the liner could still smudge if rubbed excessively.
Suitability for Sensitive Skin
84%
This eyeliner’s formulation is gentle enough for users with sensitive skin, and many appreciate that it doesn’t cause irritation. The use of calming ingredients like Bisabolol helps reduce the likelihood of reactions, making it a solid option for those prone to sensitivity around the eyes.
Despite the gentle ingredients, some users with extra-sensitive skin experienced mild discomfort, particularly when wearing the eyeliner for extended periods. A few also mentioned that it can feel a little heavy on the skin, especially in the inner corners of the eyes.
Color Intensity
93%
Users are highly impressed with the rich, intense color payoff this eyeliner delivers. The deep hue creates a bold, defined look that stays vibrant throughout the day, which is perfect for anyone looking for a high-impact eyeliner.
While many loved the color intensity, some users felt that the shade could be too strong for everyday wear, especially in more subtle or natural makeup looks. Additionally, a few complained that the color fades slightly in very humid or wet environments.
Value for Money
86%
Many customers find the price of this eyeliner justified by its premium features, such as the long-lasting wear, quality ingredients, and ease of use. The integrated sharpener also adds extra value, making it a solid purchase for those seeking both performance and convenience.
However, some users feel the price is a bit steep compared to other high-end eyeliners with similar performance. A few buyers mentioned that while the product is good, it doesn’t stand out enough to warrant such a premium price.
Consistency Across Batches
81%
19%
While most users are satisfied with the product's performance, there’s a general sense of consistency in the quality of this eyeliner, with most batches delivering solid results. Many buyers note that their experiences were largely positive, with only occasional minor issues.
A handful of users reported slight variations in texture or consistency between batches, such as differences in firmness or color payoff. These inconsistencies led to some disappointment, particularly for repeat buyers who expected uniform quality.

Suitable for:

The Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, 2 Matte Tonka is ideal for users who prioritize long-lasting, waterproof performance. Those with active lifestyles or who spend time outdoors will appreciate its resistance to rain, sweat, and tears. It's also well-suited for individuals looking for precision in their eyeliner application, as it allows for both thin and bold lines with ease. Additionally, this eyeliner's matte finish is perfect for those seeking a more subtle, everyday look that remains intact throughout the day. Those with sensitive skin will also find this product beneficial, as it is enriched with nourishing ingredients like Rosehip Oil and Vitamin E, ensuring comfort and care during wear.

Not suitable for:

This eyeliner may not be the best choice for users who prefer a dramatic, glossy finish. The matte effect is subtle and may not provide the bold, shiny look some users desire for evening wear or special occasions. Additionally, individuals with very oily skin may experience smudging or fading over time, as some reviews mentioned slight transfer during high humidity. Those who have very sensitive eyes or are prone to irritation may also find that this product causes mild discomfort, especially after extended wear. Lastly, users expecting a more forgiving, softer application may find the pencil's firm tip too rigid for their liking.

Specifications

  • Product Type: Retractable waterproof eyeliner pencil.
  • Shade: 2 Matte Tonka – a rich matte brown shade.
  • Waterproof: The formula is waterproof, resistant to rain, sweat, and tears.
  • Finish: Matte finish that provides a bold and defined look.
  • Precision Tip: The eyeliner features a fine precision tip for detailed application.
  • Integrated Sharpener: Includes a built-in sharpener for easy on-the-go use.
  • Key Ingredients: Contains Rosehip Oil, Bisabolol, and Vitamin E for nourishment and comfort.
  • Smudge-proof: The eyeliner is designed to be smudge-proof for long-lasting wear.
  • Long-lasting: Offers long-lasting performance throughout the day, even in humid conditions.
  • Sensitive Skin Friendly: Formulated for sensitive skin, minimizing the risk of irritation.
  • Retractable: The eyeliner pencil is retractable, ensuring convenience and no mess.
  • Formula Type: Creamy, firm formula that glides smoothly for precise application.
  • Application Type: Designed for easy application along the upper and lower lash lines.
  • Suitability: Ideal for both thin and thick eyeliner looks, depending on preference.
  • Packaging: Comes in a sleek, travel-friendly pencil form with a built-in sharpener.
  • Fragrance: Fragrance-free, making it suitable for sensitive eyes and skin.
  • Size: Standard pencil size for precision and ease of use.
  • Durability: Highly durable, holding up well during long wear or in hot, humid conditions.

FAQ

To apply this waterproof eyeliner, simply twist up the pencil and glide it along your lash line for a precise, defined look. The creamy texture allows smooth application, whether you're creating a thin line or a thicker, bolder style.

The integrated sharpener is a convenient feature that ensures your eyeliner pencil remains sharp for precise application, even when you're on the go. It helps maintain a fine tip, which is crucial for creating defined lines.

This eyeliner is suitable for most skin types, including sensitive skin. The formula is designed to be gentle and nourishing with ingredients like Rosehip Oil and Vitamin E, which help to care for the delicate eye area.

No, this product is designed to be smudge-proof and long-lasting, even in humid or rainy conditions. It stays intact for hours, making it ideal for long days or active wear.

This pencil provides a matte finish, giving your eyes a bold yet natural look. It offers a defined, intense color without the shine of traditional eyeliners, which makes it great for both daily and special occasion use.

Yes, the precision tip of this retractable pencil allows for both thin, delicate lines and thicker, bolder looks. Whether you prefer a subtle line or a dramatic cat-eye, this eyeliner is versatile enough for both.

The waterproof formula is designed to resist moisture, sweat, and tears, ensuring your eyeliner stays intact even in challenging conditions like rain or humidity. This makes it perfect for all-day wear without worrying about smudging.

Yes, this product is generally safe for contact lens wearers. Its formula is designed to be gentle on the eyes, but if you have particularly sensitive eyes or experience irritation, it's always best to do a patch test first.

To keep your eyeliner in good condition, store it in a cool, dry place and always make sure the cap is securely closed. Avoid leaving it in direct sunlight or heat, as extreme temperatures can affect its performance.

No, this eyeliner does not have a strong fragrance. It is formulated to be sensitive-skin-friendly, so it should not cause irritation or discomfort, even for those with fragrance sensitivities.