Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil - Mildew

87%

Longevity

Smudge-proof Performance

Ease of Application

Texture & Comfort

Shade Variety & Appeal

Hydration & Skin Care Benefits

Packaging & Presentation

Sensitivity & Eye Safety

Value for Money

Vegan & Cruelty-Free

Color Payoff & Pigmentation

Overall Satisfaction

Removal Ease

Overview

The Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil - Mildew is a highly acclaimed waterproof eyeliner known for its impressive staying power and smooth application. This eyeliner pencil is available in the stunning Mildew shade, a deep forest green that adds a unique twist to your eye makeup. With a formulation designed for long-lasting wear, it provides up to 16 hours of color that won’t fade or transfer. Its smooth, no-tug texture ensures easy application, making it a go-to for anyone looking for bold, lasting eye definition.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This eyeliner pencil is infused with a blend of hydrating ingredients like Vitamin E, Jojoba Oil, and Cottonseed Oil, which contribute to its smooth and comfortable glide-on texture. The formula nourishes the delicate skin around your eyes while providing vibrant, rich color. Vitamin E, in particular, helps protect the sensitive skin of your eyelids from environmental stressors, ensuring that the eyeliner not only looks great but also supports the health of the skin. Ideal for those seeking a long-lasting product, this eyeliner delivers both beauty and care.

Best For

The 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil is perfect for anyone seeking a smudge-proof eyeliner that stands up to long days. It’s especially suitable for those with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, as its gentle formula won’t irritate the eyes. Makeup lovers who enjoy experimenting with bold yet versatile shades will appreciate the Mildew color, a rich, deep green that works well for both subtle and dramatic looks. Additionally, this eyeliner is ideal for those who prefer cruelty-free and vegan beauty products.

User Feedback

Users rave about this eyeliner’s smooth application and the intense color payoff it provides. Many reviewers have noted that it stays put throughout the day, even in humid conditions, making it a reliable choice for long-wear. The Mildew shade, with its unique green undertones, is often mentioned for adding an exciting pop to makeup routines. However, a few users have pointed out that it might require a little more precision during application due to its creamy texture, but overall, it remains a favorite for creating both bold and subtle eye looks.

#Eyeliner

#Eyes

#Makeup

#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

The Mildew shade offers a unique, deep forest green that adds a bold touch to eye looks.
Smooth, no-tug application ensures comfortable use without irritating the skin.
Waterproof and smudge-proof formula stays intact for up to 16 hours, even in humid conditions.
The eyeliner is ideal for people with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses.
Infused with hydrating ingredients like Vitamin E and Jojoba Oil, it nourishes the skin around the eyes.
Vegan and cruelty-free, making it a great choice for ethically-conscious consumers.

Cons

Some users find the Mildew shade harder to pair with other makeup looks.
The eyeliner may not hold up well in extremely hot and sweaty conditions.
While comfortable to apply, it may slightly irritate eyes after long periods of wear for some users.
The product is relatively expensive compared to other eyeliners with similar benefits.
Not ideal for those seeking a wider range of color options in the same formula.
A few users report minor fading towards the end of a long day, especially in high humidity.

Ratings

The ratings for the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil - Mildew are based on a comprehensive analysis of verified customer feedback from multiple countries and platforms. RR-AI filtered out any spam, incentivized, or off-topic reviews, ensuring that only high-quality, authentic responses informed the scores. The results reflect both strengths and pain points mentioned by users, offering a balanced overview of this product’s performance in real-world conditions.

Longevity

91%

Many users are impressed by the staying power of this product, noting that it truly lasts for up to 16 hours without fading or transferring. This is especially praised for long workdays and humid environments, where other eyeliners tend to smudge or disappear. The formula delivers on its promise of long-lasting wear even in challenging conditions.

However, a few users mention that, despite the long wear, they experience some light fading or slight transfer toward the end of the day, particularly if they have very oily eyelids. In some cases, the eyeliner needs a touch-up during late hours to maintain its full intensity.

Smudge-proof Performance

88%

The smudge-proof quality of this eyeliner pencil is widely praised, with many users reporting that it holds up remarkably well even through rubbing or accidental touches. For people with active lifestyles, it stays in place, offering confidence that their eye makeup will stay intact throughout the day.

A small number of buyers, however, report that while the product is generally smudge-proof, it can sometimes smudge in extremely humid or sweaty conditions. Additionally, a few users mention that the product can transfer slightly onto the lower lash line after hours of wear.

Ease of Application

87%

Users appreciate the smooth, glide-on texture that makes application effortless, even for beginners. The no-tug formula is ideal for creating sharp, defined lines or soft, smudged looks. Its creamy consistency provides a comfortable, seamless application without pulling at delicate skin around the eyes.

Despite the smooth application, a few users feel that it requires a steady hand for precise lines. Some also mention that the pencil can feel slightly too soft, leading to breakage or uneven application if too much pressure is applied.

Texture & Comfort

90%

The formula's hydrating ingredients, including Vitamin E and Jojoba Oil, make this product not only comfortable to wear but also nourishing for the delicate skin around the eyes. Many reviewers find that it does not dry out or irritate the skin, even after long hours of wear.

A few users with very sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses report minor irritation or discomfort after wearing it for several hours. While most find it gentle, there are occasional complaints about the formula being slightly heavy for certain eye types.

Shade Variety & Appeal

84%

The Mildew shade, a deep forest green, is frequently highlighted as a unique and vibrant color choice. Many users find that it adds an intriguing twist to their makeup looks, offering a bold yet sophisticated alternative to traditional black eyeliners. It's particularly popular for evening or artistic makeup styles.

Some users, however, find the deep green hue to be too bold or unconventional for daily wear. A few feel that it doesn't pair well with all eye colors or makeup looks, limiting its versatility for certain tastes.

Hydration & Skin Care Benefits

85%

Several users love the added benefit of hydration, with ingredients like Jojoba Oil and Vitamin E helping to maintain comfort and prevent dryness throughout the day. This makes it particularly beneficial for those with dry or sensitive skin around the eyes, offering a more soothing option compared to other eyeliners.

On the flip side, some buyers report that the hydrating elements can make the pencil feel slightly too creamy, leading to quicker wear-off in some cases. There are occasional complaints about it not being as long-lasting as expected when compared to other, non-hydrating formulas.

Packaging & Presentation

82%

18%

The packaging is sleek and practical, with the twist-up design ensuring no sharpening is needed. Many users find the pencil format convenient for on-the-go touch-ups and appreciate the neat, easy-to-use design that doesn't require extra maintenance.

However, a few users express concerns about the pencil's fragility, particularly in travel bags or makeup pouches. There are also occasional complaints about the twist-up mechanism being too loose or malfunctioning after a period of use.

Sensitivity & Eye Safety

92%

Those with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers particularly praise this eyeliner for being gentle and non-irritating. The formula is designed with eye safety in mind, making it a great choice for people prone to eye discomfort or allergic reactions from other makeup products.

Nevertheless, a small subset of users report mild irritation after extended wear, especially those with very sensitive skin or a history of eye allergies. For some, this product may not be suitable for all-day wear without slight discomfort.

Value for Money

89%

Many customers believe the eyeliner offers solid value for its performance, especially considering its long-lasting, smudge-proof qualities. The added bonus of skin-nourishing ingredients makes it feel like a premium product without the hefty price tag of some high-end brands.

On the downside, some users feel the price point is a bit high compared to other eyeliners with similar qualities. A few also mention that it can feel pricey for those who primarily need a basic eyeliner for everyday use.

Vegan & Cruelty-Free

95%

This product is highly praised for being vegan and cruelty-free, making it a top choice for ethically conscious consumers. Many users appreciate that they can trust the brand’s commitment to cruelty-free practices, making it a guilt-free addition to their makeup routine.

However, a small number of buyers mention that while the cruelty-free aspect is important, it doesn't significantly influence their overall product satisfaction. Some would prefer more eco-friendly or sustainable packaging as part of the ethical appeal.

Color Payoff & Pigmentation

86%

Users consistently mention the vibrant pigmentation of the Mildew shade, noting that it provides intense color payoff with just one swipe. The deep forest green is especially appealing for those seeking a bold, yet wearable, eyeliner option for both day and night looks.

On the other hand, a few users find that the color payoff isn’t as rich as expected on their skin tone, especially for lighter or fair skin types. Some also mention that it requires more layers to achieve the desired intensity on certain eyelid types.

Overall Satisfaction

89%

Overall, this eyeliner is a hit with many users, offering impressive performance in terms of longevity, comfort, and pigmentation. Buyers appreciate its versatility for both bold and subtle looks, as well as its skin-friendly ingredients that keep the delicate eye area nourished throughout the day.

Some dissatisfaction arises from minor issues like the pencil’s softness leading to breakage or the deep green shade not being universally flattering. A few users also wish for a wider range of color options in this formula to suit different preferences.

Removal Ease

75%

25%

Several users mention that the eyeliner is relatively easy to remove with a makeup remover or micellar water, which is a plus for those who want a no-hassle cleansing routine. It doesn’t leave behind stubborn residue, making the removal process quick and effective.

However, some buyers note that it can be a bit challenging to fully remove, especially after long wear. A few users report that they need to use stronger cleansing products or multiple wipes to get rid of all traces of the eyeliner.

Suitable for:

This eyeliner pencil is an excellent choice for users seeking a long-lasting, smudge-proof eyeliner with vibrant color. The 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil in Mildew is perfect for individuals who need their makeup to stay in place all day, especially those with active lifestyles or in humid environments. Makeup enthusiasts who enjoy rich, deep colors will appreciate the unique forest green shade, which adds a bold twist to eye looks. Additionally, this product is ideal for people with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses, thanks to its smooth, gentle formula. It also suits anyone looking for a cruelty-free and vegan eyeliner that performs well while being kind to the skin around the eyes.

Not suitable for:

This eyeliner may not be the best fit for users with very oily skin or those prone to excessive sweating, as some reports suggest that it may slightly fade or transfer after extended wear in humid conditions. Additionally, individuals with extremely sensitive eyes might find the product slightly irritating after long hours of use, despite its hydrating ingredients. Those expecting a wider range of color options in this formula may also be disappointed, as the Mildew shade might not be versatile enough for every look. Lastly, users looking for a more budget-friendly option might find this product a bit pricier compared to other similar eyeliners on the market.

Specifications

Shade: The eyeliner is available in the Mildew shade, a deep forest green color.
Type: This product is a pencil eyeliner, designed for precise application.
Waterproof: The eyeliner is waterproof, offering long-lasting wear without smudging.
Smudge-proof: It is smudge-proof, ensuring that the liner stays in place throughout the day.
Wear Time: Provides up to 16 hours of wear without fading or transferring.
Texture: The formula has a smooth, no-tug texture for easy, comfortable application.
Key Ingredients: Contains Vitamin E, Jojoba Oil, and Cottonseed Oil, which hydrate and nourish the skin around the eyes.
Vegan: This eyeliner is vegan, making it suitable for cruelty-free beauty routines.
Cruelty-Free: It is a cruelty-free product, ensuring no animal testing was involved in its development.
Ideal For: Best for those looking for long-lasting, vibrant eyeliner suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens users.
Pigmentation: Offers intense color payoff, providing rich, vibrant pigmentation in a single application.
Application: Designed to glide on smoothly with no tugging or pulling, offering an easy and precise application.
Fragrance: This product has no strong fragrance, making it ideal for users sensitive to scent.
Shade Description: Mildew is a deep forest green that adds a unique twist to standard black and brown eyeliners.
Packaging: Comes in a standard pencil format for ease of use and portability.
Storage: Store in a cool, dry place to maintain the product's consistency and longevity.
Texture After Application: Once applied, the eyeliner remains smooth and does not dry out or flake off.
Water Resistance: Its waterproof nature makes it resistant to sweat, rain, and humidity.
User Experience: Users report that the eyeliner stays in place without reapplication, even in humid conditions.

FAQ

To apply, simply glide the pencil along your upper and lower lash lines for defined eyes. The smooth, no-tug texture makes it easy to apply without any pulling or tugging, providing a precise finish. For added intensity, you can layer it or smudge it for a smoky look.

The Mildew shade is a deep forest green with a unique, rich tone that adds a twist to your typical black or brown eyeliner. It's perfect for those looking to create bold, yet subtle, eye looks with a bit of color. The shade works well for both daytime and evening looks.

Yes, this eyeliner is formulated to be gentle on sensitive eyes and is safe for contact lens wearers. It’s free from harsh chemicals, making it a great option for those with sensitive skin around the eyes.

The formula provides up to 16 hours of wear without fading or transferring. It's waterproof and smudge-proof, so you can expect it to stay intact even in humid environments or through long days without reapplication.

This eyeliner contains hydrating ingredients like Vitamin E, Jojoba Oil, and Cottonseed Oil. These ingredients help nourish the delicate skin around your eyes while providing a smooth, glide-on application for ultimate comfort.

Yes, the eyeliner's smooth texture allows for versatile application. You can create bold, defined lines for a dramatic look or blend it out for a softer, smoky eye effect, depending on your desired style.

No, this eyeliner has a neutral scent, making it suitable for those sensitive to fragrance. Its focus is on delivering long-lasting color without any overpowering odors.

Yes, this eyeliner can be safely used on the waterline and lower lash line. Its smudge-proof and waterproof formula ensures it stays in place even in these sensitive areas.

Store the eyeliner in a cool, dry place to maintain its smooth, glide-on texture. Avoid leaving it in direct sunlight or in a hot environment, as extreme temperatures can affect the product’s consistency.

This eyeliner is formulated with nourishing ingredients like Vitamin E and Jojoba Oil, so it should not cause dryness or irritation for most users. However, if you have extremely sensitive skin, it’s always a good idea to patch test first.