Overview

The Maybelline Total Temptation Waterproof Mascara, Brownish Black, 0.3 fl. oz. is a standout choice for anyone seeking defined, bold lashes. This waterproof formula ensures smudge-free wear throughout the day, perfect for long-lasting results. The mascara is designed to add volume and length to your lashes without any clumping or flaking, leaving behind a smooth and clean finish. Its rich Brownish Black shade offers a natural yet striking look, making it ideal for both everyday use and special occasions. With a sleek 0.3 fl. oz. tube, this mascara is easy to carry and apply.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This mascara is crafted with a waterproof formula, making it perfect for those who need long-lasting, smudge-proof wear. The creamy texture ensures a smooth and easy application, allowing you to coat your lashes evenly without worrying about clumping. It enhances your lashes with bold definition and added volume while maintaining a lightweight feel. The formula is enriched with ingredients that nourish and condition, helping to keep lashes looking full and beautiful throughout the day, even in humid or rainy conditions.

Best For

Maybelline Total Temptation Waterproof Mascara is ideal for those seeking a mascara that offers both volume and length without clumping. Its waterproof properties make it a great option for individuals with active lifestyles or those in need of a long-lasting solution for all-day wear. It’s also suitable for people with sensitive eyes, offering a smudge-proof option that won’t irritate or cause discomfort. Whether you’re heading to the gym, a long day at work, or a night out, this mascara delivers a reliable, defined lash look.

User Feedback

Many users rave about the impressive lash volume that this mascara delivers without the heaviness or clumping often associated with other mascaras. A large percentage appreciate its waterproof nature, particularly for its ability to stay intact through sweat and humidity. However, a few users mention that it can be slightly difficult to remove at the end of the day, requiring a good makeup remover. Despite this, most find that it works well for both casual and more dramatic lash looks, making it versatile for various occasions.

Pros

  • Provides long-lasting, smudge-proof wear throughout the day.
  • The Brownish Black shade offers a natural yet defined look.
  • Easy to apply without clumping or flaking.
  • Ideal for users with sensitive eyes or those prone to irritation.
  • Works well for both casual and dramatic lash looks.
  • The creamy formula ensures smooth application without overload.

Cons

  • May not provide enough volume for those seeking a very dramatic look.
  • The waterproof formula can be difficult to remove completely.
  • Not ideal for users who prefer a lighter mascara for daily use.
  • Can feel a bit heavy for some, especially in warm or humid climates.
  • Some users find the wand to be too thick for precise application.
  • The formula may be too thick for people who prefer a more natural lash appearance.

Ratings

The scores for Maybelline Total Temptation Waterproof Mascara, Brownish Black, 0.3 fl. oz. were derived from a comprehensive analysis of verified user reviews from multiple platforms and languages worldwide. We filtered out spam, incentivized, and duplicate reviews, ensuring only authentic feedback contributed to the results. Both strengths and pain points have been considered to provide a balanced view of the product's performance.

Volume Enhancement
88%
Many users are pleased with the noticeable volume this mascara gives to their lashes. It creates a bold and fuller lash look without clumping, making it ideal for those seeking a more dramatic effect. The product provides a natural yet enhanced volume, perfect for both casual and more glamorous occasions.
A few users feel that the volume enhancement could be more intense, especially for those with naturally sparse lashes. Some mention that it may not be as voluminous as advertised for their specific lash types, leaving them wishing for more lift and thickness.
Longevity (Smudge-Proof)
92%
The waterproof formula truly stands out for its long-lasting, smudge-proof wear throughout the day. Users rave about its performance in humid or rainy conditions, keeping lashes intact without any flaking or smudging. This makes it a reliable option for all-day wear and those with active lifestyles.
While the waterproof nature is appreciated, some users find it a bit challenging to remove, requiring a bit of effort or special makeup removers. A few also mention that the mascara may feel a little stiff by the end of the day, especially if worn for extended hours.
Clump-Free Application
85%
Users are generally impressed with the smooth, clump-free application. The creamy texture allows for even coverage, making it easy to achieve defined lashes without the risk of overload. For many, this means a polished and smooth finish every time, with minimal touch-ups required.
However, a small number of users report that the product sometimes clumps when applied too generously. Some also mention that, in certain cases, the formula can become a bit thick after multiple uses, making it harder to achieve a completely clump-free look.
Comfort for Sensitive Eyes
87%
This mascara is particularly praised by those with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers. The gentle formula causes minimal irritation, allowing users to wear it comfortably for long hours without discomfort. It's a go-to choice for individuals who need makeup that won't aggravate their eyes.
While most users with sensitive eyes report positive experiences, a few mention slight irritation or dryness after prolonged wear. A handful of users with more severe sensitivities found that it still caused mild discomfort, especially during removal.
Texture/Feel During Application
90%
The creamy and smooth texture of this mascara makes for a pleasant application. It glides effortlessly onto lashes, providing a seamless coat that doesn’t tug or pull at delicate eye areas. Many users love how easy it is to apply, especially for those with thinner lashes.
Some users feel that the creamy texture can be a bit too thick for their liking, especially in warmer weather. A few have also noted that the product tends to weigh down their lashes if too many coats are applied, resulting in a less voluminous effect.
Shade Richness (Brownish Black)
81%
19%
The Brownish Black shade strikes a balance between natural and bold, providing a softer alternative to traditional black mascaras. It’s perfect for users seeking a more understated, yet defined, lash look that complements various skin tones without feeling too harsh.
Some users feel that the shade could be darker or more intense, especially if they’re used to jet black mascaras. A few have mentioned that the Brownish Black might not show up as prominently on darker lashes, leaving them wanting a deeper, more noticeable effect.
Ease of Removal
75%
25%
For those with non-sensitive eyes, removal is fairly straightforward with an oil-based makeup remover. It doesn’t require excessive scrubbing, and users appreciate that it comes off cleanly when using the right products.
However, many users find it difficult to remove at the end of the day. The waterproof formula, while great for longevity, makes it harder to fully remove, especially without the proper makeup remover. Some report needing to repeat the process multiple times, leading to frustration.
Waterproof Performance
94%
The waterproof performance is a standout feature, especially praised by those who need a mascara that can handle sweat, tears, or moisture. It’s highly resistant to smudging, providing all-day wear even in challenging conditions such as rain or heat.
A few users note that, while waterproof, the mascara sometimes creates a harder finish, making it feel a bit stiff on lashes. Some also report that it might flake slightly towards the end of a long day of wear, though this is rare.
Packaging and Design
80%
20%
The sleek and compact packaging makes the mascara easy to handle and store. Many users appreciate the simple, practical design that feels secure in the hand, allowing for precise application. The size is also convenient for travel or everyday use.
On the downside, some users feel the packaging could be a bit more durable. A few report that the cap sometimes gets loose after extended use, which could lead to drying out the product over time.
Value for Money
82%
18%
For its performance and reliability, this mascara offers solid value for money. Users feel they get a high-quality product without spending a premium, particularly considering its longevity and effective waterproof formula.
However, a few buyers think it’s slightly overpriced for the amount of product. While many are satisfied with the value, some feel there are comparable mascaras available at a lower price, particularly those without waterproof features.
Overall User Satisfaction
85%
Overall, users are generally satisfied with this mascara’s performance, especially regarding its volume, longevity, and waterproof qualities. Many recommend it as a reliable choice for everyday wear, particularly for those with sensitive eyes or active lifestyles.
While most users are happy with the product, some are disappointed by the occasional clumping or the removal difficulty. Additionally, there are a few users who wish for a more intense volume or a darker shade.
Ideal for Active Lifestyles
86%
For users with active lifestyles, this mascara is a solid choice, offering long-lasting wear that holds up even during physical activities. Whether at the gym or out in the heat, it stays in place without smudging or flaking.
While great for active users, a few mention that it might not be the best option for those who need a lighter, more breathable formula. Some report it feeling a bit too heavy for extended wear or in hot climates.

Suitable for:

The Maybelline Total Temptation Waterproof Mascara, Brownish Black, 0.3 fl. oz. is ideal for users looking for a long-lasting, smudge-proof mascara that provides volume and length. Those with active lifestyles or sensitive eyes will appreciate the gentle formula, which offers all-day wear without irritation. It’s also a great choice for individuals seeking a natural yet defined lash look, as the Brownish Black shade delivers just the right amount of intensity. This product is well-suited for both everyday use and special occasions, making it versatile for various occasions and needs. Whether you're attending a long event or simply going through your daily routine, this mascara is designed to keep lashes bold and defined without the worry of smudging or flaking.

Not suitable for:

While this mascara works well for most, it may not be the best fit for those seeking extreme volume or intense dark lashes. Users who expect a more dramatic look might find the volume enhancement lacking compared to other formulas. Additionally, those with very sensitive eyes may experience slight discomfort, especially during removal, as the waterproof formula can be a bit stubborn to fully cleanse. It’s also not ideal for those who prefer a lighter mascara, as the creamy texture can feel heavy for some users, particularly in warmer climates or after extended wear. Lastly, if you’re someone who frequently needs to reapply or adjust your mascara throughout the day, you might find the removal process a bit too time-consuming.

Specifications

  • Brand: This product is manufactured by Maybelline, a well-known brand in the cosmetics industry.
  • Product Type: Waterproof mascara designed for adding volume and length to lashes.
  • Shade: The mascara comes in a rich Brownish Black shade, offering a natural yet bold look.
  • Size: The product is packaged in a 0.3 fl. oz. (8.8 mL) tube.
  • Formula: It features a waterproof formula that ensures smudge-free wear throughout the day.
  • Application: The mascara has a smooth, creamy texture that provides a clump-free, even application.
  • Special Features: The mascara is specifically formulated to be clump-free and smudge-proof.
  • Volume & Length: Designed to add both volume and length to lashes for a bold, defined look.
  • Consistency: The product has a creamy, smooth consistency that glides on easily.
  • Target Audience: Ideal for those with sensitive eyes or active lifestyles who require smudge-proof makeup.
  • Longevity: Offers long-lasting wear, holding up throughout the day without flaking.
  • Clumping: The formula is designed to avoid clumping, providing a clean lash look.
  • Waterproof: The mascara is fully waterproof, making it resistant to water, sweat, and humidity.
  • Usage: Suitable for both casual and dramatic lash looks, depending on the number of coats applied.
  • Eye Sensitivity: The mascara is formulated for sensitive eyes and is suitable for contact lens wearers.
  • Packaging: Comes in a compact, easy-to-use tube with a wand for precise application.
  • Fragrance: The mascara is free from strong fragrances, making it ideal for those with sensitivities.
  • Removal: Requires a gentle makeup remover or micellar water to effectively remove the waterproof formula.
  • Storage: Should be stored in a cool, dry place and tightly closed after use to maintain its consistency.

FAQ

For the best results, start by curling your lashes with an eyelash curler. Then, use the mascara wand to apply the product from the base of your lashes to the tips in a zig-zag motion. This helps to separate lashes while adding volume and length. You can apply additional coats for a more dramatic look.

Yes, this mascara is designed to be gentle on sensitive eyes, making it a good choice for those who wear contact lenses or have irritation-prone eyes. Its smudge-proof formula ensures it stays in place without causing discomfort, making it ideal for daily wear.

The Brownish Black shade provides a softer, more natural look compared to the standard Black. It enhances your lashes with a subtle depth while still offering a bold lash definition, making it great for those seeking a more subdued yet defined lash look.

This mascara is designed to last all day without smudging or flaking, thanks to its waterproof formula. Users report that it holds up well through various activities, including humid weather, sweat, and even light rain, making it a reliable choice for long-lasting wear.

Yes, this mascara works well for both casual and dramatic lash looks. For a natural look, a single coat is enough to add definition, while multiple layers can build volume for a more dramatic effect, giving you versatility depending on your needs.

No, this mascara is formulated to be gentle on your eyes and free from strong fragrances or irritating chemicals. It is designed for long-lasting wear without causing discomfort or irritation, even for sensitive eyes.

Yes, the creamy formula of this mascara is specifically designed to go on smoothly without clumping. The application is even, and it delivers a clean, defined lash look, which is a key benefit reported by users.

Because this mascara is waterproof, it may require a gentle eye makeup remover or micellar water to effectively remove it. Avoid rubbing your eyes too harshly, as this could cause irritation. A gentle, oil-based makeup remover is typically the most effective.

Yes, this waterproof mascara is ideal for outdoor activities like a day at the beach. Its waterproof nature ensures that it stays in place even when exposed to water or sweat, making it a great option for an active lifestyle.

To keep your mascara in the best condition, store it in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Be sure to tightly close the cap after each use to prevent it from drying out, and avoid sharing the mascara to maintain hygiene.