Overview

Benefit They're Real! Mascara, Beyond Black, 0.3oz is a highly regarded lash product designed to give your lashes dramatic length and volume. This mascara is known for its long-lasting formula, ensuring your lashes stay voluminous and defined without smudging or flaking throughout the day. The mascara’s unique brush helps to separate and define each lash, giving you a bold, full look that lasts from morning to night. Whether you’re getting ready for work or a night out, this product promises to keep your lashes looking flawless.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This mascara is enriched with conditioning ingredients that nourish and enhance the appearance of your lashes while providing a thickening effect. The unique formula adds noticeable volume, creating fuller, more voluminous lashes from root to tip. It’s designed for all-day wear, ensuring that lashes stay defined and curled without the need for touch-ups. The smudge-proof and flake-resistant formula also helps maintain its performance through humid conditions or long hours, making it a reliable choice for busy days.

Best For

This mascara is perfect for anyone who wants bold, defined lashes with maximum volume. It's especially ideal for those looking for a smudge-proof mascara that offers long-lasting wear throughout the day, whether in humid weather or on long nights. Additionally, it’s great for individuals with shorter or thinner lashes who want to achieve dramatic length and fullness without the need for multiple coats. If you’re after a mascara that delivers both volume and definition, this one fits the bill.

User Feedback

Users love how this mascara delivers instant volume and definition, making lashes appear fuller and longer with just one coat. Many appreciate its smudge-proof formula, which holds up well during long days or in humid environments. The brush design is often praised for making the application smooth and easy without clumping. However, some users note that getting the perfect application may take a bit of practice, especially to avoid over-application and ensure the lashes stay separated. Overall, it's highly regarded for its reliable performance.

Pros

  • This mascara provides impressive volume and dramatic length, making lashes appear fuller instantly.
  • The formula is long-lasting and smudge-proof, even in humid conditions or long wear scenarios.
  • Its specially designed brush separates and defines lashes without causing clumps.
  • Ideal for users with shorter or thinner lashes looking for noticeable volume and length.
  • Works well for all-day wear, maintaining lash definition and curl throughout busy workdays.
  • The conditioning ingredients help nourish lashes, keeping them healthy and strong over time.

Cons

  • Some users found the mascara difficult to remove, especially with long-wear formulas.
  • The formula may feel heavy for those who prefer a lighter mascara option.
  • A few people mentioned the brush design requires practice to avoid clumping.
  • Not ideal for those with very sensitive eyes, as some users reported irritation.
  • Users with oily skin noted that the mascara didn’t hold up as well throughout the day.
  • The price point may be higher than some users are comfortable with for a mascara product.

Ratings

Based on verified user reviews across multiple languages and platforms, the feedback for Benefit They're Real! Mascara, Beyond Black, 0.3oz has been generally positive. Spam, bot, and incentivized reviews were filtered out to ensure that only authentic and high-quality user experiences shaped these ratings. Both strengths and areas for improvement have been reflected, providing a balanced view of this mascara’s performance and user satisfaction worldwide.

Lengthening Effect
91%
Users consistently praise this mascara for its impressive ability to lengthen lashes. Many note that it provides a noticeable difference, helping to open up the eyes for a more dramatic look. The effect is especially appreciated by individuals with shorter lashes who find it hard to achieve a defined length with other products.
However, some users report that the lengthening effect may not be as dramatic as expected, particularly for those with naturally long lashes. A few also mentioned that the mascara tends to clump slightly during the application process, especially if too many layers are applied.
Volume Boost
88%
This mascara is widely praised for adding significant volume to lashes. Many buyers love how it creates a bold, full look, making their lashes appear thicker and more voluminous without the need for multiple coats. It's particularly effective for those seeking a fuller lash line for day or evening looks.
On the downside, some users feel the volume effect is less pronounced than other high-volume mascaras. A few reviews mention that it can make lashes look a bit too heavy or spidery if over-applied, particularly for those with naturally thick lashes.
Smudge-Proof Performance
92%
Many users are impressed by the smudge-proof formula, which stays in place throughout the day without fading or transferring. This makes it ideal for long workdays, humid environments, or even workout sessions. It’s particularly appreciated by those who struggle with mascara smudging or flaking, offering all-day wear.
That said, a few users report difficulty removing the mascara at the end of the day, noting that it can be stubborn to remove with just regular makeup remover. Some also point out that, while it’s smudge-proof, it can become a bit stiff on lashes, making them feel crunchy.
Ease of Application
85%
The mascara is generally easy to apply, with many users noting that the specially designed brush helps separate and define lashes without causing clumps. It’s particularly favored by beginners who appreciate a mascara that’s simple to work with for a clean, smooth finish.
However, a number of reviews mention that the brush may take a bit of practice to master, as it can feel awkward to handle at first. Some users also found that the formula needs to be built up in layers for a fuller effect, which can sometimes lead to uneven application.
Brush Design
87%
The unique brush design is highly appreciated by users for its ability to separate lashes and define them without clumping. Many users find it effective for reaching the small lashes on the corners of the eyes, and it provides a more precise application compared to standard mascara brushes.
A few users mention that the brush can feel too large for smaller eyes, making it difficult to apply mascara evenly. Additionally, some report that the brush picks up too much product, which can lead to a heavier, less natural look unless carefully applied.
Long-Lasting Wear
90%
This mascara stands out for its longevity, with many buyers commenting that it stays put throughout the day without fading or smudging. It holds the curl well, keeping lashes defined and voluminous from morning to evening, making it a go-to for those looking for a reliable, all-day mascara.
However, there are a few reports from users with oily skin who found that it didn’t perform as well for them, especially towards the end of the day. Some also found that it didn’t provide quite the same long-lasting effect in humid conditions as it did in dry environments.
Packaging
82%
18%
The sleek packaging of this mascara is praised for being stylish and easy to handle. It’s compact and travel-friendly, making it a convenient choice for users on the go. The design also prevents excess product from clumping on the wand, ensuring a cleaner application each time.
On the downside, some buyers feel that the packaging could be sturdier. A few users mentioned that the tube tends to get messy, with excess product sometimes leaking out, making it less convenient for long-term storage or travel.
Clump-Free Application
86%
One of the key selling points is the clump-free formula, which many users love. The mascara glides on smoothly and separates lashes well, leaving them looking naturally voluminous without the worry of harsh clumping or flaking. It’s especially beneficial for users looking for a more refined look.
However, a few reviewers did report occasional clumping, especially when applying multiple coats. For some, it took a bit of effort to get the right amount of product on the brush, leading to less-than-perfect results if not applied carefully.
Value for Money
89%
Overall, users find this product to offer good value for its performance. Despite being on the pricier side, many feel it’s worth the investment due to its long-lasting wear, smudge-proof formula, and overall effectiveness in creating bold, voluminous lashes. It provides a premium mascara experience at a mid-range price point.
On the flip side, some users consider the price to be a bit steep compared to other mascaras that offer similar results. A few buyers also mention that, while effective, it may not be significantly better than other mascaras available at a lower price.
Ingredient Quality
80%
20%
Many users appreciate that this mascara contains conditioning ingredients that help nourish and protect lashes while enhancing their appearance. Those with sensitive eyes or lash concerns find it gentle enough to use daily without irritation, which is a major plus for regular mascara users.
However, there are a few users who feel that the ingredients could be improved in terms of being more natural or hypoallergenic. Some mention that the mascara can feel heavy on the lashes, possibly due to the formula's thickness, which may cause discomfort for those with more delicate eyes.
User-Friendly for Beginners
78%
22%
Several beginners noted that this mascara was easy to work with, particularly due to the well-designed brush and smooth formula. It’s a great option for anyone new to makeup who wants a product that doesn’t require a lot of skill or experience to apply effectively.
However, a few beginner users struggled to apply it evenly, especially when using multiple layers. Some also felt that the formula clumped more easily than expected, making it harder to perfect the look without a bit of practice and patience.
Overall Satisfaction
90%
The overall satisfaction with this mascara is very high, with most users praising its performance and ease of use. It consistently delivers bold lashes with good volume, length, and smudge-proof wear. Many report feeling confident in recommending this mascara for various occasions, from everyday wear to special events.
While the majority of feedback is positive, some users do mention that they expected more from the product given the brand’s reputation. A few noted that while the mascara was effective, it didn’t exceed their expectations in terms of dramatic results, particularly for more voluminous or thicker lashes.

Suitable for:

Benefit They're Real! Mascara, Beyond Black is ideal for users seeking bold, voluminous lashes with lasting definition. It's particularly suited for individuals with thinner or shorter lashes who want to achieve dramatic length and fuller volume. The smudge-proof formula makes it a great choice for long days at work, humid climates, or events where lasting performance is important. Users who prefer a clump-free application will appreciate the specially designed brush that separates and defines lashes without the mess. If you need a reliable mascara that provides both length and volume for all-day wear, this product is a solid option.

Not suitable for:

This mascara may not be the best fit for users with oily skin or those who struggle with stubborn makeup removal. While it offers smudge-proof performance, some users with oily skin reported it didn't hold up as well as expected throughout the day. Additionally, those looking for a super lightweight formula might find the mascara a bit heavy, especially if too many layers are applied. It also may not be ideal for beginners who are still learning how to perfect mascara application, as some users mentioned it takes practice to avoid clumping and achieve an even look.

Specifications

  • Brand: Manufactured by Benefit Cosmetics, a leading beauty brand.
  • Product Type: This is a volumizing and lengthening mascara.
  • Shade: The mascara is available in the Beyond Black shade for a bold black finish.
  • Size: Each tube contains 0.3oz (8.5g) of mascara.
  • Formula: This mascara has a smudge-proof, long-lasting formula that resists flaking.
  • Brush Design: The specially designed brush helps separate and define each lash without clumping.
  • Benefits: Offers dramatic volume and length for fuller, more defined lashes.
  • Application: The mascara is easy to apply, though some users may need practice to avoid clumping.
  • Ideal Use: Best for users looking for all-day wear and a smudge-proof mascara.
  • Ingredients: Contains conditioning ingredients that help nourish and protect lashes while enhancing their appearance.
  • Volume Effect: Delivers a thickening effect for fuller, more voluminous lashes.
  • Suitability: Great for individuals with shorter or thinner lashes seeking dramatic length and volume.
  • Longevity: The formula provides long-lasting wear, maintaining curl and definition for up to 12 hours.
  • No Clumping: Users report a clump-free application when applied with the correct technique.
  • Weather Resistance: Ideal for humid conditions or long days, as it resists smudging and flaking.
  • Removal: May require an oil-based makeup remover or micellar water for full removal.
  • Allergen Info: Suitable for most skin types, though users with sensitive eyes should patch test first.
  • Brush Type: Features a precise brush that separates lashes for a defined, bold look.
  • Fragrance: Fragrance-free formula to minimize irritation or sensitivity to scents.
  • Packaging: Comes in a sleek, compact tube with a convenient applicator brush for precise application.

FAQ

To achieve maximum volume and definition, start by wiggling the brush at the base of your lashes and then sweep upward. For added length, layer a second coat while the first one is still slightly damp. Make sure to separate lashes as you apply to avoid clumping.

Benefit They're Real! Mascara is generally safe for sensitive eyes, but as with any eye product, it's recommended to do a patch test first. Some users with very sensitive eyes have reported irritation, so if you have known sensitivities, proceed with caution.

No, this mascara is designed to resist smudging and flaking, making it ideal for long-lasting wear. It's a great option for users who need a mascara that stays in place, even in humid conditions or after long days.

Yes, this mascara is ideal for people with shorter or thinner lashes looking for dramatic length and volume. Its formula helps to thicken and separate lashes, providing noticeable fullness and lift.

Yes, the formula includes conditioning ingredients that nourish and protect your lashes while enhancing their appearance. This helps to keep your lashes healthy and strong with continued use.

Due to its long-lasting, smudge-proof formula, this mascara may require an oil-based makeup remover or micellar water to fully remove. Gently wipe from base to tip to avoid tugging on delicate lashes.

Yes, this mascara is well-suited for humid or rainy conditions as it has a smudge-proof and long-wearing formula. It will stay intact throughout the day, even in challenging weather.

The unique brush is designed to separate and define lashes without clumping. While it helps coat each lash evenly, some users find that it requires a bit of practice to master the application technique for the best results.

Currently, Benefit They're Real! Mascara is available in the Beyond Black shade. This rich black color provides bold definition, but if you're looking for a more subtle look, you may want to consider other options in the Benefit mascara line.

Benefit They're Real! Mascara is known for its long-lasting performance. It can keep lashes defined, curled, and voluminous for up to 12 hours without smudging or flaking, making it perfect for all-day wear.