Overview

The Laura Geller Inkcredible Gel Eyeliner - Brown Eyed Girl is a waterproof, smudge-proof gel eyeliner pencil designed for easy application and lasting wear. This eyeliner delivers rich, intense color that glides on smoothly, making it a great option for both beginners and makeup enthusiasts. Featuring a built-in sharpener, it ensures precision and maintains the tip for detailed application. Available in the Brown Eyed Girl shade, this eyeliner is perfect for everyday looks, offering versatility without compromising on performance.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This gel eyeliner boasts a smooth, creamy formula that applies effortlessly without tugging on the delicate skin around the eyes. Its long-lasting formula ensures it stays put throughout the day, resisting smudging, fading, and streaking. The waterproof design provides extra durability, keeping your eyeliner intact through sweat and humidity. The included built-in sharpener keeps the eyeliner tip precise, ensuring every line is sharp and clean. Overall, it's a reliable choice for anyone seeking all-day wear with minimal touch-ups.

Best For

This gel eyeliner is ideal for those who want a long-lasting solution for daily wear, whether it's for a subtle natural look or a bold, defined eye. It's perfect for anyone who needs a versatile pencil that can create both fine lines for a more natural appearance or thicker, more dramatic strokes. If you're someone who struggles with eyeliner that smudges or fades throughout the day, this is the product for you. The waterproof and smudge-proof properties make it especially suitable for those living in humid climates or anyone who enjoys a long-lasting look.

User Feedback

Many users rave about the smooth, creamy texture of this gel eyeliner, which allows for an effortless application without any tugging. The impressive staying power is another frequent highlight, with many reporting that it lasts all day without fading or smudging. The built-in sharpener is often mentioned as a convenient feature for maintaining the eyeliner tip, allowing for more precise lines. On the flip side, some users find the Brown Eyed Girl shade a bit too light for dramatic looks, but it’s appreciated for natural everyday wear.

Pros

  • This product glides on smoothly without tugging, providing an effortless application.
  • The built-in sharpener ensures the eyeliner tip stays precise and easy to maintain.
  • Users appreciate the long-lasting, smudge-proof formula that stays intact all day.
  • The Brown Eyed Girl shade offers a versatile, natural look for everyday wear.
  • Its waterproof formula performs well in humid conditions and resists sweat.
  • Many users find the creamy texture ideal for both fine and bold lines.
  • The eyeliner's staying power is particularly praised for surviving long hours without fading.
  • Its smooth application makes it easy to use, even for beginners.
  • Perfect for those seeking a reliable, no-fuss eyeliner for daily use.

Cons

  • Some users find the eyeliner too soft, which can cause breakage with pressure.
  • The Brown Eyed Girl shade may not provide enough intensity for those looking for a bold, dramatic look.
  • In humid or excessively oily environments, it may not hold up as well as expected.
  • The product might require a bit more effort to remove, especially for sensitive skin.
  • For people with very watery eyes, this eyeliner may smudge in the inner corners.
  • A few users noted that the product can feel a little too soft for precise, long-lasting definition.
  • This gel eyeliner is not the best choice for those who prefer a firmer pencil.
  • Some customers mentioned that the eyeliner doesn’t offer much in terms of color intensity.
  • It may not be ideal for those looking for a bold, statement eyeliner.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews from multiple platforms and countries, RR-AI provides an aggregated rating for the Laura Geller Inkcredible Gel Eyeliner - Brown Eyed Girl. We filtered out spam, bot-generated, and incentivized reviews to ensure the scores reflect authentic feedback. Both strengths and pain points are represented in these ratings, offering a balanced view of the product's performance and user experience.

Smooth Application
91%
Many users love how effortlessly this gel eyeliner glides on, providing a smooth and even application without any tugging or pulling. It’s especially praised for its creamy texture, which makes it easy to apply even on sensitive skin, creating flawless lines with minimal effort.
However, a few buyers mentioned that the formula can feel slightly too soft at times, making it prone to breakage if not sharpened regularly. Additionally, a small group of users found that it requires a steady hand for precision, as the smooth glide can sometimes result in unintended smudging.
Longevity/All-Day Wear
88%
This eyeliner consistently impresses with its long-lasting wear. Many users report that it stays put throughout busy workdays and even during workouts without needing touch-ups. It’s a reliable choice for those who need makeup that can handle sweat, humidity, and long hours.
On the downside, a few users found that the eyeliner starts to fade slightly after several hours, particularly in hot and humid conditions. While it generally holds up well, some wearers noted occasional smudging or fading at the inner corners of their eyes by the end of the day.
Waterproof Performance
90%
The waterproof design is one of this eyeliner's standout features. Reviewers often highlight how it withstands water, sweat, and humidity, making it perfect for hot weather or long days at the pool or beach. Users appreciate that it doesn’t budge or smudge even in challenging conditions.
However, some users mentioned that removing this waterproof eyeliner can be a bit of a challenge. They found that it requires a strong makeup remover, which can be frustrating for those with sensitive skin or eyes, leading to extra rubbing or irritation during removal.
Smudge-Proof Properties
86%
This product is frequently praised for its smudge-proof nature. Many buyers report that it stays perfectly intact throughout the day, even in moments of rubbing the eyes or in humid weather. For those with oily eyelids, it provides extra reassurance that the eyeliner won't smudge or transfer.
Despite its smudge-resistant properties, a small number of users noticed that it could sometimes smudge when applied to the waterline. This was particularly an issue for those with very oily skin or those who have naturally watery eyes, causing it to fade a bit sooner than expected.
Precision and Sharpening
84%
The inclusion of a built-in sharpener is a standout feature for many users. It ensures that the eyeliner remains sharp and precise for detailed application, which is ideal for those who enjoy creating both fine lines and bolder, more dramatic looks. It’s also appreciated for convenience, eliminating the need for a separate sharpener.
However, some buyers mentioned that the sharpener may not work as effectively after repeated use, particularly if the eyeliner tip becomes too soft. A few users felt that it didn’t sharpen the pencil evenly, leading to an uneven application on occasion.
Shade Versatility (Brown Eyed Girl)
83%
The Brown Eyed Girl shade is often cited as a perfect everyday color for a natural yet enhanced look. Reviewers appreciate how versatile it is, complementing a wide range of skin tones and eye colors. It’s also subtle enough for daytime wear while still offering enough intensity for evening looks.
Some users, however, found that the Brown Eyed Girl shade was too light for their liking. They mentioned that it didn’t provide the bold, defined look they were hoping for, especially for more dramatic makeup styles. A few felt that the color appeared dull or faded after a few hours of wear.
Texture and Feel
89%
This eyeliner’s creamy texture is frequently highlighted in positive reviews, with many noting how comfortable it feels on the eyelids. It doesn’t dry out or cause irritation, even for those with sensitive skin or eyes. The smooth formula allows for a soft, effortless glide without tugging.
A few users reported that the creamy texture can sometimes make the eyeliner a bit too soft, which can result in it breaking off during use. For those who prefer a firmer consistency, this might not be the best choice.
Packaging and Usability
80%
20%
The pencil packaging is simple yet effective, with the built-in sharpener adding to its ease of use. Many users find it convenient for travel or on-the-go touch-ups, as there’s no need to carry an additional sharpener. It’s compact, making it easy to store in a makeup bag.
Some users, however, expressed dissatisfaction with the pencil packaging, citing that the cap can sometimes be tricky to secure properly, leading to the eyeliner breaking or getting messy in their bags. A few also found that the sharpener didn’t work as smoothly after some time.
Ease of Removal
79%
21%
For the most part, the eyeliner’s removal process is manageable with an oil-based makeup remover. Many buyers appreciate how it doesn’t leave behind residue when removed correctly, offering a clean and fresh feeling after cleansing.
However, some users found the eyeliner to be difficult to remove, requiring more effort than expected. This was particularly true for those who have sensitive eyes or skin, as they experienced irritation from the strong makeup removers needed to break down the product.
Value for Money
92%
Buyers frequently mention that this eyeliner provides excellent value for money, considering its long-lasting performance, waterproof features, and high-quality application. It’s often seen as a reliable, affordable option for those who want a dependable eyeliner without spending too much.
A few users felt that the price was slightly higher compared to other eyeliners on the market, though they acknowledged that the quality justifies the cost. Some would prefer a more budget-friendly alternative with similar performance, but overall, the consensus is that the product offers good value.
Overall Satisfaction
87%
Overall, many users express satisfaction with how this product performs, particularly its versatility for everyday and more defined looks. It’s a favorite for its long wear, waterproof nature, and the smooth application that makes it easy to use daily. It’s particularly appreciated by those who want reliable, all-day eyeliner.
However, there are a few complaints regarding the eyeliner’s tendency to fade or smudge over time, particularly in warmer or more humid conditions. Some users also felt the color wasn’t as bold as they had hoped, which left them slightly disappointed with its intensity after application.

Suitable for:

This product is ideal for users who need a reliable, long-lasting eyeliner for everyday wear. Those who prefer a waterproof and smudge-proof option will benefit greatly from its performance, especially during active days or in humid environments. If you're looking for a versatile pencil that can create both fine and bold lines, this gel eyeliner is a great fit. Its smooth application and the built-in sharpener make it convenient for on-the-go users, particularly those who favor a natural yet defined look, like the Brown Eyed Girl shade. People who prioritize long-wear makeup that won’t fade or smudge are also likely to appreciate this eyeliner's durability throughout the day.

Not suitable for:

This eyeliner may not be the best choice for those with very oily skin or those prone to watery eyes, as it may smudge slightly, especially around the inner corners. Additionally, sensitive users might find the removal process challenging, requiring strong makeup removers that could irritate the skin. If you're someone who prefers a firmer eyeliner pencil or one that holds a bolder intensity throughout the day, this product might feel too soft or light, leaving you disappointed. Furthermore, people seeking a very intense, dramatic eyeliner look may find the Brown Eyed Girl shade a bit too subtle for their preferences.

Specifications

  • Product Type: Gel eyeliner pencil with waterproof and smudge-proof properties.
  • Shade: Available in the Brown Eyed Girl shade, ideal for natural, everyday looks.
  • Formulation: Waterproof formula designed to resist sweat, humidity, and water.
  • Application: Smooth, creamy texture that glides on easily without tugging.
  • Sharpener: Built-in sharpener for maintaining a precise tip for detailed application.
  • Longevity: Long-lasting wear that stays intact throughout the day without fading or smudging.
  • Usage: Suitable for creating both fine and bold lines, depending on the application pressure.
  • Packaging: Convenient pencil form with a built-in sharpener for easy maintenance.
  • Smudge Resistance: Smudge-proof formula ensures eyeliner stays intact in various conditions.
  • Skin Compatibility: Compatible with all skin types, including sensitive eyes.
  • Eye Sensitivity: Safe for use on sensitive eyes, though patch testing is recommended for first-time users.
  • Color Intensity: Provides rich, intense color that enhances eye definition.
  • Versatility: Ideal for both natural and bold looks, suitable for daily wear.
  • Water Resistance: Resistant to water, ensuring long-lasting wear in humid or rainy conditions.
  • Size: Pencil length and diameter suitable for comfortable handling and precise application.
  • Storage: Store in a cool, dry place to maintain product integrity and extend shelf life.
  • Cruelty-Free: This product is not tested on animals.
  • Applicator: Pencil format for easy and precise application without the need for brushes.
  • Ideal Use: Perfect for daily makeup routines, offering effortless application for both casual and formal looks.

FAQ

To apply this gel eyeliner, gently glide it along your lash line for a smooth, precise line. You can build up the intensity for a bolder look or use it for a subtle definition. The built-in sharpener helps keep the pencil in top condition for accurate application.

This eyeliner features a waterproof and smudge-proof formula that resists sweat, humidity, and water, ensuring long-lasting wear throughout the day without fading or smudging. It's ideal for those needing makeup that stays put in various conditions.

Yes, this product is generally safe for sensitive eyes. However, as with any makeup, it's recommended to do a patch test first if you have a history of eye irritation or allergies. The creamy formula is gentle but still provides a bold, defined look.

This eyeliner works well for all skin types, including oily, dry, and combination skin. Its long-wear, waterproof formula helps it stay intact throughout the day, even in humid or oily conditions. It's a great choice for users seeking reliable, all-day wear.

Yes, the Brown Eyed Girl shade is versatile and can complement a wide range of skin tones, including darker complexions. Its natural, warm tone provides a subtle definition that works well for both everyday and more dramatic looks.

The built-in sharpener makes it easy to maintain a sharp, precise tip for detailed application. Simply twist the pencil to expose more product, and use the sharpener when you need a finer point for more precise lines.

Yes, this gel eyeliner is designed for all-day wear. Its smudge-proof and waterproof properties ensure it stays intact without needing frequent touch-ups, making it ideal for long workdays or events.

To remove this waterproof eyeliner, use a gentle eye makeup remover or micellar water. Because the formula is long-lasting, it may require a bit more effort to fully cleanse, but a good makeup remover should do the job without irritation.

Currently, the Laura Geller Inkcredible Gel Eyeliner - Brown Eyed Girl is available in the Brown Eyed Girl shade, ideal for everyday use. However, there may be other shades in the brand’s range, so check the product line for more options.

Yes, this eyeliner is versatile enough to create both fine and bold lines, making it a great option for a cat-eye look. Its smooth glide and long-lasting formula ensure the cat-eye will stay sharp and defined all day.