Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil

Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil — image 1
Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil — image 2
Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil — image 3
Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil — image 4
Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil — image 5
Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil — image 6
Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil — image 7
Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil — image 8
Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil — image 9
80%
20%
89%
Pigmentation & Color Payoff
82%
Waterproof Performance
78%
Smudge Resistance
87%
Formula & Texture
73%
Wear Longevity
61%
Built-in Sharpener
92%
Ease of Application
76%
Shade Range
71%
Value for Money
86%
Portability
77%
Tip Precision
83%
Application Versatility
More

Overview

The Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil sits in a comfortable mid-range sweet spot — pricier than a drugstore pick, but well short of prestige counter territory. The core appeal is a gel formula that promises liquid-liner intensity delivered through the easier, more forgiving control of a pencil. That's a combination worth paying attention to, especially for people who've struggled with liquid liner's unforgiving learning curve. The built-in sharpener tucked into the cap is a genuinely useful detail that twist-up pencils simply can't match. Set expectations accordingly, though: this gel eyeliner pencil is built for reliable everyday wear, not precision graphic liner or dramatic stage looks.

Features & Benefits

The formula here is worth unpacking. On the lid, this gel eyeliner pencil glides on with noticeable rich pigment payoff — very little drag, and the color deposits evenly from the first stroke. The waterproof staying power is where it earns its keep: it holds up through humidity, accidental eye rubbing, and the kind of watering eyes that wipe out a standard kohl pencil by noon. Brown Eyed Girl is a warm, slightly earthy brown that reads natural on most skin tones without looking muddy. For application, a freshly sharpened tip gives you clean, precise thin lines, while tilting the pencil slightly lets you lay down a thicker, smokier line with the same tool.

Best For

The INKcredible pencil is a strong fit for daily makeup routines where reliability matters more than experimentation. If you have oily or watery eyes — the kind where most liners turn into raccoon rings by afternoon — the waterproof formula is a legitimate solution worth trying. It also works well for beginners who find the commitment and pressure of a liquid liner stressful; the pencil format forgives small wobbles and allows for easy correction. The warm-toned Brown Eyed Girl shade is particularly well-suited to fair to medium complexions looking for a softer everyday look rather than a sharp graphic line. The built-in sharpener makes it easy to toss in a bag without needing to pack a separate tool.

User Feedback

Buyers of this Laura Geller liner tend to come away impressed by the pigment payoff on application — it's one of the most consistent compliments for gel pencil formulas in this tier. Longevity gets broadly positive marks, with most users reporting the color holds through a full workday without significant fading. Where feedback becomes more mixed is around the built-in sharpener: some find it works reliably for the life of the pencil, while others note it can feel flimsy or inconsistent over time. The Brown Eyed Girl shade draws particular appreciation from those with fair to medium skin who want a warm everyday brown without crossing into orange or muddy territory. Pencil wear-down rate is worth keeping an eye on if heavy daily use is expected.

#Eyeliner
#Eyes
#Makeup
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • Creamy gel formula glides on without tugging, depositing rich color from the very first stroke.
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof performance holds up through humidity, watery eyes, and accidental rubbing.
  • The built-in cap sharpener keeps the tip precise and ready without requiring a separate tool.
  • Brown Eyed Girl is a flattering warm tone that reads natural and wearable on fair to medium skin.
  • One pencil covers multiple techniques — fine precise lines or thicker, smokier looks depending on application angle.
  • Lightweight and compact, the INKcredible pencil slips easily into a bag for on-the-go touch-ups.
  • Strong market validation with a top-20 ranking in the Eye Liners category on Amazon.
  • Shade range spans neutrals to blues and purples, offering meaningful variety beyond basic brown and black.

Cons

  • Sharpening the pencil with each use shortens product life faster than twist-up or pot-based gel liner formats.
  • The built-in sharpener has drawn mixed feedback — some users find it feels flimsy or stops working consistently.
  • Brown Eyed Girl may not deliver enough contrast for deeper skin tones seeking bold, high-impact definition.
  • Pencil tip dulls quickly with frequent use, requiring repeated sharpening just to maintain a clean, fine line.
  • Not well-suited for sharp graphic liner looks — a razor-clean edge is difficult to maintain with any pencil tip.
  • Mid-range pricing can feel hard to justify if the product wears down faster than expected with regular sharpening.
  • The formula sets relatively quickly, leaving a limited window to blend or correct mistakes after application.
  • Shade range, while varied, skews toward softer everyday tones — bold or fashion-forward colors are not part of the lineup.

Ratings

Our AI-generated scores for the Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil are built from a systematic analysis of verified buyer reviews sourced globally, with active filtering applied to remove incentivized, bot-generated, and low-credibility feedback. Each category rating reflects genuine patterns in real buyer experience — not marketing copy — so both the consistent strengths and recurring frustrations are represented with equal weight. The result is a balanced, data-grounded snapshot designed to give you an honest picture of what buyers actually encounter after purchase.

Pigmentation & Color Payoff
89%
The gel formula delivers rich, immediate color that reads true-to-shade from the very first stroke — no layering or buildup required. Buyers consistently mention that the Brown Eyed Girl tone deposits a warm, defined line that genuinely matches the shade in the pan, which is not always a given at this price point.
A subset of users notes that color intensity can diminish toward the end of the pencil's life once the tip has been repeatedly sharpened down to a smaller core. Those expecting graphic-level saturation comparable to a felt-tip liquid liner may find the pigment density falls just short under certain lighting conditions.
Waterproof Performance
82%
18%
On normal to combination skin, this gel liner holds up impressively against humidity, unexpected rain, and the kind of eye watering that ruins most standard pencils by mid-morning. Users who swim or work in humid environments consistently report noticeably better retention compared to non-waterproof alternatives they had used previously.
On very oily lids, the formula reaches its limits — some buyers report minor fading or transfer into the crease area by late afternoon, particularly without an eyeshadow primer base. The waterproofing is reliable for everyday conditions but should not be treated as infallible in extreme heat or prolonged moisture exposure.
Smudge Resistance
78%
22%
For the first several hours of wear, the gel formula holds its shape and resists the under-eye transfer that makes standard kohl pencils frustrating for oily or watery-eyed users. Most buyers who previously dealt with raccoon-eye fading by midday noted a clear improvement after switching to this gel pencil format.
A notable subset of buyers — particularly those with very oily skin or living in warm, humid climates — report smudging below the eye after extended wear, especially along the lower lash line. The performance gap between normal and oily skin types is wide enough that results will not be consistent across all users.
Formula & Texture
87%
The creamy gel texture glides across the lid without the drag or tugging that harder pencils cause, depositing color cleanly in a single smooth stroke. Buyers with sensitive eyes especially appreciate the soft, non-irritating feel that does not pull at delicate lid skin during application.
The creamy consistency that makes application feel effortless also means the pencil softens noticeably in warm temperatures, which can make the tip harder to control and more prone to skipping. Storing the pencil somewhere cool helps restore firmness, but it is an inconvenient extra step most users should not need to think about.
Wear Longevity
73%
27%
For most users under normal daily conditions — desk work, moderate activity, average humidity — the liner holds reasonably well through a full workday without requiring touch-ups. Several buyers specifically note wearing it through long shifts or multi-hour events and being pleasantly surprised by how much color remained by the end of the day.
Longevity is where the most mixed feedback clusters: a meaningful segment of buyers report noticeable fading or crease transfer by the four-to-six-hour mark, particularly on oily skin or in warm weather. Without a primer base, the liner does not consistently deliver the all-day performance its waterproof label implies.
Built-in Sharpener
61%
39%
The integrated sharpener housed in the end cap is a practical touch that removes the need to carry a separate cosmetic sharpener — a genuine convenience for travel routines and minimal makeup kits. For buyers running a tight kit, having the sharpening tool built directly into the pencil eliminates one piece of clutter entirely.
The sharpener is the most polarizing aspect of this product — many buyers find it works adequately early on but becomes unreliable over time, leaving uneven edges or failing to catch the pencil cleanly. Some users note the mechanism feels lightweight and stops performing well before the pencil itself runs out of usable product.
Ease of Application
92%
The pencil format makes this one of the most approachable liners in its tier — beginners consistently report achieving a clean, defined line on the first try without the shakiness or pressure that liquid liners demand. Even users transitioning from basic drugstore pencils found the creamy formula easy to lay down and adjust before it fully set.
If the pencil is not freshly sharpened before use, the rounded tip makes precise detail work difficult and often results in a heavier line than intended. Experienced liquid-liner users occasionally find the pencil format feels less controlled at the very tip than a fine-point felt applicator for close inner-corner work.
Shade Range
76%
24%
Offering options across neutrals, warm browns, blues, and purples puts this line above single-shade or monotone offerings at the same price. The Brown Eyed Girl shade earns consistent praise as a versatile, warm everyday brown that fills the gap between light taupe and deep espresso.
The palette, while varied enough for daily wear, leans toward softer and more neutral tones — buyers seeking bold fashion shades, vivid neons, or deeply saturated blacks may find the range underwhelming. Deeper skin tones may also find that the brown spectrum is too understated to create visible, high-contrast definition.
Value for Money
71%
29%
At a mid-range price point, this liner delivers quality clearly above the drugstore tier in both pigmentation and wear time, without requiring buyers to spend at luxury counter prices. For daily eyeliner users who value the convenience of a built-in sharpener, the per-use cost feels fair relative to what is on offer.
The value equation weakens as the pencil wears down through regular sharpening — users who go through product faster than expected may find the effective cost per use higher than anticipated. Compared to pot-based gel liners that offer significantly more product for a similar or lower price, the pencil format is a less economical option for heavy daily users.
Portability
86%
Weighing 0.32oz and measuring just under 6.4 inches, this liner fits easily in any makeup bag, clutch, or jacket pocket without adding noticeable bulk. Buyers who rely on on-the-go touch-ups — between work and evening plans, at the gym, or during travel — consistently highlight the slim, self-contained format.
The end cap that houses the sharpener can loosen gradually with repeated removal, which some users find becomes less secure over time. A few buyers report that a loosened cap allows debris from the bottom of a bag to reach the sharpener mechanism, affecting its reliability before the pencil is finished.
Tip Precision
77%
23%
A freshly sharpened tip delivers clean, controlled lines that are precise enough for a defined upper lash line or careful inner corner placement. Buyers who sharpen consistently report reliable results and value the control the pencil offers over twist-up options, which often come with a fixed and frequently too-blunt tip diameter.
Precision degrades relatively quickly — after just a few uses without resharpening, the tip rounds off and the resulting line becomes noticeably thicker and less defined. Users focused on fine inner corner or waterline detail work will need to sharpen far more frequently than average, which meaningfully accelerates overall product wear-down.
Application Versatility
83%
The INKcredible pencil functions as both a precision liner and a base for blended smoky looks — angling the pencil and pressing the side of the tip deposits a wider, workable line that can be smudged with a brush or fingertip. This dual capability makes it useful across everyday and evening eye looks without requiring a tool switch.
The range of looks achievable is still narrower than what a dedicated brush paired with a pot-based gel liner can produce — for dramatic or precisely symmetrical editorial results, the pencil format has real creative limits. Blending must also happen quickly before the gel sets, which can feel rushed for less practiced users.

Suitable for:

The Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil is a strong match for everyday makeup wearers who want dependable, pigment-rich color without the stress and precision demands of a liquid liner. If your eyes tend to water, sweat, or produce excess oil throughout the day, the waterproof gel formula gives you a meaningful advantage over standard kohl or wax pencils that crease and fade by midday. Beginners and casual wearers will find the pencil format forgiving — small mistakes can be blended or corrected before the formula fully sets, something liquid liner simply does not allow. The Brown Eyed Girl shade is a particularly practical choice for fair to medium skin tones looking for warm, natural-looking definition rather than a stark, dramatic line. People who travel frequently or prefer a minimal kit will also appreciate the self-contained design: the built-in sharpener means one less tool to pack, and the compact size slips easily into any makeup bag or purse.

Not suitable for:

Buyers with very specific performance demands may want to look elsewhere before committing to this gel eyeliner pencil. If you rely on liner for precise, sharp graphic looks — think cat-eye wings with a laser-clean edge — a felt-tip liquid liner will give you more consistent tip control than any sharpened pencil can maintain over time. The Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil is also not the best fit for those who use eyeliner heavily every day, since pencil format products wear down faster than twist-up or pot-based alternatives, and sharpening — however convenient — does shorten overall product life. Deeper skin tones looking for bold, high-contrast definition may find that the warm brown shade does not deliver enough visual punch, and would be better served by a deeper espresso or black option. Finally, anyone prioritizing absolute value at the lowest cost per use may find the mid-range price harder to justify if the pencil depletes faster than expected with daily sharpening.

Specifications

  • Brand: Laura Geller New York is the manufacturer and brand of record for this eyeliner.
  • Product Type: This is a gel-formula eyeliner pencil with an integrated sharpener, not a twist-up or liquid liner.
  • Shade Name: The shade in this listing is Brown Eyed Girl, catalogued as shade number 07 in the product lineup.
  • Net Weight: The pencil and its packaging together weigh 0.32oz, placing it in the standard full-size eyeliner category.
  • Formula Type: The formula is a waterproof and smudge-proof gel, designed to resist fading, humidity, and friction throughout the day.
  • Pigmentation: The liner is high-pigmented, delivering vivid, intense color with a creamy texture that deposits evenly on the lid.
  • Applicator: A built-in sharpener is housed inside the removable cap at the opposite end of the pencil tip.
  • Dimensions: The packaged product measures 6.38 x 1.26 x 0.67 inches, fitting easily inside a standard makeup bag.
  • Finish: The product is described as delivering an intensely pigmented, defined finish suited for everyday eye looks.
  • Shade Range: The broader product line includes shades in neutrals, browns, blues, and purples across multiple color options.
  • Item Form: The product is sold as a traditional sharpened pencil, distinct from twist-up or pot-based gel liner formats.
  • Key Feature: The core formula claim is delivering liquid-liner color intensity through the more forgiving control of a pencil format.
  • Longevity: The liner is designed for long-lasting all-day wear, supported by its waterproof and smudge-proof gel composition.
  • Unit Count: Each standard purchase contains one eyeliner pencil; multi-unit bundles are not included in this listing.
  • UPC: The Universal Product Code for this specific item is 849154002771.
  • Market Rank: This product ranks #19 in Eye Liners and #1,618 in Beauty & Personal Care on Amazon.
  • Application: The pencil tip can be held upright for precise fine lines or angled for a thicker, blended smoky effect.
  • Removal: As a waterproof gel formula, an oil-based or micellar makeup remover is recommended for thorough, gentle removal.

Related Reviews

Laura Geller INKcredible Waterproof Brow Pencil - 03 Medium Brown
Laura Geller INKcredible Waterproof Brow Pencil - 03 Medium Brown
87%
91%
Waterproof Performance
88%
Ease of Application
85%
Long-Lasting Wear
89%
Precision & Control
72%
Shade Range
More
Laura Geller Sculpt-n-Stay Waterproof Brow Pencil Gel
Laura Geller Sculpt-n-Stay Waterproof Brow Pencil Gel
78%
83%
Waterproof Performance
81%
Pencil Tip Precision
78%
Gel Hold Strength
88%
Ease of Application
86%
Natural Finish
More
Laura Geller Kajal Kohl Eyeliner Pencil 0.71oz
Laura Geller Kajal Kohl Eyeliner Pencil 0.71oz
81%
91%
Pigment Payoff
89%
Formula Texture
63%
Wear Longevity
93%
Blendability
82%
Built-In Sharpener
More
Laura Geller Kajal Longwear Kohl Eyeliner - Smoky Plum Kohl
Laura Geller Kajal Longwear Kohl Eyeliner - Smoky Plum Kohl
86%
90%
Longwear Performance
88%
Blendability
92%
Ease of Application
87%
Shade Intensity (Smoky Plum Kohl)
91%
Smoothness of Formula
More
Mia Secret UV Finish Gel 0.5 oz
Mia Secret UV Finish Gel 0.5 oz
80%
93%
Shine & Finish Quality
88%
Wear & Chip Resistance
86%
Adhesion & Bonding
71%
Ease of Application
74%
Value for Money
More
Too Faced Killer Liner 36-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil - Killer Queen (Plum)
Too Faced Killer Liner 36-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil - Killer Queen (Plum)
86%
94%
Longevity
91%
Waterproof Performance
85%
Ease of Application
89%
Comfort for Sensitive Eyes
93%
Pigmentation
More
Estée Lauder Double Wear Long-Lasting 24H Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil - 01 Onyx
Estée Lauder Double Wear Long-Lasting 24H Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil - 01 Onyx
88%
96%
Waterproof Performance
92%
Smudge-Proof Effectiveness
88%
24-Hour Wear
89%
Application Ease
93%
Color Intensity
More
Estée Lauder Smoke and Brighten Kajal Eyeliner Pencil Duo, 0.03oz - Dark Chocolate/Rich Bronze
Estée Lauder Smoke and Brighten Kajal Eyeliner Pencil Duo, 0.03oz - Dark Chocolate/Rich Bronze
85%
91%
Waterproof Performance
88%
Ease of Application
85%
Longevity (Wear Time)
93%
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes
89%
Blendability & Texture
More
blinc Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil 0.5g
blinc Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil 0.5g
80%
88%
Longevity & Wear Time
91%
Smudge, Water & Transfer Resistance
86%
Application & Glide
71%
Built-In Sharpener Reliability
78%
Tip Precision & Control
More
Laura Geller Ideal Fix 1.06oz Liquid Concealer
Laura Geller Ideal Fix 1.06oz Liquid Concealer
77%
88%
Coverage Performance
74%
Shade Accuracy
69%
Longevity & Wear
83%
Texture & Application
61%
Skincare Ingredient Benefit
More

FAQ

The Laura Geller INKcredible 0.32oz Gel Eyeliner Pencil is built on a waterproof, smudge-proof gel base, so it generally holds up well through a standard workday. Results can vary depending on skin type — oily lids tend to test any liner more aggressively than normal. Adding a thin eyeshadow primer underneath before application can meaningfully extend wear time if fading is a recurring issue for you.

Yes, the pencil format offers considerably more control and forgiveness than a liquid liner brush tip. If you wobble slightly or need to adjust the line, there is a short window before the gel sets where you can blend or correct the shape. For anyone who has had trouble steadying their hand with liquid liner, a creamy gel pencil like this one is a practical step down in difficulty without giving up much pigment intensity.

That depends largely on how often you sharpen it and how much product you lay down per session. Sharpening removes product each time, so the more frequently you do it, the faster the pencil wears down. For a moderate daily user applying liner to upper and lower lids, expect anywhere from a few weeks to a couple of months — which is typical for any standard-size pencil eyeliner in this format.

The built-in sharpener is a genuine convenience and works well for most users, particularly early in the pencil's life. Some buyers have noted it can feel a bit lightweight and become less consistent as the pencil gets shorter. Keeping a small, quality cosmetic sharpener as a backup is not a bad idea — especially if you prefer a very precise tip for fine-line work.

Brown Eyed Girl leans warm — it is an earthy, medium brown with subtle warmth rather than a cool or ashy undertone. It reads natural and flattering on fair to medium skin tones, and serves as a softer alternative to black for those who want definition without a stark contrast. Deeper skin tones may find it understated for bold looks, though it works well as a gentle daytime option even then.

The waterproof gel formula is one of the better arguments for choosing this liner if you have oily lids. Gel formulas generally outlast standard kohl or wax-based pencils when oil production and humidity are factors. Applying a translucent setting powder or eyeshadow primer over the lid before lining can push staying power even further if creasing is a persistent problem.

Pencil eyeliners with a gel formula can be used on the waterline, and the INKcredible pencil is no exception. Keep in mind that the waterline is a naturally moist area and virtually no liner lasts as long there as it does on the lid — waterproof formulas still fade faster in that location. Sharpening the tip beforehand will give you the cleanest application along the inner rim.

Regular face wash or standard micellar water alone may not fully cut through a waterproof gel formula. An oil-based cleanser or a remover specifically labeled for waterproof makeup works best — press a soaked cotton pad gently against the liner for a few seconds before wiping, rather than rubbing, to avoid irritating the skin around the eyes. This is the standard removal approach for any waterproof liner in this category.

The product listing does not carry specific ophthalmologist-tested or hypoallergenic certifications, so anyone with known cosmetic sensitivities should review the full ingredient list before purchasing. Contact lens wearers can generally use gel pencil liners without issue — the practical advice is to insert lenses first, then apply liner, and to avoid placing product directly on the waterline if you wear contacts regularly.

It handles both well. A freshly sharpened tip gives you a clean, controlled line; tilting the pencil slightly and pressing the side of the tip along the lid deposits more product that you can then blend with a brush or fingertip into a soft, smoky effect. The creamy gel texture blends relatively easily before it fully sets, which actually makes it more cooperative for smoke-out techniques than harder, drier pencil formulas.