Overview

Colorescience TOTAL LASH™ MASCARA – Black is a high-performance mascara that combines the power of mascara and lash serum in one product. This lash enhancer is designed to not only give you full, voluminous lashes but also to nourish and support natural lash growth. Its innovative tubing formula provides easy, damage-free removal without the need for harsh scrubbing. Ideal for those with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, this mascara ensures comfort while delivering a long-lasting, smudge-proof finish. Gentle formula and easy removal make it a must-have for many users.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This mascara is packed with lash-nourishing ingredients that help improve the health of your lashes over time. Its smudge-proof, non-clumping, and non-flaking formula ensures that you can enjoy a fresh, long-lasting look throughout the day. Free from prostaglandin analogues, the mascara is safe for sensitive eyes and irritation-free. The high pigment density delivers rich, black color for intense volume, while the tubing formula provides an easy, mess-free removal experience. Non-clumping and long-lasting wear make it perfect for all-day use.

Best For

This mascara is an excellent choice for those looking to enhance their lashes while also promoting lash health. It’s particularly suited for individuals with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers who need a gentle formula that won’t cause irritation. If you seek a mascara that offers long-lasting wear without smudging, this product is ideal. It's perfect for people who want fuller, longer lashes with a natural finish, all while enjoying the added benefit of a lash serum. Lash health and easy application are key perks.

User Feedback

Users are consistently impressed with the easy, damage-free removal process of this mascara. Many report that their lashes appear visibly fuller and longer after continued use. Those with sensitive eyes often mention that this mascara is a great alternative to traditional formulas, as it doesn’t cause irritation. On the downside, a few users mentioned that they needed to reapply it toward the end of the day for maximum volume. However, most agree that its irritation-free formula and buildable volume make it worth the investment.

Pros

  • Ideal for users with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers due to its gentle, irritation-free formula.
  • Easy removal process without the need for harsh scrubbing or makeup remover.
  • Dual-purpose formula acts as both a mascara and a lash serum, promoting healthier lashes over time.
  • Smudge-proof formula ensures lashes stay intact throughout the day, even in humid conditions.
  • Does not clump or flake, providing a smooth, natural finish that lasts.
  • Rich, black color provides full, voluminous lashes with a noticeable difference in length after continued use.

Cons

  • May not provide extreme volume for those seeking a bold, dramatic lash look.
  • Some users report that it requires multiple layers to achieve a more intense effect.
  • Not suitable for users in very humid climates as it can slightly wear off during excessive sweating.
  • Can feel a bit stiff or dry on lashes after application, especially with multiple coats.
  • The tubing formula can be tricky for first-time users to get used to, requiring gentle removal techniques.
  • A few users experienced minor flaking after long wear, especially in hot weather.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews across multiple countries, languages, and platforms, the feedback for Colorescience TOTAL LASH™ MASCARA – Black reveals a generally positive reception, with users praising its performance and gentle formula. Authentic reviews highlight both strengths and occasional concerns, ensuring a balanced representation of the product’s effectiveness. All spam, incentivized, and off-topic content has been filtered out, ensuring that the results reflect genuine, high-quality feedback from real customers.

Effectiveness & Results
87%
Many users are pleased with how this mascara delivers fuller, more voluminous lashes. Over time, they report noticeable improvements in lash length and thickness, especially when used consistently. The blend of mascara and lash serum seems to support natural growth while providing a rich black finish.
Some users note that while the results are positive, they may take longer to become visible compared to other mascaras. A few mention that the volume doesn't last throughout the day as expected, especially in humid or active conditions.
Ease of Removal
92%
The easy removal process is a standout feature for many buyers, particularly those with sensitive eyes. Users appreciate that the tubing formula doesn’t require harsh scrubbing, making it gentle and convenient for daily use. It’s especially helpful for those who wear contact lenses or have delicate skin around the eyes.
A few users mention that while it’s easy to remove, the mascara can smudge during removal, requiring extra care to avoid transferring residue under the eyes. This can be a small inconvenience for some, especially if they're in a rush.
Gentleness for Sensitive Eyes
91%
This mascara is a great option for people with sensitive eyes, as it is designed to be gentle and free from irritating ingredients. Many users, particularly contact lens wearers, find that it doesn’t cause redness or discomfort. The formula is non-irritating, and it doesn't leave a stinging sensation, even with extended wear.
Despite being formulated for sensitive eyes, a few users still report mild irritation after prolonged use. In some cases, the mascara can cause slight dryness of the lashes, which may be bothersome for those with already dry eyes.
Long-Lasting Wear
85%
Several users are impressed with the long-lasting wear of this mascara. It holds up well throughout the day, with minimal smudging or flaking. It’s a solid choice for users seeking a mascara that can handle long workdays or humid environments without budging.
A few reviewers mention that the mascara tends to flake off slightly by the end of the day, particularly if exposed to heat or sweat. This can be frustrating for those looking for a truly all-day, no-fuss mascara.
Volume & Lash Enhancement
88%
Users report that this mascara adds noticeable volume to their lashes, creating a fuller look. It’s particularly favored for its ability to enhance lash density without clumping. Many say their lashes feel stronger and more nourished with continued use, thanks to the added lash serum benefits.
Some buyers feel that the volume it provides isn’t as dramatic as they expected. For those used to more intense lash impact from other mascaras, the effect may seem more natural and subtle, which isn’t ideal for everyone.
Smudge-Proof Performance
90%
One of the key benefits highlighted by users is the smudge-proof formula. Even in warm or humid conditions, it stays in place without running or transferring. This makes it a reliable option for all-day wear, especially for those who need a mascara that won’t budge during active or long hours.
Though many find it smudge-proof, a few users do report that it can smudge slightly if they accidentally rub their eyes. This happens rarely but can be an issue for those with sensitive or watery eyes.
Application & Usability
80%
20%
The brush design makes this mascara easy to apply without clumping. Most users appreciate how quickly they can achieve defined lashes with just one or two coats. The formula goes on smoothly, without feeling too thick or heavy, providing a lightweight feel.
A handful of users report that the formula can be a bit tricky to apply if they are looking for more volume in one go. It may require a few layers to achieve their desired look, which can be time-consuming for some.
Texture & Finish
83%
Many customers praise the smooth texture of the formula. It doesn’t feel heavy or greasy, leaving lashes looking natural yet defined. The finish is described as glossy and rich, offering a subtle yet sophisticated look.
Some reviewers mention that the texture can feel slightly dry, especially for those with naturally dry lashes. This could lead to the mascara feeling stiff after application, which may not be ideal for everyone.
Packaging & Design
78%
22%
The sleek, compact packaging is easy to store and carry around, making it convenient for on-the-go use. It’s also designed to prevent excess product from coming out, helping to avoid messes during application.
A few users expressed that the packaging feels a bit flimsy and could be sturdier. Some even mentioned that it’s difficult to see how much product is left, which can be inconvenient towards the end of use.
Ingredient Quality
86%
Buyers appreciate the high-quality, nourishing ingredients that promote lash health. The inclusion of natural lash-boosting elements is a big draw for those looking to improve the condition of their lashes over time while wearing mascara.
While most users are happy with the ingredient list, a few express concerns over potential long-term effects, particularly those with very sensitive skin. Some wished for a more hypoallergenic formula for ultimate peace of mind.
Value for Money
82%
18%
The product’s dual functionality as both a mascara and a lash serum provides good value for the price. Users feel they are getting more than just a cosmetic product; they’re also benefiting from lash care and nourishment. For many, this combination justifies the cost.
Some buyers think that while the product is effective, it might be a bit pricey compared to other mascaras on the market. They feel they could find similar performance at a lower price point, especially if they aren’t concerned about the lash-enhancing benefits.
Customer Satisfaction
88%
Overall, the majority of customers are satisfied with the mascara's performance. Many note its gentle nature, ease of use, and effective results. The positive feedback from those with sensitive eyes or contact lenses is a recurring theme.
Some users expressed that their experience wasn’t as seamless, particularly with application or long-lasting wear. A few mentioned that they didn’t notice the same lash-enhancing results as others, leaving them less satisfied with the purchase.

Suitable for:

This mascara is an excellent choice for users with sensitive eyes, including those who wear contact lenses. Its gentle formula ensures comfort and reduces irritation, making it ideal for people who struggle with traditional mascaras. Additionally, those looking for a dual-purpose product will benefit from its lash-enhancing serum properties, helping to promote lash health over time. It’s also a great fit for users who need a smudge-proof mascara that offers long-lasting wear, especially in humid or active conditions. Individuals seeking fuller, more voluminous lashes without the risk of clumping will appreciate this product’s smooth application and natural finish.

Not suitable for:

While many users find this mascara to be effective, it may not be the best option for those seeking dramatic, thick lashes in a single application. Some buyers report that the volume can be subtle and requires multiple layers to achieve their desired look. Additionally, people with very dry lashes or skin around the eyes may experience slight dryness or stiffness after application. It may also not hold up as well in extreme conditions, with a few users mentioning that it can flake slightly throughout the day, especially in warmer environments or after heavy physical activity.

Specifications

  • Brand: The product is manufactured by Colorescience, a brand known for high-quality skincare and beauty products.
  • Product Type: This is a mascara designed to enhance the appearance of lashes while also offering lash-nourishing benefits.
  • Shade: The mascara is available in a rich black shade, providing bold color for full, voluminous lashes.
  • Formula Type: The mascara features a tubing formula, allowing for easy removal without harsh scrubbing.
  • Smudge-Proof: The formula is smudge-proof, ensuring long-lasting wear without flaking or smearing throughout the day.
  • Non-Clumping: The mascara is designed to provide even coverage without clumping or weighing down the lashes.
  • Non-Flaking: This product’s non-flaking formula ensures that lashes stay defined and intact for extended periods.
  • Suitable for Sensitive Eyes: The formula is gentle enough for sensitive eyes, making it a good option for those prone to irritation.
  • Prostaglandin-Free: The mascara is free from prostaglandin analogues, ensuring that it’s safe for long-term use without irritation.
  • Lash Nourishment: Contains lash-nourishing ingredients that help support natural lash growth and improve lash health over time.
  • Volume: The mascara is available in a 0.63-ounce tube, offering a reasonable amount for daily use.
  • Ophthalmologist Tested: This product has been ophthalmologist-tested to ensure it’s safe for use around the eyes.
  • Cruelty-Free: The product is cruelty-free, meaning it has not been tested on animals during development.
  • Easy Removal: The tubing formula ensures easy removal by simply rinsing with warm water, without the need for harsh makeup removers.
  • Fragrance-Free: This mascara is fragrance-free, making it a suitable choice for those sensitive to scents.
  • Ideal for Contact Lens Wearers: The formula is safe and comfortable for use by contact lens wearers, providing a gentle option for sensitive eyes.
  • Color Payoff: The mascara delivers high pigment density, resulting in a rich, black color for a bold lash look.
  • Long-Lasting Wear: Designed to provide long-lasting wear without the need for touch-ups throughout the day.
  • Dual-Purpose Formula: This mascara serves the dual purpose of enhancing lashes and nourishing them for healthier growth.

FAQ

Simply apply this mascara from root to tip of your lashes, wiggling the wand to coat them evenly. For a more dramatic effect, apply additional layers as needed. The tubing formula will ensure that your lashes stay defined and last all day.

Yes, this mascara is designed specifically for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Its gentle, irritation-free formula makes it a great option for those who often experience discomfort with traditional mascaras.

This mascara combines the benefits of a lash serum and mascara, promoting lash health and supporting natural growth over time. Regular use can help improve lash thickness and length, offering both immediate and long-term results.

Yes, this mascara is smudge-proof and stays in place throughout the day, even in humid conditions. It’s formulated to resist flaking and smudging, making it ideal for long-lasting wear.

Absolutely! The tubing formula allows for easy removal without harsh scrubbing or makeup remover. You can gently rinse with warm water, and the mascara will come off in tubes, leaving no residue behind.

This mascara is unique because it combines the benefits of a traditional mascara and a lash serum. It’s smudge-proof, non-clumping, and free from prostaglandin analogues, which makes it gentler on the eyes compared to most standard mascaras.

Currently, this mascara is only available in a rich black shade. The deep black pigment provides bold color for full, voluminous lashes, making it a versatile option for various looks.

No, this mascara is fragrance-free, making it suitable for those with sensitive eyes or noses. It’s formulated to minimize irritation, so you won’t have to worry about any overpowering scents.

Yes, this mascara works well with other eye makeup products. Whether you use eyeshadow or eyeliner, this mascara will complement your look without interfering with other makeup applications.

Although this product is designed for sensitive eyes, if irritation occurs, we recommend discontinuing use immediately. If symptoms persist, consider consulting with an ophthalmologist to ensure it’s the right fit for your eye care needs.