Overview

The Besame Black Cake Mascara, Liquid Eyeliner & Brow Definer is a versatile 3-in-1 beauty product that combines essential makeup tools in one compact item. This water-activated formula is perfect for those who value both convenience and quality. The product is packaged in a reusable tin with a recyclable insert, reflecting its eco-friendly design. With this one product, you can easily apply mascara, define your brows, and create bold eyeliner looks. Whether you're heading to work or a night out, this multi-use product helps streamline your beauty routine.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This 3-in-1 makeup kit is crafted with 7 clean, natural ingredients that are free from harsh chemicals and parabens. The vegan formula ensures it's suitable for even the most sensitive eyes, while its cruelty-free nature supports ethical beauty practices. The product offers long-lasting, smudge-proof wear, so you can rely on it throughout the day without worrying about touch-ups. Whether you're after a defined brow, flawless eyeliner, or voluminous lashes, this formula stands up to the challenge of providing reliable, beautiful results.

Best For

This product is ideal for individuals who appreciate a minimalist approach to makeup. If you're looking for a multi-use makeup product that combines mascara, eyeliner, and brow definer in one, this is the perfect solution. It's especially beneficial for those with sensitive eyes or anyone who seeks clean, eco-conscious beauty. Its durable and long-lasting formula makes it a great choice for busy individuals who need their makeup to stay put from morning to night, without constant reapplication.

User Feedback

Users are overwhelmingly positive about the Besame Black Cake Mascara, Liquid Eyeliner & Brow Definer, with many praising its versatility and convenience. The fact that it combines three products into one makes it a top choice for minimalists. Many also highlight the easy application and natural finish, making it perfect for both everyday wear and special occasions. However, a few users note that it can take some practice to master the water-activated formula. Despite this, most agree that the smudge-proof formula is a standout feature.

Pros

  • The 3-in-1 design is convenient for users who want to minimize the number of products in their makeup bag.
  • Water-activated formula allows for buildable coverage, making it adaptable for both subtle and bold looks.
  • Eco-friendly packaging with a reusable tin is a big plus for sustainability-conscious buyers.
  • Vegan and cruelty-free formula is perfect for those with sensitive eyes or those committed to clean beauty.
  • Smudge-proof performance lasts throughout the day, even in more active environments.
  • This product is great for travel due to its compact size and multifunctionality.

Cons

  • Some users find the water-activated formula requires a bit of practice to achieve the right consistency.
  • May not provide the intense volume or definition some users expect from a mascara.
  • Not ideal for humid climates, where the formula may fade or smudge.
  • The reusable tin packaging, while eco-friendly, may not be ideal for users seeking ultra-lightweight makeup options.
  • Some users report that the product doesn't provide enough definition for brows in comparison to traditional brow pencils.
  • The price point may be considered high for those only looking for a mascara or eyeliner.

Ratings

After analyzing verified reviews from multiple platforms and languages worldwide, we've compiled the scores for the Besame Black Cake Mascara, Liquid Eyeliner & Brow Definer based on authentic feedback. Spam, bot-incentivized, and off-topic reviews were filtered out to ensure only genuine opinions shaped the results. Both strengths and pain points are reflected in the scores, giving a balanced view from a wide range of users across various countries and languages.

Versatility (3-in-1 Functionality)
91%
Many users love the convenience of having three beauty essentials in one product. The combination of a mascara, liquid eyeliner, and brow definer saves time and space in their makeup bags. It's especially popular with those who prefer minimalist beauty routines without sacrificing performance.
Some users felt that while the product excels in versatility, the mascara and brow definer could use a bit more volume or definition. A few found that it doesn't deliver the same intensity as individual products, especially for more dramatic looks.
Long-lasting Wear
88%
Reviewers consistently highlight how well this product stays in place throughout the day. The long-lasting formula holds up even through busy workdays, hot weather, or active schedules, making it ideal for those who need reliable, all-day wear.
A few buyers noted that while it’s generally long-lasting, the product may start to show slight fading or smudging by the end of the day, especially in very humid conditions. This could be a concern for those looking for a truly all-day, flawless look.
Smudge-proof Formula
84%
This product is praised for its smudge-proof formula, making it an excellent choice for users who want to avoid constant touch-ups. Many find it holds up well against sweat, tears, and daily activities, providing a clean look from morning to night.
While most users find the smudge-proof aspect reliable, some mentioned that it can be difficult to remove at the end of the day. A few people reported it left stubborn residue even after using makeup removers, requiring extra effort to clean.
Eco-friendly Packaging
89%
Buyers appreciate the product’s commitment to sustainability, especially the reusable tin and recyclable packaging. Many feel good about using an eco-friendly product that helps reduce waste while still providing a high-quality makeup experience.
A small group of users expressed frustration that the packaging, though eco-friendly, feels a bit bulky. Some find it less convenient for travel, preferring a more streamlined design to save space in their makeup bags.
Ease of Application
80%
20%
Several reviewers note how easy it is to apply, thanks to the water-activated formula. The consistency is smooth, making it user-friendly for both beginners and experienced makeup enthusiasts who want a quick, natural look.
Some users struggled with the water-activated formula, mentioning that it requires a bit of practice to get the right consistency. A few also found that it took longer to apply compared to traditional liquid eyeliners or mascaras.
Vegan & Cruelty-free Ingredients
92%
This product receives high marks for its clean, vegan, and cruelty-free ingredients, which is a major draw for ethically-minded consumers. Many users with sensitive eyes also appreciate the gentle, non-irritating formula.
A few users noted that while the product is cruelty-free, they would prefer more transparency on the sourcing and formulation process. A small group also mentioned that they wish it included more natural oils or moisturizing ingredients for extra comfort.
Water-activated Formula
78%
22%
The water-activated formula is highly appreciated by users who prefer a more customizable makeup experience. It's easy to adjust the intensity of the color by adding more water, which allows for a versatile look from light to bold.
However, some users struggled to get the consistency right, with the product either becoming too watery or too thick. A few found the formula tricky to work with, leading to uneven application or drying out too quickly.
Packaging Durability
85%
The durable tin packaging is a hit with many buyers, as it provides a secure, sturdy container for travel. Users appreciate that the reusable tin helps keep the product safe and well-protected from external elements.
Some found the tin packaging a bit too bulky for their liking. A few reviewers mentioned that while the tin is eco-friendly, it takes up more space than typical plastic tubes, which can be inconvenient for those with minimal storage.
Scent/Fragrance
75%
25%
While not a primary feature, the product's neutral or minimal scent is appreciated by users sensitive to fragrances. It doesn't overwhelm the senses, making it suitable for those who prefer their beauty products to be fragrance-free or lightly scented.
A few users reported a slight chemical or artificial scent upon application, which can be off-putting, especially for those sensitive to smells. While the fragrance fades quickly, it's something some buyers wish could be avoided entirely.
Sensitive Eye Suitability
87%
Many users with sensitive eyes find this product gentle and non-irritating. The vegan, cruelty-free formula works well for those prone to eye redness or discomfort, making it an appealing choice for individuals with delicate skin around the eyes.
Despite its gentle formula, a few users with extremely sensitive eyes experienced irritation after prolonged wear. Some found it uncomfortable after applying the product, especially if worn for an extended period.
Product Consistency (Batch to Batch)
80%
20%
Most buyers report a consistent experience across different batches, with the formula and performance largely matching expectations. This reliability is important for users who want the same quality every time they purchase the product.
A few users mentioned slight differences between batches in terms of texture or color payoff. While not a widespread issue, some found that their recent purchases didn’t perform as well as their initial ones, causing some inconsistency in their makeup routine.
Value for Money
90%
This product offers great value considering its versatility and multi-use nature. Users feel they’re getting three beauty products for the price of one, which many find reasonable given the high-quality, eco-conscious ingredients.
Some buyers felt that while the product is affordable for what it offers, it might not be the best option for those who prefer more specialized, high-performance mascaras or eyeliners. A few were willing to pay more for more intensive formulas in each category.

Suitable for:

This product is ideal for individuals looking for a minimalist beauty routine, especially those who prefer a multi-use product. Users who want to streamline their makeup bag will appreciate the versatility of having mascara, liquid eyeliner, and brow definer all in one compact option. It's particularly well-suited for people with sensitive eyes, as the vegan and cruelty-free formula is gentle and free from harsh chemicals. Those who are eco-conscious will also benefit from its reusable tin packaging and recyclable insert. The water-activated formula is perfect for those who enjoy customizable coverage, from a subtle, natural look to more defined intensity.

Not suitable for:

The Besame Black Cake Mascara, Liquid Eyeliner & Brow Definer may not be the best choice for individuals who need highly specialized formulas. Those expecting a dramatic, high-volume mascara or more intense eyeliner may find the product's performance lacking. Users with very oily skin or in humid conditions might experience fading or smudging over the course of the day, as some reviewers noted that it doesn't hold up as well under such circumstances. Additionally, people who prefer a traditional, non-water-activated formula might find the application process slightly cumbersome, requiring some experimentation to get the right consistency.

Specifications

  • Product Type: A 3-in-1 makeup kit that includes mascara, liquid eyeliner, and brow definer.
  • Formula: Water-activated formula for easy application and natural, long-lasting results.
  • Packaging: Comes in a reusable tin with a recyclable insert, making it eco-friendly.
  • Vegan: The product is vegan and free from animal-derived ingredients.
  • Cruelty-Free: This product is cruelty-free and not tested on animals.
  • Free From: Formulated without harsh chemicals, parabens, or synthetic fragrances.
  • Smudge-Proof: Designed to be smudge-proof, ensuring the makeup stays intact throughout the day.
  • Long-Lasting: Offers long-lasting wear, resistant to fading during normal daily activities.
  • Ideal For: Perfect for users with sensitive eyes or those seeking eco-conscious beauty products.
  • Ingredients: Contains 7 clean, natural ingredients, providing a gentle, safe formula.
  • Application: Can be applied to lashes, eyelids, and brows for a versatile beauty routine.
  • Shade: Available in a versatile black shade suitable for a variety of skin tones.
  • Texture: The product has a smooth, easy-to-apply texture when activated with water.
  • Waterproof: Water-activated, providing a waterproof finish once dried.
  • Travel-Friendly: Compact size and sturdy packaging make it ideal for travel.
  • Storage: Store in a cool, dry place to preserve the water-activated formula.
  • Suitability: Ideal for users seeking a minimalist, multi-use product for their makeup routine.
  • Environmental Impact: The packaging is designed to minimize environmental impact with recyclable materials.
  • Allergy-Safe: Formulated to minimize irritation, making it suitable for those with allergies to common cosmetics ingredients.

FAQ

This versatile 3-in-1 product can be used as a mascara, liquid eyeliner, and brow definer. Simply wet the product with a small amount of water to activate the formula, and apply it to your lashes, eyelids, or brows as desired. Adjust the water amount for varying levels of intensity.

Yes, this product is vegan, cruelty-free, and formulated without harsh chemicals, making it ideal for sensitive eyes. Its clean, natural ingredients are gentle, and many users appreciate its non-irritating properties, even for those with sensitive skin.

This 3-in-1 product is made with 7 clean, natural ingredients and is free from parabens and harsh chemicals. It’s a great option for those seeking a more natural, eco-conscious beauty routine.

Yes, the formula is smudge-proof and resistant to fading, providing all-day wear. Whether you’re using it for mascara, eyeliner, or brows, this product stays in place through daily activities.

This product is fragrance-free, making it suitable for users sensitive to scented cosmetics. The clean, simple formula focuses on performance rather than fragrance.

To use this product as a brow definer, simply wet the formula to activate it, then use a small brush or applicator to fill in your brows. The water-activated formula gives you flexibility to control the intensity of your brow color.

Yes, the product comes in a reusable tin with a recyclable insert, making it a great choice for eco-conscious buyers. The compact design also makes it travel-friendly and environmentally responsible.

While this product is generally smudge-proof, users in humid climates or with oily skin may find that it requires touch-ups after long periods of wear. It works best in moderate conditions where sweat and humidity are not excessive.

Store the product in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Make sure to securely close the tin after use to prevent the formula from drying out and to maintain its water-activated properties.

Yes, this product is safe for contact lens wearers, as it’s formulated with gentle ingredients and is free from irritating chemicals. Many users with contact lenses have reported that it doesn’t cause discomfort or dryness.