Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette

Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette — image 1
Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette — image 2
Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette — image 3
Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette — image 4
Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette — image 5
Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette — image 6
Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette — image 7
77%
23%
91%
Pigmentation
88%
Blendability
74%
Shade Range
67%
Longevity
58%
Shimmer Fallout
79%
Packaging Quality
72%
Value for Money
83%
Scent Experience
89%
Beginner Friendliness
94%
Cruelty-Free Credentials
63%
Portability
76%
Color Payoff on Deeper Skin Tones
61%
Shade Uniqueness
More

Overview

The Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette is a prestige-tier eyeshadow collection built around warm, chocolate-inspired tones that work equally well for a low-key daytime look or something more dramatic after dark. The brand sits comfortably in the mid-to-premium makeup space, and this palette reflects that positioning — the packaging feels considered, the color story is cohesive, and its cruelty-free commitment is worth noting for shoppers who care about ethical beauty. Expect 18 shades ranging from soft, wearable neutrals to deeper, richer tones with both matte and shimmer finishes. It's not a niche editorial palette; it's designed to be genuinely usable, day in and day out.

Features & Benefits

This chocolate-scented palette packs 18 pressed-powder shades into a single compact case, covering the full spectrum from flat mattes to foil-like metallics. What makes it practical is the one-swipe pigmentation — most shades show up on the lid without requiring multiple passes or heavy-handed application, which is genuinely useful when you're in a hurry. The formula blends out smoothly, so hard edges aren't much of a concern even for less experienced hands. The packaging is on the larger side at roughly 9 by 6 inches, but it sits flat and includes a mirror. And yes, it smells like chocolate cake — which is either charming or distracting depending on your perspective.

Best For

This eyeshadow collection is a natural fit for anyone who gravitates toward warm, neutral tones and wants a palette that can handle both a quick everyday look and something more polished for evenings. It's particularly well-suited to beginners — the shades are forgiving, the formula is blendable, and you don't need advanced technique to get decent results. Gift-givers tend to like it too; the packaging is attractive, the scent is a talking point, and the brand recognition takes some of the guesswork out of buying makeup for someone else. Anyone committed to cruelty-free beauty will also appreciate that it checks that box without any real compromise on quality.

User Feedback

With a 4.5-star average from a substantial number of reviewers, the Too Faced palette earns its rating — but it's worth understanding where the praise lands and where it doesn't. Most people highlight strong pigmentation as the consistent win, noting that shades deliver color without needing to be built up. The chocolate scent gets mentioned often, usually positively, as a fun detail that sets it apart. On the other side, some users report shimmer fallout during application, and a few note that the deeper mattes benefit from an eyeshadow primer to stay put throughout the day. Packaging feedback is generally positive, though some find the case bulkier than expected for everyday carry.

#Eyeshadow
#Eyes
#Makeup
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • Most shades deliver strong color payoff in a single swipe, reducing application time significantly.
  • The 18-shade range covers a versatile mix of matte, shimmer, and metallic finishes in one palette.
  • Blendable formula is genuinely beginner-friendly, with little risk of harsh or patchy results.
  • The molten chocolate cake scent is a fun, distinctive detail that sets this eyeshadow collection apart.
  • Cruelty-free certification makes it an easy pick for ethically conscious shoppers.
  • Warm neutral shade range transitions naturally from daytime to evening without needing a second palette.
  • The packaging includes a built-in mirror, adding practical value for on-the-go touch-ups.
  • Strong brand recognition makes it a reliable, well-received gift option for makeup lovers.
  • Consistently high user ratings reflect a formula that delivers on its core pigmentation promise.

Cons

  • Shimmer and metallic shades can produce noticeable fallout during application without a sticky base.
  • Deeper matte shades tend to fade faster on oily lids without an eyeshadow primer underneath.
  • The case is bulkier than average, making it less practical for minimalist travel kits.
  • The warm-only color story leaves no options for cooler or unconventional tones.
  • A few shades in the lineup are similar enough to feel redundant rather than genuinely distinct.
  • The chocolate scent, while fun for many, can be off-putting for fragrance-sensitive users.
  • At its price point, the shade count and pan sizes may feel modest compared to some competing palettes.
  • No dedicated brush or application tool is included in the packaging.

Ratings

Our AI-generated scores for the Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette were built by analyzing thousands of verified global purchases, with spam, bot-submitted, and incentivized reviews actively filtered out before scoring. The ratings below reflect both the consistent strengths buyers appreciate and the friction points that show up repeatedly across independent feedback. Nothing has been smoothed over — this chocolate-scented palette earns its praise in several areas, but a few real trade-offs are worth knowing before you buy.

Pigmentation
91%
Color payoff is the single most praised aspect of this eyeshadow collection across all feedback segments. Users consistently report that most shades — particularly the mid-tone mattes and bronze metallics — show up fully saturated on the lid in one pass, even without a base underneath, which makes rushed morning routines much more manageable.
A small but notable portion of reviewers found that a few of the lighter, sheer shimmer shades needed extra layering to reach the intensity shown in promotional imagery. The gap between the deepest and most sheer shades is wider than average, which can create inconsistency across the 18-pan lineup.
Blendability
88%
The pressed-powder formula blends out smoothly and without excessive effort, which is a consistent talking point among beginners who note it is more forgiving than comparable palettes they have tried. Transitions between shades in the crease read naturally rather than muddy, even when applied with a basic brush.
A handful of users with drier skin or those working in low-humidity environments reported that some of the matte shades could feel slightly stiff during blending and required more layering than expected. The shimmer shades, while blendable, are less cooperative at the edges compared to the mattes.
Shade Range
74%
26%
For someone who lives in warm neutrals — tawny browns, bronze tones, deep chocolates, and golden highlights — the 18-shade lineup covers a well-thought-out range that transitions naturally from a soft daytime look to a smokier evening application without needing to reach for a second palette.
The palette is firmly committed to a single warm-brown color story, which is great if that is your wheelhouse but limiting otherwise. Cool-toned users, those who like the occasional pop of color, or anyone wanting versatility beyond the chocolate spectrum will find this collection restrictive fairly quickly.
Longevity
67%
33%
On normal to dry lids, most users report the shades hold through a standard workday without significant creasing or fading. The matte shades in particular tend to anchor well, making them a solid base layer for building more complex looks that need to last through long shifts or back-to-back commitments.
Wear time drops noticeably on oily lids without a primer, and this comes up frequently enough in feedback to treat it as a known limitation rather than an edge case. Several users specifically flagged that the deeper mattes fade at the outer edges by midday when applied directly to bare skin.
Shimmer Fallout
58%
42%
When applied with a flat shader brush rather than a fluffy blending brush, the metallic shades pack onto the lid with impressive density and a foil-like finish that photographs well. Users who prep with a damp brush or sticky glitter glue base report a significant reduction in the amount of fallout they experience.
Shimmer and metallic fallout is one of the most consistently raised complaints about this eyeshadow collection. Loose particles frequently drop onto the cheek area during application, which is an annoyance when foundation is already in place. It is manageable but requires a deliberate workflow adjustment that not every buyer wants to deal with.
Packaging Quality
79%
21%
The compact feels substantial in hand with a magnetic closure that snaps securely and keeps pans protected during travel. The full-panel interior mirror is a genuinely useful addition that gets called out positively in a large share of reviews, particularly from users who apply makeup away from home.
The case is wide and flat, which works well on a vanity but is cumbersome in smaller bags. A few buyers noted that the exterior finish shows fingerprints and smudges easily, and over time the hinge and closure can loosen slightly — not a dealbreaker, but worth noting for heavy daily use.
Value for Money
72%
28%
For a prestige-branded palette with 18 shades, strong pigmentation across most of the lineup, and cruelty-free credentials, the price lands in a range that most buyers find reasonable relative to other department store options. Gift buyers in particular consistently express satisfaction with how premium the product feels relative to its cost.
Drugstore alternatives have closed the gap on pigmentation and blendability enough that price-focused buyers may question whether the brand premium is justified. Pan sizes are also on the smaller side, meaning frequent users may find themselves reaching the bottom of their favorite shades sooner than expected.
Scent Experience
83%
The molten chocolate cake fragrance is a genuine differentiator that buyers mention unprompted as a memorable, enjoyable detail — it makes the application experience feel more indulgent and is strong enough to be noticeable without lingering heavily on the skin after blending.
The scent is polarizing at the margins. Users with fragrance sensitivities or those who prefer unscented cosmetics flag it as a real drawback rather than a gimmick they can ignore. It is also worth noting that the fragrance is infused into the formula itself, so there is no way to reduce it.
Beginner Friendliness
89%
This eyeshadow collection earns strong marks from newer makeup users who specifically cite the cohesive color story and smooth blendability as reasons they felt confident picking up the palette with minimal prior experience. The warm neutrals are naturally complementary, making it difficult to put together a combination that looks visibly wrong.
The shimmer fallout issue, while manageable for experienced users, can be frustrating for beginners who have not yet developed a deliberate application workflow. A brief guide or technique card included in the packaging would go a long way for this audience, but none is provided.
Cruelty-Free Credentials
94%
Too Faced holds a well-established cruelty-free certification, and this palette carries that status without compromise. For ethically motivated shoppers who have started scrutinizing beauty purchases more carefully, this is a significant trust signal that adds real perceived value to the overall proposition.
The palette is not certified vegan, and the ingredient list includes animal-derived components that are common in pressed-powder cosmetics. Buyers who specifically require a vegan formulation should verify before purchasing, as cruelty-free and vegan are not interchangeable certifications.
Portability
63%
37%
The slim profile — just over an inch thick — means the palette lays flat without creating awkward bulk in a makeup bag or carry-on. Users who pack it in a structured cosmetics case for travel report it fits neatly alongside other essentials without wasted space.
The footprint at over nine inches long and nearly six inches wide is objectively large relative to what many buyers expect from a day-to-day carry palette. Reviewers who purchased it expecting a compact travel option are among the more vocal disappointed voices, noting it fits a travel kit but does not fit a small handbag.
Color Payoff on Deeper Skin Tones
76%
24%
The deeper mattes — dark taupes, rich browns, and near-black chocolates — perform well across a wide range of skin tones and are frequently highlighted by users with medium to deep complexions as the strongest shades in the collection. Bronze and copper metallics also read with good visibility and payoff.
Several lighter shimmers and transition shades show minimal visual impact on deeper skin tones and effectively function only as highlighters or lid brighteners rather than the blendable mid-tones they appear to be in the pan. This limits the functional shade count for some users to roughly half the palette.
Shade Uniqueness
61%
39%
Within the warm brown spectrum, the palette does offer a genuine range of depth and finish variation — there are meaningful differences between the lighter taupes, mid-tone bronzes, and deeper espresso shades that make multiple shades worth reaching for across a single look.
Makeup enthusiasts who already own a warm neutral palette will find meaningful overlap with what they likely have. Several shade pairs are close enough in tone that they are effectively interchangeable, which reduces the true unique-shade count and is a fair criticism at this price point.

Suitable for:

The Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette is a strong match for anyone who wants a reliable, warm-toned palette that pulls double duty between everyday wear and more polished evening looks. Beginners will find the blendable, high-pigment formula forgiving enough to work with without advanced technique, while more experienced users will appreciate the range of finishes available across 18 shades. If you tend to gravitate toward earthy neutrals, tawny browns, and rich chocolatey tones, the color story here was essentially built for you. It also makes a genuinely thoughtful gift — the recognizable brand, attractive packaging, and novelty chocolate scent give it a premium feel that lands well without requiring the recipient to have a specific wishlist. Shoppers who prioritize cruelty-free formulations will find this collection ticks that box without compromising on color payoff.

Not suitable for:

The Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette will likely disappoint buyers looking for cool-toned, jewel-toned, or highly editorial shades — the entire palette leans warm and neutral, so there is not much here for anyone chasing blues, purples, or unconventional pops of color. Users with oily lids who skip eyeshadow primer may find wear time shorter than expected, particularly with the deeper matte shades. Those who prefer ultra-compact, on-the-go palettes should know the case is on the larger side and not the most pocketbook-friendly for travel. If shimmer fallout is a known pet peeve for you, the metallic shades in this collection have drawn some complaints on that front. And buyers on a tight budget who are purely after pigmentation and variety may find comparable options at a lower price point in the drugstore space.

Specifications

  • Brand: Too Faced is a U.S.-based prestige cosmetics brand known for its novelty-themed, cruelty-free makeup collections.
  • Shade Count: The palette contains 18 individual pressed-powder eyeshadow shades in a single compact case.
  • Finishes: Shades span three finish types: matte, shimmer, and metallic, offering a range of flat to high-shine looks.
  • Formula: All shades use a pressed-powder formula engineered for high pigmentation and smooth, buildable application.
  • Color Range: The shade selection is built around warm, neutral-to-rich tones including taupes, browns, bronzes, and deep chocolates.
  • Scent: The palette carries a signature molten chocolate cake fragrance infused into the formula.
  • Net Weight: The total product net weight is 0.7 oz (approximately 19.8 g) across all 18 pans.
  • Packaged Weight: The fully packaged unit weighs 8.78 oz (approximately 249 g) including the compact case.
  • Dimensions: The outer case measures approximately 9.17 x 5.91 x 1.14 inches, making it flat and vanity-friendly.
  • Mirror Included: The inside lid of the compact includes a full-panel mirror for on-the-go application reference.
  • Cruelty-Free: This product is certified cruelty-free, meaning it has not been tested on animals at any stage of production.
  • Item Form: All 18 shades are delivered in pressed-powder form, individually set into separate pans within the palette.
  • Brush Included: No applicator brush or blending tool is included in the standard packaging.
  • Avg. Rating: The palette holds an average customer rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars based on aggregated user reviews.
  • Category Rank: It ranks approximately #205 in the Eyeshadow category on Amazon and #29,608 in Beauty and Personal Care overall.
  • UPC: The product UPC is 651986007493, corresponding to the single-unit standard retail configuration.
  • Model Number: The manufacturer item model number is 2600856 as listed in official product records.
  • Manufacturer: The product is manufactured and distributed by Too Faced Cosmetics, LLC.

Related Reviews

Too Faced Chocolate Soleil Matte Bronzer
Too Faced Chocolate Soleil Matte Bronzer
78%
91%
Finish & Pigmentation
88%
Blendability
54%
Shade Range
78%
Longevity & Wear
67%
Value for Money
More
Laura Geller The Ultimate Palette Baked Eyeshadow Palette Sensation Soiree - 31 Shades
Laura Geller The Ultimate Palette Baked Eyeshadow Palette Sensation Soiree - 31 Shades
88%
94%
Pigmentation
88%
Blendability
91%
Longevity
78%
Fallout
85%
Texture
More
Too Faced Chocolate Soleil Bronzing Stick 0.28oz
Too Faced Chocolate Soleil Bronzing Stick 0.28oz
83%
93%
Blendability
89%
Formula & Texture
82%
Color Payoff
88%
Finish Quality
67%
Longevity
More
Laura Geller Party in a Palette Set
Laura Geller Party in a Palette Set
71%
83%
Value for Money
61%
Pigmentation & Color Payoff
74%
Blendability
57%
Wear Longevity
88%
Ease of Use
More
ColourPop After Hours Eyeshadow Palette 0.65oz
ColourPop After Hours Eyeshadow Palette 0.65oz
80%
88%
Pigmentation
91%
Blendability
74%
Shade Range
76%
Longevity
61%
Glitter Performance
More
BUXOM Makeup Eyeshadow Palette
BUXOM Makeup Eyeshadow Palette
86%
91%
Pigmentation Quality
87%
Blendability
88%
Longevity
90%
Sensitive Skin Compatibility
85%
Shimmer Effect
More
ColourPop Twilight Eyeshadow Palette
ColourPop Twilight Eyeshadow Palette
88%
94%
Pigmentation
88%
Blendability
92%
Finish Variety
89%
Longevity
80%
Packaging Design
More
ColourPop Golden Hour Eyeshadow Palette
ColourPop Golden Hour Eyeshadow Palette
87%
91%
Pigmentation & Color Payoff
88%
Blendability & Application
85%
Longevity & Wear Time
87%
Versatility for Day & Night Looks
82%
Texture & Feel on Skin
More
bareMinerals Mineralist 6-Shade Eyeshadow Palette
bareMinerals Mineralist 6-Shade Eyeshadow Palette
78%
72%
Pigmentation & Color Payoff
88%
Blendability
74%
Wear Longevity
91%
Formula & Ingredients
89%
Ease of Use
More
LORAC Mini PRO Eyeshadow Palette
LORAC Mini PRO Eyeshadow Palette
86%
88%
Color Payoff
92%
Blendability
94%
Packaging & Portability
90%
Versatility of Shades
85%
Finish Options (Matte, Shimmer, Metallic)
More

FAQ

It depends on your skin type. For normal to dry lids, most shades hold up reasonably well on their own. If you have oily lids or want maximum longevity, especially with the deeper mattes, using a dedicated eyeshadow primer beforehand makes a noticeable difference in wear time and color intensity.

The scent is present but not overwhelming for most people. It is most noticeable when you first open the case or swatch directly into the pans. During actual application the fragrance is subtle. That said, if you are sensitive to fragrance in cosmetics, it is worth knowing the scent is genuinely detectable rather than just a faint marketing claim.

It holds its own well in the prestige category. The pigmentation is consistently strong, the shade range is thoughtfully curated rather than padded with near-identical colors, and the formula blends smoothly without being chalky. Where some competitors edge it out is in shade variety or pan size, so if you want more experimental tones or larger pans, it is worth comparing a few options.

Yes, this is one of the more commonly noted drawbacks. The metallic and shimmer shades can shed a bit onto the under-eye area during application. Tapping your brush before applying and doing your eye makeup before foundation can help minimize cleanup afterward.

Absolutely. The blendable formula is forgiving, which means hard edges and patchy application are less of a problem here than with more pigment-dense or finicky formulas. The warm neutrals are also beginner-friendly in the sense that the shades pair naturally with each other, so it is hard to put together a combination that looks off.

A soft, dry brush or a clean cotton pad works well for sweeping loose fallout out of the case between the pans. Avoid using any wet wipes or liquid cleaners directly on the pressed pans, as moisture can break down the powder formula and affect how the shades apply.

Technically yes — applying a damp brush to pressed shimmer or metallic shades is a common technique to boost payoff and reduce fallout. That said, Too Faced does not officially promote this palette for wet application, so do a small test first and avoid over-saturating the pan.

The richer, deeper shades in this collection translate well on deeper skin tones, especially the bronzes and dark brown mattes. Some of the lighter, sheer shimmers may show up less dramatically but can still work as highlight shades. Overall the warm tone range is inclusive enough to be useful across a variety of skin tones.

It is genuinely well-suited for gifting. The packaging has a polished, premium look, the chocolate scent makes it feel like a novelty item rather than just a standard palette, and the Too Faced brand name is recognizable enough that most makeup enthusiasts will appreciate it. It also avoids niche or trend-dependent shades, which makes it a safer bet when you are buying for someone whose tastes you do not know in detail.

It is on the larger side, measuring just over 9 inches long and nearly 6 inches wide. It will fit in most standard makeup bags or train cases, but it is not something you would slip into a small clutch or a gym bag side pocket. Think of it more as a vanity or travel-kit palette rather than an everyday-carry item.