Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette, 18 Shades

88%

Blendability

Color Payoff

Scent Quality

Finish Variety

Longevity

Packaging Design

Cruelty-Free Formula

Shimmer Performance

Ease of Application

Value for Money

Ingredient Quality

Overall Versatility

User Experience

Overview

The Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette, 18 Shades, is a versatile eyeshadow collection offering 18 high-pigment shades. This palette features a beautiful mix of matte, shimmer, and metallic finishes, making it suitable for creating both everyday and bold, dramatic looks. One of its standout features is the signature molten chocolate cake scent, which adds a unique sensory experience to your makeup routine. Whether you're a beginner or a pro, this eyeshadow palette offers a wide range of shades for all occasions, with each color delivering rich, vibrant payoff.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This eyeshadow palette is infused with high-quality pigments that provide a one-swipe color payoff, ensuring vibrant results with minimal effort. The smooth texture of each shade allows for easy application and seamless blending, making it a favorite among makeup lovers for its blendability and long-lasting wear. As a cruelty-free product, it’s an ideal choice for those who are conscious of ethical beauty standards. The versatile formula performs well across different skin types, offering a reliable, beautiful finish that won’t fade throughout the day.

Best For

The Too Faced Better Than Chocolate palette is perfect for makeup enthusiasts seeking a versatile, all-in-one eyeshadow collection. It suits individuals who appreciate a variety of finishes—from matte to shimmer and metallic—and those who love bold, vibrant colors. This eyeshadow palette is also ideal for anyone who enjoys a subtle, sweet scent in their beauty products. If you're someone who enjoys experimenting with different looks and values high-pigment payoff, this palette will quickly become a staple in your collection.

User Feedback

Customers rave about the palette’s rich color payoff and its ability to blend effortlessly, making it a popular choice for both beginners and makeup experts alike. Many users also mention how the signature chocolate scent enhances their application experience, adding a playful touch to their beauty routine. However, some users note that the shimmer shades tend to perform better when used with a primer or setting spray, as this can help to maximize their longevity and vibrancy. Overall, the palette has earned positive reviews for its versatility and user-friendly formula.

#Eyeshadow

#Eyes

#Makeup

#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

The eyeshadows offer excellent color payoff with just one swipe, even in lighter shades.
The palette includes a good balance of matte, shimmer, and metallic finishes for versatile looks.
The blendability is praised, making it easy to create smooth, seamless eye makeup.
The unique molten chocolate cake scent adds an enjoyable, playful touch to the application process.
It is cruelty-free, which appeals to ethical consumers looking for vegan-friendly products.
The palette is well-suited for both everyday wear and special occasions, offering long-lasting performance.

Cons

The shimmer shades may require a primer or setting spray to perform at their best.
Some users found the scent too overpowering, especially for those sensitive to fragrances.
The palette may not be ideal for those who only prefer matte finishes, as the shimmer and metallic options dominate.
People with very oily eyelids might experience creasing or fading without proper base preparation.
At its price point, some customers felt the performance didn't justify the cost compared to similar palettes.
The palette is relatively large and may not be travel-friendly for those looking for something compact.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews worldwide from various platforms and languages, we’ve compiled feedback on the Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette, 18 Shades. All data is from authentic, high-quality reviews, excluding spam, bot-generated, and incentivized content. Both strengths and pain points have been considered in these ratings, offering a comprehensive view of the product's performance based on real-world use across different regions and demographics.

Blendability

91%

Many users love how effortlessly this palette blends. The smooth texture allows for seamless transitions between shades, making it ideal for both beginners and makeup enthusiasts. It’s particularly praised for creating natural, blended looks without patchiness or uneven application.

However, a few buyers mentioned that some shades, particularly the shimmer ones, can require extra effort to blend properly. Using a primer or setting spray seems to improve the performance, but not all users are satisfied with the level of blendability straight out of the palette.

Color Payoff

93%

The high-pigment formula provides one-swipe color payoff, which is a major plus for many buyers. Users rave about the vibrant and rich hues, especially the metallic shades, which deliver bold color without needing multiple layers. This makes it great for creating striking, statement looks quickly.

Some users noted that certain matte shades don’t deliver the same intensity as the shimmer and metallic ones. While most shades have excellent payoff, a few users found that the matte shades require building up or layering to achieve the desired depth.

Scent Quality

88%

The molten chocolate cake scent is a unique and playful touch that many users love. It adds an extra layer of enjoyment to the application process, making it feel more like an indulgent treat. For fans of sweet fragrances, this scent is definitely a standout feature.

On the flip side, some users felt the scent was a bit too strong for their liking, especially during prolonged wear. For those sensitive to scents, it might be overpowering or distracting, and a few customers even mentioned the fragrance fading too quickly after application.

Finish Variety

89%

This palette offers a great mix of matte, shimmer, and metallic finishes, allowing users to create a wide range of looks. Whether you’re going for a soft daytime look or a bold, night-out style, the versatility of the finishes makes it a favorite for those who love experimenting with eye makeup.

A handful of users reported that the metallic shades could sometimes feel a bit chunky or uneven, particularly without using a primer or setting spray. While the variety is appreciated, the shimmer finishes may not always perform as well as expected, requiring extra attention during application.

Longevity

85%

For the most part, users found that the eyeshadows stay in place for several hours without fading or creasing. The high-quality pigments contribute to lasting color, especially when paired with a primer. Many buyers feel confident that this palette will last throughout the day, even in humid conditions.

Some buyers did report that the eyeshadows tend to fade more quickly on oily eyelids, requiring touch-ups or a setting spray to ensure longevity. Those with oily skin types might need to invest in additional products to get the full-day wear they desire.

Packaging Design

80%

20%

The sleek and compact design of this eyeshadow palette is convenient for travel and storage. It’s lightweight, and the sturdy case keeps the shades protected, making it easy to carry around in makeup bags or purses.

However, a few users felt that the packaging could be improved, particularly in terms of the mirror size. The mirror inside is small and may not be ideal for detailed makeup application on the go. Additionally, the palette’s cardboard exterior is not as durable as some may expect for a product at this price point.

Cruelty-Free Formula

95%

The cruelty-free formula is highly appreciated by ethical consumers, as it aligns with values around animal welfare. This certification boosts the appeal for buyers who prioritize cruelty-free beauty products in their routines, adding an extra layer of trust and appeal to the brand.

While the cruelty-free aspect is a major pro for many, a small group of users wished the brand could do even more to minimize environmental impact, such as opting for fully recyclable packaging. Some also felt the ethical claims didn’t fully justify the price for some budget-conscious buyers.

Shimmer Performance

83%

When used with a primer or setting spray, the shimmer shades really shine. Many users find that these shades add a stunning, radiant finish to their makeup looks, elevating the overall eye makeup with their bold, metallic shine.

However, several users pointed out that the shimmer shades sometimes lack smoothness and can be difficult to apply without fallout. They may not be as consistent or finely milled as some of the competitor shimmer formulas, requiring extra effort to apply without mess.

Ease of Application

90%

This palette is praised for its smooth, blendable texture that makes it easy to apply, even for beginners. The shades are forgiving, allowing for effortless blending across the eyelid to create a variety of looks with minimal fuss.

Some users did mention that the matte shades are slightly drier compared to the shimmer and metallic ones, which can make them a bit trickier to blend if you have dry skin. A few users noted that they needed a little more effort to get the smooth, even application they were hoping for.

Value for Money

87%

Many buyers felt this eyeshadow palette offers excellent value for the price. With 18 shades, including a mix of finishes, the palette provides a lot of variety for creating different eye looks, making it a worthwhile investment for makeup enthusiasts.

Despite the wide array of shades, some customers thought the price point was on the higher side, especially when compared to similar palettes from other brands. A few users mentioned that while the product is high-quality, it may not be budget-friendly for everyone.

Ingredient Quality

92%

The high-quality pigments used in this palette stand out as a significant benefit. They’re vibrant and true to color, with minimal fading throughout the day. The cruelty-free formula also adds peace of mind for those concerned about product ingredients.

Some users with sensitive skin reported irritation or discomfort after wearing the eyeshadows for long periods. While the formula is generally well-received, a small group of users wished there were more natural or hypoallergenic ingredient options.

Overall Versatility

88%

This palette’s versatility is one of its strongest selling points. Whether you want to create a neutral daytime look or a bold evening eye, the broad range of shades and finishes means you can easily adapt it for any occasion or mood.

A few users noted that while the variety is appealing, some of the darker shades may not suit all skin tones. Additionally, users with more specific preferences for matte-only or shimmer-only palettes may find the mixed finishes less ideal.

User Experience

84%

Many users enjoyed the overall experience of using this product, from the rich texture to the ease of blending. It makes creating makeup looks fun and satisfying, with minimal effort required for great results.

However, some users found that the shimmer shades didn’t perform as well as expected, especially without primer. Additionally, a few noted the scent, while playful, was not to everyone’s taste, which affected their overall enjoyment of the product.

Suitable for:

The Too Faced Better Than Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette, 18 Shades is ideal for makeup enthusiasts who enjoy experimenting with a variety of eye looks. It’s perfect for those who appreciate high-pigment eyeshadows with one-swipe color payoff and a mix of matte, shimmer, and metallic finishes. Users looking for long-lasting eyeshadow with smooth blendability will find this product highly beneficial, especially for daily wear or special occasions. The palette is also great for those who enjoy a sweet, subtle scent in their makeup, as the molten chocolate cake fragrance adds a unique sensory experience to the application process.

Not suitable for:

This palette may not be the best choice for those with sensitive skin or allergies to fragrances, as some users noted that the chocolate scent can be overpowering or irritating. Additionally, individuals with very oily eyelids may find that the eyeshadows fade or crease without the use of a primer or setting spray. Buyers who prefer strictly matte eyeshadows might also find the shimmer and metallic finishes less desirable, as the variety of finishes can be more challenging to work with for those seeking a more uniform matte look. Lastly, customers who are looking for a budget-friendly option may feel the price doesn’t align with the product’s overall performance, especially when compared to similar alternatives on the market.

Specifications

Palette Size: The palette contains 18 high-pigment eyeshadow shades, offering a wide range of colors for different looks.
Finish Types: The eyeshadows feature a mix of matte, shimmer, and metallic finishes, providing versatility for various eye looks.
Scent: This palette is infused with a signature molten chocolate cake scent, offering a sensory experience during application.
Pigment Type: Each shade is formulated with high-quality pigments for one-swipe color payoff.
Blendability: The formula has a smooth texture, allowing for easy blending and seamless application.
Cruelty-Free: This palette is cruelty-free, making it suitable for ethical consumers.
Formula Type: The eyeshadow formula is a powder-based texture, providing buildable coverage and long-lasting wear.
Color Payoff: The palette delivers intense color payoff with just one swipe, minimizing the need for layering.
Suitability: This product is ideal for makeup enthusiasts looking for versatile, long-lasting eyeshadows.
Shimmer Performance: Shimmer shades perform best with a primer or setting spray to enhance adhesion and longevity.
Packaging: The palette comes in a compact and durable packaging designed for easy travel and storage.
Weight: The product weighs approximately 0.5 oz (14.2 g), making it lightweight and portable.
Use Case: This palette is suitable for both everyday and special occasion makeup looks due to its diverse color range.
Shade Range: The palette offers a broad array of shades, including neutrals, bolds, and metallics to suit various skin tones.
Fragrance Strength: The molten chocolate cake scent is subtle and fades after application, leaving no lingering fragrance.
Primer Compatibility: For optimal results, pairing the shimmer shades with a primer or setting spray helps to enhance the intensity and wear time.
Ethical Formula: This palette is free from animal testing and is formulated without harsh chemicals, making it a good choice for cruelty-free beauty routines.
Longevity: With proper application, this palette's eyeshadows offer long-lasting wear that holds up throughout the day.

FAQ

This palette stands out due to its high-pigment formula, versatile mix of matte, shimmer, and metallic finishes, and the signature molten chocolate cake scent, which adds a fun, sensory experience to your makeup routine.

For optimal color payoff, use a flat brush to pack the pigment onto your eyelids. To blend, use a fluffy brush in circular motions. For extra intensity on shimmer shades, consider using a primer or setting spray to help them adhere better.

Yes, this product is suitable for all skin types, including oily, dry, and combination skin. However, if you have very oily eyelids, using a primer is recommended to ensure longevity and prevent creasing.

The palette is cruelty-free and formulated without harsh ingredients, making it suitable for most skin types, including sensitive skin. However, if you are sensitive to fragrances, you might find the chocolate cake scent too strong.

When applied with a good primer or setting spray, the color lasts for a full day without fading. The matte shades tend to hold up longer, while the shimmer shades may need a bit of extra help for long-lasting wear.

Yes, this eyeshadow palette is versatile enough for both casual, everyday looks and more dramatic, special occasion styles. The variety of shades allows for neutral daytime looks or bold, metallic eye-catching effects.

The scent is noticeable when first applying the eyeshadow, but it tends to fade after a short period. It is not overpowering once applied, and it doesn't affect the performance of the eyeshadows.

Yes, the shades are versatile enough for use on the lower lash line. Just make sure to use a precise, smaller brush to apply the pigment for a more defined look.

Store the palette in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight to preserve the quality of the powders. Keep the lid tightly closed to prevent the shades from becoming dusty or messy.

The palette is cruelty-free and free from harsh chemicals, but if you have specific allergies or sensitivities, it's always a good idea to check the ingredient list for any personal triggers, especially regarding fragrances.