The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor

The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor — image 1
The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor — image 2
The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor — image 3
The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor — image 4
The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor — image 5
The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor — image 6
The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor — image 7
The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor — image 8
86%
93%
Build Quality
82%
Shave Performance
74%
Blade Gap & Aggressiveness
86%
Skin Comfort
78%
Value for Money
88%
Handle Grip & Control
91%
Weight & Balance
94%
Blade Compatibility
92%
Durability & Longevity
83%
Ease of Use
89%
Aesthetics & Finish
96%
Eco-Friendliness
71%
Packaging & Unboxing
More

Overview

The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor comes from an Italian artisan shaving brand that has built a quiet but solid reputation among serious wet shavers. Rather than chasing aggressive performance numbers, this brass safety razor is engineered around a 0.65 mm blade gap — a deliberate, mild setting that suits daily shavers and those prone to irritation far better than it suits someone hunting for maximum blade exposure. There is no plastic anywhere on it. That all-metal construction is not just a sustainability choice; it signals that this is a tool designed to last years, not months. Expectations should be set accordingly: this is a refined, approachable razor, not an extreme-shave instrument.

Features & Benefits

Solid brass is a meaningful material choice, not a marketing one — it carries more heft than zinc alloy alternatives, resists corrosion better over years of bathroom humidity, and produces a noticeably more balanced feel in the hand. At 3.49 oz, the Bayonetta razor has enough weight that the blade does much of the work, which is exactly what you want when learning proper angle technique. The sand-blasted satin finish adds practical grip that a polished surface simply cannot offer, and it looks understated rather than flashy. Being compatible with any standard DE blade means you can experiment freely with blade brands — a significant cost advantage over systems that lock you into proprietary cartridges.

Best For

This Italian-made DE razor is particularly well-matched to shavers making the switch from multi-blade cartridges — the mild blade exposure means there is very little penalty for imperfect technique while you build your angle and pressure instincts. If you have sensitive or reactive skin that flares up with conventional razors, the single-blade format combined with that conservative gap tends to reduce drag and irritation substantially. It also suits those who shave every day or every other day, where a gentler razor prevents cumulative skin fatigue. And if cutting down on plastic waste is a priority, the all-metal build and universal blade compatibility make this a genuinely low-waste grooming choice.

User Feedback

Across owner reviews, a few patterns show up reliably. Build quality and heft come up consistently as strengths — people who handle it for the first time are often surprised by how substantial it feels compared to its price point. Reduced post-shave irritation versus cartridge razors is another frequent observation, and it appears to be a genuine, repeatable result rather than a one-off comment. On the other side, more seasoned DE shavers occasionally note that the 0.65 mm gap feels underwhelming on dense or longer stubble, requiring extra passes. One important variable: blade brand matters significantly here, with sharper blades producing noticeably better efficiency. Long-term owners report the finish holds up well after extended daily use.

#Safety Razors
#Razors & Blades
#Men's
#Shave & Hair Removal
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • Solid brass construction resists corrosion and maintains weight and balance better than zinc alloy alternatives over years of use.
  • The 0.65 mm blade gap is genuinely forgiving, making this brass safety razor ideal for shavers still developing their angle and pressure technique.
  • Sand-blasted satin finish provides meaningfully better wet-hand grip than a polished surface without sacrificing a clean, premium look.
  • At 3.49 oz, the heft encourages proper technique by letting the razor's weight do the work rather than relying on added manual pressure.
  • Compatible with any standard double-edge blade, giving you access to dozens of blade brands at a fraction of cartridge system costs.
  • CNC machining in Italy produces tight, consistent tolerances — the head seats firmly and there is no play or misalignment between parts.
  • Fully metal with zero plastic components, making it a durable, low-waste grooming tool built to last for years with basic care.
  • Post-shave irritation reduction versus multi-blade cartridges is one of the most consistently reported real-world benefits across long-term owners.
  • The understated matte finish ages well and long-term owners regularly note that the surface retains its appearance after months of daily use.
  • Eco-friendly by design — no proprietary cartridges, no plastic disposal, and ongoing blade costs that remain very low per shave.

Cons

  • The 0.65 mm blade gap is too conservative for experienced DE shavers who need to clear heavy or multi-day stubble efficiently in fewer passes.
  • No blade is included in the box, leaving new buyers with an immediate additional purchase and a round of trial-and-error blade testing.
  • Shaving results vary considerably by blade brand — paired with a dull or mediocre blade, the mild gap can feel frustratingly inefficient.
  • Shavers with larger hands may find the handle length and overall dimensions slightly compact and less comfortable to grip during longer shaving sessions.
  • Brass requires routine drying and occasional maintenance to prevent water spots and mineral buildup, which some users find adds friction to the routine.
  • The price does not include a storage case or blade sampler, which comparable offerings in this tier sometimes provide as added value.
  • Infrequent shavers dealing with dense, longer beard growth will likely need multiple passes to finish cleanly, reducing the time and irritation advantages.
  • The light satin surface can show soap scum and hard-water mineral deposits more readily than darker or coated finishes, requiring more frequent rinsing.

Ratings

The scores below reflect an AI-driven analysis of verified buyer reviews for The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor, drawn from international marketplaces and shaving communities worldwide, with spam, duplicate, and incentivized feedback actively filtered out before any score was calculated. Each category is rated independently, capturing both the strengths that genuine owners highlight most often and the real pain points that appear consistently across verified feedback. The result is a transparent, balanced picture of what this brass safety razor actually delivers across the broadest possible range of real buyers.

Build Quality
93%
The solid brass body is consistently praised for feeling genuinely substantial rather than decorative — owners describe picking it up for the first time and immediately sensing the difference from zinc alloy or plastic razors. CNC machining in Italy produces tight tolerances, and the head-to-handle connection has none of the wobble or looseness that appears in cheaper DE razors.
A small number of users have noted minor surface irregularities on the satin finish near the head — not functional issues, but noticeable under close inspection for buyers expecting premium-tier consistency throughout. No protective case is included, which makes preserving that build quality during travel or storage an afterthought the buyer must solve independently.
Shave Performance
82%
18%
For daily shavers running this razor across a one-to-two-day beard, the Bayonetta razor delivers a clean, close result with noticeably less post-shave redness than most cartridge systems. Pairing it with a sharper blade like a Feather or Gillette Nacet pushes efficiency meaningfully higher, and many users report achieving a barbershop-close finish within a few shaving sessions.
Heavy three-plus-day stubble is where the mild 0.65 mm gap starts to show its limits — some users need two or three passes to fully clear dense growth, which adds time and can increase irritation if technique is not dialed in. Experienced DE shavers transitioning from more aggressive razors may find the performance ceiling frustratingly low for their expectations.
Blade Gap & Aggressiveness
74%
26%
The 0.65 mm gap is a deliberate, well-considered choice for its intended audience — daily shavers, beginners, and anyone with reactive skin will find it significantly more forgiving than open-comb or wider-gap razors, reducing the learning curve and making the single-blade transition far less risky. Regular shavers consistently report clean results without requiring perfect technique on every pass.
The same mildness that protects beginners becomes a real limitation for experienced DE users who want efficiency — the gap simply does not expose enough blade to cut through multi-day or coarse stubble effectively in a single pass. For seasoned wet shavers, this razor will likely feel like a step backward in performance rather than a meaningful lateral move.
Skin Comfort
86%
Post-shave irritation reduction is the most consistently reported benefit across verified owner feedback, and the pattern is reliable enough to take at face value — shavers with chronic razor burn from cartridge systems frequently describe near-complete resolution after a few weeks with this brass safety razor. The single-blade format creates far less frictional disruption per pass than stacked multi-blade cartridges.
Skin comfort is genuinely blade-dependent here — users who install an overly sharp blade in the mild head can still experience irritation, since the conservative gap alone cannot compensate for a mismatched blade choice. Some new DE converts also report a two-to-three week adjustment period before consistent comfort develops as their technique and blade selection gradually improve.
Value for Money
78%
22%
Relative to cartridge systems that require expensive ongoing blade purchases, this brass safety razor offers a strong long-term cost structure — DE blades cost a fraction per unit, and the all-brass construction means the razor itself should not need replacing for years. Committed shavers consistently report meaningful cumulative savings over a two-to-three year window, making the upfront investment reasonable in context.
The upfront price without any included blade, sampler, or carrying case feels less complete than several competitors at a similar price point that bundle accessories into the package. For buyers who try DE shaving and abandon it during the learning curve — a real attrition rate among new converts — the value calculation deteriorates significantly, making this an investment that rewards long-term commitment.
Handle Grip & Control
88%
The sand-blasted satin finish is the real practical win here — unlike polished metal handles that become slippery the moment shaving cream contacts them, this surface maintains genuine traction through a full shave. Users with a tendency to over-grip report the texture naturally encourages a lighter, more controlled hold, which is exactly the habit that produces better DE shaving results over time.
A minority of users with particularly large hands note the handle diameter feels slightly narrower than ideal, which can reduce precision control on tricky areas like the jawline and upper lip. Mineral buildup from hard water can also gradually fill the textured surface if not rinsed regularly, slightly dulling the grip advantage the satin finish is designed to provide.
Weight & Balance
91%
At 3.49 oz, this Italian-made DE razor hits a balance point that experienced shavers consistently describe as ideal — enough mass to guide the blade through each stroke without effort, but not so much that the wrist tires during a full face shave. Users stepping up from plastic cartridge handles almost universally cite the heft as an immediate and strongly positive revelation.
A subset of users who prefer ultralight razors — particularly those who shave their head and require more continuous wrist movement — find 3.49 oz moderately tiring over an extended session. The compact overall length also means the weight is concentrated in a shorter handle than some shavers prefer, which can alter the lever feel when navigating difficult angles.
Blade Compatibility
94%
Universal DE compatibility means no proprietary blade lock-in — buyers gain instant access to dozens of brands, from gentle options like Derby to sharper performers like Feather, at a fraction of cartridge costs. The ability to swap blade types and find the ideal match for their skin and beard type is consistently cited by long-term owners as a major and lasting advantage.
The open blade selection is a hidden pitfall for beginners who have no reference point for what suits their skin — installing an overly sharp blade on an early shave can produce poor results that unfairly taint perceptions of the razor itself. No blade sampler is included, so newcomers must navigate this trial-and-error process entirely at their own time and cost.
Durability & Longevity
92%
Solid brass with no plastic parts is essentially a blueprint for bathroom durability — nothing corrodes quickly, no plastic cracks or yellows, and there is no plating to chip away over time. Long-term owners consistently report the razor looks and performs identically after twelve or more months of daily use, which is a genuine differentiator from cheaper zinc alloy alternatives.
Brass demands more active drying habits than stainless steel — in hard-water areas, mineral deposits accumulate on the surface and in thread areas if the razor is routinely left wet. A small number of long-term users report faint oxidation on hard-to-reach interior surfaces, though this remains a cosmetic rather than a functional concern for the vast majority of owners.
Ease of Use
83%
For shavers switching from cartridges, the mild blade gap genuinely helps during the initial adjustment weeks — reduced blade exposure means technique mistakes produce feedback rather than cuts, which accelerates learning without too much penalty. Most users report feeling comfortable and confident with this Italian-made DE razor within one to two weeks, which is faster than more aggressive razors typically allow.
DE shaving demands real technique adjustments that cartridge razors never require — correct blade angle, minimal pressure, and skin stretching are skills that take time to internalize, and many buyers underestimate this upfront. Users expecting an experience identical to their cartridge routine will likely feel frustrated in early sessions, even with a forgiving razor like this one.
Aesthetics & Finish
89%
The sand-blasted satin matte finish hits a tone that resonates strongly with buyers who want something premium without being ostentatious — it photographs well, ages gracefully, and sits on a bathroom shelf without demanding attention. Multiple owners specifically cite the understated aesthetic as a key reason they chose this razor over shinier alternatives, finding it more refined than chrome-plated options at the same tier.
The matte surface shows soap scum, hard-water mineral deposits, and fingerprint oils more readily than polished or darker finishes, requiring more frequent rinsing to maintain a clean appearance. A small subset of detail-focused buyers have also noted minor inconsistencies in the blast texture near the head area — not a functional issue, but visible under direct light for those who inspect closely.
Eco-Friendliness
96%
Zero plastic construction and universal DE blade compatibility make the Bayonetta razor one of the more genuinely low-waste options in this product category — no proprietary cartridges to dispose of, no plastic handle to replace, and the brass body is fully recyclable at end of life. Eco-focused buyers consistently rank this sustainability profile as one of the razor's most compelling long-term selling points.
The razor itself produces no plastic waste, but used DE blades are sharp enough to puncture standard household bins and require proper disposal in a dedicated blade bank or sharps container — an extra step that catches most new DE converts off guard. It is a minor process addition, but one worth factoring into the routine before committing to the switch.
Packaging & Unboxing
71%
29%
Buyers consistently describe the presentation as appropriately considered — the razor arrives displayed in a way that reads as gift-worthy rather than generic retail packaging, which matters for buyers treating themselves to a grooming upgrade or presenting it as a thoughtful gift. For the Italian positioning, the unboxing experience generally meets expectations without feeling overproduced or padded.
Multiple buyers flag the absence of any blade, blade bank, or protective carrying case as a meaningful disappointment relative to competitors at similar price points that bundle accessories into the package. For a razor positioned as a premium Italian product, the accessories gap is a recurring criticism in reviews, with buyers feeling the out-of-box experience does not fully match the premium pricing tier.

Suitable for:

The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor is an excellent fit for shavers making their first serious move away from multi-blade cartridge systems, particularly those who want to learn proper wet-shaving technique without being punished for early mistakes. The 0.65 mm blade gap sits in forgiving territory, meaning minor errors in angle or pressure translate to mild feedback rather than nicks and weepers, which makes the transition far less intimidating than starting on an aggressive razor. People with sensitive skin, persistent razor burn, or a tendency toward ingrown hairs are among those most likely to notice a genuine improvement, since a single blade with controlled exposure causes substantially less drag and skin disruption than stacked cartridge designs. Daily and alternating-day shavers will also find that the mild geometry keeps skin in consistent condition over time without cumulative irritation building up across the week. Finally, anyone actively working to reduce disposable plastic in their routine will appreciate that universal DE blade compatibility eliminates proprietary waste entirely and drives the long-term cost per shave down to almost nothing.

Not suitable for:

The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor is unlikely to satisfy experienced DE shavers who have already graduated past mild razors and now want a more open blade gap for efficient, high-exposure shaving. If you regularly go three or more days between shaves, have a coarse or dense beard, and expect to clear heavy stubble cleanly in one or two passes, the 0.65 mm gap will very likely leave you making additional passes to finish the job — which adds time and can negate the low-irritation advantage. Shavers who already have solid technique and are looking to push efficiency rather than refine comfort will find this razor feels noticeably tame compared to mid-aggressive or open-comb alternatives. It is also not a good choice for anyone expecting a complete kit out of the box, since no blade is included and new DE converts will need to spend additional time and money finding a compatible blade that suits their skin and beard type. Those with notably large hands may also find the handle length and overall dimensions on the compact side.

Specifications

  • Brand: The Goodfellas' Smile is an Italian artisan shaving brand with a craft-focused reputation in the traditional wet-shaving market.
  • Model Name: Bayonetta is the specific razor model designation within The Goodfellas' Smile product lineup.
  • Material: The razor body is machined entirely from solid brass, with no zinc alloy, plastic, or composite components anywhere in the construction.
  • Manufacturing: Every component is CNC-machined for consistent dimensional tolerances and reliable blade-seat alignment across units.
  • Country of Origin: Designed and manufactured in Italy, where precision metalworking is carried out at the facility level rather than outsourced assembly.
  • Surface Finish: A sand-blasted satin matte treatment is applied directly to the brass, providing an understated aesthetic and improved grip on wet hands.
  • Blade Gap: The blade gap measures 0.65 mm, placing this razor firmly in the mild-to-moderate range suited to daily shaving and sensitive skin.
  • Weight: The assembled razor weighs 3.49 oz, delivering noticeably more heft than standard plastic cartridge handles without becoming unwieldy.
  • Dimensions: Overall assembled dimensions measure 4.02 × 2.01 × 1.18 inches, resulting in a compact profile that fits most hands comfortably.
  • Blade Format: Accepts any standard double-edge (DE) blade; the razor uses no proprietary blade system and is compatible with all major DE brands.
  • Blade Count: Single-blade DE format — one blade edge is exposed per shaving pass, reducing multi-blade drag on the skin.
  • Plastic Content: The razor contains zero plastic parts; the entire construction from handle to head plate is fully metal.
  • Eco Profile: Universal DE blade compatibility means no proprietary cartridge waste, and the durable all-metal body is designed for decades of use.
  • Grip Property: The sand-blasted surface texture measurably reduces slippage during wet-hand use compared to polished or chrome-plated metal finishes.
  • Unit Contents: Each purchase includes one fully assembled razor; no double-edge blade, carrying case, or blade sampler is included in the box.

Related Reviews

Goodfellas' Smile Syntesi Double Edge Safety Razor
Goodfellas' Smile Syntesi Double Edge Safety Razor
82%
93%
Build Quality
82%
Shave Comfort
74%
Shave Closeness
71%
Value for Money
67%
Ease of Use
More
MÜHLE Companion Double Edge Body Razor
MÜHLE Companion Double Edge Body Razor
82%
88%
Build Quality & Materials
86%
Handle Grip & Control
79%
Skin Comfort & Irritation Reduction
68%
Beginner Learning Curve
73%
Value for Money
More
Standard Razors Aluminum Double Edge Safety Razor
Standard Razors Aluminum Double Edge Safety Razor
84%
91%
Build Quality
74%
Value for Money
83%
Shave Performance
67%
Ease of Use
94%
Blade Compatibility
More
Rockwell Razors 2C White Chrome Double Edge Safety Razor
Rockwell Razors 2C White Chrome Double Edge Safety Razor
87%
85%
Ease of Use
92%
Shaving Precision
88%
Weight & Control
90%
Adjustable Settings Performance
95%
Eco-Friendliness
More
Henson Shaving Razor - Jet Black Double Edge Safety Razor
Henson Shaving Razor - Jet Black Double Edge Safety Razor
87%
92%
Shaving Performance
89%
Durability
90%
Ergonomics & Comfort
85%
Irritation Reduction
93%
Eco-Friendliness
More
Merkur 37C Slant Bar Safety Razor
Merkur 37C Slant Bar Safety Razor
83%
93%
Build Quality
89%
Shave Closeness
58%
Beginner Friendliness
84%
Value for Money
88%
Weight & Balance
More
Parker Convertible Double Edge Safety Razor
Parker Convertible Double Edge Safety Razor
79%
91%
Build Quality
86%
Shave Performance
88%
Plate Versatility
84%
Weight & Balance
73%
Handle Grip
More
Merkur 25C Open Comb Safety Razor
Merkur 25C Open Comb Safety Razor
84%
94%
Build Quality
88%
Shave Performance
61%
Ease of Use
86%
Handle Ergonomics
91%
Open Comb Effectiveness
More
Feather Adjustable Double Edge Safety Razor
Feather Adjustable Double Edge Safety Razor
80%
77%
Build Quality & Materials
92%
Adjustability & Versatility
88%
Shave Closeness
85%
Skin Comfort & Sensitivity
89%
Blade-Change Convenience
More
Merkur 23C Double Edge Safety Razor
Merkur 23C Double Edge Safety Razor
84%
88%
Shaving Performance
75%
Ease of Use for Beginners
90%
Comfort & Irritation
95%
Durability & Build Quality
85%
Grip & Handle Comfort
More

FAQ

No, this brass safety razor ships without a blade included. You will need to purchase standard double-edge blades separately, which is genuinely not a drawback — DE blades are inexpensive, universally available, and trying a few different brands is the best way to find the one that works with your skin and beard type.

Blade gap is the distance between the blade edge and the safety bar — a smaller number means the blade is more guarded and the shave is more forgiving, while a larger number means more blade exposure and a more aggressive feel. At 0.65 mm, the Bayonetta razor sits in mild territory, which is a real benefit for daily shavers and anyone with sensitive skin, but it can feel underwhelming if you shave infrequently and have dense, heavy stubble to clear.

After each shave, rinse the razor thoroughly under warm running water, remove the blade, and shake or tap the head gently to clear trapped lather and hair. Dry it with a towel or leave it somewhere with good airflow — avoid leaving it sitting in pooled water. Because it is solid brass, periodic drying prevents mineral deposits and water spots from building up. No special cleaning products are needed for routine maintenance.

Yes, in practical terms. Brass is significantly denser than zinc alloy, which translates to better balance and a more planted, controlled feel during shaving. It also resists corrosion far better than zinc alloy under the humidity and moisture typical of a bathroom environment, where cheaper razors often develop pitting or surface corrosion within a year or two. Stainless steel edges it out in extreme long-term corrosion resistance, but for everyday bathroom use, solid brass performs very well with minimal care.

Any standard double-edge blade will fit without issue — Astra, Feather, Derby, Gillette Nacet, Personna, Wilkinson Sword, and every other mainstream DE brand are all compatible. The double-edge blade format has been standardized for decades, so there are no proprietary restrictions to worry about here.

The Goodfellas' Smile Bayonetta Double-Edge Safety Razor is frequently recommended for exactly this situation. The single-blade format creates far less mechanical friction and drag than stacked multi-blade cartridges, and the mild 0.65 mm gap keeps blade exposure conservative enough to significantly reduce razor burn, nicks, and post-shave redness. One practical tip: start with a milder blade like a Derby Extra or Astra SP rather than an aggressive blade like a Feather, since blade sharpness plays a big role in how gentle the overall shave feels.

Noticeably heavier. Most plastic cartridge handles weigh somewhere between 1 and 2 oz, so at 3.49 oz, this Italian-made DE razor has a substantially more substantial feel in the hand. Once you adjust to it, that extra weight becomes an advantage — it encourages you to let the razor glide under its own weight rather than pressing down, which is the correct technique for DE shaving and a major reason it causes less skin irritation.

The razor handle and head are perfectly fine in carry-on luggage. The blade, however, must be removed before travel and either packed in checked baggage or disposed of — exposed razor blades are prohibited in carry-on bags under TSA rules and equivalent regulations in most other countries. Since this razor ships without a protective travel case, it is worth picking up a small pouch or hard case if you plan to travel with it regularly.

Most shavers get between three and seven shaves per blade, though this varies depending on beard coarseness, skin type, and how often you shave. The clearest sign a blade needs replacing is when it starts to tug or drag rather than gliding smoothly — do not push a blade past that point, as a fatigued blade causes more irritation than a fresh one. Since DE blades cost just a few cents to around a dollar each, there is no real reason to stretch them further than they are comfortable.

The sand-blasted satin texture is worked into the brass surface itself rather than applied as a thin coating or plating over a base metal, so it does not peel, chip, or flake the way chrome or lacquer finishes can on cheaper razors. Long-term owners consistently report the finish looks consistent after many months of daily use. In areas with very hard tap water, mineral spotting can develop over time, but a regular wipe-down after shaving is enough to keep it looking clean and even.