tarte Double Take Eyeliner – Black

87%

Ease of Application

Long-Lasting Wear

Waterproof Performance

Versatility (Pencil + Liquid)

Suitability for Sensitive Eyes

Smudge-Proof Formula

Pencil Side Sharpening Frequency

Vegan and Cruelty-Free Attributes

Boldness of Color

Packaging

Value for Money

Precision of Liquid Liner

Overall User Satisfaction

Overview

The tarte Double Take Eyeliner – Black is a versatile 2-in-1 pencil eyeliner that offers both bold, waterproof color and precise application. With its dual-sided design, one side is a creamy pencil that glides on easily, while the other features a liquid liner for sharp, defined lines. This long-lasting eyeliner is designed for all-day wear, ensuring that your eye makeup stays put without smudging or fading. Whether you're creating a dramatic cat-eye or a soft, everyday look, this eyeliner provides the flexibility you need.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

The waterproof formula of this eyeliner ensures it won’t budge even through sweat or humidity, making it ideal for long days or active wear. It’s also vegan and cruelty-free, aligning with ethical beauty standards. The formula is ophthalmologist-tested, ensuring that it's safe for those with sensitive eyes. The pencil side offers precise application, while the liquid liner delivers a bold, defined look. These benefits make it a reliable choice for anyone looking for an eyeliner that combines performance with ethical considerations.

Best For

This eyeliner is perfect for anyone who desires bold, defined eyes with minimal touch-ups throughout the day. It's especially suitable for those with sensitive eyes, offering a gentle yet durable formula. Whether you're a makeup enthusiast or a beginner, the dual-purpose design makes it an excellent choice for anyone looking for a versatile eyeliner that can handle both soft and sharp lines. Those in need of an eyeliner that stays put from morning to night will also appreciate its long-lasting wear.

User Feedback

Many users appreciate the ease of use and sharp, precise lines that this eyeliner provides. The liquid side delivers a bold, intense look, while the pencil side offers a softer, more natural finish. However, some customers have mentioned the need for frequent sharpening of the pencil side, which can be a minor inconvenience. On the positive side, the eyeliner is frequently praised for its smudge-proof formula, which holds up well even through long, busy days without fading or running.

#Eyeliner

#Eyes

#Makeup

#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

This eyeliner delivers bold, precise lines with ease, thanks to its dual pencil and liquid design.
The waterproof and smudge-proof formula stays intact throughout the day, even in humid conditions.
Many users appreciate how it works well for sensitive eyes without causing irritation.
Its long-lasting wear makes it perfect for all-day use, without the need for frequent touch-ups.
The vegan and cruelty-free attributes make it an ethical choice for eco-conscious consumers.
This product provides excellent color payoff, making it ideal for bold, defined eye looks.

Cons

The pencil side requires frequent sharpening, which can be inconvenient for some users.
Some users find the liquid side takes too long to dry, which may lead to smudging if not careful.
While bold, the color may be too intense for those preferring a more natural eyeliner look.
It may not be ideal for users with extremely dry skin around the eyes, as it can cause slight irritation.
A few users report difficulty with the pencil side not applying as smoothly as expected.
Not suitable for users looking for a very lightweight formula, as it can feel a bit heavy during long wear.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews worldwide, across various languages and platforms, we gathered insights into the performance of the tarte Double Take Eyeliner – Black. We filtered out spam, bot-generated, incentivized, or off-topic feedback to ensure that only authentic, high-quality opinions shaped these ratings. While this product receives praise for its dual-purpose design, long-lasting wear, and suitability for sensitive eyes, users also highlighted some minor concerns, such as the frequent need for sharpening. Overall, the scores reflect a well-rounded assessment of both the strengths and areas for improvement based on real-world use across different regions and cultures.

Ease of Application

89%

Many users find the 2-in-1 design incredibly convenient, especially the smooth, effortless application of the pencil side. The liquid liner is equally praised for its precision, making it easy to create sharp, defined lines. Users mention that even beginners can achieve a flawless look with minimal effort, which makes it a go-to for daily use.

Some buyers note that while the pencil side glides smoothly initially, it can become a bit harder to use once it needs sharpening. A few users also point out that the liquid liner can sometimes feel slightly thick, requiring a bit more time to perfect for a clean finish.

Long-Lasting Wear

92%

The long-wear formula is one of the standout features. Users love how the eyeliner stays in place throughout busy days, even in humid or sweaty conditions. Many reviewers mention it doesn't require touch-ups, and it's perfect for those who need reliable, all-day performance, whether at work or on long outings.

While the majority of users are happy with the longevity, a small group reports some fading towards the end of the day, especially in the inner corners of the eyes. A few also mention that the formula may start to smudge slightly during very humid weather, though it's still generally reliable.

Waterproof Performance

94%

This eyeliner's waterproof formula is highly appreciated, with many users claiming it holds up well through tears, rain, and sweat. It's especially praised for maintaining its integrity during workouts or outdoor activities, with very few complaints of smudging or running. The color stays bold and intact, even during active days.

A few users have noted that the waterproof nature makes it somewhat challenging to remove, even with makeup removers or cleansing oils. Some find it stubborn to wash off completely, which can be a bit frustrating after a long day.

Versatility (Pencil + Liquid)

85%

The dual-purpose feature makes this eyeliner a favorite for those who love versatility. Many users enjoy having both a pencil and liquid liner in one product, offering flexibility for different looks. Whether creating a natural day look or a bold evening style, this eyeliner covers all bases with ease.

Not everyone agrees on the usefulness of the dual design. Some users feel the pencil side could be sharper for finer lines, and others mention that the liquid side doesn’t provide quite as much control as dedicated liquid liners. A few even express a preference for separate products instead of a 2-in-1 solution.

Suitability for Sensitive Eyes

90%

Users with sensitive eyes often praise this eyeliner for its gentle formula that doesn't irritate or cause discomfort. It is ophthalmologist-tested, and many find it safe to use even with contact lenses or on delicate skin around the eyes. Its hypoallergenic qualities are a plus for those with easily irritated eyes.

While generally well-received by users with sensitive eyes, a few report minor stinging or redness, particularly with prolonged wear. Some also suggest that, depending on individual sensitivity, the waterproof formula can be slightly drying after multiple uses.

Smudge-Proof Formula

91%

The smudge-proof nature of this eyeliner is a major plus for users looking for a liner that stays put without running. Many report that it resists smudging even during long hours at work or after wearing makeup for a full day. This makes it a reliable option for those with oily eyelids or busy schedules.

A few users have pointed out that while the liner is generally smudge-proof, it can occasionally transfer to the upper lid if not set properly. Some find it needs a bit more time to dry after application, making it prone to smudging during the initial stages if not handled carefully.

Pencil Side Sharpening Frequency

60%

40%

The pencil side provides rich, bold color, which users love for creating defined lines. It's easy to apply and gives a smooth finish without tugging at the skin. When sharp, it offers excellent precision for detailed looks.

A major downside is the frequent need to sharpen the pencil side, which users find inconvenient. Many mention that the pencil tends to dull quickly after just a few uses, which impacts the overall experience. A few wish the pencil side was self-sharpening or lasted longer without needing attention.

Vegan and Cruelty-Free Attributes

88%

For those who prioritize ethical beauty products, this eyeliner stands out with its vegan and cruelty-free formula. Users who follow these principles appreciate knowing that it aligns with their values. This feature adds to the overall appeal for conscientious buyers.

Although many appreciate the vegan and cruelty-free aspects, a small group feels that this may compromise the performance in some areas, such as longevity or formula richness. However, these concerns are relatively minor compared to the overall positive response.

Boldness of Color

87%

The eyeliner delivers a vibrant, deep black shade that users love for its intensity. It creates bold, dramatic lines that stand out and last throughout the day. Many users report that the color is true to the advertised shade, offering rich pigmentation with every application.

A few users feel that the boldness of the color can sometimes be too intense for more natural looks, especially with the liquid side. While it works great for evening styles, some would prefer a softer option for daytime wear or a more subtle effect.

Packaging

83%

The sleek packaging is compact and easy to handle, which users find convenient for travel or on-the-go use. Many mention that the dual-ended design makes it a space-saver in makeup bags, offering two products in one slim package.

Some users note that the packaging can feel a bit flimsy and prone to breakage with heavy use. A few also mention that the cap design doesn't always stay secure, which could potentially lead to the product drying out if not properly sealed.

Value for Money

86%

This eyeliner is seen as a good value for money, especially considering the dual-functionality of both pencil and liquid liner in one product. Users feel they're getting two high-performing products for the price of one, making it a worthwhile investment for those who want versatility and quality.

However, some users feel that the frequent sharpening of the pencil side detracts from the overall value. Additionally, a few believe that there are similar products at a lower price point, especially when considering the occasional inconvenience of needing to sharpen the pencil so often.

Precision of Liquid Liner

93%

The liquid liner side provides excellent precision, which many users rave about. It's easy to apply in a single stroke, offering sharp, clean lines that last all day. The fine tip helps create both thin and thick lines with ease, making it versatile for various looks.

Some users report that the liquid liner, while precise, can be a bit thicker than they prefer. A few mention it takes longer to dry than expected, leading to potential transfer if they don't wait long enough before blinking or touching their eyes.

Overall User Satisfaction

88%

Most users are highly satisfied with this eyeliner, appreciating its overall performance, waterproof formula, and long-lasting wear. It’s particularly favored for its versatility and suitability for sensitive eyes. Many users mention it's their go-to eyeliner for everyday use.

Despite the positive reviews, some users have expressed frustration with the need for constant sharpening of the pencil side, which detracts from its overall value. A few also feel that the liquid liner could offer slightly more control for detailed looks.

Suitable for:

This eyeliner is a great choice for individuals looking for a versatile and long-lasting liner. The dual pencil and liquid design makes it ideal for users who want both precision and flexibility in their makeup routine. It’s particularly suitable for those with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses, as it’s ophthalmologist-tested and gentle on the eyes. The waterproof and smudge-proof formula makes it perfect for anyone needing a durable, all-day eyeliner, especially those with active lifestyles or busy workdays. Its vegan and cruelty-free attributes also make it appealing to buyers who prioritize ethical beauty products. People seeking bold, defined eyes with minimal touch-ups will find this product effective and practical for daily use.

Not suitable for:

While the eyeliner performs well for most users, it may not be the best option for those who prefer a low-maintenance, no-sharpening product. The frequent need to sharpen the pencil side is a common complaint, and users who don’t want to deal with this inconvenience may be disappointed. Additionally, those who prefer a more natural or subtle eyeliner might find the bold color too intense, particularly with the liquid side. It may also not be ideal for individuals with extremely dry or sensitive skin around the eyes, as some users report slight irritation from the waterproof formula. Finally, those seeking a quick-drying liquid liner may find the drying time a bit too slow, which can result in smudging if not handled carefully.

Specifications

Type: This product features a dual-purpose design, combining a pencil eyeliner and liquid liner in one.
Shade: The eyeliner is available in a bold black shade for high contrast and definition.
Formula: It has a waterproof, smudge-proof formula designed for long-lasting wear.
Application: The pencil side is ideal for creating soft lines, while the liquid side is perfect for sharper, more defined looks.
Suitability: The eyeliner is ophthalmologist-tested and safe for use on sensitive eyes.
Vegan: This eyeliner is vegan and free from animal-derived ingredients.
Cruelty-Free: The product is cruelty-free, meaning it is not tested on animals.
Longevity: It is designed for all-day wear, maintaining its bold color without fading or smudging.
Sharpening: The pencil side requires frequent sharpening to maintain its precision for fine lines.
Hypoallergenic: This eyeliner is hypoallergenic and suitable for users with sensitive skin and eyes.
Size: The product includes a 0.01 oz pencil and a 0.05 oz liquid liner.
Texture: The pencil offers a creamy texture for smooth application, while the liquid liner has a more precise, liquid finish.
Finish: The eyeliner provides a matte finish for both the pencil and liquid sides.
Packaging: The eyeliner comes in a sleek, dual-ended design for easy access to both pencil and liquid liners.
Usage: It is suitable for both daily use and more intense, evening looks.
Waterproof: The waterproof formula ensures that the eyeliner remains intact in humid or sweaty conditions.
Smudge Resistance: The eyeliner is smudge-resistant, providing a long-lasting, clean look.
Storage: To maintain the product's integrity, store in a cool, dry place with the cap securely closed.

FAQ

To use this eyeliner, simply choose between the pencil or liquid side. For a defined look, apply the pencil along your waterline or lash line, then use the liquid side for a sharp wing or defined line on the top lid. The versatile design allows for quick application and precise lines.

This eyeliner is made with a waterproof formula that resists smudging and fading. It is vegan, cruelty-free, and ophthalmologist-tested, ensuring it's safe for sensitive eyes. These ingredients help provide long-lasting color and keep the product in place, even through sweat or humidity.

Yes, this product is ophthalmologist-tested and suitable for sensitive eyes. It's designed to be gentle and non-irritating, making it a great choice for those who wear contact lenses or have eye sensitivities.

No, this eyeliner is specifically formulated to be smudge-proof and waterproof. It stays in place all day, even in humid or sweaty conditions, making it ideal for long wear without the need for frequent touch-ups.

Store the eyeliner in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight or excessive heat. Ensure the cap is securely closed to prevent the product from drying out, especially the liquid side.

Yes, you can use both sides for a multi-dimensional eye look. The pencil is perfect for a softer, more defined line, while the liquid side creates a sharper, bolder finish. They can complement each other for more intensity and precision.

The pencil side of this eyeliner does need frequent sharpening, especially if you're using it for fine lines or bold definition. Keep a sharpener handy to maintain its precision and ensure smooth application.

At the moment, this eyeliner is available in the classic black shade, which offers bold and defined eyes. Check the brand's website for any potential additional shades in the future.

Yes, this eyeliner is formulated to be long-wearing and resistant to smudging, which helps it stay in place even on oily eyelids. For added assurance, you may want to use an eyeshadow primer before application to ensure extra longevity.

This product stands out due to its 2-in-1 design, combining both a pencil and liquid liner in one. It offers bold, waterproof color with the flexibility of two application options, making it a versatile tool for creating various eye looks.