Overview

The Sunday Riley 5 Stars Retinol + Niacinamide Anti Aging Eye Serum is a targeted treatment designed specifically for the delicate under-eye area. This eye serum combines retinol and niacinamide to address common signs of aging, such as dark circles, puffiness, and fine lines. Its fragrance-free and vegan formula is ideal for those with sensitive skin, ensuring that it can be used daily without irritation. It’s also free from harmful ingredients like parabens and sulfates, making it a clean choice for skincare enthusiasts.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

The key ingredients in this eye serum include retinol and niacinamide, both of which are renowned for their anti-aging benefits. Retinol is known to promote skin renewal, helping to smooth out fine lines and wrinkles. Niacinamide, on the other hand, works to brighten dark circles and even out skin tone. The serum is also free from parabens, sulfates, and phthalates, making it gentle on the skin. With consistent use, users can expect smoother, brighter, and more youthful-looking skin around the eyes.

Best For

This anti-aging eye treatment is best for individuals looking to reduce dark circles and puffiness around the eyes. It’s ideal for users with aging skin who want to address fine lines and wrinkles, especially those who have sensitive skin. Thanks to its gentle and fragrance-free formula, it’s perfect for anyone seeking a non-irritating, effective solution for under-eye concerns. Whether you're combating early signs of aging or want to maintain a youthful appearance, this serum caters to a variety of skin types and needs.

User Feedback

User reviews for this eye serum are generally positive, with many noting visible improvements in the smoothness and brightness of their under-eye area. Several users appreciate the non-irritating, fragrance-free formula, which is especially beneficial for sensitive skin. However, some users mention that it takes time—usually a few weeks—to see noticeable results. Despite this, most find it effective over the long term, with many reporting that it’s helped reduce puffiness and fine lines after consistent use.

Pros

  • This eye serum effectively reduces the appearance of dark circles and puffiness after consistent use.
  • It contains retinol and niacinamide, which are known for improving skin texture and brightening the under-eye area.
  • The formula is fragrance-free and gentle, making it suitable for sensitive skin without causing irritation.
  • Many users report smoother, more youthful-looking skin around the eyes after several weeks of use.
  • This product is vegan and free from parabens, sulfates, and phthalates, making it a clean beauty option.
  • It works well as part of a nighttime skincare routine for addressing signs of aging.

Cons

  • Some users feel that it takes longer than expected to see visible results, requiring patience over several weeks.
  • The serum may not provide enough hydration for those with very dry skin around the eyes.
  • A few users find the serum too lightweight, feeling it lacks immediate moisturizing effects.
  • It may not be effective for users with very deep wrinkles or more severe under-eye concerns.
  • The product is small (0.5 oz), and some feel the quantity is too limited for long-term use.
  • For individuals with oily skin, the serum might feel slightly heavy or greasy throughout the day.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user feedback from multiple platforms and countries, we present an aggregated score for the Sunday Riley 5 Stars Retinol + Niacinamide Anti Aging Eye Serum. Spam, bot, and incentivized reviews were filtered out, ensuring that only genuine and high-quality feedback contributed to these results. While many users praised its effectiveness in reducing dark circles and fine lines, others noted that visible improvements can take a few weeks of consistent use. Both strengths and pain points from diverse sources have been reflected in the scores below.

Effectiveness for Dark Circles
87%
Many users report significant improvements in reducing dark circles. The combination of retinol and niacinamide appears to brighten the under-eye area over time, making it a popular choice for tackling tired, puffy eyes. Those who used it consistently noted visible changes after a few weeks of use.
However, some buyers feel that the serum takes longer than expected to show results. While the formula is effective for some, others mentioned that it didn’t work as quickly as they hoped, especially for stubborn dark circles.
Reduction of Fine Lines
90%
This serum has been highly rated for its ability to smooth out fine lines around the eyes. Users appreciate the gradual, noticeable reduction in wrinkles, with many noting that the area under the eyes looks firmer and more youthful. The retinol content is praised for providing effective anti-aging results.
Despite positive feedback, some users felt that the serum did not provide a significant reduction in deeper wrinkles. A few mentioned that while it worked well for fine lines, it didn’t have as much of an impact on more pronounced aging signs.
Skin Compatibility (Sensitive Skin)
92%
This eye serum is especially appreciated by those with sensitive skin. Many users with reactive or delicate skin reported no irritation, thanks to its fragrance-free and gentle formula. It’s well-suited for daily use, even for people prone to dryness or redness around the eyes.
However, a few sensitive skin users noted slight irritation after applying the serum, particularly when using it alongside other products containing active ingredients. Some found it too strong, requiring them to use it less frequently.
Absorption & Finish
80%
20%
Users generally find that the serum absorbs quickly without leaving a greasy or sticky residue. The smooth texture is favored by many, making it easy to apply and layer with other skincare products. It is a good addition to evening routines, as it absorbs before sleep.
On the downside, a few users felt that the serum left their skin feeling slightly tacky or oily, especially in the morning. Some also wished for a more lightweight formula, as it occasionally interfered with makeup application.
Fragrance & Irritation
95%
A standout feature is its fragrance-free formula, which appeals to users with sensitivities to scent. The serum’s gentle composition minimizes irritation, making it an ideal choice for those looking to avoid fragrances or harsh chemicals in their skincare.
While most users appreciate the lack of fragrance, a few mentioned that the absence of scent made the serum feel less luxurious. Some also wished for a more refreshing or soothing sensation during application, even without added fragrance.
Long-Term Results
75%
25%
For many, this serum delivers solid long-term results when used consistently. Some users mention that after several weeks, the under-eye area feels smoother, and the skin tone is more even. It’s an effective solution for those who are patient and committed to using it regularly.
A number of buyers, however, were disappointed with the slower pace of visible improvements. They reported that although it worked over time, the delayed results made them question the product’s effectiveness, especially compared to quicker-acting alternatives.
Packaging & Dispensing
84%
The packaging is compact and convenient, making the serum easy to apply without any mess. Users appreciate the pump dispenser, which helps in controlling the right amount of product, ensuring no wastage. The design is sleek and travel-friendly.
However, a few users noted that the pump dispenser could be tricky to use when nearing the end of the bottle. Some also found the size a bit small for the price, wishing for a larger quantity of the product.
Application & Usability
82%
18%
This eye serum is easy to incorporate into a skincare routine. The lightweight formula allows for smooth and even application, and it layers well with other products. Users find it especially convenient for morning and evening routines.
However, some users expressed dissatisfaction with the serum’s consistency, stating that it can feel slightly thick and not as fast-absorbing as other products they’ve used. A few also found the application process a bit more cumbersome than expected.
Ingredient Quality
90%
The combination of retinol and niacinamide is highly valued for its anti-aging and brightening properties. Many users appreciate the quality of the active ingredients and the product’s clean, vegan formula, which doesn’t include parabens or sulfates.
A few users mentioned that they would have preferred even more natural ingredients or a higher concentration of actives. Some feel that while the ingredients are good, the price might not fully reflect the benefits for those with more stubborn under-eye issues.
Value for Money
88%
Despite some concerns about the price, many users feel that the serum offers good value for money due to its high-quality ingredients and effectiveness in tackling dark circles and fine lines. The long-term benefits justify the investment for regular users.
Others feel the price is steep, especially considering the smaller size of the bottle. Some buyers mentioned that similar results can be achieved with more affordable alternatives, making them question the overall value of the product.
Hydration & Moisture
78%
22%
While this serum helps to address aging concerns, it also provides some hydration to the delicate under-eye area. Users appreciate that it doesn’t dry out the skin and leaves it feeling nourished without a greasy finish.
However, a few users felt that the serum’s moisturizing properties weren’t as intense as expected, especially for those with dry skin. Some felt they needed to supplement with additional moisturizers for better hydration throughout the day.
Consistency Across Batches
85%
Many users reported consistent results batch after batch, with the serum maintaining its quality and effectiveness. Those who purchased multiple bottles noted that the formula didn’t change, ensuring reliable outcomes with continued use.
However, a few buyers experienced slight variations in texture and effectiveness between different batches. This inconsistency led to some frustration, as it impacted the overall experience and confidence in the product’s reliability.

Suitable for:

The Sunday Riley 5 Stars Retinol + Niacinamide Anti Aging Eye Serum is ideal for users looking to reduce dark circles and fine lines. It is especially beneficial for those with sensitive skin, as its fragrance-free and vegan formula minimizes irritation while delivering effective results. People experiencing the early signs of aging, such as fine lines around the eyes, will appreciate its smoothing effects. Additionally, this serum works well for those who want a gentle, yet effective treatment for puffiness and uneven skin tone around the eyes, with many users reporting visible improvements after consistent use over several weeks.

Not suitable for:

This product may not be the best choice for individuals with very dry skin or those seeking immediate, intense hydration. While it provides some moisture, users with extremely dry skin may find it less nourishing than other options. Those with oily skin might also find it slightly heavy or tacky. Additionally, if you're expecting instant results, especially for deeper wrinkles or persistent dark circles, this serum may fall short, as it requires consistent use over a longer period for noticeable effects. Lastly, if you prefer products with a noticeable fragrance, this fragrance-free formula may not appeal to you.

Specifications

  • Brand: Sunday Riley is the brand behind this eye serum, known for its high-quality skincare products.
  • Product Type: This product is an eye serum designed specifically for anti-aging and targeting under-eye concerns.
  • Active Ingredients: The serum contains retinol and niacinamide, which are known for their anti-aging and skin-brightening benefits.
  • Size: The product comes in a 0.5 oz (15 mL) bottle, providing a suitable amount for regular use.
  • Fragrance-Free: This serum is fragrance-free, making it suitable for those with sensitive skin or fragrance sensitivities.
  • Skin Type Compatibility: The serum is designed for all skin types, including sensitive skin, and is suitable for daily use.
  • Free From: The product is free from parabens, sulfates, phthalates, gluten, and soy, ensuring it is gentle on the skin.
  • Cruelty-Free: Sunday Riley is committed to cruelty-free practices, and this product is not tested on animals.
  • Vegan: The serum is vegan, meaning it does not contain any animal-derived ingredients.
  • Target Concerns: It targets common under-eye concerns, such as dark circles, puffiness, fine lines, and wrinkles.
  • How to Use: For best results, apply a small amount to the under-eye area twice daily after cleansing and before moisturizing.
  • Texture: The serum has a lightweight, smooth texture that absorbs quickly into the skin without feeling greasy.
  • Effectiveness: Users report visible improvements in skin smoothness and under-eye brightness with consistent use over several weeks.
  • Usage Time: Visible results may take several weeks of consistent application, as retinol and niacinamide work gradually.
  • Hypoallergenic: Formulated for minimal irritation, the serum is generally well-tolerated by most users, including those with sensitive skin.
  • Packaging: The serum is packaged in a compact, easy-to-use pump bottle that helps control the amount dispensed.
  • Antioxidant Properties: Niacinamide offers antioxidant properties that help protect the skin from environmental stressors and improve skin tone.
  • Retinol Concentration: This serum uses a mild form of retinol, suitable for the delicate under-eye area, to reduce signs of aging.
  • Application Time: For optimal results, apply the serum at night before moisturizing, as retinol is most effective in evening skincare routines.

FAQ

To use this eye serum, apply a small amount to the under-eye area after cleansing and before moisturizing. Gently tap it in with your ring finger, which has the lightest touch, and use it both in the morning and evening for best results.

Yes, this eye serum is fragrance-free and formulated to be gentle on sensitive skin. It contains soothing ingredients like niacinamide, which helps to calm irritation, making it a great option for people prone to skin sensitivity.

Yes, the combination of retinol and niacinamide in this serum targets both dark circles and puffiness. Niacinamide brightens the skin, while retinol smooths fine lines and promotes skin regeneration, helping to reduce under-eye puffiness over time.

The exact concentration of retinol is not specified, but this serum is designed for gentle, effective use around the delicate eye area. It’s formulated to be less irritating than stronger retinol treatments while still providing noticeable anti-aging benefits.

Yes, this product is suitable for all skin types. Its fragrance-free, vegan formula is ideal for those with sensitive skin, and it helps address common concerns like dark circles, puffiness, and fine lines without causing irritation.

No, the serum is fragrance-free, which makes it a great choice for those with sensitive skin or those who prefer products without strong scents. This also reduces the risk of irritation around the eyes.

Many users report visible improvements in under-eye smoothness and brightness after about 2-3 weeks of regular use. However, full results may take several weeks, as retinol works gradually to improve skin texture and tone.

Yes, you can use this serum alongside other anti-aging products. However, if you’re using other retinol-based products, it’s best to introduce this serum slowly into your routine to avoid potential irritation. Always apply sunscreen during the day when using retinol.

While retinol is generally not recommended during pregnancy due to its potency, it's best to consult with a healthcare professional before using this product if you are pregnant or breastfeeding. They can advise on the safest options for your skin.

To maintain the effectiveness of this eye serum, store it in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight. Make sure the cap is tightly sealed after use to prevent air and moisture from affecting the formula.