stila Stay All Day Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Liner - Lionfish Bronze

85%

Longevity

Smudge-Proof Performance

Application Smoothness

Pigmentation Intensity

Waterproof Effectiveness

Precision for Tightlining

Blendability for Smoky Eyes

Ease of Removal

Packaging Quality

Cruelty-Free & Ethical Production

Value for Money

Waterline Longevity

Color Variety

Overview

The stila Stay All Day Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Liner - Lionfish Bronze is a gel eyeliner pencil that promises to deliver long-lasting, smudge-proof wear throughout the day. This waterproof gel liner is available in the rich shade of Lionfish Bronze, which adds depth and definition to the eyes with ease. The formulation ensures that it stays put without smudging or fading, making it perfect for all-day wear. Its smooth application offers intense color payoff, and the creamy texture makes it ideal for both beginners and experienced makeup lovers alike.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This waterproof gel liner is formulated to stay intact even in the most humid conditions. The rich pigment provides a bold and intense color that defines the eyes beautifully. Its smooth, creamy texture glides on effortlessly, allowing for easy application, whether you're creating a defined line or smudging for a smoky effect. The cruelty-free formula is also made in the USA, ensuring that it’s both high-quality and ethical. Its long-wear formula ensures it stays in place without fading or transferring throughout the day.

Best For

This gel liner is perfect for those looking for a long-lasting eyeliner that offers a smudge-proof, waterproof finish. It's especially suited for users who want to define their eyes with precision, making it a great choice for tightlining or creating dramatic smoky eye looks. The rich, bronze shade of Lionfish Bronze works well for both day and evening makeup, adding depth to any eye look. If you're after an eyeliner that won’t budge, this waterproof gel liner is the ideal choice.

User Feedback

Users appreciate the smooth, easy application of this eyeliner pencil, with many highlighting its intense color payoff and its ability to stay put all day long. The smudge-proof formula is highly praised, especially for its staying power, even on the waterline. However, some users have noted that while it works well for most, it could be more long-lasting on the waterline, with occasional fading or smudging after several hours. Overall, it’s a favorite for those looking for reliable, high-quality eyeliner.

#Eyeliner

#Eyes

#Makeup

#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

The Lionfish Bronze shade offers a rich, vibrant color that's perfect for creating smoky eye looks.
This eyeliner pencil provides excellent smudge-proof performance, staying in place throughout the day.
It glides on smoothly, making application quick and easy, even for tightlining.
Waterproof formula holds up well in humid conditions or around the eyes during long workdays.
Cruelty-free and made in the USA, appealing to users seeking ethically produced makeup.
Great for users who need an eyeliner that stays put during busy, active days without fading.

Cons

Some users report that the liner fades more quickly on the waterline than on the eyelids.
The creamy texture can cause smudging when used in hotter or more humid environments.
A few users found the pencil to be too soft, which can lead to breakage if not applied gently.
The pencil's longevity may not be sufficient for those needing all-day wear in extreme conditions.
The shade range is limited, leaving users who prefer more variety feeling disappointed.
Not suitable for sensitive eyes in some cases, as it may cause irritation after prolonged wear.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews from multiple platforms and languages, we've compiled an in-depth look at the stila Stay All Day Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Liner - Lionfish Bronze. Feedback has been carefully sifted to ensure authenticity, with only high-quality responses considered. Both strengths and pain points are reflected in the scores, with insights drawn from diverse sources around the world, giving you a complete picture of this product's performance.

Longevity

90%

Many users highlight the impressive long-lasting power of this product, with some reporting that it lasts well into the evening without needing touch-ups. The waterproof formula ensures it stays intact even through humid or rainy conditions, making it perfect for all-day wear, especially during busy workdays or events.

However, a few customers mentioned that while the eyeliner lasts well on most areas of the eye, it can start to fade or smudge slightly on the waterline after extended wear. Those seeking absolute all-day wear may find this slightly disappointing in certain conditions.

Smudge-Proof Performance

93%

Users consistently praise the smudge-proof quality, noting that once applied, it stays in place all day without transferring or fading. This is especially beneficial for those with oily skin or people who wear makeup in more active environments, like during workouts or outdoor events.

On the flip side, some users expressed frustration with removal, finding that it can be difficult to completely clean off without using strong makeup removers or oil-based cleansers. This might be inconvenient for those looking for a product that washes off easily with regular cleansing routines.

Application Smoothness

87%

The smooth application is frequently mentioned by users who love how easily the pencil glides across the skin. Many appreciate how effortlessly it draws crisp lines without tugging, making it ideal for tightlining or creating bold eye looks. This smoothness is a key reason many return to this product for daily use.

Some buyers, however, pointed out that the pencil can feel slightly too soft, with a few experiencing breakage during use. Others suggested it could be more consistent in its texture, as some batches appeared to be a little firmer than others, which may affect ease of use.

Pigmentation Intensity

91%

The rich pigmentation of this gel liner is one of its standout features, delivering an intense color payoff in just one swipe. Many customers rave about how vibrant and bold the Lionfish Bronze shade appears on their eyes, making it perfect for both everyday looks and more dramatic, smoky eye effects.

Despite the generally positive feedback, a small group of users found the color to be slightly less intense than expected. Some reported having to layer the product to get the full effect, which could be a bit inconvenient for those who prefer a single-pass, bold color payoff.

Waterproof Effectiveness

89%

This waterproof gel liner impresses many users who need an eyeliner that won't budge, even in wet conditions. Whether swimming, sweating, or caught in the rain, it stays in place throughout the day without smudging, making it a reliable option for active lifestyles or humid climates.

A few reviewers noted that while the product holds up well, it can be difficult to remove completely. Some mentioned that the eyeliner left behind faint traces on the skin, requiring additional effort during makeup removal, which could be a downside for users seeking a more effortless cleanup.

Precision for Tightlining

88%

Many users find this pencil perfect for tightlining due to its precision and smooth glide. It reaches the waterline without irritation and stays put, making it a go-to product for those who need a liner that enhances their eye shape without smudging or fading throughout the day.

However, a handful of users felt that the pencil's softness made it less effective for creating ultra-fine, precise lines in the tightest areas. Some wished for a sharper tip for more controlled application, particularly when working on the lower waterline.

Blendability for Smoky Eyes

86%

The product’s blendability is highly rated for creating smoky eye looks, as it smudges easily when applied without losing its color intensity. This makes it great for those looking to create a sultry, blended finish without the liner disappearing after a few minutes.

However, some users experienced difficulty with blending on certain eye types, particularly those with oily eyelids. In these cases, the liner did not stay as blendable as hoped, and some users reported it set too quickly to achieve the desired smoky effect.

Ease of Removal

75%

25%

A few users appreciate that the eyeliner offers long-lasting coverage but still removes reasonably well with a cleansing oil or makeup remover. It's a good option for those who typically use products that require extra care when removing.

The most common complaint about this product is that it can be very hard to remove. Some users found that even with standard makeup removers, the product left behind residue, which led to irritation or required multiple cleansing attempts to fully remove.

Packaging Quality

80%

20%

The pencil packaging is generally well-received for being sturdy and easy to handle. The twist-up design is convenient, ensuring users don’t have to sharpen it frequently, which saves time and effort in daily routines.

On the downside, a few users felt that the packaging could be more durable, with some experiencing the twist-up mechanism becoming faulty after repeated use. This led to some frustration for users who expected a longer lifespan from the product.

Cruelty-Free & Ethical Production

96%

Customers appreciate the product's cruelty-free certification, aligning with the values of consumers who prioritize ethical beauty products. Many feel reassured by its USA-made status, ensuring higher standards of production and accountability.

While the cruelty-free aspect is praised, some users wished for more transparency regarding the sourcing of ingredients. A small number also questioned the environmental impact of packaging, suggesting that it could be more eco-friendly.

Value for Money

85%

The product’s quality and performance justify the price for many users, particularly those looking for a reliable, long-wearing gel liner. Given its effectiveness in creating both bold and subtle looks, many consider it a worthwhile investment for everyday use.

That said, a few customers felt that the price was slightly higher than other similar products, particularly considering the longevity issues some encountered on the waterline. Some prefer a more affordable option if it delivers comparable results.

Waterline Longevity

70%

30%

Some users have found that it performs well on the waterline, especially in non-humid conditions. It offers an intense, rich line that enhances the eyes without too much hassle in application.

However, several reviews mention that the liner does not hold up well on the waterline for extended periods. It tends to fade, smudge, or disappear after a few hours, leaving those with longer workdays or active lifestyles dissatisfied with its longevity.

Color Variety

80%

20%

The availability of the Lionfish Bronze shade is appreciated by many users who enjoy a unique yet wearable color that adds depth and warmth to their eyes. Some users mention that this particular shade offers a fresh twist on classic eyeliner colors.

While the shade is well-loved, a few users noted the limited variety in color options compared to other brands. Those looking for a wider range of shades may find this product lacking in variety, particularly for those who prefer bolder or more colorful eyeliner choices.

Suitable for:

This gel eyeliner pencil is ideal for users seeking a long-lasting, smudge-proof eyeliner that can withstand a full day of wear. Those who enjoy intense color payoff, particularly the rich Lionfish Bronze shade, will appreciate how it enhances both subtle and bold eye looks. Perfect for those with busy lifestyles, the waterproof formula ensures that it stays put without fading, even in humid or rainy conditions. Makeup enthusiasts looking for precision will find it excellent for tightlining and creating defined smoky eyes. It's also a great choice for cruelty-free product lovers, as it's made in the USA and free from animal testing.

Not suitable for:

While this product offers impressive staying power for many, users seeking absolute waterline longevity may find it lacking. Some buyers noted that the eyeliner tends to fade or smudge on the waterline after extended wear, making it less suitable for those who need a liner that stays put for longer periods. Additionally, those with very sensitive eyes or prone to irritation may experience discomfort, as the product’s creamy texture can be a bit too soft and may cause smudging in certain environments. Lastly, users who prefer a wide range of color options might feel limited, as the product offers only a select few shades, including Lionfish Bronze.

Specifications

Product Type: Gel eyeliner pencil designed for precise, long-lasting application.
Shade: Comes in the shade Lionfish Bronze, a warm bronze with subtle shimmer.
Formulation: Waterproof formula ensures that the eyeliner stays in place without smudging or fading.
Color Payoff: Provides intense color payoff for bold, defined eye looks.
Application Type: Easy-to-use pencil format for quick and controlled application.
Duration: Offers up to 12 hours of wear without fading or smudging.
Cruelty-Free: The product is cruelty-free, meaning it is not tested on animals.
Made in: Manufactured in the USA for quality assurance.
Use Cases: Ideal for creating precise lines, tightlining, and smoky eye looks.
Waterproof: Waterproof formula ensures long-lasting wear even in humid or rainy conditions.
Smudge-Proof: Stays in place without smudging or transferring throughout the day.
Skin Compatibility: Suitable for most skin types, including sensitive eyes, but patch test recommended.
Packaging: Comes in a pencil format with a twist-up design for ease of use.
Texture: Smooth, creamy texture that glides on easily for precise application.
Removal: Requires a gentle makeup remover or cleansing oil to fully remove.
Buildable: The product can be layered for a more intense or dramatic look.
Storage: Keep the pencil capped tightly and store in a cool, dry place to maintain product integrity.
Compatibility with Other Products: Works well when paired with other makeup products, including eyeshadows and primers.
Longevity on Waterline: While designed for use on the waterline, some users report slightly shorter longevity compared to eyelid use.

FAQ

To apply, gently glide the pencil along your lash line, starting from the inner corner of your eye. You can build up the intensity for a bolder look or smudge it slightly for a softer, smoky effect. For tightlining, carefully apply the liner to the waterline for a more defined look.

Yes, Lionfish Bronze is a versatile shade that adds depth to the eyes and works well for a variety of skin tones. It has a rich, warm tone with subtle shimmer, making it ideal for creating both everyday looks and more dramatic, evening styles.

This product offers long-lasting wear, staying put for up to 12 hours without smudging or fading. The waterproof formula ensures it holds up well, even in humid or sweaty conditions, making it ideal for long days or special occasions.

Yes, this waterproof gel liner is ideal for use on the waterline. It provides intense color that stays in place without smudging or fading throughout the day, although some users note it could be slightly less long-lasting on the waterline compared to the eyelids.

The eyeliner is formulated to be safe for most users, but if you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses, it's always best to perform a patch test first. The waterproof, smudge-proof formula may be more challenging to remove, so gentle removal with a suitable makeup remover is recommended.

This gel eyeliner pencil has a smooth, creamy texture that glides on easily without tugging or skipping. It provides a precise application and is great for creating defined lines or softer, blended looks for smoky eyes.

Yes, you can easily layer this gel liner for a more intense, dramatic look. The formula builds well without becoming patchy or clumpy, making it ideal for creating a bold, defined eye or a smoky, sultry effect.

Store the eyeliner pencil in a cool, dry place to prevent the formula from drying out. Make sure the cap is securely on after each use, and periodically sharpen the pencil to maintain a precise application tip.

Yes, the formula is both waterproof and smudge-proof. It stays in place for up to 12 hours, making it ideal for long wear, and resists fading or smudging even in humid or active environments.

The eyeliner is generally well-tolerated by most users, but as with any cosmetic product, it may cause irritation for those with extremely sensitive eyes or skin. If irritation occurs, discontinue use and consult with a dermatologist.