Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill)

Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill) — image 1
Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill) — image 2
Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill) — image 3
Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill) — image 4
Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill) — image 5
Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill) — image 6
Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill) — image 7
Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill) — image 8
84%
92%
Volume & Curl Performance
88%
Waterproof & Smudge-Proof
85%
Eco-Friendly Refill Option
78%
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes
65%
Ease of Removal
90%
Longevity (36-Hour Wear)
80%
Application & Buildability
95%
Clumping & Flaking
87%
Packaging & Design
88%
Overall User Satisfaction
83%
Price-Quality Ratio
82%
Consistency of Results Across Batches
More

Overview

The Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill) is designed to provide exceptional volume and curl for lashes, making it a must-have for anyone seeking bold definition. This mascara features a waterproof formula that promises up to 36 hours of wear without smudging or flaking. Its eco-friendly refillable packaging makes it ideal for those looking to reduce waste, offering a sustainable option without compromising on performance. Whether you're heading to work or a special event, this mascara is a reliable choice to keep your lashes looking full and defined all day long.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This mascara is formulated with a water-resistant formula that protects your lashes from sweat, sebum, and humidity, ensuring it stays in place throughout the day. It delivers long-lasting volume and curl, giving your lashes a fuller, more defined appearance without the risk of flaking. The unique formula is designed to lift and separate lashes, providing both length and volume with a natural, clump-free finish. If you're looking for a mascara that offers reliable, all-day hold without sacrificing comfort, this product ticks all the boxes.

Best For

This mascara is perfect for those who need a long-lasting and waterproof formula that can withstand all-day wear. It works especially well for users with sensitive eyes, as it is designed to minimize irritation and smudging. Eco-conscious shoppers will also appreciate the refillable nature of this mascara, making it an excellent choice for reducing waste. If you’re someone who values both performance and sustainability, this product offers the best of both worlds.

User Feedback

Users consistently praise this mascara for its ability to stay intact throughout the day, with many reporting that it doesn’t flake or smudge. Customers also appreciate the volume and curl it adds to lashes, creating a fuller, more dramatic look. However, some users note that it may require a bit more effort to remove compared to other mascaras, thanks to its strong waterproof formula. Despite this, the majority of feedback highlights its long-lasting performance and dependable wear.

#Mascara
#Eyes
#Makeup
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • The mascara delivers impressive volume and curl that lasts all day.
  • Waterproof formula holds up well even in humid conditions or during physical activity.
  • Eco-conscious users will appreciate the refillable packaging option.
  • Lashes remain smudge-free and intact without flaking for up to 36 hours.
  • Ideal for those with sensitive eyes, as it is gentle and doesn’t irritate.
  • The buildable formula allows for customizable lash volume, from natural to dramatic.

Cons

  • Removing this mascara can be difficult due to its strong waterproof formula.
  • Some users find it feels heavy or clumpy with multiple layers.
  • Not suitable for those who need a quick, easy makeup removal routine.
  • The waterproof formula might cause discomfort for individuals with very sensitive eyes.
  • May not be ideal for those preferring a more natural, lightweight mascara look.
  • A few users report that the mascara can be difficult to layer without clumping.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews from multiple platforms and languages, we found that the Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill) is generally well-received by users worldwide. The scores reflect a balanced mix of strengths and pain points, with most customers praising its long-lasting, waterproof formula and ability to provide impressive volume and curl. However, some feedback indicates challenges with removal due to its strong waterproof nature. All reviews were filtered to ensure authenticity, removing any spam or incentivized comments, and only high-quality feedback informed these results.

Volume & Curl Performance
92%
Many users report that this mascara delivers exceptional volume and defines lashes without clumping. It creates a striking, full lash look that lasts all day, which is perfect for those seeking bold results. The curl it provides holds strong even during long hours of wear, making it a favorite among those who need lasting volume and lift.
A few users mention that the mascara's formula may not provide the level of volume they expected for more sparse lashes. While it adds noticeable volume, some feel that it doesn't significantly enhance the curl for them, especially those with naturally straight lashes who require extra lift.
Waterproof & Smudge-Proof
88%
The waterproof formula is highly praised for its ability to stay intact through long workdays, workouts, or humid conditions. Users note that it resists smudging and doesn't flake, even in challenging environments. This makes it ideal for individuals who need reliable, all-day performance without worrying about touch-ups.
However, some users report difficulty in removing the mascara due to its strong waterproof nature. This makes it less suitable for those who prefer a more easily removable mascara, especially at the end of a long day. The removal process can be time-consuming and may require an oil-based makeup remover.
Eco-Friendly Refill Option
85%
Eco-conscious buyers appreciate the refillable design, which reduces waste and supports sustainable beauty routines. Many feel good about reducing their environmental impact while still getting a high-quality product. The refillable packaging is easy to use and can be reused multiple times, making it a great choice for those who prioritize sustainability.
On the downside, some users find the refill packaging to be a bit more cumbersome than a standard tube. There were mentions that refilling the mascara could be a bit tricky, especially if not done carefully, which might turn off those who value convenience over sustainability.
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes
78%
22%
The mascara is generally well-tolerated by users with sensitive eyes, with many noting that it doesn't irritate or cause discomfort after hours of wear. Those with allergies or prone to redness appreciate the gentle formula, which performs without causing stinging or itching. It offers a great option for those seeking a mascara that won't compromise their eye health.
That said, a few users with extremely sensitive eyes did experience irritation, especially after long wear. While the mascara is suitable for many, it may not be ideal for everyone, particularly those with very reactive eyes or skin conditions like eczema around the eyes.
Ease of Removal
65%
35%
For those who don't mind spending extra time removing their makeup, this mascara’s long-lasting nature means it stays in place without smudging or fading. Users who prefer a more durable formula appreciate that they can rely on it to stay intact through various conditions, without worrying about mascara migrating throughout the day.
Many users find the removal process difficult and time-consuming. The waterproof formula, while effective in providing all-day wear, can be a challenge to remove, requiring more effort and specialized makeup removers. This is a notable downside for individuals looking for a low-maintenance mascara that comes off easily.
Longevity (36-Hour Wear)
90%
The 36-hour wear claim is well-supported by users, with many noting that the mascara stays in place without any fading or smudging throughout the day. Whether users are attending long events or need to wear their mascara for extended hours, this formula holds up exceptionally well. It’s an excellent choice for those seeking durable, all-day beauty.
While it holds up well, a small number of users mentioned that the mascara could feel a bit heavy or stiff after long hours of wear. Those who prefer a more lightweight mascara might find the extended wear a bit uncomfortable, especially towards the end of the day.
Application & Buildability
80%
20%
This mascara offers a buildable formula that allows users to achieve their desired volume and intensity without clumping. It glides smoothly onto lashes, making the application process quick and easy. Many users appreciate the ability to layer the mascara for a more dramatic look or apply a lighter coat for a natural effect.
A few users noted that while the formula is buildable, it can sometimes get a bit thick after multiple layers, leading to some minor clumping. Those who prefer a super smooth, clump-free finish might need to be extra careful during application, as too much product can create a less polished result.
Clumping & Flaking
95%
Many users report that this mascara does an excellent job of preventing clumping and flaking. Lashes appear full and separated, with no noticeable product buildup. This mascara is ideal for those who seek a clean, defined lash look that stays intact throughout the day without any mess.
There are minimal complaints about clumping or flaking, though a few users mentioned that, in very humid conditions or after wearing for several hours, the mascara showed slight signs of product migration. However, these occurrences seem to be rare.
Packaging & Design
87%
The refillable packaging is sleek and sturdy, providing both eco-friendliness and practicality. Users find it easy to refill and appreciate that it can be reused, helping reduce environmental waste. The overall design is user-friendly, with an ergonomic applicator that makes for easy, controlled application every time.
Some users feel that the refillable design could be more compact and travel-friendly. A few reported that the larger size and refill process made the mascara less convenient for on-the-go use, especially compared to standard disposable mascaras.
Overall User Satisfaction
88%
Overall, users are very satisfied with this mascara, particularly for its long-lasting performance and eco-friendly refillable packaging. Most buyers are pleased with the volume, curl, and smudge-proof qualities. It’s a great option for those looking for a reliable, environmentally conscious mascara that delivers on its promises.
Some users noted that, despite its many strengths, it may not be suitable for every lash type or personal preference. Some felt that the mascara didn't provide enough volume or curl, and others were frustrated by the challenges of removal. Nonetheless, these complaints were in the minority.
Price-Quality Ratio
83%
Many users feel the price is justified given the high performance and eco-friendly nature of the product. The refillable packaging and lasting formula make it a solid investment for those seeking a quality, long-wear mascara. For the benefits it provides, users believe it offers good value for the cost.
However, a few buyers feel that the price is slightly high for a mascara, especially when compared to other options that may not have the refillable feature. While the quality is generally praised, some expect a lower price point given that there are other affordable waterproof mascaras available in the market.
Consistency of Results Across Batches
82%
18%
For the most part, users report consistent results with this mascara, noting that each tube provides a reliable, long-lasting formula that delivers volume and curl without flaking or smudging. This makes it a dependable product for those who value consistency.
A small number of users mentioned experiencing slight variations in the formula or performance across different batches. Some noticed differences in the texture or the intensity of the mascara's effect, which may be an issue for those who seek uniformity with every purchase.

Suitable for:

The Neogen Dermalogy Extra Volume Curl Metal Mascara - Volume, Black (Refill) is a great option for users looking for a long-lasting, waterproof mascara that provides volume and curl throughout the day. It's especially ideal for individuals with sensitive eyes or those who are prone to smudging. The waterproof formula holds up well under sweat, humidity, and sebum, making it perfect for active users or people living in humid climates. Eco-conscious buyers will also appreciate the refillable packaging, offering a sustainable alternative to traditional mascaras. This product suits those who need reliable, all-day performance without worrying about frequent touch-ups or flaking, making it an excellent choice for busy professionals, travelers, and anyone seeking a durable mascara solution.

Not suitable for:

However, this mascara may not be the best fit for users who prioritize easy removal. The waterproof formula is tough to take off, which could be frustrating for those looking for a quick, hassle-free makeup removal process. Additionally, individuals with very sensitive eyes or those who are prone to irritation might experience discomfort after extended wear. Although the mascara is marketed as suitable for sensitive eyes, some users have reported irritation, especially after long hours of use. Finally, those who prefer lightweight, natural makeup looks might find this mascara a bit too heavy, as it can feel stiff or thick after several layers, which could lead to clumping for some users.

Specifications

  • Brand: Neogen Dermalogy is the manufacturer of this product.
  • Color: This mascara is available in a classic black shade.
  • Type: This is a refillable mascara, offering an eco-friendly packaging option.
  • Formulation: The mascara has a waterproof formula that resists smudging and flaking.
  • Benefit: It provides volume and curl to lashes, enhancing their definition.
  • Duration: The formula lasts for up to 36 hours without needing touch-ups.
  • Application: The mascara is buildable, allowing users to layer for added volume.
  • Suitable for Sensitive Eyes: This mascara is formulated to be safe for users with sensitive eyes.
  • Packaging: The packaging is refillable, reducing environmental waste.
  • Water Resistance: This product offers protection against sweat, humidity, and water exposure.
  • Free from Flaking: The mascara is designed to prevent flaking throughout the day.
  • Target Audience: This mascara is ideal for eco-conscious users and those needing long-lasting wear.
  • Curl Effect: The formula is specifically designed to lift and curl lashes for a defined look.
  • Volume Effect: It provides significant volume, making lashes appear fuller.
  • Smudge Proof: The mascara is resistant to smudging, even during long wear.
  • Removal: Due to its waterproof formula, removal may require an oil-based makeup remover.
  • Eye Makeup: Ideal for users who need long-lasting mascara for full-day eye makeup wear.
  • Vegan & Cruelty-Free: This product is free from animal testing and suitable for vegan users.
  • Volume per Container: The mascara typically contains 8 mL of product in the refillable packaging.

FAQ

Start by curling your lashes with an eyelash curler for added lift. Then, gently apply this mascara from the base of your lashes to the tips in a zigzag motion to build volume and separation. For extra drama, apply multiple layers, allowing each coat to dry before adding more.

Yes, this mascara is formulated to be safe for sensitive eyes. It is free from flaking and smudging, making it a great option for those prone to irritation or allergic reactions. However, as with all products, if you have extremely sensitive eyes, it’s always best to do a patch test first.

The waterproof formula of this mascara provides up to 36 hours of wear, staying intact even through sweat, humidity, and water exposure, making it ideal for long days or special occasions.

Yes, this mascara is designed to withstand oil, sweat, and humidity, so it should work well for those with oily skin. It won’t smudge or flake, even during long days in humid or hot conditions.

Because of its long-lasting waterproof formula, this mascara may require a bit more effort to remove. It's best to use a gentle makeup remover or an oil-based cleanser to break down the formula without irritating your skin.

Yes, the mascara is specifically designed to provide both volume and curl. It lifts and defines lashes for a fuller, more voluminous look while maintaining a natural curl throughout the day.

Yes, this mascara comes in a refillable packaging option. Once you’ve used up the mascara, you can simply purchase a refill pod and swap it into the original container, making it an eco-friendly choice.

Yes, the waterproof and water-resistant formula of this mascara helps it stay intact in humid or rainy conditions. Many users report that it remains smudge-proof and does not flake, even during long days in warm weather.

The formula is buildable, so you can apply multiple layers to achieve more volume without significant clumping. However, it’s important to let each layer dry slightly before applying the next to prevent any buildup.

Yes, this mascara works well on all lash types, whether your lashes are short, long, fine, or thick. It provides volume and curl while lifting and separating each lash for a more defined look.