Overview

The Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil comes from a French makeup house known for working closely with professional artists, and this multi-use pencil reflects that pedigree in a small package. It is sold in a range of shades, with Cranberry sitting among the warmer, berry-leaning options rather than standing alone as a one-off color. Physically, this color stick is compact — about six inches long with a fill of just 0.05 oz — closer in spirit to a precision tool than a bulky cosmetic. Priced in that mid-to-premium tier, it positions itself less as a drugstore impulse buy and more as a considered addition to a working kit, something you reach for because of its versatility rather than its size.

Features & Benefits

What makes this color stick stand out is its flexibility across the face. The same pencil that defines a lip line can soften into a cheek tint or fill in sparse brows, which cuts down on how many products you need to carry. The formula blends easily, so you can build a soft, diffused wash of color or sharpen it into a more defined line depending on the tool — a finger, brush, or the pencil tip itself. Pigment payoff is strong enough that one pass usually delivers full coverage rather than requiring multiple swipes. The brand describes the formula as suitable across different skin tones, though as with any pigmented cream-to-powder product, individual results will vary depending on skin texture and oil levels. The slim, travel-friendly shape rounds out the practical appeal.

Best For

This cheek-and-lip pencil makes the most sense for a few specific kinds of buyers. Makeup artists who like consolidating their kits will appreciate having one pencil that handles several jobs instead of carrying separate products for cheeks, lips, and brows. It also suits anyone curious about a monochromatic look, where matching tones across the face creates a cohesive, soft-focus effect. People trying to simplify a crowded routine — fewer steps, fewer products — will find the multi-use format genuinely useful rather than just a marketing angle. Frequent travelers benefit too, since one slim pencil replacing three or four products saves real space in a bag. And if Cranberry specifically appeals to you as a brow or cheek tone, this is a direct match for that shade preference.

User Feedback

Feedback on multi-use pencils like this one tends to follow a pattern, and this is no exception. The most consistent praise centers on how easily the formula blends and how rich the color payoff is straight out of the package — people often note that a little goes a long way. On the other side, the 0.05 oz fill is genuinely small, and buyers comparing that amount against the price sometimes feel the value proposition is shaky, especially if they are used to larger drugstore pencils. Wear time is another point worth weighing honestly; oilier skin types may need a setting powder to keep the color from migrating by midday. Shade accuracy versus product photos also comes up, since Cranberry can read slightly different depending on lighting and screen calibration.

Pros

  • Works on cheeks, lips, eyes, and brows without needing separate products for each
  • Blends easily for a soft wash of color or a sharper, defined line
  • Delivers strong pigment payoff, often in a single swipe
  • Slim, compact shape slips easily into a makeup bag or travel kit
  • Pencil format allows precise application without extra brushes or tools
  • Formula is described as suitable across a range of skin tones
  • Cranberry shade offers a warm, versatile option for cheeks or brows
  • Multi-use design genuinely simplifies a routine for minimalist users

Cons

  • The 0.05 oz fill is small and may not feel proportional to the price
  • Wear time can be inconsistent on oilier skin without a setting powder
  • Shade can look slightly different in person compared to online photos
  • Limited to one shade per pencil, so multicolor looks require buying more than one
  • Not ideal for buyers who prefer larger, longer-lasting standalone pencils
  • Sharpening may be needed sooner than expected given the compact size
  • Premium positioning means less product value compared to budget-tier alternatives

Ratings

These scores for the Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil are generated by AI after analyzing verified user reviews from buyers around the world, with spam, bot activity, and incentivized feedback filtered out before any scoring takes place. Each category below reflects an honest mix of what people genuinely love about this color stick alongside the real trade-offs they encountered using it day to day.

Pigmentation & Color Payoff
89%
Most reviewers say this pencil delivers strong, true color in just one swipe, which makes quick morning routines or midday touch-ups noticeably easier. The cranberry shade in particular reads as rich and saturated rather than sheer or patchy.
A small number of users with very fair skin noted the pigment can feel a touch intense at first, requiring a lighter hand or extra blending to avoid an overly bold cheek or lip look.
Blendability
86%
Buyers consistently mention how easily the formula melts into skin with just a finger or brush, letting them shift from a soft cheek flush to a sharper lip line using the same pencil.
On very dry skin, a few users felt the pencil needed extra warmth or a damp finger to blend smoothly, otherwise edges could look slightly less seamless than on normal skin.
Versatility (Multi-Use Design)
84%
The ability to use one pencil on cheeks, lips, eyes, and brows is a recurring highlight, especially among people packing light for travel or simplifying a crowded daily makeup bag.
Some reviewers felt that while it performs adequately everywhere, it does not fully replace a dedicated brow pencil or eyeliner for those who want sharper precision in those specific areas.
Value for Money
67%
33%
Fans of the formula argue that the color intensity and blending quality justify the price, especially for professional makeup artists who prioritize performance over sheer product quantity in their kit.
A common complaint centers on the 0.05 oz fill feeling small relative to the cost, with several buyers comparing it unfavorably to larger drugstore multi-sticks that offer more product for less.
Longevity & Wear Time
71%
29%
On normal to dry skin, many users report the color holding up well through a full workday or evening out without needing major touch-ups, particularly on the lips and cheeks.
Those with oilier skin or warmer climates more frequently mention fading or movement by midday, suggesting a setting powder is often necessary to extend wear in humid or active conditions.
Travel Convenience & Portability
88%
The slim, six-inch pencil format earns consistent praise from travelers and minimalists who like swapping several products for one slim tool that fits easily into a small pouch or clutch.
A few reviewers noted that, like any pencil, it needs occasional sharpening to maintain a clean tip, which means packing a sharpener if relying on it during a longer trip.
Shade Accuracy (True-to-Photo)
63%
37%
Buyers who researched swatches and lighting conditions beforehand generally felt cranberry matched their expectations once applied, describing it as a warm, wearable berry tone in real life.
Several shoppers mentioned the shade looked noticeably different on screen than in person, a common issue with color cosmetics, which led to a few unmet expectations after unboxing.
Skin Tone Compatibility
79%
21%
The brand's claim of suiting a range of skin tones held up for many reviewers, who found the cranberry shade flattering across various complexions when used on cheeks or lips.
A handful of users with very deep or very fair skin felt the single shade option limited how universally flattering it could be without blending it with another product first.
Application Precision
82%
18%
The pencil tip allows for controlled, precise lines on the lips or brows without needing a separate brush, which many reviewers appreciated for quick, on-the-go application.
Because it is not retractable, repeated sharpening is required to maintain that precision over time, which a few users found mildly inconvenient compared to twist-up pencil formats.
Texture & Glide
85%
Most reviewers describe the texture as smooth and creamy without feeling greasy, gliding over skin easily during application on cheeks, lips, or brows alike.
A small subset of users with combination or oily skin felt the creamy texture could feel slightly heavy if layered too thickly in one concentrated spot.
Packaging & Build Quality
74%
26%
The simple pencil casing feels sturdy enough for daily use and tossing into a bag, with reviewers noting it survives typical travel handling without breaking or cracking.
Some buyers wished for a built-in sharpener or protective cap, since the basic pencil design lacks the conveniences found in some competing multi-use sticks.
Suitability for Sensitive Skin
69%
31%
Several reviewers with normal to mildly sensitive skin reported no irritation, even when using the pencil near the eyes or lip line over extended periods.
A few users with reactive or sensitive skin recommended patch testing first, since individual tolerance varied and a small number reported mild irritation with repeated use.

Suitable for:

The Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil works best for people who like the idea of one tool doing several jobs instead of carrying a separate product for every step. Makeup artists building out a professional kit will appreciate being able to swap between cheeks, lips, and brows without switching pencils mid-application. It also suits anyone curious about a monochromatic look, since using one shade across the face creates a soft, blended effect that is hard to replicate with mismatched products. Frequent travelers or anyone who prefers a slim makeup bag will likely find the compact size genuinely convenient rather than a gimmick. Shoppers who specifically want a cranberry-toned option for brows or cheeks, and who do not mind paying a bit more for a pro-oriented formula, are exactly who this pencil was made for.

Not suitable for:

Buyers who go through pigment quickly, or who apply makeup to a large surface area daily, may find the small 0.05 oz fill frustrating relative to the cost. Anyone shopping purely on a budget will likely get more total product for their money from a standard drugstore cheek or brow pencil instead. People with very oily skin should also temper expectations, since longevity can be inconsistent without a setting product to lock the color in place. If you are someone who needs an exact shade match before buying, relying on screen photos alone is risky, as Cranberry can shift depending on lighting and display calibration. Those who prefer dedicated, single-purpose products for each part of the face — rather than one item stretched across multiple uses — may also find the Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil less appealing than a more specialized formula.

Specifications

  • Brand: This pencil is made by Make Up For Ever, a French professional makeup brand.
  • Product Type: It is a multi-use color pencil designed for cheeks, lips, eyes, and brows.
  • Shade: The shade reviewed here is Cranberry, a warm berry-toned color.
  • Net Weight: Each pencil contains 0.05 oz (about 1.4 g) of product.
  • Dimensions: The pencil measures approximately 0.4 x 0.4 x 6 inches.
  • Item Form: The product comes in a solid pencil format rather than a liquid or cream.
  • Quantity: Each unit includes one pencil per package.
  • Application Areas: It is intended for use on the cheeks, lip line, eyes, and eyebrows.
  • Finish Style: The formula blends easily for either a soft, diffused look or a sharper, defined line.
  • Coverage Level: The pencil offers full-coverage pigment in a single application.
  • Skin Tone Range: The formula is described as suitable across a variety of skin tones.
  • Sharpening: As a pencil format, it requires a standard cosmetic pencil sharpener for maintenance.
  • Storage: It should be stored at room temperature away from direct heat or sunlight.
  • Category Placement: On Amazon, the product is listed under the Eyebrow Color subcategory.
  • Price Tier: It is positioned within the mid-to-premium range for professional-grade makeup pencils.

Related Reviews

Dynamic Color Circa 1oz Tattoo Ink Set
Dynamic Color Circa 1oz Tattoo Ink Set
82%
91%
Color Vibrancy
88%
Pigment Consistency
86%
Flow Rate & Workability
83%
Healing & Color Retention
84%
Packaging & Authenticity
More
Make Up For Ever Equalizer 30ml Primer
Make Up For Ever Equalizer 30ml Primer
81%
91%
Oil Control & Shine Reduction
88%
Foundation Longevity
86%
Texture & Application
74%
Pore Appearance
79%
Skin Comfort & Nourishment
More
Make Up For Ever HD Microfinish Powder
Make Up For Ever HD Microfinish Powder
79%
93%
Photo & Camera Performance
91%
Texture & Skin Feel
88%
Pore & Line Softening
76%
Shade Universality
61%
Value for Money
More
Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Concealer
Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Concealer
76%
91%
Blendability
74%
Coverage Performance
78%
Wear Longevity
88%
Finish & Skin Realism
86%
Sensitive Skin Compatibility
More
Make Up For Ever Matte Velvet Skin Foundation 1oz
Make Up For Ever Matte Velvet Skin Foundation 1oz
81%
92%
Oil Control
89%
Coverage Performance
88%
Finish Quality
86%
Wear Longevity
83%
Blendability
More
COS Color Out System Hair Color Remover
COS Color Out System Hair Color Remover
85%
88%
Effectiveness in Color Removal
92%
Ease of Use
91%
Speed of Results (20-Minute Process)
85%
Hair Health After Use
86%
Gentleness on Hair
More
Solong Tattoo 9-Color 1oz Tattoo Ink Set
Solong Tattoo 9-Color 1oz Tattoo Ink Set
74%
88%
Value for Money
79%
Color Vibrancy
83%
Ink Flow & Consistency
61%
Color Longevity
76%
Color Range & Selection
More
Goldwell Dualsenses Color Revive Color Conditioner 7.1oz
Goldwell Dualsenses Color Revive Color Conditioner 7.1oz
85%
91%
Effectiveness in Toning Blonde Hair
87%
Shine Enhancement
90%
Brassiness Reduction
83%
Ease of Use
80%
Texture and Feel on Hair
More
Matrix Color Obsessed Antioxidant Shampoo for Color Treated Hair
Matrix Color Obsessed Antioxidant Shampoo for Color Treated Hair
89%
95%
Color Protection
92%
Neutralizes Yellow Tones
88%
Hair Softness
90%
Manageability
85%
Fragrance Appeal
More
COLOR WOW Color Security Conditioner for Fine to Normal Hair
COLOR WOW Color Security Conditioner for Fine to Normal Hair
87%
92%
Hydration Effectiveness
89%
Heat Protection Performance
85%
Frizz Reduction
93%
Suitability for Color-Treated Hair
88%
Lightweight Feel
More

FAQ

It genuinely is formulated to work across all those areas. The Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil uses a blendable, pigmented formula that performs differently depending on where and how you apply it, which is what makes the multi-use claim hold up in practice.

Wear time varies by skin type. On normal to dry skin it tends to hold up well through several hours, but oilier skin may need a setting powder to keep it from fading or shifting by midday.

Yes, that is a typical fill size for professional color pencils in this format. It is small compared to a full-size lipstick or blush, so it is worth knowing that going in rather than expecting a larger quantity.

Not always exactly. Color cosmetics can shift slightly depending on screen calibration and lighting, so cranberry might read a touch warmer or cooler in person than it appears online.

A standard cosmetic pencil sharpener works fine. Just avoid generic pencil sharpeners made for graphite, since they are not designed for softer makeup formulas and can crumble the tip.

The brand states the formula suits a range of skin tones, but tolerance can still vary person to person. If you have particularly reactive skin, it is a good idea to patch test before applying it near your eyes or lips.

Yes, that is actually one of its strongest use cases. Using the same shade on cheeks, lips, and even lightly on the lids creates a cohesive, soft-focus effect that is hard to get with mismatched products.

This cheek-and-lip pencil generally offers more precise pigment and easier blending than typical budget multi-sticks, but it also comes in a smaller quantity and at a higher price point, so it is more about quality per swipe than overall volume.

It can work for brows, especially if you are looking for a warmer, reddish-brown tone like cranberry, but it is worth noting it is not a dedicated brow pencil, so the tip shape may feel less precise than brow-specific tools.

Like most cream-based pencils, it can move slightly if you have very oily skin or touch the area a lot. Setting it lightly with powder in high-movement areas like the lips or under-eye helps minimize transfer throughout the day.