MAC Paint Pot Painterly 5g/0.17oz

MAC Paint Pot Painterly 5g/0.17oz — image 1
MAC Paint Pot Painterly 5g/0.17oz — image 2
MAC Paint Pot Painterly 5g/0.17oz — image 3
MAC Paint Pot Painterly 5g/0.17oz — image 4
88%
88%
Ease of Application
92%
Long-lasting Wear
90%
Texture and Blendability
85%
Versatility for Different Looks
87%
Matte Finish Performance
91%
Oily Eyelid Compatibility
78%
Shade Suitability for All Skin Tones
83%
Packaging and Portability
86%
Overall Coverage
89%
Value for Money
94%
Blend with Other MAC Products
88%
Customer Satisfaction
More

Overview

The MAC Paint Pot Painterly 5g/0.17oz is a versatile cream eyeshadow designed for smooth, long-lasting wear. This neutral, matte shade, Painterly, provides the perfect base for any eye look, working seamlessly as both an eyeshadow and a primer. Whether used alone or as a base to enhance other eyeshadows, this product delivers a flawless, even canvas. Its smooth texture glides effortlessly onto the eyelids, blending easily for a natural, polished finish. This MAC product is a great choice for those looking for a reliable, all-in-one eye makeup solution.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

Formulated for long-lasting wear, this cream eyeshadow offers smooth, even coverage without creasing. Its unique formula provides a matte finish while maintaining a crease-free look throughout the day. Ideal for those with oily eyelids, it prevents smudging and fading, ensuring that your makeup stays intact for hours. This versatile product can be layered with other MAC eye products, allowing users to experiment with different looks. Its blendable texture ensures easy application, making it suitable for both beginners and seasoned makeup enthusiasts alike.

Best For

The Paint Pot is best suited for those looking for a reliable base to enhance their eyeshadow. Perfect for individuals who prefer neutral, everyday makeup looks, it creates a flawless, natural canvas for other products. If you have oily eyelids, this product will work wonders in keeping your eyeshadow in place without creasing or fading. Whether you’re a makeup beginner or an experienced user, this eyeshadow can be customized to suit a range of looks, from subtle to bold, making it a versatile addition to any makeup collection.

User Feedback

Many users rave about the creamy texture and easy blendability of this MAC product. It’s often praised for its long wear and ability to stay intact without creasing, even for those with oily eyelids. However, some users have noted that the shade may appear lighter on deeper skin tones, which can make it less suitable for everyone. Overall, this product has received positive feedback for its versatility—whether used as a primer or stand-alone eyeshadow, it delivers a reliable and polished finish every time.

#Eyeshadow
#Eyes
#Makeup
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • This eyeshadow provides a smooth, blendable texture that glides easily onto the eyelids.
  • Its long-wearing formula ensures a crease-free finish for several hours.
  • Works well as both a standalone eyeshadow and a primer under other products.
  • The neutral Painterly shade is versatile, perfect for creating a natural, everyday look.
  • Many users with oily eyelids appreciate its ability to stay intact throughout the day.
  • The compact jar packaging is convenient for travel and easy to store.

Cons

  • The shade may be too light for users with deeper skin tones, causing an unnatural look.
  • Some users find it slightly dry or difficult to blend on drier eyelids.
  • While long-lasting for many, it may start to fade in extremely humid conditions.
  • Not suitable for those seeking a highly pigmented or dramatic eye look.
  • The matte finish can emphasize dryness or fine lines on more mature skin.
  • Users with sensitive skin may experience slight irritation with prolonged wear.

Ratings

The ratings for this product were generated by RR-AI after analyzing verified user reviews from multiple countries, languages, and platforms, ensuring only authentic and high-quality feedback was considered. Both positive aspects and pain points were reflected in the scores, giving a balanced view of user experiences. The results are based on a wide range of feedback from real buyers, free from spam, bot, or incentivized reviews, to offer a true representation of the product’s performance across different demographics.

Ease of Application
88%
Many users appreciate how easy it is to apply this eyeshadow. Its smooth, creamy texture allows it to glide on effortlessly, and it blends seamlessly into the eyelids. It’s a go-to for those looking for quick and hassle-free makeup application, whether as a primer or standalone shadow.
Some reviewers mention that it can be a bit difficult to apply evenly on very dry eyelids. A few users also report that it requires a good amount of blending to achieve the desired finish, especially for those who prefer a more pigmented look.
Long-lasting Wear
92%
The long-wearing formula stands out for its impressive staying power. Users note that it remains intact throughout the day without fading, even on oily eyelids. This product is often praised for providing reliable coverage during long workdays or events without needing touch-ups.
Not all users are satisfied with the longevity. Some buyers with oily skin report that, while it lasts longer than other products, they still notice creasing after several hours, especially in humid environments or on particularly hot days.
Texture and Blendability
90%
The creamy consistency of this product is a major hit among users. It feels smooth on the skin and blends effortlessly with both fingers and brushes. Buyers often mention that it’s easy to layer and build, making it suitable for a variety of looks, from subtle to bold.
However, some customers feel that it can be a little too creamy for their liking, leading to occasional patchiness if not applied quickly. For some, it might take a bit longer to set, which can affect the final look if not properly blended.
Versatility for Different Looks
85%
This product is valued for its flexibility. Users enjoy how it can be used both as an eyeshadow and as a primer. The neutral shade makes it perfect for creating both natural, everyday looks or bold, dramatic eye makeup when combined with other colors.
While many users find the versatility appealing, some feel that the Painterly shade doesn’t offer enough depth or variation for more dramatic looks. Those who prefer vibrant, highly pigmented shades might not find this product as exciting or dynamic on its own.
Matte Finish Performance
87%
Buyers appreciate the matte finish it provides, making it a great choice for those looking for a more understated look. It’s particularly effective for creating a smooth, velvety base that doesn’t draw attention to fine lines or imperfections on the eyelids.
Some users mention that the matte finish can be too dry for certain skin types, particularly those with mature or drier eyelids. It might not provide the same dewy effect some users desire, which could be a downside for those with dry skin or looking for more luminosity.
Oily Eyelid Compatibility
91%
This product has earned praise for its compatibility with oily eyelids. Users with oily skin note that it helps control shine and keeps their eyeshadow in place all day, making it a go-to for those with oily skin or those who struggle with eyeshadow slipping off.
Though it works well for many with oily eyelids, some users report that it doesn’t completely prevent creasing or smudging over time, especially for those with extremely oily skin or in hot and humid climates. Additional setting powder may be needed for some users.
Shade Suitability for All Skin Tones
78%
22%
The neutral Painterly shade works well for many users, providing a natural base that enhances other eye makeup. Its muted tones make it a versatile choice for various looks, from everyday to more polished styles.
However, some users with deeper skin tones feel that the shade is too light for their complexion, resulting in an ashy or unnatural appearance. It’s not as universally flattering as some had hoped, particularly for those seeking a deeper, richer base.
Packaging and Portability
83%
The compact jar packaging is praised for its practicality and portability. It’s easy to carry around in a makeup bag for quick touch-ups or travel. The small size ensures it fits in most makeup cases, making it a convenient choice for on-the-go use.
On the flip side, some users find the jar packaging a bit cumbersome and prone to mess. The product can sometimes dry out if not sealed properly, and it may not be as hygienic as tube or stick formulations, requiring more careful handling.
Overall Coverage
86%
This cream offers decent coverage, acting as both an eyeshadow and a primer. It provides a smooth canvas that enhances the vibrancy of other shadows or blends well as a standalone product for those seeking a more natural look.
However, some buyers feel that the coverage could be more pigmented, especially when used as a primary eyeshadow. Those seeking fuller, more dramatic coverage may need to layer the product or combine it with additional eyeshadows to achieve the desired effect.
Value for Money
89%
Users often mention that this product offers good value for money considering its versatility and long-lasting performance. It’s a solid investment for those who appreciate high-quality eye makeup that lasts throughout the day without fading.
However, some feel that the product is slightly overpriced compared to other similar options on the market. While the quality is generally well-received, a few buyers think they could find comparable performance at a lower price point.
Blend with Other MAC Products
94%
Many users appreciate how easily this eyeshadow integrates with other MAC eye products. It works well with MAC’s other eyeshadows, liners, and brow products, allowing for a cohesive and polished look that blends seamlessly across different textures and finishes.
That said, a few users point out that blending with other brands' eyeshadows can be a bit tricky. Some feel that non-MAC products may not layer as effectively, requiring more effort to achieve the desired look or color payoff.
Customer Satisfaction
88%
Overall, customers report a high level of satisfaction with this product. Many are pleased with its performance, especially its smooth application and ability to stay put throughout the day. It’s considered a dependable staple in many makeup routines.
Despite the high overall satisfaction, some buyers express disappointment in the product's longevity for extremely oily skin types or in particularly hot weather. A few users also note that it may not be the best option for those with deeper skin tones due to the light shade.

Suitable for:

The MAC Paint Pot Painterly 5g/0.17oz is ideal for users who need a reliable, long-lasting eyeshadow base. Its smooth, blendable texture makes it a great choice for individuals seeking an everyday, neutral makeup look. It’s particularly well-suited for those with oily eyelids, as it provides a crease-free finish that lasts throughout the day. Whether used as a primer or a standalone eyeshadow, this product offers versatility and staying power, making it perfect for busy individuals looking for a low-maintenance yet polished look. Its matte finish also appeals to those who prefer a more understated, natural eye look rather than a glossy or shimmering effect.

Not suitable for:

This product may not be the best choice for users with dry or mature eyelids, as its matte finish could accentuate dryness or fine lines. Some users with darker skin tones also find the Painterly shade too light, leaving an ashy or unnatural look. Additionally, those expecting a highly pigmented, dramatic effect may be disappointed, as the coverage can be subtle and may require layering. Individuals living in very humid or hot climates may also face some fading or creasing after several hours, even though it is marketed as long-wearing. Therefore, those with extremely oily skin may need to use additional setting products for optimal results.

Specifications

  • Type: Cream eyeshadow suitable for use alone or as a primer.
  • Shade: Offered in the neutral Painterly shade, ideal for natural looks.
  • Size: Contains 5g (0.17oz) of product.
  • Formulation: Long-wearing formula that resists creasing and fading.
  • Skin Type: Suitable for all skin types, including oily eyelids.
  • Finish: Matte finish provides a smooth, even coverage.
  • Consistency: Smooth and creamy texture that blends easily.
  • Packaging: Compact jar with secure lid to prevent drying out.
  • Application: Can be applied with fingers or a brush, depending on preference.
  • Versatility: Works as both an eyeshadow and an eyeshadow primer.
  • Customization: Can be layered with other MAC eye products for varied looks.
  • Longevity: Stays intact for hours without fading or creasing.
  • All-day Wear: Suitable for extended wear, offering consistent color throughout the day.
  • Storage: Store in a cool, dry place to preserve its smooth texture.
  • Buildable Coverage: Offers customizable intensity based on application technique.
  • Color Payoff: Delivers a natural, neutral base with a subtle wash of color.
  • Ideal For: Great for those seeking a reliable eyeshadow base or primer.
  • Usage: Can be used for both everyday and more bold makeup looks.
  • Weight: Lightweight formula that feels comfortable on the eyelid.
  • Cruelty-Free: MAC is known for its commitment to cruelty-free testing practices.

FAQ

This cream eyeshadow is designed to be used as a base for eyeshadow or worn alone. It provides a smooth, long-lasting formula that creates a neutral, natural look with a matte finish. It's versatile enough to be used as an eyeshadow or primer to enhance the wear of other shadows.

For a flawless application, use your fingertip or a brush to apply this product directly onto your eyelid. If you're using it as a primer, apply a thin layer before your eyeshadow to create a smooth base. It blends easily and can be built up for more intensity if needed.

Yes, this eyeshadow is formulated for all skin types, including oily, dry, and combination skin. However, those with oily eyelids may find it especially effective in preventing creasing or fading throughout the day.

While this cream eyeshadow is suitable for most skin types, those with very sensitive skin should patch test it first, as some users with sensitive skin have noted minor irritation with prolonged wear.

The texture of this product is smooth, creamy, and easy to blend. It has a thick consistency that feels comfortable on the eyelid without being too heavy, making it great for layering or building up color.

This eyeshadow has a long-wearing formula that stays intact for several hours without creasing or fading. Many users report that it lasts all day, even for up to 8-10 hours, especially when used as a primer under other shadows.

The Painterly shade is a neutral, light beige that works well for fair to medium skin tones. However, deeper skin tones may find it too light, and it may not provide the same natural look as it does on lighter skin tones.

While this eyeshadow is perfect for neutral, everyday makeup looks, it can also serve as a base for more dramatic eye looks when paired with darker shades. Its versatility allows it to be used for both subtle and bold eye makeup.

The main benefits of this product include its smooth texture, long-lasting wear, and ability to prevent creasing. It can be used both as an eyeshadow and a primer, offering flexibility and a versatile base for different makeup styles.

Store this cream eyeshadow in a cool, dry place to ensure it maintains its smooth consistency. Make sure the lid is tightly closed to prevent it from drying out over time. Avoid exposing it to high temperatures or humidity.