Overview

The Lune+Aster Formidable Lengthening Mascara - Black is designed to deliver dramatic lash length and lift. Its long-lasting formula ensures up to 16 hours of wear, without any flaking or smudging. Ideal for all-day use, this mascara is both vegan and cruelty-free, making it an excellent choice for those who prioritize ethical beauty products. Whether you're heading to work or a night out, this mascara stays intact, providing a bold lash look that lasts.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This mascara is enriched with a unique blend of natural waxes, ensuring a smooth, buildable application for customizable volume. The formula is water-resistant yet lightweight, offering a comfortable wear throughout the day. Not only does it lengthen and lift, but it also strengthens lashes, providing definition without the risk of clumping. With its easy-to-apply formula, you get defined lashes that stay in place, making it a reliable beauty staple for any occasion.

Best For

The lengthening mascara is perfect for those seeking long-lasting, defined lashes that stand out all day. It's especially suited for individuals with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses, as the formula is gentle and safe for these conditions. Anyone who prefers vegan and cruelty-free beauty products will also appreciate the ethical makeup options this mascara provides. Whether you want to enhance your lashes for daily wear or special events, this product offers versatile results.

User Feedback

Many users have praised the smudge-proof formula, noting that it holds up well even through long days and workouts. The mascara provides natural-looking length and lift, offering a lightweight feel without weighing lashes down. However, a few users mentioned that the mascara can be challenging to remove at the end of the day. Overall, the curved brush is frequently highlighted for its precision, making application easier and more controlled, even for those new to mascara.

Pros

  • The formula lasts up to 16 hours without smudging or flaking, making it ideal for long workdays.
  • It provides natural-looking length and lift, enhancing lashes without feeling heavy.
  • The water-resistant feature holds up well even through workouts or humid conditions.
  • This mascara is gentle enough for sensitive eyes and suitable for contact lens wearers.
  • The curved brush allows for precise application, reaching even the smallest lashes.
  • It is vegan and cruelty-free, appealing to those seeking ethical beauty products.

Cons

  • Some users found it difficult to remove, even with makeup remover designed for waterproof products.
  • A few individuals felt that it didn't provide enough volume for a more dramatic lash look.
  • It may not be ideal for those with extremely oily skin, as it can transfer slightly during intense physical activity.
  • The buildable formula may clump if too many layers are applied in a short period.
  • Some people found it slightly irritating when worn for extended periods, despite being safe for sensitive eyes.
  • It is not the best option for those looking for a high-impact, ultra-voluminous effect.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews from multiple languages and platforms worldwide, we gathered insights on the Lune+Aster Formidable Lengthening Mascara - Black. Only authentic, high-quality feedback was considered, filtering out any spam, bot, incentivized, or exaggerated reviews. Both strengths and pain points are reflected in the scores, offering a balanced overview of user experiences with this product.

Effectiveness in Lengthening Lashes
91%
Many users praise the lengthening effect, with some reporting noticeably longer, more defined lashes. The formula provides a dramatic lift without feeling heavy, making it ideal for those looking for a bold yet natural look. It works well for both everyday wear and special occasions, offering impressive results with a single coat.
A few users mentioned that the mascara did not provide as much lengthening as they had hoped, especially on shorter lashes. Some also felt that it worked better for certain lash types but wasn't as effective for others. Those with very sparse lashes might need to layer it for optimal results.
Smudge-Proof Wear
88%
This mascara is praised for its long-lasting, smudge-proof formula, even through long days and workouts. Many users appreciate that it stays intact without smudging, even in humid conditions, making it a go-to for active individuals. It's especially ideal for those looking for a mascara that can withstand all-day wear without worrying about touch-ups.
A small group of users noted that while the mascara stays put for the most part, it can still leave slight marks on the skin after extended wear. Some also mentioned that it may not be as resistant to smudging for those with oily skin or during extreme conditions like excessive sweating.
Comfort for Sensitive Eyes
94%
Users with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses have found this mascara to be gentle and non-irritating. Its hypoallergenic and cruelty-free formula offers peace of mind for anyone concerned about eye health. Several buyers also mentioned that it didn’t cause stinging or discomfort, even after hours of wear.
A few users with extremely sensitive eyes reported that the mascara caused mild irritation or discomfort, especially when worn for extended periods. Some also experienced dryness, which could be due to individual skin sensitivities, though this was less common among users with sensitive eyes.
Buildable Formula
86%
The buildable formula allows users to adjust the intensity of their lashes. Whether aiming for a more natural look or full-on volume, the mascara adapts well to different preferences. Many buyers noted that it layered beautifully without clumping, making it versatile for various looks and occasions.
Some buyers felt that the formula became too thick when layered, leading to a somewhat clumpy appearance. Others mentioned that while it offers a buildable effect, it takes a bit longer to achieve the desired volume, especially if you're looking for a dramatic finish.
Longevity (16-hour Wear)
89%
The 16-hour wear time is highly appreciated, as it allows users to go through their day without worrying about reapplication. Many reviewers confirmed that the mascara maintained its shape, offering long-lasting lift and volume from morning until night. The formula holds up well under everyday activities and weather conditions.
A small number of users felt that while the mascara lasts all day, it can start to show slight signs of fading or flaking after the 12-hour mark. Some reported that, although it’s longwearing, it wasn’t as resilient in extreme weather conditions like heavy rain or sweat.
Volume and Definition
84%
This mascara excels in giving lashes a defined, natural look with moderate volume. Many users enjoy the subtle volume boost without the clumping or spider-leg effect. The formula provides a clean, smooth finish that makes lashes appear fuller and more defined without being overdone.
Some users were disappointed by the volume it provided, feeling that it wasn’t as voluminous as they had expected. It also didn’t create as much dramatic fullness on thinner lashes, leaving them wishing for more noticeable results.
Packaging and Brush Design
80%
20%
The curved brush design makes it easier to apply the product with precision, especially on the outer corners. Many users found it easy to coat their lashes evenly, with the brush reaching every lash without excess product buildup. The sleek, compact packaging is also convenient for on-the-go use.
However, some users felt that the brush’s curve didn't suit their lash shapes, making application less precise. A few mentioned that the wand could be a bit too stiff, leading to less control during application, particularly for those with shorter or sparse lashes.
Ease of Removal
60%
40%
Several users mentioned that the mascara, while water-resistant, is easy to remove with makeup removers or micellar water. It doesn't require excessive rubbing or harsh chemicals, which is a relief for users with delicate skin or sensitive eyes.
On the flip side, some buyers found the mascara difficult to fully remove, especially with just water or basic cleansers. They noted that residue remained on their lashes or under-eye area, requiring additional steps and effort, which detracted from their overall experience.
Value for Money
92%
This mascara provides excellent value for money given its high-quality formula and long-lasting results. Many users agreed that it offers performance comparable to more expensive options, making it a great choice for those seeking both effectiveness and affordability.
A few buyers felt that while the product is priced reasonably, it didn’t quite offer the same level of performance as some luxury mascaras. Some mentioned that they would have preferred a more budget-friendly alternative without sacrificing effectiveness.
Water-Resistance
87%
The water-resistant formula is appreciated by users who need a mascara that can hold up during humid weather or occasional splashes of water. It stays in place without running or smudging, making it ideal for those who spend time outdoors or in environments where their mascara might be tested.
However, some users reported that it wasn’t entirely waterproof, as it started to smudge or fade slightly in extremely wet conditions, such as heavy rain or swimming. A few also mentioned that it could be a bit difficult to remove after exposure to water.
Vegan and Cruelty-Free Features
96%
The vegan and cruelty-free formula is a major plus for ethical shoppers, with many users appreciating the brand’s commitment to animal welfare. It provides peace of mind for buyers who prioritize sustainable and cruelty-free beauty products in their routines.
While most users support the ethical stance, a small group felt that the product’s ethical claims didn’t always translate into performance. These users suggested that, at times, vegan formulas might not meet the same high standards as non-vegan mascaras, especially regarding long-lasting performance.
Consistency Across Batches
82%
18%
Many users reported consistent performance with every purchase, enjoying the same high-quality results. The product maintains its effectiveness over time, and repeat buyers have been pleased with its consistency in formula and application.
A few customers experienced slight variations between batches, including differences in the mascara’s consistency and application. Some noted that the formula seemed thicker or thinner with certain purchases, which affected its overall performance.

Suitable for:

The Lune+Aster Formidable Lengthening Mascara - Black is a great choice for anyone looking for a long-lasting, defined lash look. It’s especially well-suited for users with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses, as the formula is gentle and irritation-free. Those who need a reliable mascara that stays intact through long workdays, workouts, or humid weather will appreciate its smudge-proof and water-resistant qualities. Additionally, if you prefer vegan and cruelty-free beauty products, this mascara aligns well with those values, offering both performance and ethical benefits. It's also perfect for anyone who wants a buildable formula that can easily go from natural to more dramatic lashes without clumping or weighing them down.

Not suitable for:

This mascara may not be the best fit for users with very oily skin or those who engage in activities that might cause heavy sweating, as some found that the product could slightly smudge under such conditions. While it offers buildable volume, users seeking a dramatic, ultra-voluminous effect might be disappointed as it doesn’t provide the intense fullness some may desire. Additionally, people who struggle with mascara removal may find this product somewhat tricky to take off completely, despite its water resistance. Those with extremely sensitive eyes may also experience mild irritation, especially if worn for extended periods, though this was a less common issue.

Specifications

  • Formula: Longwear formula provides up to 16 hours of wear without flaking or smudging.
  • Vegan: This mascara is 100% vegan and contains no animal-derived ingredients.
  • Cruelty-Free: This product is cruelty-free, meaning it has not been tested on animals.
  • Water-Resistant: The mascara is water-resistant, helping it stay in place in humid conditions or light moisture.
  • Brush Type: Features a curved brush designed for precise application and easy lash separation.
  • Buildable: The formula is buildable, allowing users to layer for more volume and length without clumping.
  • Suitable for Sensitive Eyes: This mascara is formulated to be gentle and safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
  • Color: The mascara is available in Black, offering dramatic color payoff for lashes.
  • Lash Benefits: Provides length, lift, and definition to lashes, creating a natural yet enhanced look.
  • Texture: The texture is lightweight, allowing for comfortable wear throughout the day.
  • Clump-Free: The mascara's formula helps prevent clumping, ensuring smooth, separated lashes.
  • Application: Designed for easy application with a curved brush that conforms to the shape of the lashes.
  • Duration: Stays intact for up to 16 hours without needing touch-ups, ideal for long days.
  • Removal: Can be easily removed with a makeup remover or cleansing oil, even though it is water-resistant.
  • Size: The mascara comes in a standard tube size, suitable for everyday use.
  • Suitable for All Lashes: The formula works well for all lash types, from fine to full lashes.
  • No Irritation: Formulated to minimize irritation, making it ideal for those with sensitive eyes or skin.
  • Packaging: Packaged in a sleek tube with a precision applicator for easy use.
  • Fragrance: This product is fragrance-free, reducing the risk of irritation around the eyes.

FAQ

This mascara offers a longwear formula that lasts up to 16 hours without flaking or smudging, making it ideal for all-day wear.

Yes, this mascara is designed specifically for sensitive eyes and is also suitable for contact lens wearers. It is made with a gentle formula to minimize irritation.

To apply, start at the base of your lashes and use the curved brush to sweep the mascara upward. For added length and volume, you can build up multiple layers, but avoid over-layering to prevent clumping.

Yes, this mascara is both vegan and cruelty-free, so it contains no animal-derived ingredients and has not been tested on animals.

The texture is smooth and lightweight, making it easy to apply without weighing down your lashes. It provides buildable coverage for both subtle and dramatic lash looks.

Yes, thanks to its water-resistant formula, this mascara stays intact during workouts and other activities, helping to prevent smudging or running.

While the mascara is primarily designed to lengthen and lift, it also adds definition and some volume to lashes without clumping, providing a natural yet enhanced look.

This mascara contains a unique blend of natural waxes that ensure smooth application and a buildable finish, without clumping or weighing down your lashes.

This mascara is water-resistant but not fully waterproof. It will hold up well in humid conditions and light moisture, but heavy rain or swimming may cause it to smudge.

Although water-resistant, this mascara is designed to be easily removed with makeup remover or cleansing oil, so you won't have to struggle with harsh rubbing.