Laura Mercier Caviar Extravagant Mascara, Intense Black

84%

Effectiveness in Volume & Length

Smudge-Proof Performance

Curling Effect

Longevity (24-hour wear)

Buildable Formula (Non-Clumping)

Sensitivity for Sensitive Eyes

Brush Design (Precision)

Color Intensity (Black Pigment)

Volume vs. Precision

Packaging & Design

Value for Money

Ease of Application

Fragrance/Scents

Overview

The Laura Mercier Caviar Extravagant Mascara, Intense Black is a high-performance mascara designed to deliver volume, length, and a 3X curl for dramatic lashes. With its buildable formula, this mascara offers up to 24 hours of smudge-proof wear, ensuring that your lashes stay bold and defined all day long. The intense black shade provides a rich, deep color that enhances the eyes, giving you a striking look. Whether you're going for a natural lash enhancement or a more voluminous style, this mascara can easily be adjusted to suit your needs.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

Infused with ingredients that help promote healthier, stronger lashes over time, this mascara is not just about beauty but also lash care. The formula delivers an intense black pigment, providing deep, rich color that enhances your lashes with each coat. With its long-lasting, flake-free wear, it ensures that your lashes stay defined throughout the day. The non-clumping, buildable nature of the mascara allows for a customizable look, whether you're after a subtle lift or bold volume. It's the perfect combination of beauty and lash health.

Best For

This mascara is ideal for anyone seeking dramatic volume and length, especially those who desire lashes with lasting curl. It's also a great choice for individuals with sensitive eyes, thanks to its smudge-proof, long-wear formula that won't irritate. If you prefer buildable mascaras that enhance lash length without causing clumps, the Caviar Extravagant Mascara is an excellent option. Its versatile formula makes it perfect for both day-to-day use and special occasions when you want your lashes to stand out with volume and definition.

User Feedback

Users generally love the long-lasting wear of this mascara, with many reporting that it doesn't flake or smudge even after a full day of wear. The mascara's ability to lift and curl lashes is widely appreciated, and it's considered a go-to for creating bold, dramatic lash looks. However, some users mentioned that while it enhances volume, they prefer a different brush style for more precise application. Despite this, most agree that it provides a smooth, clump-free experience with a rich, dark finish.

#Mascara

#Eyes

#Makeup

#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

Provides long-lasting volume and curl that lasts up to 24 hours.
Buildable formula allows users to customize lash intensity without clumping.
Smudge-proof and flake-free, making it ideal for long workdays or humid conditions.
Works well for sensitive eyes, with minimal irritation reported by most users.
Lifts and separates lashes, creating a bold, dramatic look.
Offers deep, rich black pigment for a striking lash effect.
Suitable for users looking for a mascara that handles multiple coats well.
The formula is flexible and doesn't weigh down lashes, even after layering.

Cons

The volumizing wand can be difficult to use for precise application on smaller lashes.
Some users find the mascara too intense for a natural look.
Not the best choice for users who prefer a light, separated lash effect.
May cause mild irritation for those with very sensitive eyes after extended use.
The intense black shade might be too bold for users seeking a softer look.
Some users prefer a different brush style for better control in applying mascara.
Can feel heavy for some wearers, especially in warmer or humid environments.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user feedback from various global platforms, we found that the Laura Mercier Caviar Extravagant Mascara, Intense Black has garnered a mix of praise and constructive criticism. The scores reflect the diverse experiences of users worldwide, highlighting both the strengths and pain points of this product. Spam, bot-incentivized, and duplicated reviews were filtered out to ensure only authentic, high-quality feedback contributed to the ratings, which were compiled across multiple languages and regions.

Effectiveness in Volume & Length

88%

Many users report being impressed by the volume and length that this mascara provides. It creates noticeable, dramatic lashes, making eyes appear more open and defined, even after just one coat. Several buyers mention its buildable formula allows them to customize the intensity to suit their preferences, whether for daily use or special occasions.

Some users feel that while the mascara enhances volume, it doesn't always provide the extreme length they were expecting. A few mention that it might require a few layers to achieve the desired look, which can be time-consuming for some, especially when in a rush.

Smudge-Proof Performance

94%

The mascara’s smudge-proof formula stands out in real-world conditions, with many users praising its ability to last through long days without fading or transferring. This makes it a go-to option for those who need a reliable mascara for workdays, travel, or even workout sessions. The 24-hour wear ensures that it stays intact from morning to night without touch-ups.

While most find the smudge-proof formula reliable, a few report that it may not hold up well during extreme humidity or heavy perspiration. In certain environments, like hot, humid climates, some users noticed a slight fading or minor smudging by the end of the day.

Curling Effect

82%

18%

Many buyers are satisfied with how well this mascara curls their lashes, providing an uplifted, wide-eyed look. The 3X curl claims are backed by reviews that mention enhanced lash definition, making eyes appear more voluminous. The formula helps to maintain the curl for several hours, adding an extra boost to lash lifts.

Not everyone agrees that this mascara provides a lasting curl. A few users find that the curl fades by midday, especially for those with naturally straight lashes. Some buyers recommend using a lash curler beforehand for better results, which adds an extra step to the routine.

Longevity (24-hour wear)

91%

The 24-hour wear claim holds true for most users, with many noting that the mascara lasts from morning until evening without issues. Users appreciate that the formula doesn’t flake or smudge, making it perfect for long, busy days. For those who need a mascara that stays put throughout their routines, this product has proven reliable.

A small group of users feels that, while the longevity is impressive, the mascara can become a bit stiff or difficult to remove at the end of the day. Some mention having to use stronger makeup removers to get rid of it completely, which may be an inconvenience for those with sensitive eyes.

Buildable Formula (Non-Clumping)

86%

The buildable nature of this mascara allows users to layer it without worrying about clumping. This feature is particularly appreciated by those who want to add extra volume or length without the lashes sticking together. Many mention how easy it is to achieve a customized look depending on the occasion or desired effect.

Although most users appreciate the buildable formula, some find that it takes several coats to achieve the desired volume and length, which can be a bit time-consuming. A few users also mentioned that the formula can get slightly thick after a few layers, leading to a heavier feel on the lashes.

Sensitivity for Sensitive Eyes

78%

22%

The mascara is well-suited for those with sensitive eyes, offering a gentle formula that doesn’t cause irritation or discomfort. Users with allergies or easily irritated eyes report having no issues with redness or stinging, which makes it a good choice for daily wear.

Despite its claims, some users with particularly sensitive eyes mention experiencing mild irritation after long wear. This could be due to individual sensitivities or the formula’s ingredients. A few customers recommend testing it for a few days before using it regularly to see how it reacts with their eyes.

Brush Design (Precision)

72%

28%

The volumizing wand is appreciated for its ability to grab and coat the lashes evenly, especially for users looking for a fuller lash look. The brush design allows for good coverage on both upper and lower lashes, making it easy to achieve a uniform appearance.

However, some users feel that the brush design could be more precise. A few mention struggling to apply mascara to smaller or hard-to-reach lashes, such as in the corners of the eyes. Some would prefer a more tapered or thinner wand for better control and precision.

Color Intensity (Black Pigment)

90%

The intense black shade delivers rich, bold color that makes the lashes stand out dramatically. Many users enjoy how vibrant the pigment is, even after several hours of wear. The deep black hue enhances the overall eye makeup, adding definition and impact.

A few users mention that the black pigment can sometimes appear too stark for those with lighter or more subtle makeup styles. Some prefer a softer or more natural black shade, finding this one to be a bit too intense for everyday use.

Volume vs. Precision

80%

20%

For those looking for volume, this mascara delivers impressive results. The formula adds thickness to the lashes, making them appear fuller and more voluminous. Users who prioritize a bold, dramatic look are generally pleased with the outcome.

However, those seeking precision for more defined, separated lashes might be disappointed. A few users feel the product is better suited for creating volume and might not provide the level of definition they desire, particularly in the lower lashes or on smaller eyes.

Packaging & Design

85%

The sleek and sturdy packaging is highly regarded, with many users noting that the mascara feels premium in hand. The compact design makes it easy to carry around for touch-ups throughout the day. The elegant appearance adds a touch of luxury to the beauty routine.

A few users feel that the packaging could be more functional, with some reporting difficulty in retrieving every last bit of product from the tube. Others mention that the wand is slightly larger than expected, making it less convenient for on-the-go application.

Value for Money

89%

The high performance of this mascara justifies its price for many users. Given its lasting power, smudge-proof formula, and ability to enhance volume and curl, many find it to be a worthwhile investment for their makeup routines. Buyers feel that the product offers good value considering the results it provides.

Some users feel that the price is slightly higher compared to other mascaras on the market. While the performance is generally praised, a few buyers think there are other options that deliver similar results at a lower cost, making it less appealing for budget-conscious shoppers.

Ease of Application

88%

The mascara is easy to apply, with a smooth formula that glides on without tugging or pulling. Users mention that the wand is comfortable to hold, making the application process quick and efficient. The product layers nicely, ensuring no clumping, even after multiple coats.

However, some users find that the formula can get a bit thick over time, making application a bit more cumbersome after a few uses. A few mention that the mascara can take slightly longer to dry than expected, which could result in smudging if applied too heavily.

Fragrance/Scents

65%

35%

Some users appreciate that the mascara has no noticeable fragrance, making it suitable for those who are sensitive to scented products. The lack of fragrance ensures that it doesn’t irritate the eyes or cause any discomfort for sensitive individuals.

On the downside, a few users note that the lack of scent may make the product feel a bit ‘sterile’ or unappealing to those who prefer mascaras with a light, pleasant fragrance. This could be a minor drawback for those who enjoy a more sensory experience with their makeup products.

Suitable for:

This mascara is ideal for users seeking dramatic, voluminous lashes with lasting curl. Those who need a reliable, long-wearing option will appreciate the 24-hour, smudge-proof formula, which holds up well throughout busy days or in humid conditions. It's particularly suited for people with sensitive eyes who need a gentle yet effective product that doesn't irritate or cause discomfort. The buildable formula makes it versatile for different preferences, whether you're after a subtle boost or bold, full lashes. It’s also a great choice for those who want a product that can handle multiple coats without clumping, offering a customized look depending on the occasion.

Not suitable for:

This mascara may not be the best option for individuals who prioritize precision or prefer a more defined, separated lash look. Some users find the volumizing wand less effective for applying mascara to smaller or harder-to-reach areas, such as the inner corners or lower lashes. Additionally, those looking for a super light, natural finish might find the mascara too heavy or intense for daily wear. While most find it long-lasting, those with extremely sensitive eyes or allergies might experience mild irritation after extended use. People who prefer a soft, non-intense black shade may also find the deep pigment too bold for their taste.

Specifications

Type: Volumizing mascara designed to enhance the appearance of lashes.
Shade: Comes in an intense black shade for bold, dramatic lash color.
Volume: Each tube contains 0.63 oz (18 g) of product.
Wear Time: Offers up to 24 hours of smudge-proof and flake-free wear.
Smudge-Proof: Formulated to prevent smudging throughout the day.
Flake-Free: Designed to resist flaking, ensuring long-lasting wear without residue.
Curl Effect: Provides up to 3X curl to enhance the shape of lashes.
Brush Type: Features a volumizing wand designed to coat and lift lashes.
Formula: Buildable formula that allows for customized intensity without clumping.
Suitable for Sensitive Eyes: Specially formulated to be gentle on sensitive eyes, including those with contact lenses.
Application: Easy-to-use wand for precise application that adds volume and length.
Lash Health: Infused with ingredients to support healthier, stronger lashes over time.
Pigment: Delivers deep, rich black color for a bold lash look.
Clumping Resistance: Designed to provide a non-clumping finish, even with multiple layers.
Water Resistance: Water-resistant formula designed to withstand light moisture or rain.
Removal: Easily removable with a makeup remover without excessive rubbing.
All-Day Wear: Maintains volume, curl, and color without requiring touch-ups during the day.
Intended Use: Best suited for individuals looking for dramatic, voluminous lashes.

FAQ

To get the most dramatic volume and curl, start at the base of your lashes and wiggle the brush upward. For more intense results, apply multiple layers, allowing each coat to dry slightly before adding the next. The buildable formula allows you to create your desired lash effect without clumping.

Yes, this mascara is designed to be safe for sensitive eyes. Many users have reported minimal irritation, making it a great option for those with allergies or sensitivities to other mascara formulas. It is also smudge-proof and flake-free, which helps prevent discomfort during the day.

This mascara offers up to 24 hours of smudge-proof wear, ensuring that your lashes stay voluminous and curled all day long. It won't flake or smudge, even during long hours of wear, making it ideal for busy days or special events.

The Laura Mercier Caviar Extravagant Mascara provides buildable volume, length, and 3X curl for dramatic lashes. It also enhances lash health with ingredients that promote stronger lashes over time. Additionally, the smudge-proof and flake-free formula ensures long-lasting wear without discomfort.

Yes, this mascara is suitable for contact lens wearers. It is formulated to minimize irritation and is gentle enough for those who wear lenses, ensuring comfort throughout the day without flaking or smudging.

This mascara features a volumizing wand that helps coat each lash evenly while providing intense volume and curl. Some users find that it works best for lifting and separating lashes, though others may prefer a more precise applicator for a defined look.

Currently, this mascara is only available in an intense black shade, which provides bold, dramatic lash color. The deep black pigment enhances the eyes with a rich and captivating finish, perfect for creating a striking look.

No, this mascara is not waterproof, but it is water-resistant and smudge-proof for up to 24 hours. It can withstand light moisture or rain, but for swimming or heavy sweating, a waterproof formula might be more suitable.

Yes, this mascara is great for people with short or thin lashes. Its buildable formula enhances both volume and length, making lashes appear fuller and more defined. The 3X curl helps lift lashes, giving them a longer, more dramatic look.

The mascara contains ingredients designed to promote healthier and stronger lashes over time. However, excessive removal or rubbing may cause lash breakage. For the healthiest results, gently remove the mascara with an oil-free makeup remover at the end of the day.