Overview

Kiehl's Calendula Herbal Extract Alcohol-Free Toner 4.2oz is a gentle, soothing toner designed for those with normal to oily skin. This toner uses the calming powers of calendula, a botanical known for its skin-soothing properties. The formula helps to reduce redness and control excess oil, leaving the skin with a clearer, more balanced appearance. Its alcohol-free composition ensures that it won't dry out your skin, making it suitable for daily use without irritation. With a lightweight, hydrating texture, this toner enhances your skincare routine by preparing the skin for moisturizers or serums.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

The main ingredient in this toner is calendula, which has anti-inflammatory properties to calm and soothe irritated skin. Allantoin works alongside calendula to help maintain moisture and improve skin texture, while burdock root is added for its purifying and soothing effects. The alcohol-free formula ensures that users won't experience dryness or irritation, making it ideal for sensitive skin. This toner not only reduces redness and excess oil but also balances skin, leaving it feeling fresh and smooth. Its natural ingredients work harmoniously to provide a gentle yet effective skincare experience.

Best For

This toner is best suited for individuals with normal to oily skin who want a gentle yet effective skincare solution. If you're looking to reduce redness or control excess oil without drying out your skin, this product is an excellent choice. Those who prefer alcohol-free products will appreciate its non-irritating, gentle formula. Additionally, if you're looking to improve overall skin texture and maintain a balanced complexion, this toner can be a valuable addition to your routine. It works well for those with sensitive skin who seek a calming solution to everyday skin concerns.

User Feedback

Users generally praise this toner for its ability to soothe and refresh the skin without causing dryness. Many have noticed a visible improvement in skin texture and clarity after consistent use. The calming effect of calendula has been highlighted as a standout feature, especially for those with sensitive skin. On the downside, some users mention slight sensitivity to certain ingredients, though this seems to be rare. Overall, the toner is highly regarded for its non-drying, gentle formulation that effectively reduces oil and redness, making it a favorite among skincare enthusiasts.

Pros

  • Gentle formula that effectively soothes irritated skin without causing dryness.
  • Fragrance-free, making it suitable for those sensitive to scents.
  • Alcohol-free, ideal for users seeking a non-stripping toner.
  • Helps to reduce redness and inflammation, especially for those with sensitive or reactive skin.
  • Works well under makeup, providing a smooth base for application.
  • Lightweight lotion texture absorbs quickly without leaving a sticky residue.
  • Many users report clearer skin with consistent use, especially in reducing excess oil.

Cons

  • Not suitable for dry skin, as it may not provide enough hydration.
  • Some users experience irritation from calendula or other ingredients.
  • May not offer long-lasting oil control for those with very oily skin.
  • Doesn't provide a noticeable fragrance, which might be a downside for some users.
  • Results may take time, with some users not seeing immediate improvements.
  • Could feel too light for those seeking a more intensive, moisture-rich toner.
  • Not ideal for humid climates where it may feel too lightweight for oil control.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews from multiple platforms and languages, we found that Kiehl's Calendula Herbal Extract Alcohol-Free Toner 4.2oz has garnered high praise for its soothing and non-drying formula, though there are occasional mentions of sensitivity to certain ingredients. Reviews were filtered for authenticity, with spam, bot-driven, and off-topic feedback excluded. Both strengths and minor concerns are reflected in the scores, ensuring a balanced assessment of this toner’s performance across various skin types and conditions.

Effectiveness in Reducing Redness
88%
Many users note that this toner has significantly reduced redness, especially in sensitive areas of the face. The calming properties of calendula help to soothe irritation, making it a go-to for those with redness-prone skin. It's often praised for its ability to provide noticeable relief after just a few applications.
A few users mention that while the toner helps reduce redness, it doesn't always provide the fast-acting results some people expect. Some users with more severe skin issues found that the product wasn't strong enough to provide dramatic relief in all cases.
Skin Compatibility (Sensitive Skin)
91%
This toner is highly regarded for its gentle, alcohol-free formula that is particularly suited for sensitive skin. Many people with conditions like rosacea or acne have reported no irritation or breakouts. Its soothing qualities make it a top choice for individuals with delicate skin who struggle with harsher formulations.
However, a few users with very sensitive skin noted some mild irritation after prolonged use. While the toner is generally well-tolerated, it may not be suitable for those who are extremely reactive to certain natural ingredients like calendula.
Soothing & Calming Properties
93%
Users overwhelmingly agree that this toner provides a refreshing, calming sensation right after application. The blend of calendula and burdock root works effectively to reduce inflammation, making it a favorite for those with irritated or inflamed skin. The soothing properties are frequently highlighted as the main benefit.
While most users find the calming effects impressive, some feel that it doesn’t completely address all types of skin inflammation. A few individuals with more persistent skin issues mentioned that they didn’t experience the level of relief they hoped for from this toner alone.
Texture & Feel
85%
The toner has a lightweight, non-greasy texture that absorbs quickly into the skin. It's not heavy or sticky, which makes it a comfortable addition to daily skincare routines. Users appreciate how it leaves the skin feeling refreshed without any residue or unpleasant feeling.
A small number of users found the texture a bit too watery and not as moisturizing as they’d hoped. While it works well for oily skin, those with dry patches felt that it didn’t provide enough hydration on its own.
Absorption Rate
82%
18%
Many users report that the toner absorbs quickly, making it easy to layer other skincare products on top. The fast absorption rate is especially appreciated by those with busy routines or individuals who don’t want to wait around for their toner to dry before moving to the next step.
Some users mentioned that the toner could leave a slightly tacky feeling if not allowed to dry fully. A few individuals felt that it didn’t absorb as efficiently on areas with drier skin, leaving them with a somewhat sticky residue.
Oil Control & Balance
86%
The toner is often praised for its ability to balance oil production without stripping the skin. Users with oily skin appreciate its ability to control shine throughout the day without causing dryness. It's seen as an ideal product for maintaining a healthy, balanced complexion.
While it works well for many, some users with more oily skin feel that it doesn’t provide lasting oil control throughout the day. A few mentioned that they needed to reapply the toner or use additional products to maintain a matte finish.
Hydration & Moisture
79%
21%
For most users, the toner provides just enough hydration to maintain moisture balance without feeling greasy. It’s a good option for individuals who need a toner that doesn’t dry out their skin while still being effective at managing oil and reducing redness.
A few users with drier skin found that this toner wasn’t hydrating enough on its own. Those with more dehydrated skin mentioned that they needed to apply additional moisturizing products to avoid tightness after use.
Fragrance Sensitivity
92%
The fragrance-free formula makes it ideal for those who are sensitive to scents or prefer unscented skincare. Users with fragrance sensitivities or allergies have reported that this toner doesn’t irritate their skin or cause discomfort, which is a big plus.
While fragrance-free products are often well-received, some users felt that the lack of scent made the toner feel less refreshing compared to other scented options. A few mentioned that a light scent might enhance the overall experience.
Long-term Results
84%
Over time, many users have noticed improved skin texture and clarity with continued use. This toner has been credited with helping to maintain a healthy complexion, keeping redness and oil under control in the long run.
Some users felt that the toner didn’t produce as dramatic results over time as they had hoped. They reported that while it worked well in the short term, it didn’t have lasting effects without consistent use or added products.
Packaging & Dispensing
87%
The packaging is sleek and functional, with a user-friendly dispensing system that prevents wastage. The size is convenient for travel, and the bottle is easy to handle, making it ideal for daily use.
A few users mentioned that the packaging can be prone to leaks if not closed tightly. Some also felt that the bottle could be slightly larger for the price point, especially if they use it as part of their routine every day.
Value for Money
90%
Given the high-quality ingredients and the results users experience, many find this toner to be well worth the price. The alcohol-free, calming formula, combined with its ability to balance oil and reduce redness, makes it a solid investment for those seeking gentle but effective skincare.
Some users felt that the price point was a bit high compared to other toners that offer similar benefits. While the product works well for most, there are those who think it’s more expensive than necessary for the quantity provided.
Overall User Satisfaction
89%
Overall, users are very satisfied with how this toner calms irritated skin and helps balance oil production. The gentle formula makes it suitable for a wide range of skin types, and many appreciate how it improves skin texture without being drying.
A few users were disappointed by the toner’s performance on more severe skin concerns, feeling that it wasn’t strong enough to tackle deeper issues. Additionally, some had issues with its hydration levels, needing additional products for optimal results.

Suitable for:

This toner is ideal for individuals with normal to oily skin types, particularly those looking to balance oil production without stripping the skin. People seeking a gentle, alcohol-free formula for daily use will find this product particularly appealing. The calming properties of calendula make it a great choice for those with redness-prone skin or mild inflammation, offering a soothing effect after application. If you prefer fragrance-free skincare or have sensitive skin, this toner’s gentle formulation provides a good balance of hydration and oil control, making it a practical addition to your routine.

Not suitable for:

This product may not be the best fit for individuals with dry or very sensitive skin, especially those prone to extreme irritation from natural ingredients like calendula. Users with severe skin issues or those seeking a stronger, more intensive treatment may find that this toner doesn’t offer the relief they need. Additionally, people with oily skin who require long-lasting oil control throughout the day might feel that the toner’s effects are not robust enough to prevent shine or excess oil by the afternoon. Those expecting a noticeable scent or extra hydration may also find this toner lacking.

Specifications

  • Brand: Kiehl's is a trusted skincare brand known for its natural formulations and high-quality products.
  • Product Type: This is an alcohol-free toner designed for balancing and soothing skin.
  • Size: The product comes in a 4.2 oz (125 mL) bottle.
  • Skin Type: This toner is ideal for normal to oily skin types.
  • Formulation: The toner features an alcohol-free formula, making it gentle and non-drying.
  • Key Ingredients: It contains calendula, allantoin, and burdock root, which work together to soothe and purify the skin.
  • Benefits: The toner helps reduce redness, control oil, and improve skin texture without causing dryness.
  • Fragrance: The toner is fragrance-free, making it suitable for sensitive skin.
  • Texture: The toner has a lightweight lotion-like texture that absorbs easily into the skin.
  • Paraben-Free: This product is free from parabens, ensuring a cleaner formulation.
  • Non-Acnegenic: It is non-acnegenic, meaning it won't clog pores or contribute to breakouts.
  • Application Method: To use, apply with a cotton pad to your face after cleansing, avoiding the eye area.
  • pH Level: The toner has a balanced pH that supports the skin's natural protective barrier.
  • Absorption: The toner absorbs quickly into the skin without leaving a greasy or sticky residue.
  • Skin Sensitivity: While generally well-tolerated, some users with highly sensitive skin may experience mild irritation due to calendula.
  • Alcohol-Free: This toner is formulated without alcohol, which helps to avoid skin dryness and irritation.
  • Packaging: The toner comes in a plastic bottle with a secure cap for easy application.
  • Usage Frequency: It is suitable for daily use, both in the morning and at night, as part of your skincare routine.
  • Safety: This product is dermatologist-tested and safe for regular use on the face.

FAQ

After cleansing your face, apply a small amount of this toner onto a cotton pad and gently swipe it over your face. It can be used both morning and night as part of your daily skincare routine to balance oil and soothe the skin.

Yes, this toner is alcohol-free and formulated with calming ingredients like calendula, making it a good option for sensitive skin. Many users with reactive skin report it being gentle and soothing without causing irritation.

This toner contains calendula, which calms irritated skin, allantoin for moisture retention and improved texture, and burdock root for its soothing and purifying properties. These ingredients help balance oil and reduce redness while promoting healthier skin.

No, this toner is fragrance-free, making it suitable for those sensitive to scents or looking for a gentle product without added fragrances.

While this toner is primarily designed for normal to oily skin, it may not provide enough moisture for very dry skin types. It’s best for those looking to balance oil and calm irritation rather than deeply hydrate.

Many users report noticing clearer skin and reduced redness after a few weeks of regular use. However, results may vary depending on your skin type and concerns. Patience is key with most skincare products.

Store the toner in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight and heat. This helps to preserve its ingredients and maintain its effectiveness over time.

Yes, this toner is lightweight and works well as a prep step before applying makeup. It helps to balance the skin and provide a smooth base, which can enhance makeup application and longevity.

While this toner is gentle and formulated for sensitive skin, avoid direct contact with the eyes. If contact occurs, rinse thoroughly with water. Always be cautious when applying products near the eye area.

This toner’s alcohol-free formula is gentle on the skin and helps balance oil production, which can be beneficial for those with acne-prone skin. However, it may not be potent enough for treating active breakouts; for more severe acne, you may want to consider a targeted treatment.