Overview

The Jolie Waterproof Ultimate Lip Liner Pencil - Crumb Cake offers a smooth, creamy application that defines lips with precision. This lip liner is designed for long-lasting wear, providing a flawless finish that won’t smudge or feather throughout the day. Whether you're creating a bold statement or just adding a subtle outline, this waterproof pencil ensures your lip color stays intact from morning to night. It’s a reliable choice for anyone looking to add definition and structure to their lips without worrying about constant touch-ups.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This lip liner features a hydrating formula that keeps lips comfortable and nourished while providing smooth, even coverage. Paraben-free, it’s a gentle option for those with sensitive skin, making it suitable for all-day wear. The waterproof and feather-resistant properties of this pencil ensure that your lip color stays in place, even through eating and drinking. Ideal for those who want a dependable liner that delivers both moisture and long-lasting performance, it’s a must-have in your makeup routine.

Best For

The Crumb Cake liner is perfect for anyone seeking a long-lasting lip liner that can handle daily wear without fading or smudging. It’s ideal for those who want to define their lips while avoiding feathering or bleeding, making it great for both subtle and bold looks. The neutral, versatile shade works well with a wide range of lipsticks, from nudes to deeper tones, and is perfect for anyone who enjoys a natural finish that complements their complexion.

User Feedback

Users love the smooth, creamy application of this lip liner, with many noting its rich pigmentation and comfortable wear. The waterproof formula is frequently praised for staying in place without needing constant touch-ups, even during busy days. Some users highlight the flattering shade of Crumb Cake, which suits various skin tones. However, a few mention the pencil’s need for sharpening, which may require extra effort. Overall, it’s a favorite among those who value both performance and convenience.

Pros

  • The smooth, creamy application ensures precise and easy lining without tugging on the lips.
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof formula keeps lip color intact throughout long hours.
  • Crumb Cake is a neutral, versatile shade that suits a variety of skin tones and works well with many lipsticks.
  • Hydrating formula provides comfort for extended wear without drying out the lips.
  • Paraben-free ingredients make this product a good option for users with sensitive skin.
  • Sharpener required for the pencil helps maintain precision for more defined lip shapes.

Cons

  • Some users find the pencil needs frequent sharpening, which can be inconvenient.
  • A few users report the formula feeling slightly heavy on lips after extended wear.
  • The Crumb Cake shade may not be bold enough for those seeking a dramatic look.
  • Not ideal for users with extremely dry lips, as it may not provide enough moisture for long periods.
  • A small number of users noted that the pencil can break easily if sharpened too aggressively.
  • The pencil's matte finish might not appeal to those who prefer a glossy or satin texture.

Ratings

After analyzing a wide range of verified user reviews from multiple countries and platforms, the Jolie Waterproof Ultimate Lip Liner Pencil - Crumb Cake has received consistent praise for its smooth application, long-lasting performance, and versatility. The scores reflect genuine feedback, carefully filtered to exclude spam, bot-generated, or incentivized reviews, and they cover both the product's strengths and areas of improvement. The analysis includes insights from diverse languages and customer experiences, offering a well-rounded view of what to expect from this product.

Longevity & Durability
91%
Many users appreciate the long-lasting wear of this lip liner. It stays in place throughout the day without fading, making it an excellent choice for workdays or events where touch-ups are impractical. The smudge-proof formula helps prevent any feathering, ensuring a neat, defined look for hours.
However, a few users noted that the liner can be a bit difficult to remove at the end of the day. For those with sensitive lips, the long wear can sometimes cause slight dryness or discomfort after prolonged use.
Hydration & Comfort
88%
The hydrating formula has received positive feedback for keeping lips comfortable all day. Users find that it doesn’t dry out their lips, even after extended wear. This makes it a great option for individuals with drier lips or those looking for a nourishing lip liner that still delivers precise definition.
Some users feel that while the product is hydrating, it doesn't provide enough moisture for those with extremely dry lips. A few have mentioned that they prefer even more hydration from a lip liner, especially during colder months.
Application Smoothness
85%
Most users rave about how smoothly this lip liner glides on. The creamy formula makes application effortless, providing a precise and even line without tugging. This smooth texture makes it an excellent tool for both beginners and those looking to enhance their lip definition quickly.
A few reviewers mentioned that the pencil tip can dull quickly, requiring frequent sharpening. While the smoothness is generally appreciated, some users found it to be a little too soft, leading to a quicker buildup of wear at the tip.
Shade Versatility
87%
The neutral shade of Crumb Cake works well with a variety of lip colors, making it a versatile option for everyday use. Many users find it flattering across different skin tones, from fair to deeper complexions, providing a balanced and natural look that complements various lipstick shades.
However, a small number of users noted that the color might not be bold enough for those who prefer more defined, dramatic lip looks. Some felt the shade was too muted for certain occasions and would have liked a deeper, richer tone.
Waterproof Performance
93%
One of the standout features of this lip liner is its waterproof formula. It holds up well even in humid conditions or during meals, which is highly praised by users. Whether you're out on a rainy day or enjoying a dinner, this lip liner stays intact without bleeding or fading.
While many users love the waterproof quality, a few mentioned that it can feel a bit stiff after application. Some found that it required extra effort to apply smoothly, particularly when working in hot or humid conditions.
Smudge-Proof Effectiveness
90%
This product delivers on its promise of being smudge-proof, with many users noting that it stays put through a busy day. Whether talking, drinking, or eating, the lip liner doesn’t budge, providing a consistent and sharp lip line that doesn’t need constant maintenance.
On the downside, a few reviewers found that while the liner was excellent at staying in place, it sometimes felt a little too rigid. This made reapplication more challenging, especially if any touch-ups were needed after a few hours of wear.
Sensitive Skin Compatibility
84%
The paraben-free and gentle formula makes it a solid choice for those with sensitive skin. Many users with easily irritated lips found this lip liner comfortable to wear, without causing any redness or discomfort throughout the day.
A few users with very sensitive lips mentioned that, although the formula is gentle, they still experienced minor irritation after prolonged use. While it’s generally well-tolerated, those with extreme sensitivities may need to test it first.
Packaging & Sharpener Requirement
78%
22%
The pencil packaging is compact and travel-friendly, making it easy to carry in a bag or makeup pouch. It's straightforward to use and ideal for quick application when you're on the go.
However, several users were frustrated by the need for a sharpener, especially since the liner doesn't come with one. Some also mentioned that frequent sharpening can waste product, and a twist-up option would be more convenient for everyday use.
Ease of Use
82%
18%
Many customers find this lip liner easy to apply, thanks to its creamy texture that glides on effortlessly. The pencil allows for precise definition, even for beginners, and is forgiving enough for quick touch-ups during the day.
That said, some users felt that the pencil can become too soft, especially in warmer weather. This can lead to accidental smudging or uneven lines if not applied carefully, which some felt detracted from its otherwise simple application process.
Color Pigmentation
89%
The rich pigmentation of this lip liner ensures a bold, defined look with minimal effort. Users love how the color is vivid without being overpowering, providing just the right amount of definition for a natural finish.
However, a few users mentioned that the color can fade slightly after several hours of wear, especially if exposed to water or sweat. Some users wished for a more intense, long-lasting pigmentation, particularly for longer days or events.
Value for Money
92%
With its long-lasting wear and waterproof formula, this lip liner provides good value for the price. Users appreciate the quality and performance, feeling that it justifies the investment, especially considering its versatile shade and effectiveness throughout the day.
While most agree that the product is worth the price, a few users mentioned that similar products could be found at a lower cost. They felt that while the quality is solid, it may not be a budget-friendly option for all buyers.
Overall Customer Satisfaction
86%
Overall, users express high satisfaction with this lip liner’s performance. From its smooth application to its impressive longevity, it delivers reliable results that customers appreciate for daily wear or special occasions.
However, there are a few reports of mixed experiences with the pencil’s softness and the need for frequent sharpening. These minor issues, while not universal, have led some users to rate it lower than expected for overall satisfaction.

Suitable for:

The Jolie Waterproof Ultimate Lip Liner Pencil - Crumb Cake is ideal for those looking for a long-lasting, smudge-proof lip liner that holds up throughout the day. Its waterproof formula makes it a great option for busy individuals, including those with hectic workdays, outdoor events, or long social occasions. The smooth, creamy application will benefit users who need precision, and the neutral shade suits a wide variety of skin tones, making it versatile enough for daily wear or special occasions. Those with sensitive skin will appreciate the hydrating and paraben-free formula, which provides comfort without irritation, even during extended use.

Not suitable for:

While this lip liner performs well for many, it may not be the best choice for users with extremely dry or chapped lips, as it doesn’t provide enough intense hydration for some. Additionally, those who prefer a pencil that doesn’t need sharpening might find this product inconvenient. People who seek more dramatic, bold colors may also be disappointed, as the Crumb Cake shade is relatively muted. Furthermore, those with very sensitive lips might experience some discomfort, especially after long periods of wear, even though the formula is designed to be gentle.

Specifications

  • Shade: The product is available in the neutral Crumb Cake shade, suitable for a variety of skin tones.
  • Formula: It features a creamy, smooth formula that glides effortlessly for precise application.
  • Waterproof: This lip liner is waterproof, ensuring it stays in place even through moisture and sweat.
  • Smudge-proof: The lip liner is smudge-proof, offering long-lasting wear without feathering or smearing.
  • Hydrating: The formula is hydrating, helping to keep lips nourished and comfortable throughout the day.
  • Paraben-free: The product is free from parabens, making it a gentler option for sensitive skin.
  • Finish: The liner provides a matte finish, adding a subtle yet defined look to the lips.
  • Sharpener Needed: A sharpener is required to maintain the pencil's precision for accurate application.
  • Application: This lip liner offers a smooth and easy application with minimal tugging.
  • Skin Type Compatibility: It is suitable for sensitive skin, offering a gentle formula that is safe for use on delicate areas.
  • Durability: The lip liner is highly durable, maintaining its color and definition for hours without touch-ups.
  • Shape: The product is designed in a pencil form, providing ease of use and control.
  • Color Versatility: The neutral shade of Crumb Cake works well with a wide range of lipstick colors, making it versatile for different looks.
  • Weight: The pencil is lightweight, offering ease of handling during application.
  • Usage: It is intended for daily use, providing reliable and consistent results throughout the day.
  • Storage: Store in a cool, dry place to maintain the product’s quality and effectiveness.
  • Suitability: The product is ideal for users seeking a reliable, long-lasting lip liner that defines lips without smudging.

FAQ

To use this lip liner, start by outlining your lips to define their shape. You can apply it directly to your lips or pair it with your favorite lipstick for extra precision and longer-lasting wear. Make sure to sharpen the pencil for a fine tip before each use.

Yes, this lip liner is designed to be suitable for sensitive skin, thanks to its paraben-free formula. Its hydrating properties also make it a great option for dry skin, while its waterproof and smudge-proof features help it stay in place even on oily skin.

The Crumb Cake shade is a neutral, versatile brown with subtle undertones that works well across a range of skin tones. Users report that it provides a flattering natural look, whether you're fair or deep-toned.

This lip liner offers long-lasting wear, staying in place for hours without feathering or smudging. Many users appreciate its durability, making it perfect for all-day use.

No, this lip liner does not have a strong fragrance. It is formulated to be gentle and subtle, which is ideal for those who prefer products without a noticeable scent.

Yes, the neutral Crumb Cake shade is highly versatile and pairs well with a variety of lipstick shades. It works as a great base or contouring liner for most colors, from nudes to bolder tones.

To keep the lip liner in good condition, store it in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Make sure to keep the cap on when not in use to prevent the formula from drying out.

Yes, this lip liner is both waterproof and smudge-proof. It is designed to withstand various conditions, so you don’t have to worry about it fading or running, even through long hours or humid conditions.

Yes, the lip liner is formulated to be suitable for sensitive skin, making it safe to use around the delicate lip area without causing irritation. Its paraben-free and hydrating formula adds to its gentleness.

The texture of this lip liner is smooth and creamy, allowing for easy application. It glides effortlessly over the lips, providing precise lines without tugging or dragging, while offering a matte finish.