Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz

Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz — image 1
Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz — image 2
Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz — image 3
Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz — image 4
Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz — image 5
Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz — image 6
Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz — image 7
Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz — image 8
81%
19%
88%
Skin Soothing & Aftercare
84%
Moisturizing Effect
79%
Fragrance Quality
71%
Scent Longevity
93%
Value for Money
82%
Spray Mechanism
67%
Scent Projection
81%
Skin Disinfection
76%
Bottle & Packaging
89%
Ease of Application
77%
Scent Complexity
74%
Skin Compatibility
83%
Brand Credibility
86%
Daily Use Practicality
More

Overview

The Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz is a dual-purpose grooming product sitting at the intersection of skin care and fragrance — doing both jobs without pretending to be a luxury designer cologne. Immortal NYC built its reputation inside barbershops, and that heritage shows in how this barber-grade formula is constructed: treat your face after a shave first, scent you second. The oriental floral profile opens with something fruity and light, settles into cedar-woody territory, then dries down to warm amber and musk. At 500ml, the bottle is unusually large for this category — most aftershave sprays top out at 100–200ml — which explains a lot of its appeal.

Features & Benefits

What makes the Reserve 01 worth reaching for daily isn't the scent alone — it's the skin-soothing function working underneath it. The formula disinfects freshly shaved skin, calms irritation, and adds a layer of moisture that doesn't leave behind any greasy residue. That's harder to find than it sounds. The spray mechanism delivers an even mist across your face and neck without the mess of splash-on applications. Fragrance-wise, the oriental floral scent has real depth — it doesn't smell flat or one-dimensional. And because the bottle holds 500ml, you're not rationing sprays every morning. Daily shavers especially benefit from a bottle this size.

Best For

This aftershave spray is an easy recommendation for men who shave regularly and want one product covering post-shave skin care and a presentable scent in the same step. It's also a smart pick if you're moving away from high-end options and want something that genuinely performs without costing a fortune. The oriental floral character — warmer and more complex than a typical aquatic or citrus — suits men who lean toward rich, mature scents. It also works as a gift: the bottle looks substantial, and a 500ml bottle reads as generous and practical rather than fussy. Men with sensitive post-shave skin get particular value from the moisturizing and calming properties.

User Feedback

Buyers consistently praise the scent longevity for an Eau de Cologne concentration — most say it carries for 3–4 hours, which is solid for this category. The skin feel post-application gets frequent mentions too: less sting and residue than classic alcohol-heavy barbershop splashes. On the critical side, a handful of users note that the fragrance intensity feels subtle at first spray, so those expecting bold projection may need a couple of extra spritzes. A small number of users with particularly reactive skin flagged mild irritation, though most sensitive-skin buyers reported no issues. Overall, ratings sit high, and repeat purchases suggest the bottle size and value-to-quality ratio keep people coming back.

#Cologne
#Men's
#Fragrance
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • The 500ml bottle is unusually large for this category, reducing how often you need to repurchase.
  • Moisturizing formula leaves skin feeling soft and refreshed rather than tight or dry after shaving.
  • Disinfects post-shave skin without the harsh alcohol sting associated with classic barbershop splashes.
  • Barber-grade credentials give the formula a credibility that generic drugstore options lack.
  • The oriental floral scent has real depth — fruity and floral upfront, warm amber and musk on dry-down.
  • Spray applicator delivers even coverage across face and neck without over-applying.
  • Works on both face and body, adding flexibility beyond just post-shave use.
  • Sits at a mid-range price point that makes the large volume feel like genuine value.
  • Scent carries well for an Eau de Cologne, with buyers reporting 3–4 hours of presence.
  • Strong repeat purchase rate suggests buyers are satisfied enough to come back for a second bottle.

Cons

  • Scent intensity can feel subtle at first spray, requiring extra spritzes for stronger projection.
  • Oriental floral character is polarizing — men who dislike warm or floral notes will not enjoy this.
  • Eau de Cologne concentration means fragrance fades faster than a proper Eau de Parfum would.
  • The 17oz bottle is bulky and impractical for travel bags or gym kits.
  • Not a substitute for a dedicated cologne if you need evening or event-level scent performance.
  • A small number of buyers with very reactive skin have reported mild irritation after use.
  • Scent profile may read as unfamiliar or unexpected to buyers accustomed to classic barbershop or fresh aquatic aftershaves.
  • Limited variant options — if Reserve 01 fragrance doesn't suit you, there's no easy alternative in the same line to pivot to.

Ratings

Our AI-generated scores for the Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz are built by analyzing thousands of verified global buyer reviews, with spam, bot-driven, and incentivized feedback actively filtered out before scoring. Every category below reflects the full picture — what real users genuinely praised and where they ran into friction. Nothing is glossed over to make the product look better than it is.

Skin Soothing & Aftercare
88%
Buyers who switched from traditional high-alcohol splashes consistently report less post-shave sting and redness when using this barber-grade formula. Men with mild sensitivity say their skin feels calm and conditioned within minutes of applying, which is the core job this product is built to do.
A small but recurring group of buyers with very reactive or acne-prone skin reported mild irritation after use, suggesting the formula doesn't work universally for all skin types. It's not a common complaint, but it's frequent enough to warrant a patch test before committing to daily use.
Moisturizing Effect
84%
The moisturizing performance genuinely surprised many buyers who expected a typical dry, astringent aftershave finish. Daily shavers in particular note that their skin feels noticeably softer throughout the morning compared to competing products at similar price points.
The hydration level, while solid for an aftershave spray, doesn't replace a dedicated moisturizer for men with chronically dry skin. In colder or drier climates, some buyers mention still needing to layer a separate moisturizer on top for adequate protection.
Fragrance Quality
79%
21%
The oriental floral scent — warm, woody, and mildly ambery — reads as genuinely complex for a product in this price bracket. Buyers who enjoy rich, barbershop-adjacent scents describe it as sophisticated without being overpowering at initial application.
Scent is inherently subjective, and this particular profile draws polarized reactions. Buyers who lean toward fresh, aquatic, or citrus fragrances frequently find the warm floral character off-putting, which is one of the more common sources of dissatisfaction in the reviews.
Scent Longevity
71%
29%
For an Eau de Cologne concentration, the Reserve 01 holds up reasonably well — most buyers report a noticeable presence for 3 to 4 hours, which comfortably covers a morning commute or office shift. That's a better-than-average result for this concentration level.
Anyone expecting all-day projection will be disappointed. By mid-afternoon the scent has typically faded significantly, and buyers who need fragrance to carry through evening events find themselves reaching for a separate cologne. This is a structural limitation of Eau de Cologne, not a defect.
Value for Money
93%
The 500ml volume is the single biggest value driver here — most competing aftershave sprays deliver 100ml to 200ml for comparable or higher prices. Daily shavers who went through smaller bottles in weeks report that this aftershave spray lasts months, dramatically lowering their per-use cost.
The value equation depends heavily on loving the scent. Buyers who disliked the oriental floral profile felt stuck with a large bottle they couldn't use, which effectively inverted the value proposition. Sampling the scent before buying a full 500ml is worth doing if possible.
Spray Mechanism
82%
18%
The spray nozzle delivers a fine, even mist that distributes the product cleanly across the face and neck without drenching the skin. Buyers coming from splash-on bottles consistently appreciate the control, noting it makes it easier to avoid over-applying.
A handful of buyers reported the nozzle becoming inconsistent or losing pressure over time, though this doesn't appear to be a widespread manufacturing issue. No significant reports of leaking during storage, but storing the bottle upright is advisable as a precaution.
Scent Projection
67%
33%
At close range — immediately after application and for the first hour or two — the Reserve 01 projects noticeably and pleasantly. Coworkers and partners in immediate proximity tend to pick it up, which is enough for most casual daily-use scenarios.
Projection beyond arm's length fades quickly, and by the second hour the sillage is minimal. Buyers who associate a good aftershave with a commanding fragrance trail will find this underwhelming, particularly if they're used to stronger Eau de Toilette or Eau de Parfum formulations.
Skin Disinfection
81%
19%
Post-shave disinfection is one of the more practically important functions of any aftershave, and buyers report this formula handles cuts and razor irritation effectively without the excessive burn associated with heavily alcoholic alternatives. Barbershop professionals using it on clients reinforce this feedback.
The formula doesn't specify its active disinfecting agents prominently, which makes it harder for ingredient-conscious buyers to evaluate. Those who specifically need a medically validated antiseptic for skin conditions may want to consult a dermatologist before relying solely on this product.
Bottle & Packaging
76%
24%
The tall, narrow bottle looks clean and intentional on a bathroom counter or grooming shelf. The size communicates generosity rather than cheapness, and gift buyers note that it photographs and presents well when wrapped.
The 9.13-inch height makes it awkward to store in smaller medicine cabinets or travel bags. For men with compact bathroom storage, the physical footprint of a 17oz bottle is a genuine daily inconvenience rather than a minor issue.
Ease of Application
89%
Spray-on application is faster and less messy than traditional splash-on aftershaves, and buyers new to this format adapt to it instantly. The bottle requires no special technique — a couple of spritzes to the palm or directly to the face is all it takes.
Because the bottle is large and somewhat heavy when full, fine motor control of the spray angle can be slightly cumbersome for some users. This is a minor ergonomic issue that most buyers adapt to quickly, but it's worth noting for anyone used to smaller, lighter bottles.
Scent Complexity
77%
23%
The layered fragrance structure — fruity opening, floral-woody heart, ambery musky base — gives the Reserve 01 more character than single-note or generic barbershop aftershaves. Fragrance-literate buyers specifically call out the dry-down as the most impressive part of the scent journey.
Buyers who aren't already familiar with oriental or structured fragrances sometimes describe the scent as confusing or inconsistent rather than layered. The complexity that earns praise from one group reads as unpredictability to another, depending on their fragrance background.
Skin Compatibility
74%
26%
The moisturizing formula works well for normal-to-dry skin types, and the majority of buyers across a wide range of skin tones and types report no adverse reactions even with daily use. The reduced-sting experience compared to classic aftershaves is a consistent highlight.
Buyers with oily or combination skin occasionally report a slightly heavier feel that doesn't suit their skin type as well. Those with known fragrance sensitivities should also approach with caution, as the oriental floral profile contains ingredients that can trigger reactions in predisposed individuals.
Brand Credibility
83%
Immortal NYC's barbershop roots give the formula a professional-use credibility that purely retail-facing grooming brands often lack. Buyers who have encountered the brand in actual barber shops tend to trust the product more and report higher satisfaction overall.
Outside major urban markets, Immortal NYC remains relatively niche and lesser-known, which creates hesitation for first-time buyers who can't easily verify the brand's reputation through local retailers. Online-only availability means there's no easy way to test before purchasing.
Daily Use Practicality
86%
For men with an established daily shaving routine, integrating this aftershave spray is straightforward — it replaces rather than adds to existing steps. The large volume means weeks or months pass before you need to think about repurchasing, reducing routine disruption.
The bottle's size, while excellent for value, is less practical for men who travel frequently for work or keep a separate gym or travel grooming kit. Decanting into a smaller travel bottle is an extra step that some buyers find annoying relative to just buying a smaller product.

Suitable for:

The Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz is a strong fit for men who shave regularly — daily or near-daily — and want a single grooming step that handles both skin recovery and a presentable scent. If you've been frustrated by aftershaves that leave your face feeling tight, dry, or irritated, the moisturizing and disinfecting formula here directly addresses that. It's also a practical choice for anyone tired of paying premium prices for small 100ml bottles that run out in weeks; the 500ml size changes the math considerably for budget-conscious buyers. Men who gravitate toward warm, complex scents — think oriental and floral with woody and ambery depth — will find the fragrance fits their taste without needing a separate cologne on top. Gift buyers will appreciate that the bottle looks and feels substantial, making it easy to give without it seeming like an afterthought.

Not suitable for:

The Immortal NYC Reserve 01 Aftershave Spray 17oz is not the right call for men who primarily want a bold, long-lasting fragrance to carry them through a full day or evening. At Eau de Cologne concentration, the scent is real and pleasant, but it's not engineered to project or linger for hours the way an Eau de Parfum would. If your grooming routine already separates aftershave function from fragrance — meaning you use a dedicated cologne regardless — you may not need or want this dual-purpose positioning. Men who strongly prefer fresh, citrus-forward, or aquatic scent profiles will likely find the oriental floral character too warm or heavy for their taste. And if you travel frequently and need compact, airline-friendly sizing, a 17oz bottle is going to create obvious practical problems.

Specifications

  • Brand: Manufactured by Immortal NYC, a grooming brand with roots in professional barbershop culture.
  • Product Type: Aftershave spray formulated for post-shave skin care with an integrated fragrance.
  • Volume: Each bottle contains 500ml (17oz) of product, which is significantly larger than most aftershave sprays on the market.
  • Concentration: Fragrance is delivered at Eau de Cologne concentration, offering lighter projection than Eau de Parfum or Eau de Toilette formulations.
  • Scent Family: Classified as Oriental Floral, a warm and complex fragrance family combining floral, woody, and ambery characteristics.
  • Top Notes: Opening notes are fruity and floral, providing an initial impression that is light and slightly sweet.
  • Middle Notes: The heart of the fragrance combines floral and woody elements, adding structure and masculinity to the scent.
  • Base Notes: Dry-down notes are ambery and musky, giving the fragrance its lasting warmth on the skin.
  • Application: Product is dispensed via a spray mechanism, allowing even and controlled distribution across the face and neck.
  • Skin Benefits: Formula is designed to soften, disinfect, moisturize, and refresh skin immediately after shaving.
  • Suitable Areas: Intended for use on both the face and body, not restricted to facial application only.
  • Dimensions: The bottle measures 9.13 x 2.4 x 2.36 inches, making it a tall, narrow package suited to countertop storage.
  • Weight: Packaged product weighs 1.1 pounds, which is typical for a filled 500ml glass or heavy plastic spray bottle.
  • Target User: Formulated specifically for men engaged in regular shaving routines who want post-shave care and light fragrance in one step.
  • BSR Ranking: Holds a Best Sellers Rank of #58 in Men's Cologne on Amazon, indicating strong and consistent consumer demand.

Related Reviews

Immortal NYC Reserve 02 Cologne Spray 500ml
Immortal NYC Reserve 02 Cologne Spray 500ml
78%
83%
Scent Quality
61%
Scent Longevity
58%
Sillage & Projection
79%
Post-Shave Performance
88%
Value for Money
More
Immortal NYC Reserve 05 After Shave Spray Cologne 17oz
Immortal NYC Reserve 05 After Shave Spray Cologne 17oz
83%
89%
Fragrance Longevity
85%
Scent Appeal
80%
Skin Hydration
92%
Ease of Application
87%
Value for Money
More
Immortal NYC Stay Blessed 02 After Shave Spray Body/Face Men's Cologne 17 oz
Immortal NYC Stay Blessed 02 After Shave Spray Body/Face Men's Cologne 17 oz
85%
88%
Scent Quality
85%
Skin Moisturization
80%
Fragrance Longevity
84%
Post-Shave Irritation Relief
91%
Packaging & Dispenser
More
Sahag Air Lift Volumizing Spray 17oz
Sahag Air Lift Volumizing Spray 17oz
87%
92%
Effectiveness for Volume
89%
Humidity and Frizz Control
85%
Hold Quality (Non-Stiff)
87%
Ease of Application
80%
Scent (Floral Fragrance)
More
Immortal NYC Strawberry Hair Wax 5oz
Immortal NYC Strawberry Hair Wax 5oz
77%
83%
Hold Strength
91%
Shine & Finish
93%
Washout & Cleanliness
74%
Fragrance
86%
Value for Money
More
Swiss Army Altitude Aftershave Spray 3.4oz
Swiss Army Altitude Aftershave Spray 3.4oz
86%
88%
Fragrance Quality
85%
Longevity of Scent
92%
Skin Compatibility (Post-Shave)
81%
Scent Balance (Cedar & Coriander)
90%
Ease of Application
More
Immortal NYC Captain Black Hair Wax 5.07oz
Immortal NYC Captain Black Hair Wax 5.07oz
88%
88%
Hold Strength
91%
Shine and Finish
95%
Water Solubility (Ease of Washout)
85%
Scent
87%
Texture and Feel
More
Perry Ellis Reserve Eau De Toilette Spray 3.4oz
Perry Ellis Reserve Eau De Toilette Spray 3.4oz
86%
94%
Scent Appeal
82%
Longevity
78%
Projection/Sillage
88%
Versatility
85%
Bottle Design & Usability
More
SJP NYC by Sarah Jessica Parker EDP Spray 3.4oz
SJP NYC by Sarah Jessica Parker EDP Spray 3.4oz
83%
88%
Scent Complexity & Appeal
82%
Longevity & Wear Duration
80%
Day-to-Night Versatility
76%
Sillage & Projection
72%
Initial Fragrance Strength
More
Perry Ellis Reserve Eau De Parfum Spray for Women 100mL
Perry Ellis Reserve Eau De Parfum Spray for Women 100mL
90%
95%
Fragrance Longevity
91%
Scent Complexity
88%
Bottle Design
90%
Ease of Application
87%
Top Notes Appeal
More

FAQ

It genuinely functions as an aftershave first. The formula disinfects freshly shaved skin, reduces irritation, and adds moisture — it's not just scented water. The fragrance is a secondary benefit built into a formula that's designed to calm and condition post-shave skin.

At Eau de Cologne concentration, most buyers report the scent staying noticeable for roughly 3 to 4 hours. It won't carry through a full day the way a stronger Eau de Parfum would, so if you need all-day projection, you'd want a separate cologne on top.

The majority of buyers with sensitive skin report a positive experience, noting far less sting and irritation compared to traditional high-alcohol aftershaves. That said, a small number of users with very reactive skin did report mild irritation, so if your skin is particularly sensitive, a patch test on your arm first is a sensible precaution.

Think of it as warm and slightly sophisticated rather than sporty or fresh. It opens with something fruity and light, then settles into a woodier, richer territory, and finishes with a soft amber warmth on the skin. It's closer in character to a barbershop-style cologne than a fresh aquatic or citrus fragrance.

For casual, everyday use it works fine on its own — the scent is pleasant and presentable. But if you need stronger projection for evenings or formal occasions, the Eau de Cologne concentration means it will fade faster than a dedicated cologne, so layering with a longer-lasting fragrance would make sense in those situations.

500ml is genuinely unusual for this product category. Most aftershave sprays come in 100ml to 200ml bottles, so this barber-grade formula gives you roughly 2.5 to 5 times the volume at a price that doesn't scale proportionally. For daily shavers, that translates to months of use before needing a replacement.

Buyers consistently report that the formula absorbs cleanly without leaving behind any tacky or oily feeling. The moisturizing effect is there, but it's more of a soft, conditioned skin feel than a heavy lotion-like residue.

No widespread reports of clogging or leaking appear in buyer feedback. The spray mechanism delivers a consistent fine mist. To keep it performing well, store the bottle upright and recap it if it comes with a protective cover.

It's actually a solid gift choice precisely because it's not intimidating to use — spray it on after shaving, done. The large bottle looks substantial and generous when unwrapped, and the scent is approachable enough for someone who isn't a fragrance enthusiast. Just keep in mind that the oriental floral scent profile may not suit everyone's taste.

The formula itself — the skin-soothing and moisturizing ingredients — has no reason it couldn't be used by anyone. The scent is positioned as masculine, leaning warm and woody-floral, but fragrance preference is personal. It's marketed toward men's grooming routines, so that's the intended context, but the formula has no ingredient that limits it by gender.