ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner - Dusk Brown

86%

Application Smoothness

Longevity and Smudge Resistance

Formula Cleanliness

Precision and Sharpness

Water Resistance

Shade Versatility

Comfort for Sensitive Eyes

Vegan and Cruelty-Free Attributes

Packaging and Sharpener Function

Value for Money

Ease of Blending

User Experience (General)

Frequent Sharpening Requirement

Overview

The ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner – Dusk Brown is a highly pigmented, water-resistant eyeliner that promises precision with every application. This liner features a soft, flexible tip that glides effortlessly along the lash line, making it perfect for both bold and smoky eye looks. Whether you're going for a sharp, defined line or a smudged, sultry effect, this eyeliner offers versatility. Convenience is key, with a built-in sharpener that ensures the perfect point every time. The creamy gel formula stays put, offering smudge-proof, long-lasting wear throughout the day.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

Formulated without harsh chemicals like carbon black and cyclomethicone, this ILIA gel liner is a clean, non-toxic option for those looking to reduce their exposure to synthetic ingredients. It's vegan, cruelty-free, and ophthalmologist-tested, making it safe for even the most sensitive eyes. The highly pigmented formula delivers bold color that resists smudging and fading, while its water-resistant properties ensure all-day wear without the need for constant touch-ups. This eyeliner is perfect for users who demand both clean beauty and reliable performance.

Best For

This eyeliner is best for anyone seeking a versatile, long-wearing liner that can create both defined and smoky eye looks. It’s ideal for individuals who prioritize clean, cruelty-free beauty products, as well as those with sensitive eyes. The ophthalmologist-tested formula makes it safe for contact lens wearers or those prone to irritation. If you're after an eyeliner that combines precision with the ability to easily blend out for a softer, more dramatic effect, this liner will be a great addition to your makeup routine.

User Feedback

Users generally love how easily this ILIA gel liner glides on, especially when achieving a smoky eye look. The long-lasting, water-resistant formula is highly praised for keeping the liner intact all day, even during humid weather or after a long day of wear. However, some users mention that the liner requires sharpening more frequently than other pencils, which can be a minor inconvenience. Still, most appreciate the sharp, precise application it offers, making it a reliable tool for both subtle and bold eye looks.

#Eyeliner

#Eyes

#Makeup

#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

This eyeliner provides a smooth application with a soft tip that glides effortlessly along the lash line.
The built-in sharpener ensures precise application every time, making it easy to maintain a sharp point.
Its water-resistant and smudge-proof formula lasts all day without fading or smearing.
Perfect for users with sensitive eyes, as the formula is ophthalmologist-tested and gentle on the skin.
Ideal for both defined and smudged eye looks, offering versatility for various makeup styles.
The vegan and cruelty-free formulation appeals to those who prefer clean beauty products.

Cons

Some users report that the eyeliner needs frequent sharpening to maintain precision.
The color may not be bold enough for users looking for a darker or more intense shade.
This product may not work well for those with very oily eyelids, as it tends to fade after long wear.
A few users mentioned the eyeliner smudges when exposed to excessive moisture or humidity.
Not everyone appreciates the soft tip, as some prefer a firmer pencil for more control.
Those expecting a long-lasting finish in humid conditions may find it less effective under such circumstances.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews worldwide from multiple platforms and languages, the ratings for the ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner – Dusk Brown reflect genuine feedback, excluding spam, bot-generated, and incentivized reviews. The scores incorporate both strengths and pain points, providing a balanced overview of this product’s performance across various user experiences. Consumers appreciate its clean, vegan formula and the precision it offers, though some note minor drawbacks such as frequent sharpening. These insights come from diverse global sources, ensuring a comprehensive evaluation of its quality and effectiveness.

Application Smoothness

92%

Many users praise the smooth application of this liner, with its soft tip that glides effortlessly across the lash line. It’s ideal for both defined lines and a more smudged, smoky look. This ease of use makes it a go-to choice for both beginners and experienced makeup users alike.

However, a few users mention that the product may drag slightly on certain skin types, especially for those with drier eyelids. Despite being smooth initially, some find it a bit stiff when applied to sensitive areas or in colder weather.

Longevity and Smudge Resistance

88%

This eyeliner is highly praised for its long-lasting formula. Most users report that it stays put throughout the day without smudging or fading, making it perfect for busy workdays or long events. The water-resistant quality ensures it holds up even in humid conditions or light tears.

On the downside, a few buyers noted that while it lasts well, it may require touch-ups for those with particularly oily skin. Some also mention it can fade a little around the outer corners by the end of the day, especially in more humid environments.

Formula Cleanliness

94%

The clean, non-toxic formula is a major selling point for many buyers. Users appreciate the fact that it’s free from harmful chemicals like carbon black and cyclomethicone, making it a safer option for those concerned about ingredients. This makes it a great choice for conscious beauty consumers.

However, a small number of users express disappointment with the pigmentation of other shades in the same product line, suggesting that the cleaner formula might not provide the same bold intensity as traditional liners. While the Dusk Brown shade performs well, some still prefer more saturated colors.

Precision and Sharpness

85%

The built-in sharpener is a standout feature, allowing users to maintain a fine, precise tip for detailed application. This feature makes it easier to create sharp lines or smudged looks without the need for a separate tool, adding convenience to the experience.

Some users do find the sharpening process a bit inconvenient. A few mention that it may need sharpening more often than other liners, which can be annoying for those who prefer a lower-maintenance product. Additionally, some reported that the sharpener doesn’t always create a perfectly fine tip.

Water Resistance

90%

Many users highlight the impressive water resistance, which allows this eyeliner to hold up under various conditions. Whether it's rainy weather or sweat from an active day, it doesn’t budge easily, making it ideal for those who need reliable, smudge-proof makeup.

While generally water-resistant, some users report that it can smudge a bit if exposed to excessive water or rubbing. It’s also worth noting that removal can be slightly difficult due to its strong staying power, requiring a more thorough cleansing routine.

Shade Versatility

80%

20%

The Dusk Brown shade is well-received for its rich, versatile tone that works for both daytime and evening looks. Many users appreciate that it complements a wide range of eye colors and can be worn both as a bold liner or blended for a softer finish.

However, some users feel that the available shades in this product line aren’t as versatile as they’d like. While Dusk Brown is a favorite, those who prefer brighter or more vibrant colors may be disappointed by the limited options in the collection.

Comfort for Sensitive Eyes

93%

Several buyers with sensitive eyes rave about the formula’s gentle nature. The product is ophthalmologist-tested, making it suitable for people prone to irritation, and many find it soothing on their eyes, even after hours of wear.

A few sensitive users still report slight irritation after extended wear, particularly if the liner comes into contact with the waterline. While the product is generally well-tolerated, those with highly sensitive skin might find occasional discomfort, especially in hotter climates.

Vegan and Cruelty-Free Attributes

95%

The vegan and cruelty-free certification is a big win for eco-conscious users. Many appreciate that this eyeliner aligns with their ethical standards, making it an appealing choice for those who prioritize animal welfare and sustainable beauty options.

While most users support the ethical formulation, a small group of individuals still prefer more affordable options. Some may feel the higher price tag for a cruelty-free product isn’t justified, particularly when considering other budget-friendly alternatives.

Packaging and Sharpener Function

78%

22%

The compact packaging, combined with the built-in sharpener, makes the product easy to carry and use on the go. Users appreciate the convenience of not needing extra tools for a precise application, which adds to the overall value of the product.

Despite the convenience, the sharpener doesn’t always perform optimally, with some users reporting that it can be tricky to sharpen the liner to a fine point. Additionally, the packaging design, while functional, may not feel as luxurious as other premium makeup products.

Value for Money

87%

For many, the product offers solid value due to its clean ingredients, long-lasting formula, and reliable performance. The inclusion of a sharpener also adds convenience, making the overall cost feel more justified for users who want a quality eyeliner.

However, some users feel the price point is slightly high for the amount of product provided. While the liner performs well, those on a tighter budget might seek more affordable alternatives, especially since it requires regular sharpening.

Ease of Blending

86%

Users appreciate how easily this eyeliner blends, especially for creating a smoky eye look. Its creamy texture allows for smooth blending without tugging, making it a popular choice for those who like to experiment with different eye makeup styles.

While most users find it blends well, a few mention that it can set too quickly, making it challenging to work with in a more detailed eye look. Those who prefer more time for blending might find this slightly frustrating.

User Experience (General)

82%

18%

Overall, the product provides a pleasant user experience with a smooth application and impressive staying power. Most buyers find it easy to incorporate into their daily makeup routine, appreciating its versatility for different looks.

On the downside, a small group of users reported that the formula can be a bit too dry for their liking. Some have experienced flaking after prolonged wear, which detracts from the overall comfort and smoothness they expected.

Frequent Sharpening Requirement

70%

30%

The precision offered by the sharpener is highly valued by many, as it helps create defined lines. Users who enjoy sharp, detailed looks find it easier to work with this feature than with other liners that require extra tools.

However, frequent sharpening is a consistent complaint. Many users are frustrated by the fact that they need to sharpen the product regularly, which they feel diminishes the value and convenience, especially considering the price.

Suitable for:

The ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner - Dusk Brown is ideal for users who seek a versatile, clean eyeliner option with long-lasting performance. Those with sensitive eyes will appreciate the ophthalmologist-tested formula, making it suitable for all-day wear without irritation. Its vegan, cruelty-free formulation will appeal to conscious beauty consumers, while the water-resistant and smudge-proof properties are perfect for individuals needing reliable makeup in humid or active environments. This product is also great for anyone looking for a soft, blendable liner that can easily transition from bold to smoky eye looks, providing flexibility for various makeup styles.

Not suitable for:

This eyeliner may not be suitable for individuals with very oily eyelids or those in extremely humid environments, as some users report that it fades or smudges after extended wear. Additionally, users who prefer a product that requires less maintenance may find the frequent sharpening needed for precision somewhat inconvenient. While the clean, non-toxic formula is a selling point for many, those who prefer more intense pigmentation or a wider range of shades might find the color selection too limited. Finally, those with highly sensitive skin may still experience some irritation despite the formula being ophthalmologist-tested.

Specifications

Product Type: Gel eyeliner designed for smooth application and long-lasting wear.
Shade: Dusk Brown, a deep, rich brown perfect for defined or smudged looks.
Formula: Water-resistant and budge-resistant, ensuring all-day wear without smudging.
Pigmentation: Highly pigmented for bold, intense color payoff with a single application.
Cruelty-Free: Vegan and cruelty-free, with no animal testing involved in the product development.
Ophthalmologist-Tested: Formulated and tested to be safe for sensitive eyes, including contact lens wearers.
Non-Toxic: Free from carbon black and cyclomethicone, offering a clean and non-toxic option.
Application Tip: Soft tip that glides smoothly across the lash line for easy and precise application.
Built-In Sharpener: Includes a built-in sharpener for maintaining a fine tip for accurate application.
Longevity: Long-lasting formula that provides smudge-proof wear for up to 12 hours or more.
Packaging: Comes in a retractable pencil format for easy storage and portability.
Texture: Creamy texture that blends easily for a smooth finish, ideal for both sharp and smoky looks.
Skin Compatibility: Safe for all skin types, including sensitive skin and those prone to irritation.
Color Finish: Provides a matte finish with no excessive shine or gloss.
Environmental Impact: Formulated without harmful chemicals, supporting a clean beauty routine.
Weight: Lightweight and compact, ideal for travel or daily use.
Performance in Humidity: Performs well in moderate humidity but may require additional setting for very humid environments.
Smudge Resistance: Resistant to smudging or fading, even in active or wet conditions.
Applicator Design: Ergonomically designed pencil for easy grip and controlled application.

FAQ

For a precise application, start by gently gliding the soft tip along your lash line. You can build the intensity for a bold look or blend it out for a softer, smoky finish. The built-in sharpener helps maintain a fine tip for accuracy.

Yes, this eyeliner is ophthalmologist-tested, making it suitable for users with sensitive eyes. The gentle formula avoids harsh ingredients, ensuring comfort for those prone to irritation.

This eyeliner is formulated without carbon black or cyclomethicone, making it a clean, non-toxic option. It’s also vegan and cruelty-free, which aligns with conscious beauty choices.

Thanks to its water-resistant and smudge-proof formula, this eyeliner offers long-lasting wear that stays intact all day without fading. It's designed to endure through normal daily activities without budging.

Absolutely! The ILIA gel liner is versatile enough for both sharp, defined lines and soft, smudged looks. It glides on smoothly, allowing you to achieve the desired intensity with ease.

While this eyeliner is water-resistant and designed to stay in place, those with very oily eyelids may find it fades or smudges over time. A primer or setting spray may help enhance its longevity in such cases.

The eyeliner comes with a built-in sharpener, making it easy to maintain a fine point for precise application. However, users have mentioned that it may need sharpening more often than some other liners.

This eyeliner is free from carbon black and cyclomethicone, making it a clean, non-toxic option for those seeking a safer formula. However, if you have specific allergies or concerns, it's always best to consult with a healthcare provider.

Although this eyeliner is water-resistant, some users find it may not hold up as well in highly humid environments. If you're in a very humid area, consider using a setting spray to prolong wear.

Yes, this eyeliner can be applied on the waterline, but be cautious if you have very sensitive eyes. Many users find it works well for defining the lower lash line without irritation.