Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes Mascara - Super Black

87%

Lengthening Effect

Volumizing Effect

Longevity (Wear Time)

Smudge-Proof Performance

Waterproof Capability

Application Ease

Brush Design (Precision)

Volume Impact

Clumping/Separation

Packaging Design

Comfort (All-Day Wear)

Price-to-Performance Ratio

Overall User Satisfaction

Overview

The Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes Mascara - Super Black is designed to enhance your lashes with bold volume and length. This mascara creates a dramatic, wide-eyed effect by lifting and separating lashes for an instantly fuller look. With a unique 24-hour vertical push-up effect, it promises long-lasting wear without smudging or flaking. Ideal for those who crave intensity, this mascara comes in the bold shade Super Black for a striking, deep finish. Whether you're going for a subtle look or full-on glam, this volumizing mascara delivers the perfect amount of drama for every occasion.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This mascara is infused with keratin, which helps condition and strengthen lashes while promoting a healthier appearance. The formula is both waterproof and smudge-proof, ensuring that your lashes stay lifted and defined throughout the day without any flaking. The brush features a lift paddle design that enables precise application, adding maximum volume and length to each lash. Whether you're facing humid weather or a long workday, this mascara is built to keep your lashes looking fresh and voluminous without compromise.

Best For

This mascara is ideal for users looking for a high-impact look that combines volume and length in one product. It's especially well-suited for individuals with medium to dark lashes who want to create a more dramatic effect. Those in need of a smudge-proof, long-wearing formula will appreciate its ability to stay intact through long days or humid conditions. If you're someone who wants to enhance your natural lashes without clumping or flaking, this volumizing mascara is a great choice for a bold, defined look.

User Feedback

Many users rave about how this mascara gives lashes a noticeable lift and extra volume, with one even mentioning that it makes lashes look fuller and longer. Its long-lasting, smudge-proof qualities are frequently highlighted, making it perfect for long hours or humid environments. However, some users note that while the formula dries quickly, it can be a bit difficult to remove at the end of the day. Despite this, the majority agree that it doesn't clump or flake, leaving lashes looking separated and defined all day long.

#Mascara

#Eyes

#Makeup

#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

Provides intense volume and lift, making lashes appear fuller and longer.
Waterproof and smudge-proof formula ensures all-day wear, even in humid conditions.
Lift paddle brush design helps achieve precise application for maximum volume and length.
The Super Black shade delivers bold, dramatic lashes for a striking look.
Dries quickly without clumping, leaving lashes separated and defined.
Long-lasting wear, with claims of up to 24 hours of vertical lift.

Cons

May be difficult to remove, especially for those with sensitive eyes or skin.
Not suitable for users with very sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers.
Formula can feel a bit heavy for those seeking a more natural look.
Some users report slight smudging in extreme conditions like heavy sweating.
Not ideal for those who prefer a softer, more lightweight mascara.
May cause irritation for those with ultra-sensitive skin around the eyes.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user feedback from multiple platforms and languages worldwide, we've compiled an overall score for the Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes Mascara - Super Black. The ratings reflect both strengths and pain points, with spam, incentivized, or duplicate reviews removed to ensure accuracy. This mascara has garnered attention for its long-lasting, bold effect, but some users also noted its quick-drying formula and application concerns. Below, you'll find scores based on global insights from diverse sources, focusing on the most critical aspects of this product.

Lengthening Effect

92%

Users love how this mascara delivers a noticeable lengthening effect, making lashes appear visibly longer and more defined. The results are consistent, with many reviewers mentioning that their lashes look dramatically extended with just one coat, even for those with naturally short lashes.

Some users found that while it lengthens well, the effect may not be as dramatic as they hoped, especially for individuals with sparse or very fine lashes. A few noted that it didn't provide enough curl or lift for their lashes, leaving them feeling flat despite the lengthening.

Volumizing Effect

89%

Many users appreciate the volume this mascara gives, with several pointing out that it creates a fuller, more voluminous lash look without clumping. The formula provides a noticeable boost to the lashes, especially when applied to the roots for added thickness.

On the downside, some reviewers reported that it didn’t add as much volume as they expected, particularly for those with sparse lashes. A few also mentioned that the volumizing effect wasn't as long-lasting, with some noticing a decrease in fullness by the end of the day.

Longevity (Wear Time)

94%

Users rave about the impressive 24-hour wear time, with many noting that this mascara stays put throughout long workdays, humid conditions, and even during exercise. It holds up exceptionally well without smudging, running, or flaking, making it ideal for those with busy schedules.

While the longevity is a big plus for most, some users mentioned that it can be a bit challenging to remove, especially at the end of the day. A few reviewers also noted that the mascara tends to feel a bit stiff after it sets, which can be uncomfortable for those who prefer softer formulas.

Smudge-Proof Performance

91%

Many buyers highlight the mascara’s excellent smudge-proof performance, making it perfect for those in hot or humid environments. It's particularly praised for staying intact throughout the day, even when exposed to sweat or rain, which is a significant plus for people looking for a reliable, all-day hold.

A few users did mention that while it's smudge-proof, it can sometimes leave behind marks or remnants under the eyes after long hours of wear, especially if you rub your eyes. These isolated cases seem to happen mainly with oily skin types or those who touch their face frequently throughout the day.

Waterproof Capability

88%

The waterproof formula is highly appreciated by users who need a mascara that will stay intact in challenging weather conditions. Many reviewers noted that this mascara doesn't run or smudge, even in the rain or while swimming, making it a go-to choice for all-day wear in wet environments.

Despite the waterproof claim, a few users found that the mascara struggled to withstand extreme humidity or perspiration for extended periods. Additionally, some complained about the difficulty in removing it completely without harsh makeup removers, which could be irritating to sensitive skin.

Application Ease

79%

21%

Several users find the mascara easy to apply due to the unique lift paddle brush design, which helps to coat lashes evenly and precisely. The formula glides on smoothly, and the brush allows for controlled application, which is especially beneficial for reaching smaller lashes.

However, some users noted that the brush can be difficult to maneuver at first, especially for those with smaller eyes or shorter lashes. Additionally, a few mentioned that the product sometimes clumps if too many layers are applied or if it's not applied quickly enough.

Brush Design (Precision)

85%

The lift paddle brush is widely praised for its ability to define and separate lashes, ensuring even application and creating a natural-looking finish. Reviewers have commented on the ease of coating both upper and lower lashes with minimal effort, thanks to the design of the brush.

Some buyers found the brush to be a bit bulky, which made it challenging to apply the mascara to the very corners of the eyes or lower lashes without smudging. A few also felt the brush didn't provide as much curl or lift as they anticipated, even with multiple coats.

Volume Impact

87%

Many users report that this mascara gives their lashes a fuller, more voluminous appearance, especially when applied in multiple coats. The formula builds nicely, and for those with naturally thin lashes, the effect is especially noticeable, making eyes appear larger and more defined.

A small group of users found the volume impact to be less impressive than expected, particularly for those who have already long lashes. They mentioned that the mascara adds more length than volume, which might be a drawback for people seeking a more dramatic, thickening effect.

Clumping/Separation

86%

Users generally appreciate how the formula does not clump or create unwanted spider lashes. The mascara provides a clean, separated look, which is ideal for those looking for precision and a natural, defined finish without heavy build-up.

However, some users pointed out that if not applied quickly enough or in one smooth stroke, the formula can start to clump. A few others mentioned that the mascara doesn't separate as well on the lower lashes, leaving them looking a bit too thick or joined together.

Packaging Design

80%

20%

The sleek packaging of this mascara is stylish and functional, with a compact tube that makes it easy to carry around in a purse or makeup bag. Many users also mention the sturdy build and secure cap that prevents the formula from drying out.

Some users found the packaging to be a bit bulky for daily use, especially if they are used to smaller, more travel-friendly mascaras. A few mentioned that the tube could be a bit slippery when handling with wet hands, leading to accidental drops.

Comfort (All-Day Wear)

91%

Many users find this mascara comfortable to wear for extended periods, with little to no irritation even for those with sensitive eyes. The lightweight formula doesn't weigh lashes down, making it ideal for all-day wear without causing discomfort.

A few users with very sensitive eyes noted that while the formula is mostly comfortable, it may cause slight irritation or dryness by the end of the day. These cases seem to be more common with contact lens wearers or those prone to eye sensitivity.

Price-to-Performance Ratio

82%

18%

Many buyers feel that this mascara provides good value for its price, especially given its longevity, performance, and high-quality formula. It stands out in comparison to other high-end mascaras, offering lasting volume and definition without the premium price tag of some other luxury brands.

On the other hand, some users felt that the price is a bit high compared to similar mascaras on the market, particularly for those on a budget. A few reviewers expressed that while it works well, there are other more affordable options that deliver similar results.

Overall User Satisfaction

90%

The overall user satisfaction is high, with many users recommending this mascara for its impressive lengthening, volumizing, and smudge-proof qualities. It's become a favorite for those seeking bold, defined lashes with lasting performance, even in challenging conditions.

However, there are some users who are not fully satisfied, especially those looking for a more dramatic volumizing effect. A few people mentioned that the mascara didn't live up to their expectations in terms of providing extreme volume or a more noticeable curl, which affected their overall experience.

Suitable for:

The Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes Mascara - Super Black is ideal for users who seek a high-impact mascara that delivers both length and volume. It’s particularly beneficial for those looking for a long-lasting formula that stays in place all day, even in humid environments. This product is perfect for individuals with medium to dark lashes who want enhanced, dramatic results without worrying about smudging or flaking. Users with busy lifestyles will appreciate its waterproof and smudge-proof qualities, as it performs well throughout the day, offering bold lashes from morning to night. Additionally, people who need a formula that works well in various conditions, such as hot weather or exercise, will find it reliable and consistent.

Not suitable for:

This mascara may not be suitable for individuals with very sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses, as some users have reported minor irritation with long wear. It may also not be ideal for people who prefer a soft, natural finish or those looking for a mascara that provides intense curl rather than volume and length. Additionally, users with very oily skin or those prone to excessive perspiration may find that this product doesn't last as long as expected, as a few reviewers noted slight smudging or transfer in extreme conditions. Those looking for an easy-to-remove mascara might also find the waterproof formula difficult to take off without a heavy-duty makeup remover, which could be irritating for sensitive skin.

Specifications

Type: Mascara designed to lengthen and volumize lashes.
Shade: Available in Super Black for a bold, intense look.
Formula: Waterproof and smudge-proof for long-lasting wear.
Key Ingredient: Infused with keratin to strengthen and define lashes.
Brush Design: Lift paddle brush for precise application and maximum volume.
Effect: Delivers a 24-hour vertical push-up effect for all-day lift.
Finish: Matte finish for a clean, defined look.
Suitability: Suitable for all-day wear and ideal for medium to dark lashes.
Clumping Resistance: Formula dries quickly without clumping, leaving lashes separated.
Longevity: Provides up to 24 hours of lift and volume without smudging.
Fragrance: Fragrance-free for sensitive eyes and skin.
Volume: Intense volumizing effect, enhancing lash fullness.
Color Intensity: Super Black shade provides a bold, dramatic finish.
Drying Time: Dries quickly after application to prevent smudging.
Packaging: Comes in a sleek tube designed for easy handling and storage.
Compatibility: Ideal for users with medium to dark lashes seeking volume and length.
Application: Requires a simple application with the lift paddle brush for optimal results.
Water Resistance: Designed to withstand water and humidity, perfect for rainy days or long wear.
Removal: Easily removed with oil-based makeup removers.

FAQ

To use this mascara, start by placing the lift paddle brush at the base of your lashes. Wiggle the brush back and forth as you move upwards to achieve volume and lift. For extra drama, apply a second coat to build more length and thickness.

Yes, this mascara features a waterproof, smudge-proof formula that ensures your lashes stay lifted and voluminous throughout the day, even in humid environments or during rainy weather.

While many users with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers enjoy this mascara, it’s always best to patch test first. If you have extremely sensitive eyes, the formula may feel heavy or cause irritation for some.

The Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes Mascara - Super Black is designed for long-lasting wear, offering up to 24 hours of vertical lift and volume. It's perfect for all-day use without worrying about touch-ups.

This mascara is infused with keratin, a protein that helps strengthen and define lashes. Keratin works to improve the health of your lashes over time, making them appear fuller and more defined with each use.

While the mascara is waterproof and smudge-proof, it may require an oil-based makeup remover to ensure thorough removal without irritating the eyes. Use a gentle makeup remover for a smoother experience.

Yes, the smudge-proof formula is ideal for those with oily skin, as it helps prevent mascara from transferring or smearing throughout the day, keeping your lashes looking fresh and voluminous.

This mascara works best for users who want intense volume and length. It's particularly effective for individuals with medium to dark lashes who want a bold, dramatic look with lasting results.

Most users report that this mascara doesn’t clump, as the formula dries quickly and the lift paddle brush ensures even application. However, some users with more delicate lashes may experience slight flaking after extended wear.

The lift paddle design of the brush is specifically engineered to separate and coat each lash evenly. This helps achieve both maximum volume and length while preventing clumping and ensuring precision with every application.