Bobbi Brown Metallic Eye Shadow #9 Burnt Sugar

86%

Pigmentation & Color Payoff

Ease of Application

Longevity / Wear Time

Crease-Free Performance

Blendability

Shimmer & Finish

Suitability for Medium to Deep Skin Tones

Packaging & Design

Value for Money

Buildable Coverage

Scent

Suitability for Sensitive Skin

Overall Customer Satisfaction

Overview

The Bobbi Brown Metallic Eye Shadow #9 Burnt Sugar offers a rich, high-pigment formula that delivers a stunning metallic finish. This eye shadow provides a smooth, crease-free application, leaving a luminous, long-lasting sheen on your eyelids. The shade #9 Burnt Sugar is a warm, shimmering brown that complements a wide range of looks. Whether you're creating a subtle daytime eye or a bold, evening statement, this eye shadow is versatile enough for all occasions. Rich pigment and a luminous finish make this a standout product in any makeup routine.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This Bobbi Brown shadow is designed with a formula that ensures long-lasting wear without the need for constant touch-ups. It glides on easily, offering a smooth and even application. The high-shimmer, metallic finish provides depth and dimension to your eyes, while the crease-free formula ensures the color stays intact throughout the day. Ideal for those looking for an eye shadow that provides both bold color and all-day wear, it blends effortlessly to create a soft, defined look.

Best For

This eye shadow is ideal for individuals seeking a sophisticated metallic look with a warm, versatile tone. Its rich, shimmering brown shade #9 Burnt Sugar is especially flattering on medium to deep skin tones, making it a go-to choice for those with warm undertones. Perfect for anyone who enjoys a high-pigment eyeshadow that's easy to apply and blends beautifully, it’s great for creating everything from everyday looks to dramatic evening styles. Blendable and long-lasting, it suits both beginners and makeup experts.

User Feedback

Users rave about the smooth application and the creaseless wear of this eye shadow, making it a favorite for those looking for something that stays in place throughout the day. Many appreciate its rich pigment and subtle shimmer, which doesn't fade or wear off even after hours of use. Some users note how well it blends with other shadows, making it easy to create custom eye looks. On the downside, a few customers mention that the shimmer may be a bit too intense for those who prefer a more matte finish, but overall, the feedback is overwhelmingly positive.

#Eyeshadow

#Eyes

#Makeup

#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

The high-pigment formula provides rich color with a luminous metallic finish.
Blends smoothly and easily for a soft, even application.
The crease-free formula ensures long-lasting wear without touch-ups throughout the day.
The warm, shimmering brown tone complements medium to deep skin tones beautifully.
Works well for creating both bold and subtle eye looks depending on application.
Many users appreciate how well this shadow layers with other eyeshadows.

Cons

Some users with oily eyelids noticed slight creasing after several hours.
The metallic finish may not be intense enough for those seeking a dramatic shimmer.
Lighter skin tones may find the color less vibrant or contrasting than expected.
It may not perform as well in humid conditions where it can feel heavier.
Not suitable for those seeking a completely matte eyeshadow look.
Sensitive skin users reported mild irritation in some cases.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews of the Bobbi Brown Metallic Eye Shadow #9 Burnt Sugar from multiple platforms and languages worldwide, we’ve compiled a comprehensive overview of its performance. Our scores reflect authentic, high-quality feedback, filtered for spam, bot, and incentivized content. Both strengths and pain points have been considered, offering a balanced look at how this eye shadow performs across different user experiences. The diverse range of sources, including reviews from various countries, highlights its versatility and appeal to different skin tones and makeup preferences.

Pigmentation & Color Payoff

94%

Many users love the rich, vibrant color that the shadow delivers with just one swipe. The pigmentation is highly praised for being bold and intense, making it ideal for those seeking eye-catching metallic looks. The warm brown tone suits a variety of skin tones, enhancing eye definition effortlessly.

A few reviewers noted that the color payoff can be slightly underwhelming on lighter skin tones, and some feel that it doesn't achieve its full intensity without building up layers. While most users are satisfied with the pigment, others expected even more depth with a single application.

Ease of Application

91%

Users consistently mention the smooth, effortless application of this eye shadow. It glides on easily, with many stating that it doesn't require a primer to achieve a flawless finish. Its silky texture allows for seamless blending, making it perfect for both beginners and makeup enthusiasts.

A handful of users reported that the product can be a bit crumbly, particularly if it’s not applied with a firm brush. A few others found it to be a bit challenging to apply evenly on certain eyelid textures, requiring additional touch-ups for a consistent look.

Longevity / Wear Time

88%

This product is widely appreciated for its all-day wear without requiring touch-ups. Many users have praised its ability to stay in place, even during long workdays or social events. The shadow holds its intensity without fading, making it a reliable option for those seeking a lasting, vibrant finish.

Some users pointed out that, while it lasts for hours, the product may start to show slight creasing or fading by the end of the day, especially in warmer climates or on oily eyelids. A few individuals felt that additional setting spray was needed to maximize its longevity.

Crease-Free Performance

92%

One of the standout features of this product is its crease-free formula. Users are impressed with how it stays in place all day without settling into fine lines or creasing, even after hours of wear. This makes it a great choice for those looking for a reliable, long-lasting eye shadow.

While many find the formula crease-free, a small group of users mentioned that it doesn't always perform as well on those with extremely oily eyelids. In some cases, a primer was recommended to maintain its smooth finish throughout the day.

Blendability

89%

Several users highlighted the ease with which this shadow blends into the skin. The smooth formula allows for a soft, even application, and it layers well with other shadows, creating depth without harsh lines. It’s perfect for creating both subtle daytime looks and more dramatic evening styles.

A few reviewers found that it can take a little extra effort to blend if too much product is applied at once. In some cases, the shadow didn’t blend as seamlessly with other formulas, especially those with a drier consistency.

Shimmer & Finish

90%

The metallic finish of this eye shadow is a major highlight for users who want a luminous, glowing effect. Its subtle shimmer provides an eye-catching shine without being overwhelming. The finish enhances the eyes with a sophisticated touch, making it suitable for both day and night looks.

Some users felt the shimmer was a bit too subtle, especially in bright lighting, and expected a more intense gleam. A few others noted that the finish may not be ideal for those seeking a completely matte look for more natural eye makeup.

Suitability for Medium to Deep Skin Tones

87%

This shadow is particularly well-suited for medium to deep skin tones, with its warm brown shade complementing these undertones beautifully. The color creates a rich, flattering effect that enhances the eyes and suits a variety of makeup styles.

Some users with lighter skin tones felt that the shade did not pop as expected, and it might not show up as vibrantly as it does on deeper complexions. A few found the warm brown tone to be too dark for their preferences, wishing for more variety in shades for different undertones.

Packaging & Design

85%

The sleek, compact packaging is easy to carry and doesn’t take up much space in a makeup bag. Many users appreciate its sturdy design and how the shadow is securely housed, preventing spills or breakage. It’s a convenient, on-the-go option for those who travel frequently.

A few users mentioned that the packaging could be improved, as the small pan size might not be ideal for those who want more product for their money. Some also noted that the lid doesn't always snap shut securely, risking potential mess when tossed into a makeup bag.

Value for Money

80%

20%

Despite being on the pricier side, many users feel that this eye shadow is a worthwhile investment, given its high quality and performance. It delivers impressive pigmentation, lasting wear, and smooth application, making it a great choice for those willing to spend more on a reliable product.

A few buyers feel that the price point doesn’t match the amount of product received, especially when compared to other options on the market. Some feel that the product could be a bit more affordable for its size, considering the performance isn't drastically better than similar alternatives.

Buildable Coverage

83%

Users enjoy the ability to build the color intensity with this shadow, allowing for versatile looks. Whether they prefer a soft wash of color or a more dramatic metallic finish, this shadow offers flexibility without losing its smooth texture.

While buildable, some reviewers found that too many layers made the product feel heavy or cakey. A few users mentioned that achieving the desired intensity required multiple applications, which some felt was inconvenient for quick makeup routines.

Scent

75%

25%

Most users didn’t find any noticeable fragrance, which is a plus for those who prefer makeup products without strong smells. This neutrality allows the product to blend seamlessly with other items in your beauty routine without clashing scents.

A small group of users noted a faint chemical smell upon first opening the product. While not overpowering, it was noticeable enough to mention. Some felt that a more pleasant scent could improve the overall experience.

Suitability for Sensitive Skin

78%

22%

Several users with sensitive skin found this product gentle and irritation-free. The smooth application and long-lasting wear didn’t cause any discomfort, making it a good option for those with delicate eye areas.

A few users with particularly sensitive skin experienced mild irritation after wearing the shadow for an extended period. Some also reported redness or dryness after removal, suggesting that the formula might not be suitable for everyone with heightened skin sensitivity.

Overall Customer Satisfaction

91%

Most customers are thoroughly satisfied with the performance of this eye shadow. Its versatility, smooth texture, and long-lasting wear have made it a favorite in many makeup routines. Users love the radiant finish and the ease with which it applies, blending seamlessly into different looks.

Some users felt that the product didn’t live up to its full potential in certain areas, such as pigmentation or blendability on specific eyelid types. While most are happy with the results, a few buyers expressed disappointment with the color payoff or texture on their skin.

Suitable for:

This eye shadow is ideal for users seeking a high-pigment, metallic finish that stays in place throughout the day. It’s particularly suited for those with medium to deep skin tones, as the warm brown hue complements these undertones beautifully. Makeup enthusiasts looking for a versatile, easy-to-apply product will also benefit, as it blends effortlessly and layers well with other shadows. Users who need long-lasting wear without the need for touch-ups will appreciate its crease-free formula, making it a great option for long workdays or evening events.

Not suitable for:

The Bobbi Brown Metallic Eye Shadow #9 Burnt Sugar may not be the best choice for those with extremely oily eyelids, as some users reported slight creasing or fading after several hours. Individuals with lighter skin tones might find the warm brown shade doesn’t stand out as much, and the metallic finish might not be intense enough for their preference. Additionally, users with sensitive eyes or skin could experience mild irritation, so it’s recommended to test it first before use. This product may also be less suitable for those expecting a completely matte look or a more subtle shimmer.

Specifications

Brand: The eye shadow is from Bobbi Brown, a well-known makeup brand.
Product Type: This is a high-pigment, metallic eye shadow.
Shade: The product is available in shade #9 Burnt Sugar, a warm brown tone.
Finish: It has a metallic finish that provides a luminous, light-catching effect.
Pigmentation: The eye shadow offers high-pigment color with intense payoff.
Formula: The formula is smooth and blends easily for a soft, even finish.
Application: The product is designed to provide a crease-free application.
Longevity: This eye shadow is long-lasting, staying in place without needing touch-ups throughout the day.
Blendability: The eye shadow blends easily, allowing for smooth layering with other shadows.
Suitability: It is especially suitable for medium to deep skin tones that complement warm brown shades.
Texture: The texture is soft and creamy, ensuring comfortable wear without dryness.
Packaging: The eye shadow comes in a compact, portable container ideal for on-the-go use.
Formulation: The product is formulated for all-day wear without fading or creasing.
Ideal For: Best suited for users looking for a sophisticated, metallic eye look.
Layering: It works well when layered with other eye shadows for custom looks.
Compatibility: This eye shadow is designed to complement various eye shapes and sizes.
Color Payoff: The eye shadow delivers rich, vibrant color with each application.
Storage: Store the product in a cool, dry place to maintain its longevity and performance.
Application Tools: It can be applied using either a fingertip or a flat eye shadow brush.

FAQ

For a smooth application, use your fingertip or a flat brush to pick up the eye shadow. Pat it onto the eyelid, starting from the center and blending outwards. You can build up the intensity for a more dramatic look or layer it with other shades for a customized eye look.

This eye shadow is generally well-tolerated by most users, but sensitive skin types should always do a patch test first. It’s formulated to be smooth and crease-free, but if you have particularly sensitive eyes, it’s best to avoid applying it near the waterline or areas prone to irritation.

Bobbi Brown Metallic Eye Shadow #9 Burnt Sugar has a high-shimmer, metallic finish that provides a luminous, light-catching effect. The texture is smooth and blends easily, making it perfect for creating both soft and bold eye looks.

Yes, this product is versatile enough for daily use. It’s crease-free, so it will stay in place throughout the day without needing frequent touch-ups. For a more subtle look, apply a light layer, and for evenings or special occasions, build it up for more intensity.

This eye shadow has a long-lasting formula that stays put for hours without fading or creasing. Most users report that it lasts through the day without needing touch-ups, making it a reliable choice for all-day wear.

While the warm, shimmering brown tone is ideal for medium to deep skin tones, fair skin can still wear this shade for a subtle, sophisticated look. It’s best to apply with a light hand for fairer skin tones to avoid the color looking too intense.

This eye shadow is formulated with high-quality pigments that deliver intense color payoff. It includes ingredients that help the product apply smoothly, resist creasing, and provide a comfortable feel throughout the day. For specific ingredient details, please refer to the packaging or official product page.

While this eye shadow is designed to be crease-free and long-lasting, extremely humid or sweaty conditions may cause some slight wear. It's generally fine for regular daily activities, but in very hot or humid environments, you might experience some fading or buildup in crease areas.

To remove this eye shadow, use a gentle makeup remover or micellar water. Because it’s a high-pigment formula, you may need to swipe a few times, but it comes off easily without excessive rubbing. Follow with a cleanser to ensure your skin is thoroughly clean.

Yes, this eye shadow blends well and layers beautifully with other shadows. You can easily pair it with matte or shimmer shades to create dimension and depth. Its smooth texture ensures that it won’t clump or become patchy when layered.