Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil 02 Mahogany

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil 02 Mahogany — image 1
88%
93%
Effectiveness & Longevity
89%
Smooth Application
91%
Waterproof Performance
88%
Color Payoff
90%
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes
82%
Packaging & Sharpener
87%
Versatility of Shade
85%
Comfort & Finish
92%
Value for Money
93%
Smudging Resistance
90%
Durability (12-Hour Wear)
80%
Ease of Removal
More

Overview

The Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil 02 Mahogany is a must-have for anyone seeking a reliable, waterproof eyeliner. This rich mahogany shade offers a deep, striking color that works perfectly for both daily wear and bold, dramatic looks. The smudge-proof formula ensures it stays intact for up to 12 hours, making it ideal for long days or special occasions. Included with the pencil is a sharpener, ensuring that you can easily maintain its precision for consistent application, whether you're touching up or creating a fresh look.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

This eyeliner features a waterproof formula that resists smudging and fading, providing lasting wear throughout the day. The creamy texture glides on smoothly, offering an intense color payoff with each stroke. It’s designed for comfort, ensuring a non-drying finish even after hours of wear. The addition of a sharpener with each pencil makes it easy to keep the eyeliner in perfect shape, allowing for precise lines every time. Overall, the formula combines long-lasting performance with easy application.

Best For

This eye pencil is perfect for anyone looking for a reliable, long-lasting eyeliner that can withstand all-day wear without the need for frequent touch-ups. It’s particularly well-suited for those who need a versatile, flattering shade like mahogany, which works well for both everyday and more dramatic makeup looks. Additionally, it’s a great option for individuals with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, as its gentle, non-irritating formula is made for comfort.

User Feedback

Users consistently praise this eyeliner for its smooth application and long-lasting, waterproof performance. The mahogany shade is frequently mentioned for its ability to flatter a wide range of skin tones, adding a unique twist to traditional eyeliner looks. However, some users report minor issues with the sharpener, noting occasional challenges in maintaining a perfectly sharp point. Despite this, the majority of reviews are positive, with many appreciating the product’s ability to stay intact throughout busy days or even in humid conditions.

#Eyeliner
#Eyes
#Makeup
#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

  • Smooth, easy application that glides on without tugging.
  • Long-wear formula stays intact for up to 12 hours, even in humid conditions.
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof, making it ideal for all-day wear.
  • The mahogany shade flatters a variety of skin tones, offering versatility.
  • Includes a sharpener for easy maintenance and precise application.
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers without irritation.

Cons

  • Some users find the pencil breaks easily during sharpening.
  • The deep mahogany color may be too bold for those seeking a more subtle look.
  • May not perform as well on oily skin types, leading to smudging after prolonged wear.
  • The creamy texture can make it slightly difficult to sharpen to a fine point.
  • Occasional complaints about the sharpener not providing precise results.
  • Not the best option for those who prefer a natural, lighter eyeliner shade.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user reviews from multiple countries, languages, and platforms, the ratings for the Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil 02 Mahogany reflect both strengths and areas for improvement. Spam, bot/incentivized, and off-topic reviews were filtered out to ensure the results accurately reflect authentic user experiences. Both positive and negative feedback have been considered, providing a balanced view of the product's performance across various criteria.

Effectiveness & Longevity
93%
Many users rave about the long-lasting performance of this pencil. Its waterproof and smudge-proof formula ensures that it stays in place throughout the day, making it an ideal choice for long hours at work or special occasions. A full 12-hour wear without fading is frequently highlighted as a major benefit.
However, some users mention that, while it stays put, removing the pencil can be challenging without a dedicated makeup remover. A few have also noted that the product can feel slightly heavy on the eyes after long periods of wear.
Smooth Application
89%
The creamy texture of this eyeliner makes it easy to apply, gliding smoothly without pulling or tugging at the skin. Buyers especially like how effortlessly it glides on, even for delicate skin around the eyes. It’s a go-to choice for users seeking a quick, smooth application.
On the downside, a few users reported that the pencil tends to break during the sharpening process. While not a widespread issue, it can be frustrating when trying to maintain the precision of the eyeliner.
Waterproof Performance
91%
The product excels in its waterproof capability, with users praising how well it withstands sweat, rain, and humidity. Many wearers have shared that they can confidently rely on it during the most demanding days without worrying about smudging.
Some users with very oily skin mentioned that the waterproof formula doesn’t always hold up throughout the day. A few reported that they noticed slight fading or smudging after several hours, particularly in the inner corner of the eyes.
Color Payoff
88%
The rich mahogany shade provides a deep, intense color that flatters a variety of skin tones. Users find it versatile enough for both casual everyday looks and more dramatic, evening styles. It’s often praised for being bold yet not too overpowering.
A small number of users mentioned that the color payoff wasn’t as vibrant as expected on certain skin tones. For those with darker complexions, the shade may appear slightly muted compared to the rich hue seen in promotional images.
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes
90%
The pencil is highly recommended by users with sensitive eyes, including contact lens wearers. It causes minimal irritation, and the smooth, creamy formula makes it ideal for those who typically experience discomfort with other eyeliners.
While generally well-tolerated, a few individuals reported mild irritation after prolonged use. This issue seems rare, but it’s something to consider if you have particularly sensitive skin around the eyes.
Packaging & Sharpener
82%
18%
Many buyers appreciate the thoughtful inclusion of a sharpener, which makes maintenance and precision application much easier. It’s a small but practical touch that adds value, especially for those who like to keep their eyeliner sharp and precise.
However, some users noted that the sharpener doesn’t always provide a perfect point, occasionally causing the pencil to break or wear unevenly. The packaging itself is functional but not necessarily the most durable over time.
Versatility of Shade
87%
The 02 Mahogany shade is versatile enough for both everyday use and more dramatic, evening looks. Users enjoy the warmth of the color, which complements various makeup styles and enhances their overall eye definition.
A few users found the shade too dark for their preference, especially those who were looking for a lighter, softer eyeliner option. The color intensity may not suit those who prefer a more natural or subtle look.
Comfort & Finish
85%
This eyeliner provides a smooth, comfortable finish that doesn’t dry out the skin. It feels lightweight on the eyes, allowing wearers to enjoy a natural finish without the heavy, cakey feeling some eyeliners tend to create.
A few users found the texture slightly too creamy, leading to some transfer throughout the day. While this doesn’t appear to be a common complaint, it can be an issue for those with very oily eyelids.
Value for Money
92%
Most users feel that this eyeliner offers great value, especially given its long wear and high performance. It is seen as a solid investment for those looking for a reliable, high-quality product that performs as promised throughout the day.
Some buyers feel that the price point is slightly high compared to other eyeliners with similar features. Although the product delivers on quality, a few mentioned they would appreciate a more budget-friendly option.
Smudging Resistance
93%
This product is praised for its excellent smudge resistance, even after long days. Users enjoy that they don’t need to constantly check or reapply throughout the day, as the eyeliner stays intact and defined.
While most users are happy with its smudge-proof formula, a few did experience some light smudging after several hours, especially on the lower lash line. This issue seems to arise in humid or particularly sweaty conditions.
Durability (12-Hour Wear)
90%
The 12-hour wear time is frequently highlighted as one of the product’s best features. Many reviewers comment that it stays put through long workdays, evenings out, or even more demanding conditions like travel or outdoor events.
A few users mentioned that the pencil’s staying power wasn’t as impressive on very oily skin, with some noticing slight fading after a few hours. This seems to vary depending on individual skin types.
Ease of Removal
80%
20%
The waterproof formula is easy to remove with the right makeup remover, making it convenient for users who prefer a thorough yet simple cleansing routine at the end of the day.
Several users noted that removing the eyeliner requires more effort than other pencils. Some found that it leaves a slight residue, which can be difficult to clean off without a dedicated makeup remover or cleansing oil.

Suitable for:

The Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil 02 Mahogany is an excellent choice for those seeking a reliable, long-lasting eyeliner. It’s particularly beneficial for users with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, thanks to its gentle, non-irritating formula. People looking for an eyeliner that offers 12-hour wear without smudging or fading will appreciate its durable, waterproof properties. This product is also a great fit for individuals who prefer versatile, rich colors that can work for both everyday and more dramatic looks. The inclusion of a sharpener makes it even more appealing for those who value precision in their makeup routine.

Not suitable for:

This eyeliner may not be ideal for users with very oily skin, as some reviewers noted that the smudge-proof formula doesn’t always hold up as well on such skin types, particularly after long periods of wear. Additionally, individuals who prefer a lighter, more natural eyeliner shade may find the deep mahogany color too intense. Some users also reported issues with sharpening, with the pencil occasionally breaking or wearing unevenly, so it may not be the best option for those looking for a hassle-free, low-maintenance pencil. Lastly, people who require a very easy removal process may find the waterproof formula a bit challenging to cleanse without specialized makeup removers.

Specifications

  • Brand: This eye pencil is manufactured by Bobbi Brown, a well-known brand in the beauty industry.
  • Product Type: This product is a long-wear, waterproof eye pencil designed for defining the eyes.
  • Shade: The shade of this pencil is 02 Mahogany, a deep and rich color suitable for various skin tones.
  • Wear Time: The eye pencil offers up to 12 hours of smudge-proof, waterproof wear without fading.
  • Waterproof: This eye pencil features a waterproof formula that resists smudging and fading throughout the day.
  • Smudge-Proof: The pencil is smudge-proof, ensuring it stays intact without running or smearing.
  • Formulation: The product has a creamy texture that glides smoothly on the skin, providing an intense color payoff.
  • Includes Sharpener: The pencil comes with an included sharpener, ensuring easy maintenance for precise application.
  • Suitable for Sensitive Eyes: This eyeliner is formulated to be gentle on sensitive eyes and is safe for use by contact lens wearers.
  • Skin Type Compatibility: The product is suitable for all skin types, offering a comfortable finish without irritation.
  • Texture: The creamy formulation ensures smooth application, providing a non-drying finish.
  • Color Payoff: The eyeliner delivers an intense color payoff, enhancing the eyes with a bold, rich tone.
  • Size: The pencil contains 0.045 oz of product, offering a compact and travel-friendly size.
  • Application: The pencil is designed for precise application, with a sharpener included to maintain its tip.
  • Shade Versatility: The Mahogany shade is versatile, suitable for both everyday and dramatic eye looks.
  • Longevity: This eyeliner maintains its color and shape for up to 12 hours, making it ideal for long-lasting wear.
  • Suitable for All Occasions: The versatile shade and long-lasting formula make this pencil suitable for both casual and formal occasions.
  • Formulation Benefits: The formula provides comfort and avoids a dry finish, ensuring smooth application throughout the day.

FAQ

This eye pencil delivers up to 12 hours of smudge-proof, waterproof wear, making it ideal for all-day use without fading or running.

Yes, this product is designed to be gentle on sensitive eyes and is safe for contact lens wearers, ensuring no irritation or discomfort.

The pencil has a creamy, smooth texture that glides on effortlessly, providing intense color payoff without tugging or skipping.

Yes, the Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil 02 Mahogany comes with a built-in sharpener, ensuring easy maintenance for precise application.

Absolutely! The rich mahogany shade is versatile, making it perfect for both subtle, everyday definition and dramatic, bold looks for evenings.

To maintain its creamy texture and performance, store the pencil in a cool, dry place, and make sure the cap is securely in place to prevent the pencil from drying out.

Yes, this eyeliner is designed to stay in place even on oily skin, as its smudge-proof and waterproof formula ensures long-lasting wear.

The shade 02 Mahogany offers a deep, rich tone that flatters a wide range of skin tones, providing a natural yet defined look that's perfect for both day and night.

Yes, many users have reported that this eyeliner works well on the waterline, offering long-lasting definition without irritation.

While this product is generally safe for sensitive eyes, some users have reported occasional sharpening issues, with the pencil breaking during use. Be sure to sharpen gently for the best results.