Overview

The bareMinerals Maximist Phyto-Fiber Volumizing Black Mascara is a high-performance mascara designed to enhance lash thickness and definition. This mascara is specially formulated to provide a voluminous look without clumping, thanks to its unique phyto-fiber technology. It also offers a waterproof, smudge-proof, and flake-free formula, ensuring that your lashes stay full and defined throughout the day. Whether you’re going for a natural look or want to layer for more intensity, this mascara builds beautifully without the heaviness of other volumizing formulas.

Key Ingredients & Benefits

At the heart of this mascara is the innovative phyto-fiber technology, which helps enhance lash volume and definition without any clumping. The formula is designed to provide long-lasting results, as it is both waterproof and smudge-proof, offering all-day wear even in humid conditions. Moreover, it’s vegan and cruelty-free, making it a great choice for those who prioritize eco-friendly beauty products. The blend of ingredients ensures that your lashes remain bold and thick, with no flakes or smudges, even after hours of wear.

Best For

This mascara is ideal for individuals who want voluminous lashes with a natural finish. It works well for people with sensitive eyes, as the formula is gentle and free from irritating chemicals. If you’re someone who prefers a mascara that lasts all day without the need for constant touch-ups, this is an excellent option. Additionally, those looking for a cruelty-free mascara that still delivers high-performance results will appreciate this product’s ethical formulation and effectiveness.

User Feedback

Many users praise the mascara for giving them thicker lashes with a natural look that lasts throughout the day. The waterproof formula is particularly popular among those who need long-lasting wear, even in humid or rainy weather. However, some reviewers have noted that removing this mascara can be a bit challenging due to its strong waterproofing. Overall, it receives high marks for its ability to define lashes and provide a bold look without clumping, though a few users recommend using a gentle makeup remover for easier removal.

Pros

  • Provides a natural, voluminous lash look without clumping.
  • Long-lasting formula stays in place all day, even in humid conditions.
  • Gentle enough for sensitive eyes, with a cruelty-free and vegan formula.
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof, perfect for active users and all-day wear.
  • Great for users with contact lenses or those prone to eye irritation.
  • Phyto-fiber technology helps build fullness and definition without heaviness.

Cons

  • Removing the waterproof formula can be challenging for some users.
  • May not offer the dramatic volume desired by those seeking bold lashes.
  • A few users report slight irritation despite the product being formulated for sensitive eyes.
  • Not ideal for those who need a mascara that is easy to remove at the end of the day.
  • May feel too heavy or uncomfortable for users with extremely sensitive skin around the eyes.
  • Not the best choice for users looking for a very lightweight mascara.

Ratings

After analyzing verified user feedback worldwide, across multiple languages and platforms, the reviews for bareMinerals Maximist Phyto-Fiber Volumizing Black Mascara reflect a generally positive reception. Scores were generated by filtering out spam, bot-generated, incentivized, duplicated, and off-topic reviews, ensuring only authentic, high-quality feedback was included. While the product has many strengths, including its volumizing effect and long-lasting wear, some users mentioned difficulty with removal due to its waterproof formula. Both the advantages and the drawbacks are reflected in the following ratings, which aim to offer a well-rounded view based on diverse user experiences.

Volumizing Effect
91%
Many users rave about the noticeable volume and thickness this mascara provides. It builds lashes effortlessly without clumping, creating a full, defined look that lasts throughout the day. The formula adds natural-looking volume, which is especially appreciated by those looking for a dramatic yet soft effect.
A few users feel that the volumizing effect could be more intense, especially for those with naturally thin lashes. Some also mention that they expected a more dramatic transformation, leaving them slightly disappointed with the results in comparison to other high-volume mascaras.
Waterproof Performance
88%
The waterproof formula excels in keeping lashes intact, even in humid conditions or rainy weather. Many reviewers highlight how well it stays put all day, ensuring no smudges or smears, making it perfect for long-lasting wear during outdoor activities or busy workdays.
However, some users struggle with the waterproof formula, especially when it comes time to remove it. The mascara tends to require more effort to take off, leading to complaints about the need for heavy-duty removers or the risk of lash damage from scrubbing.
Smudge-proof Wear
89%
Buyers love that the mascara truly lives up to its smudge-proof claims, keeping lashes perfect without smearing throughout the day. It's particularly praised by those who wear makeup in humid or active environments, as it holds up well even during sweat-inducing activities or after long hours.
Despite its smudge-proof quality, a small number of users have reported some flaking toward the end of the day, especially in hot or very humid conditions. While not a widespread issue, it’s something to consider for those seeking ultimate staying power in extreme weather.
Gentle on Sensitive Eyes
84%
Several users with sensitive eyes or contact lenses mention that this mascara is one of the few they can wear comfortably. It doesn’t irritate or cause discomfort, which is a major plus for anyone prone to eye sensitivity from other mascaras or harsh formulas.
While many appreciate its gentleness, a few individuals still experience mild irritation, especially when wearing it for long periods. Some also note that those with more extreme sensitivities might still find the formula a bit too heavy for all-day use.
Clump-free Application
92%
Users consistently highlight the smooth, clump-free application of this mascara. The formula glides on easily, giving lashes a defined, clean look without the hassle of separating or combing through. This feature makes it ideal for those who want voluminous lashes without any messy, spidery effects.
However, a few reviewers mention that the mascara can become a little thick if too many layers are applied, which may lead to some minor clumping. They suggest applying in light coats to avoid this issue and maintain a more natural finish.
Ease of Removal
65%
35%
While this mascara holds up well throughout the day, some users appreciate how easy it is to remove with the right makeup remover. When paired with an oil-based cleanser or waterproof remover, the product comes off without too much effort, making it manageable for most users.
For many, the waterproof nature of this mascara becomes a significant downside during removal. Several users complain that it’s incredibly difficult to take off, even with dedicated makeup removers, leading to irritation around the eyes from excessive rubbing or harsh cleansing methods.
Longevity of Results
87%
The mascara offers impressive longevity, with lashes looking thick and defined well into the evening. Reviewers appreciate that the look stays intact all day, even in challenging conditions like humidity, long work hours, or a busy schedule without needing a touch-up.
A few reviewers mention that the formula may not last quite as long as expected in extreme heat or after excessive sweating. For users looking for a more all-day, unshakable hold, this mascara might not be the best fit in very extreme environments.
Formula Texture
83%
The formula’s texture is smooth, lightweight, and easy to apply, giving lashes a natural yet defined look. It doesn’t feel heavy or cakey, which is ideal for those who prefer a more subtle mascara without the feel of product weighing down their lashes.
However, some users find the texture slightly too dry, especially if the mascara has been open for a while. A few individuals mention it can flake off more easily as it dries, which affects its overall staying power and leads to minor messes around the eyes.
Ethical Sourcing (Vegan & Cruelty-Free)
95%
Many eco-conscious buyers are pleased to know that this mascara is both vegan and cruelty-free. For users who prioritize ethical sourcing and animal welfare, these aspects provide peace of mind, making this a standout product in the category of conscious beauty choices.
Although the ethical aspects are a major selling point for many, a few users feel that the price point is slightly high for a cruelty-free option, questioning whether the performance justifies the investment. However, this sentiment is relatively rare compared to the positive reception of the formula’s ethical integrity.
Packaging and Dispenser
82%
18%
The sleek packaging and ergonomic brush make for a pleasant application experience. Many users appreciate the elegant design and find the brush easy to control, allowing for precise application without getting mascara on the eyelids or surrounding skin.
However, some users feel that the packaging is not as sturdy as they would like, especially after several uses. A few have reported issues with the wand becoming loose over time, leading to messier application and product wastage.
Overall Satisfaction
90%
Overall, the majority of users are highly satisfied with this mascara, appreciating its volumizing effect, long-lasting wear, and smudge-proof formula. It’s often praised for delivering natural, defined lashes that last all day, making it a reliable choice for daily wear.
While the product is highly regarded, some users express disappointment with the difficulty of removal, especially those with sensitive eyes. Additionally, a few buyers feel that the formula could be more customizable for different lash types, especially for those seeking more dramatic volume.
Value for Money
89%
Most users feel that this mascara is worth the investment, given its performance and ethical attributes. The high-quality formula, combined with its long-lasting effects and smudge-proof properties, provides great value for those looking for an all-day, dependable mascara.
Despite its merits, some users feel that the price point is a little high compared to other mascaras that offer similar results. The difficulty in removal also factors into their perception of value, as it requires additional makeup removers and effort, leading some to question if it’s worth the extra cost.

Suitable for:

The bareMinerals Maximist Phyto-Fiber Volumizing Black Mascara is ideal for individuals seeking long-lasting, voluminous lashes without clumping. Its waterproof and smudge-proof formula makes it a great choice for users with active lifestyles, long workdays, or those living in humid climates. Those with sensitive eyes or wearing contact lenses will also benefit from its gentle, cruelty-free, and vegan formulation. People who prefer a more natural, defined lash look will appreciate the added fullness this mascara provides without weighing down the lashes or causing irritation.

Not suitable for:

This mascara may not be suitable for users who have trouble removing waterproof formulas, as the product can be challenging to take off without the use of strong removers. Those looking for an ultra-dramatic lash effect may find the volumizing result underwhelming. Additionally, individuals with extremely sensitive eyes may still experience some irritation, despite the product’s gentle nature. Buyers expecting the formula to hold up perfectly in extreme heat or after heavy sweating might find its performance lacking in such conditions.

Specifications

  • Brand: The mascara is produced by bareMinerals, a brand known for its clean beauty products.
  • Shade: The mascara is available in a black shade for a bold, defined look.
  • Formulation: This mascara features a waterproof, smudge-proof, and flake-free formula designed for long-lasting wear.
  • Main Benefit: Its primary benefit is volumizing, providing thicker and more defined lashes.
  • Technology: The mascara utilizes Phyto-fiber technology to enhance lash volume and definition.
  • Vegan: This mascara is vegan, meaning it contains no animal-derived ingredients.
  • Cruelty-Free: The product is cruelty-free and not tested on animals.
  • Suitable for Sensitive Eyes: The mascara is specifically designed to be gentle and safe for users with sensitive eyes.
  • Weight: The mascara has a net weight of 0.32 oz (9 g).
  • Clumping: The formula is designed to volumize lashes without clumping, ensuring a natural look.
  • Wear Time: The waterproof formula ensures all-day wear, even in humid conditions.
  • Flake-Proof: This mascara is formulated to be flake-proof, preventing any unwanted residue under the eyes.
  • Removal: Due to its waterproof nature, removal may require an oil-based makeup remover or micellar water.
  • Brush Type: The mascara features a brush designed to distribute the formula evenly across lashes for full coverage.
  • Application: For optimal results, apply the mascara by starting at the base of the lashes and sweeping upward.
  • Eco-Conscious: Being both vegan and cruelty-free, this mascara is a suitable choice for eco-conscious consumers.
  • All-Day Wear: The formula provides reliable, long-lasting wear throughout the day without fading or smudging.
  • Packaging: The mascara is packaged in a standard tube with a traditional wand for easy application.
  • Formula Texture: The texture is smooth and buildable, allowing for customizable volume without excess product.

FAQ

To achieve the best results, apply the mascara by starting at the base of your lashes and wiggling the brush upward to the tips. Layer more product for added volume. For natural, voluminous lashes, use one or two coats. For more definition, allow each layer to dry before applying a second.

Yes, this mascara is specially formulated for sensitive eyes. It is gentle and non-irritating, making it an ideal choice for contact lens wearers or those prone to eye sensitivity.

This mascara is free of harsh chemicals and fragrances, making it a good choice for those looking for a gentle, hypoallergenic formula. It is also vegan and cruelty-free, so it's a great option for eco-conscious users.

The waterproof formula provides long-lasting wear, ensuring that the mascara stays in place even in humid conditions or during long days. It won’t smudge or flake, making it perfect for all-day wear.

While the waterproof formula ensures longevity, it can be a bit tricky to remove. We recommend using an oil-based makeup remover or micellar water to effectively break down the mascara without irritating the eyes.

This mascara uses Phyto-fiber technology to enhance lash volume and definition without clumping. The formula builds fullness gradually and gives a more natural, thicker lash look compared to traditional volumizing mascaras.

Yes, this mascara is suitable for all skin types, including those with sensitive skin. Its gentle, non-irritating formula makes it a good choice for users prone to eye sensitivities or skin reactions.

To ensure the mascara remains in good condition, store it in a cool, dry place and make sure the cap is tightly closed to prevent the formula from drying out. Avoid leaving it in a hot or humid environment.

Yes, this mascara is versatile enough for both daily wear and special occasions. Its buildable formula allows you to create a natural look for everyday use or add more layers for a dramatic, voluminous effect suitable for events.

This mascara offers a balanced volumizing effect, providing thicker, defined lashes without looking overly dramatic. It is perfect for those seeking natural fullness and definition but may not be intense enough for those looking for extreme volume.