Aryana New York Lash Eyebrow Kit 5ml

74%

26%

Wear Longevity

Waterproof Performance

Ease of Application

Brow Definition

Value for Money

Smudge Resistance

Lash Definition

Formula Texture

Shade Accuracy

Packaging & Portability

Ethical Credentials

Applicator Quality

Removal Ease

Overview

The Aryana New York Lash Eyebrow Kit 5ml is a dual-purpose cream formula designed for anyone tired of reaching for a pencil every morning. Packed into a compact container, each kit holds enough product for up to 10 applications — worth thinking about if you go through brow products quickly. What separates it from a crowded field is its PETA-certified vegan and cruelty-free status, meaning no animal-derived ingredients and no animal testing, full stop. At a mid-range price, it sits comfortably between drugstore basics and high-end tints, making it a reasonable option for ethically conscious shoppers who want real staying power without breaking the bank.

Features & Benefits

The formula is where this brow and lash kit really earns its keep. Applied with the included brow brush, it builds up gradually — light strokes give a natural fill, while a heavier hand adds more definition. The waterproof, smudge-proof finish holds reasonably well through sweat-heavy sessions and brief water exposure, though it's fair to say it performs better during a gym class than a long swim. Available in black and brown, it covers a solid range of skin tones without overdoing the shade options. Everything fits in packaging barely over an inch thick, so slipping it into a gym bag or carry-on takes no effort.

Best For

This dual-purpose kit is an obvious fit for active people — runners, swimmers, or anyone who finds standard brow products smearing halfway through a workout. It also speaks directly to shoppers making the switch from pencils; the cream kit delivers a stain-like effect that pencils simply can't replicate. Ethics-driven buyers will appreciate the PETA backing without having to dig through vague ingredient lists. And for beginners who'd rather not juggle three separate products, having brows and lashes covered in one kit simplifies the routine considerably. That said, if you need heavy filling for very sparse brows, this kit leans more toward definition and subtle volume than dramatic reconstruction.

User Feedback

Sitting at 4.3 out of 5 stars and ranked in the top 250 in its Amazon category, this brow and lash kit has clearly found a real audience. Buyers most often praise the all-day staying power, the natural-looking finish, and how easy the brush makes shaping. The positives largely line up with what the brand promises, which is reassuring. On the other side, a handful of users note the cream kit takes some practice — if you're used to a pencil, the first few applications can feel a bit clumsy. Shade matching also comes up occasionally, with some buyers finding brown leaning slightly warm for their coloring. Fair feedback overall, not a product flaw.

#Eyebrow Color

#Eyes

#Makeup

#Beauty & Personal Care

Pros

Waterproof formula holds up reliably through gym sessions and light water exposure.
The cream kit builds coverage gradually, giving you control over how bold or subtle the result looks.
PETA-certified vegan and cruelty-free credentials are verified, not just claimed on the packaging.
Includes a brow brush, so you don't need to buy additional tools to get started.
Compact enough to slip into a gym bag, travel pouch, or small purse without hassle.
The stain-like effect outlasts most pencil alternatives over the course of a full day.
Covers both brows and lashes in one product, simplifying a routine that often requires separate items.
Ranked in the top 250 in its Amazon category, reflecting genuine traction with real buyers.
Works well for subtle, natural-looking definition without looking heavy or overdone.

Cons

Each kit provides only around 10 applications, which may feel limited for daily users.
The cream formula has a noticeable learning curve — expect a few awkward applications before it feels natural.
Only two shade options means cool-toned or very light coloring may not find a close enough match.
The waterproof finish can make cleanup trickier than expected — a plain rinse is unlikely to fully remove it.
Not ideal for very sparse brows — the coverage leans toward definition rather than full reconstruction.
The 5ml volume is small; once you factor in the application limit, the cost-per-use is higher than it first appears.
Some users find the brush applicator too stiff for fine, precise hair-stroke detailing.
Waterproof performance holds against sweat but may break down faster during extended or deep water submersion.

Ratings

The scores below are generated by our AI rating engine after analyzing verified global buyer reviews of the Aryana New York Lash Eyebrow Kit 5ml, with spam, bot-submitted, and incentivized feedback actively filtered out before processing. Each category reflects a genuine synthesis of real-world experiences, transparently capturing both what users praised and what genuinely frustrated them. Nothing has been smoothed over to make the product look better than the evidence supports.

Wear Longevity

84%

The majority of buyers report the cream kit holding up impressively through full workdays, with no significant fading by early evening. Users who applied it before morning commutes consistently noted it still looked intentional and defined by the time they got home, which is more than most pencil alternatives can claim.

A subset of users with oilier skin found the staying power noticeably shorter, sometimes seeing breakdown around the brow area by mid-afternoon. Longevity also varies depending on how thoroughly the skin was prepped before application — skipping a primer or setting powder can shave hours off the wear time.

Waterproof Performance

76%

24%

For gym workouts, sweaty outdoor runs, and humid summer days, the formula performs convincingly well — buyers frequently mention being surprised that their brows looked intact after a full training session. The sweat-resistance claim holds up in real-world fitness contexts better than many competing products at this price level.

Extended water submersion tells a different story: dedicated lap swimmers report the product breaking down after prolonged pool exposure, which is a meaningful limitation if that is your primary use case. The waterproof performance is best described as activity-resistant rather than dive-proof, and buyers expecting the latter may feel misled.

Ease of Application

61%

39%

Once the learning curve is cleared — typically after the third or fourth session — users describe the cream formula as surprisingly intuitive and satisfying to use. Buyers who gave it a fair two-week trial tend to report the most positive outcomes, particularly those who took time to figure out how much product the brush actually needs.

First-time cream formula users consistently report frustration in the early days, with common complaints about over-applying, patchy results, and uneven color distribution. Anyone used to the quick and predictable stroke of a pencil should go in expecting an adjustment period that some buyers ultimately decided was not worth the effort.

Brow Definition

83%

For people with moderate brow gaps or uneven density, the buildable cream deposit does an effective job of filling and shaping without looking obviously painted on. Buyers frequently describe the end result as the kind of natural definition that prompts compliments rather than questions about whether they are wearing something.

Those with very sparse brows expecting significant reconstruction will find the results underwhelming — this dual-purpose kit is built for enhancement, not heavy fill. At maximum coverage, the finish can look slightly blocky rather than hair-like, which matters for anyone chasing a feathered, microblading-style effect.

Value for Money

64%

36%

For occasional users or those who combine this kit with other products and use it every other day, the mid-range price point feels fair given the PETA certifications, included applicator, and dual-purpose functionality. Buyers who treat it as a weekend or event product tend to report strong satisfaction with what they paid.

Daily users burning through a kit in under two weeks find the cost-per-application harder to justify, especially when comparing against standard brow products that last months. The 10-application ceiling is the single most commonly flagged disappointment in user reviews, and it is fair to say the volume-to-price ratio is a genuine weakness.

Smudge Resistance

79%

21%

In normal daily conditions — office environments, social events, light outdoor exposure — buyers report very little transfer, even after accidentally rubbing near the brow area. Several users specifically mention it holding up through allergy season eye-rubbing, which is a real and practical endorsement.

Under sustained friction or when the skin around the brow becomes very oily, some smudging does appear, particularly at the tail end of the brow where contact with hair is more likely. It is not dramatic, but perfectionist users who do periodic touch-up checks may find it less pristine by late afternoon.

Lash Definition

69%

31%

As a light lash treatment for adding subtle depth and definition, the cream kit delivers a quietly effective result — users with naturally dark lashes report it enhancing their eye look without requiring a full mascara step. It works particularly well for a no-makeup makeup aesthetic where visible product is the opposite of the goal.

Buyers hoping for mascara-level volume, curl, or lengthening will not find it here — this is a coating, not a lash builder. Those with naturally fair or sparse lashes often feel the lash benefit is too subtle to matter, and several suggest the brow application is where the product earns its keep while the lash effect is largely secondary.

Formula Texture

81%

19%

Buyers who appreciate the cream consistency describe it as smooth and easy to work into the brow hairs without clumping or dragging. The texture sits between a gel and a wax in practice, which most users find gives them better control over density than they expected once they figured out the right application pressure.

In warm or humid climates, a handful of users noticed the texture becoming slightly softer inside the container, which made it easier to over-load the brush by accident. Cold storage keeps the consistency more predictable, but that is an extra step most buyers do not want to think about for a daily makeup product.

Shade Accuracy

58%

42%

For buyers with medium to dark warm-toned brown hair, the brown shade maps closely to natural brow color and blends convincingly. Users within this range consistently report satisfaction, describing the shade as one of the more realistic browns they have tried at this price point without needing to mix anything.

The two-shade lineup is where the product visibly falls short for a meaningful portion of the market — cool-toned brunettes, ash blondes, and anyone with gray or mixed brows report the brown reading too warm against their coloring. With only black and brown available, buyers outside those two color profiles are left without a real option.

Packaging & Portability

88%

The compact, flat profile of the packaging makes it one of the easier beauty products to slip into a gym bag, clutch, or airport carry-on without taking up meaningful space. Buyers who travel frequently mention it specifically as one of the few brow products that passes through security without fuss and survives being tossed into a bag daily.

The container itself, while compact, does not feel particularly premium in hand — a few buyers describe the lid as feeling slightly flimsy relative to the price. There are also occasional reports of the lid loosening over time, which creates a minor but real risk of the cream drying out faster than expected.

Ethical Credentials

93%

The PETA-certified vegan and cruelty-free status is the most consistently praised non-performance attribute across the entire review pool. For buyers who cross-reference certifications before purchasing, the verification removes the doubt that often surrounds self-reported cruelty-free claims from smaller brands, and that credibility carries genuine weight.

There is no meaningful downside to the ethical credentials themselves, though a few buyers note they wish the brand offered more shade diversity to make the product accessible to a wider range of the vegan beauty community. The certification is real and valid — the product just does not always deliver on its other promises with equal consistency.

Applicator Quality

71%

29%

The included brush does what it needs to for standard brow filling and shaping, and most first-time users appreciate not having to source a separate tool before they can get started. Its moderate stiffness gives decent resistance against the skin, which helps with blending the cream evenly across the brow arch.

Detail-oriented buyers and anyone accustomed to high-quality angled brushes find the included applicator lacking in precision — the bristles are a touch wide for creating fine hair strokes, and the handle offers limited control. Several reviewers mention upgrading to a dedicated brow brush after a few weeks, which adds to the overall cost.

Removal Ease

54%

46%

Buyers who already own an oil-based makeup remover or a dedicated eye cleanser report clean, complete removal without irritation in most cases. The formula does release with the right product applied properly, and users with an established skincare routine rarely flag removal as a significant issue in their day-to-day use.

For buyers without a proper eye makeup remover on hand, the waterproof formula is noticeably resistant to plain water and light face washes — several report rubbing the eye area far more than is comfortable to get it off. This is a practical consideration for sensitive-eye users and anyone new to waterproof formulas who may not have the right remover ready.

Suitable for:

The Aryana New York Lash Eyebrow Kit 5ml is genuinely well-matched for active people who need their brow and lash products to stay put through sweat, humidity, or the occasional splash. If you swim recreationally, hit the gym regularly, or just live somewhere hot and humid, the waterproof cream formula offers a more reliable hold than most standard pencils. It also makes strong sense for anyone committed to ethical beauty — the PETA-certified vegan and cruelty-free credentials are documented, not just marketing language. Beginners who feel overwhelmed by building a separate brow and lash routine will appreciate having both covered in a single compact kit with an applicator already included. And if your current pencil keeps smudging by midday, the stain-like effect of this cream kit could be a real practical upgrade for daily wear.

Not suitable for:

The Aryana New York Lash Eyebrow Kit 5ml is probably not the right pick if speed is your top priority in the morning. Cream formulas require a steadier hand and a bit of practice before the application feels second nature — if you are used to a pencil and have just a few minutes before heading out, this kit will frustrate you early on. The 10-application limit also means heavy daily users will burn through it faster than the price might initially suggest, making the long-term cost worth calculating before you commit. People with very sparse brows who want high-coverage, dramatic filling are likely to find the result underwhelming, as this kit leans toward natural definition rather than full reconstruction. And if your coloring sits outside the warm brown or standard black range, the two available shades may not match closely enough for a polished, natural look.

Specifications

Brand: This kit is manufactured and sold by Aryana New York.
Volume: Each kit contains 5ml of cream formula.
Applications: One kit provides up to 10 full applications per purchase.
Formula Type: The formula is cream-based, allowing layered, buildable coverage rather than a single fixed deposit.
Finish: The finished result is waterproof and smudge-proof under normal all-day wear conditions.
Sweat Resistance: The formula is sweat-resistant and designed to hold through physical activity and moderate perspiration.
Available Shades: The kit is offered in two shades: black and brown.
Applicator: A dedicated brow brush applicator is included inside the kit packaging.
Vegan Status: The product is certified vegan by PETA, with no animal-derived ingredients in the formulation.
Cruelty-Free: PETA has certified this kit as cruelty-free, confirming no animal testing is conducted at any stage of production.
Ingredient Source: No animal-derived components are used; the formulation is built entirely from non-animal-origin ingredients.
Packaging Size: The outer packaging measures 5.94 x 5.94 x 1.14 inches.
Packaged Weight: The full packaged unit weighs 3.84 ounces.
Product Type: This is a dual-purpose kit formulated to add definition and volume to both eyebrows and eyelashes.
Item Model: The manufacturer's designated model number is LASH AND BROW KIT.
Category Rank: At the time of evaluation, the kit was ranked #236 in the Eyebrow Color category on Amazon.

Related Reviews

ARYANA NEW YORK Eyebrow Lamination Kit Professional

87%

Ease of Use

Effectiveness of Results

Long-Lasting Results

Value for Money

Ingredient Quality (Vegan & Cruelty-Free)

Laura Geller Balance-n-Glow Powder Foundation Kit

76%

Finish & Glow Quality

Coverage Performance

Performance on Mature Skin

Wear Longevity

Brush Quality & Design

Hairgenics Lavish Lash Pro 5mL Eyelash Serum

78%

Lash Growth Effectiveness

Brow Growth Effectiveness

Formula Safety

Applicator Design

Value for Money

Laura Geller New York Cult Classics Full Face Kit: Medium

87%

Overall Effectiveness

Skin Compatibility

Hydration Benefits

Texture & Feel

Blendability & Coverage

Beau Lashes Lash Lift Kit

87%

Ease of Application

Curl Longevity

Instructions for Beginners

Effectiveness of Perming Lotions

Kit Value for Money

Pro Lash 4.5 mL Oil-Based Lash Remover

81%

Adhesive Removal Effectiveness

Gentleness on Natural Lashes

Sensitivity & Eye Safety

Value for Money

Ease of Application

TUBeauty Lash Lift Kit Eyelash Perming Kit

84%

Effectiveness of Lash Lift

Ease of Application

Duration of Results

Suitability for Sensitive Skin

Value for Money

PRO LASHBEAUTY Lash Extension Kit 168 Pcs Individual Lashes

89%

Ease of Application

Waterproof Hold

Comfort for All-Day Wear

Customization of Lash Length

Suitability for Beginners

CICI Lash 2 in 1 Lash Lift & Brow Lamination Kit

84%

Ease of Use

Effectiveness of Lash Curl

Effectiveness of Brow Lamination

Longevity of Results

Collagen-Enriched Formula

Pro Lash ProWear Mini Lash Clusters Kit - Volume Shorties No. 06

86%

Ease of Application

Longevity of Wear

Waterproof & Sweatproof Performance

Adhesive Quality

Fit for All Eye Shapes

FAQ

It performs well in sweat-heavy situations like gym workouts or humid weather, but extended submersion in a pool is a tougher test. Most users find it holds adequately during recreational swimming, though prolonged laps or open-water sessions may break it down faster. For serious swimmers, a dedicated waterproof eye product may offer more reliable long-term hold.

The kit is rated for up to 10 applications, which means daily users will go through it in roughly one to two weeks. If you use it every other day or only for brows rather than both brows and lashes, you can stretch it further. It is worth factoring that math into your buying decision before assuming it is a long-term supply.

There is a real adjustment period. Cream formulas do not have the same point-and-draw precision as a pencil, and controlling the amount you pick up on the brush takes a few tries. Most users find their rhythm after three or four applications, but if you are in a rush every morning, expect the first week to feel a little clumsy.

Not quite. The cream kit adds definition and a bit of volume to lashes, but it does not lengthen or dramatically curl them the way a mascara wand does. Think of the lash effect as more of a tinted coating than a full mascara replacement. It works well for a more understated, natural look.

Because the formula is waterproof, plain water will not cut through it cleanly. A dedicated eye makeup remover or a gentle oil-based cleanser works best. Rubbing aggressively to compensate for a weak remover can irritate the delicate skin around the eyes, so having the right removal product ready before you start is a good idea.

Brown is generally the safer choice for anyone with lighter or medium-toned hair, as it blends more naturally and tends to read less harsh in daylight. Black is the better option for very dark hair or those who prefer a bolder, more defined finish. If you are unsure, brown is the more forgiving starting point.

The vegan, cruelty-free formulation avoids common animal-derived irritants, which some sensitive-skin users find helpful. That said, the product has not been marketed specifically as hypoallergenic, and individual reactions to any cosmetic ingredient are possible. If you have a history of eye sensitivity or contact dermatitis, a patch test before full use is the sensible route.

It can work, but it depends on the depth of your natural coloring. Very light blonde or fully gray brows may find the standard brown shade a touch too warm or dark for a truly seamless blend. The product is best matched to medium to dark brown hair tones, so lighter-haired buyers should manage expectations around how natural the finish looks.

Always seal the lid firmly after each use — cream formulas dry out faster than pencils or gels when left exposed to air. Storing the brow and lash kit at room temperature, away from direct sunlight or heat sources, will help preserve the consistency. Avoid leaving it in a hot car or near a sunny bathroom window.

For most users, the included brush does the job well enough to get started without any extra purchases. It gives decent control for filling and shaping. That said, if you want very fine hair-stroke detailing or prefer an angled brush with stiffer bristles, a dedicated brow brush from a beauty supply store may give you more precision over time.

Aryana New York Lash Eyebrow Kit 5ml

Overview

Features & Benefits

Best For

User Feedback

Pros

Cons

Ratings

Wear Longevity

Waterproof Performance

Ease of Application

Brow Definition

Value for Money

Smudge Resistance

Lash Definition

Formula Texture

Shade Accuracy

Packaging & Portability

Ethical Credentials

Applicator Quality

Removal Ease

Suitable for:

Not suitable for:

Specifications

Related Reviews

FAQ

Is the Aryana New York Lash Eyebrow Kit 5ml actually waterproof enough for swimming?

How long will one kit realistically last me?

I have been using a brow pencil for years. Is switching to a cream formula difficult?

Can this be used as a standalone lash product the way a mascara would be?

How do I remove the product at the end of the day?

Which shade should I pick — black or brown?

Is this safe to use for people with sensitive eyes or skin?

Does the brown shade work for blonde or gray brows?

How should I store the kit to keep it from drying out?

Is the included brow brush good enough, or should I buy a separate applicator?